■nil r>,u)i\'d\ 







•iil;Hi!;ni. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE TO THE 
CITY OF NEW YORK 





THE SEAL OF NEW YORK CITY IN 1787. 

LEGEND (unabbreviated) " Sigillum Civitatis Novi Eboraci: " Seal 
of tbe City of New York ; Eboraci being the genitive case of the 
old Roman name for York. 

SHIELD: Argent, charged with the four sails of a windmill proper; 
between their outer ends, two beavers proper, one in chief and 
one in base, and two flour-barrels proper, in fess, one on each side. 

CREST : A bald eagle proper, rising from a denu-terrestrial globe. 
The beaver is an emblem of the fur trade, so important in Dutch 
days ; the sails and barrels represent the bolting industry, a 
monopoly of which was granted New York merchants by the 
Bolting Act of 1678. 

SUPPORTERS (not heraldically part of the city arms and variously 
represented to-day) : dexter (right) side of shield, a sailor in 
dress and cap of 1700 holding in his right hand a ship's sounding- 
line; on the sinister (left) side, an Indian chief with a stringed 
bow. 

The sailor is said to be in honor of James who was not only 
Proprietor of New York but also Lord High Admiral of England ; 
the Indian represented the inhabitants and possessors of his 
Province in America. 

— From a Report of the Saint Nicholas Society. 



trtje Citp ^imxp Club of ^eto |?orfe 



105 West 40TH Street 



OFFICERS 
1912-13 



Honorary President 

President 

First Vice-President 

Second Vice-President 

Treasurer 

Secretary . 

Assistant Secretary . 

Superintendent 

Assistant Superintendent 

Assistant Treasurer 



Mrs. Robert Abbe 

Mrs. a. Barton Hepburn 

George F. Kunz, Ph.D., Sc.D. 

E. R. L. Gould, Ph.D. 

Mrs. Malcolm Stuart 

Mrs. Samuel C. Van Dusen 

Miss Augusta Drake 

Frank Bergen Kelley, Ph.D. 

Mr. Charles Kandel 

Miss Beulah E. Hepburn 



Prepared zvith the co-operation of and endorsed by 

^fje American Scenic anh J^isJtoric $res(erljation ^ocietp 



OFFICERS 
1912 



Honorary President 
President 



J. Pierpont Morgan, LL.D. 
George F. Kunz, Ph.D., Sc.D. 



Vice-Presidents 
Colonel Henry W. Sackett Dean Liberty H. Bailey 

Honorable George W. Perkins Henry M. Leipziger, Ph.D., LL.D. 

Treasurer Hon. N. Taylor Phillips 

Secretary Edward Hagaman Hall, L.H.D. 



IV 





mi 

I 




HISTORICAL GUIDE 

TO THE 

CITY OF NEW YORK 

COMPILED BY 

FRANK BERGEN KELLEY 

From Original Observatio7is and Contributions 
Made by Me77ibers and Friends of 

The City History Club of New York 

WITH SEVENTY MAPS AND DIAGRAMS AND 
FORTY -EIGHT ILLUSTRATIONS 

IReviseD BMtion 




NEW YORK 
FREDERICK A. STOKES COMPANY 

PUBLISHERS 



.5" 



Copyright, 1909, by the City History Club of New York. 
The Excursions are copyrighted separately, the notice and date of each being: 
;iven on the first page of each one. 
The copyright extends to all plates and cuts. 

Copyright, 1913, by the City History Club of New York. 







Jpn7, igi3 






SECOND EDITION 

DEDICATED BY 

THE CITY HISTORY CLUB 
(by permission) 

TO 

Founder and long President of The City 
History Club of New York 



IIISTCRIC TRACES COMMITTEE 

OF 

THE CITY HISTORY CLUB OF NEW YORK: 

Editors of the Historical Guide 
Reginald Pelham Bolton. Edward Hagaman Hall. 

Associate Editors 

Randall Comfort Hopper Striker Mott. 

Charles A. Ditmas. George W. Nash. 

Robert E. Parsons. August R. Oh man. 

Charles R. Lamb. Albert Ulmann. 

Frank Bergen Kelley, Chairman. 

Corresponding Members 
Thomas J. Burton. J. H. Innes. 

Thanks are due for special aid in securing information and for the 
use of material to: Frank Warren Crane, William T. Davis, Henry 
Russell Drowne, Charles Hemstreet, Thomas A. Janvier, Ira K. 
Morris, Josiah C. Pumpclly, Frederick Van Wyck and many other 
students of local history. 

Cartographers: August R. Ohman, Reginald Pelham Bolton. 

Draughtsmen: Morris W. Ehrlich, Charles Kandel. 

For permission to copy maps, thanks are due to : Edward Haga- 
man Hall, John H. Innes, A. Meserole, Harper Bros., W. W. Mun- 
sell, G. P. Putnam's Sons, Chas. Scrihner's Sons and. Henry Dunreath 
Tyler. 

Official Photographer: Frank F. Evans. 

Photographs have been contributed by Randall Comfort, C. Irv- 
ing Jones and George W. Nash. Other ilhistrations have been used 
by courtesy of the Century History Company, G. P. Putnam's Sons, 
and the Long Island Historical Society. 



PREFACE 

The Historical Guide to Nezv York is the result of prolonged ef- 
forts on the part of the City History Club of New York to discover 
and to direct attention to the yet visible traces of earlier times which 
lie hidden within and are fast disappearing from the city of to-day. 

When the society was founded in 1896 to promote good citizenship 
through the study of history and civics and by the establishment of 
self-governing clubs, the need was felt for a systematic survey of and 
guide to the history of New York City in a simple and convenient 
form. In order to meet this necessity the Club first published, un- 
der the direction of a number of well-known writers, The Half 
Moon Papers, a series of monographs which were afterward incor- 
porated in two volumes entitled Historic Nezv York. During the 
past thirteen years, twelve Excursion Leaflets have been prepared, 
designed to provide, at the lowest possible price, a brief but carefully 
verified historical description of every part of the city, compiled a? 
far as possible from original sources. These pamphlets have been 
extensively utilized b}- members of the junior clubs, some of whom 
have by their use become competent as trained, and in a few cases, pro- 
fessional guides ; by the children of the public and private schools of 
the five boroughs ; and by many other persons who believe, as does 
the writer, that familiarit}^ with the history of one's own city leading 
to a knowledge and love of the city itself is the foundation of true 
civic patriotism. The information thus gathered is now presented in 
complete form, thoroughly revised and illustrated by maps and photo- 
graphs. 

On behalf of the City History Club and on my own part, I thank 
the many faithful friends of the organization who have contributed 
of their time and knowledge to the compilation of this work. Some 
of their names may be found recorded on another page, but the full 
measure of skill and devotion which they have so generously expended 
can never be recorded. 

It is the sincere hope of the founder of the City History Club that 
this book may prove of real service to all those who desire to know 
the city better and to work .more effectively for its future good. 

Catharine A. B. Abbe. 

Brook End, Bar Harbor, July 5th, 1909. 



EXPLANATORY 

EXCURSIONS: the original twelve itineraries still issued as sepa- 
rate leaflets and numbered in the order of their issue. These are 
now arranged in -order of topography, beginning with lower Manhat- 
tan. 

ROUTES: the Excursions have been divided into Sections, each of 
which covers sufficient territory for an itinerary of about two hours. 
Prefixed to the Section numbers are Route numbers (running con- 
secutively from I to 60) which are also placed at the head of each 
page (abbreviation R). 

TYPE. Bold faced type is used for landmarks, tablets or other 
memorials in existence at the time of publication (1909). 

Italics indicate directions in routes ; historic sites. 

Small type indicates general historical accounts, descriptions of historic build- 
ings which have no visible trace or memorial. Small Capitals in such 
type indicate some place of importance represented by a name or memorial. 

KEY MAPS show the approximate location of the various Routes, 
the numbers thereon corresponding to Route numbers. 

PLATES : with but four exceptions the maps and diagrams have 
been specially prepared or redrawn for this Guide Book. 

The ILLUSTRATIONS in the text are from the set published by 
the City History Club ; the full page inserts, with one exception, are 
from original photographs taken for the Guide Book. 

NOTES : blank pages for original notes are placed at the end of 
each Excursion, as changes in New York City are so rapid, the old 
giving place to the new, that accounts of landmarks must be con- 
stantly amended. 

SECOND EDITION:—* refers to Addenda and Corrections in- 
serted at the end of the various Routes, etc. 



INTRODUCTION TO THE SECOND EDITION 

Since 1909 many historic buildings have been destroyed, new monu- 
ments, statues and tablets have been erected, new streets and parks 
have been opened and some street names have been changed. More- 
over, errors in the first edition have been discovered and much additional 
matter added. The changes in the Bronx have been so great that nearly 
all the maps had to be redrawn. Plates V, XII and LXVII have also 
been redrawn. 

In order to save the expense of making entirely new electroplates, 
corrections and additions to the text have been inserted at the end of 
the various Routes, reference to them being made by means of asterisks. 

Part VI has been condensed and the Bronx portion rewritten; 
Appendix D has been entirely rewritten and the Index has been 
thoroughly revised. Thinner paper has been used in order to make 
the book lighter and more portable. 

The compiler and the editors welcome criticisms and suggestions, 
as they desire to make the work thoroughly reliable and complete. 

Frank Bergen Kelley. 
February, 1913. 



GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY 

" History of the City of New York," by Martha J. Lamb. 

" History of the City of New York," by Mrs. Burton Harrison 
(completing Lamb's History to 1896). 

" The Memorial History of the City of New York," edited by 
James Grant Wilson. 

"Leslie's History of New York," edited by Dr. Van Pelt. 

" New York," (Historic Towns Series) by Theodore Roosevelt. 

" Story of the City of New York," (Great Cities of the Republic 
Series) by Charles Burr Todd. 

" A Brief History of the City of New York," by Charles Burr Todd. 

For a brief classified bibliography, see Ulmann's " Landmark His- 
tory of New York." 

For an exhaustive bibliography, see Bulletin 24 (35 cents) issued 
by the State Department at Albany. 

See also bibliographies at the beginning of each Excursion. 

"The Dutch Schools of New Netherland and Colonial New York" 
(Bull. 12, 1912, U. S. Bureau of Education), by Wm. Heard Kilpatrick. 

"History of the City of New York in the Seventeenth Century," by 
Mrs. Schuyler Van Rensselaer. 

Annual Reports of the American Scenic and Historic Preservation 
Society. 



CONTENTS 

PAGE 

The Seal of New York City in 1787 iii 

Preface ' ix 

Explanatory x 

Introduction to the Second Edition •. xi 

General Bibliography xii 

PART ONE— MANHATTAN i 

New York's Development 3 

Route I. Bowling Green (Excursion VII) . ... 11 

Route 2. Trinity Church and Wall Street 23 

Route 3. Pearl and Broad Streets 30 

Route 4. The Battery and Governor's Island .... S3 

Fraunces Tavern (Excursion VI) 39 

Route 5. City Hall Park and Vicinity (Excursion I) . 49 

Route 6. St. Paul's to Wall Street 58 

Route 7. Wall Street to Franklin Square 61 

Route 8. Greenwich Village (Excursion II) .... 69 

Route 9. Lispenard's Meadows yy 

Route 10. Washington Square and Vicinity . ... 80 

Route II. Bowery Village (Excursion III) 85 

Route 12. The Bowery, Chatham Square and Collect Pond 95 

Route 13. Corlaer's Hook and Grand Street to Broadway 99 

Route 14. Union Square to Gramercy Park (Excursion V) 103 

Route 15. Madison Square and Vicinity 11 1 

Route 16. Love Lane and Chelsea Village 115 

Route 17. Murray Hill to Central Park 117 

Route 18. Bloomingdale and Hamilton Burr Duelling Ground 121 

Route 19. Morningside Heights and Manhattanville . . 125 

Battle of Harlem Heights 128 

Side Trip to Fort Lee 131 

Route 20. Kip's Bay to Horn's Hook I33 

The East River Islands 136 

Route 21. Northern Central Park (Excursion IV) . . 141 

Route 22. Nieuw Haerlem 147 

Route 23. Hamilton Grange to Fort George .... 151 

xiii 



CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Washington's Headquarters (Morris or Jumel Mansion) . 156 

Route 24. Fort Washington 161 

Route 25. Fort Washington Monument to Fort Washing- 
ton Park 165 

Route 26. Fort Tryon 167 

Route 27. Kingsbridge to Inwood 168 

Route 28a. Colonial and Revolutionary Sites east of Broad- 
way 170 

Route 28b. West of Broadway to Cold Spring . . . . 171 

PART TWO— BOROUGH OF THE BRONX 176 

Historical Sketch of the Bronx 179 

Route 29. Kingsbridge to the City Line (Excursion IX) . 181 
Route 29a. Two Hundred and Forty-second Street to 

Yonkers 184 

Route 29b. Western Bronx 185 

Route 30. Central Bridge to University Heights . . . 187 

Route 30a. University Heights to Jerome Park Reservoir . 190 

Route 30b. Williamsbridge and Wakefield 191 

Route 31. Harlem River to Hunt's Point 195 

Route 32. Western Morrisania, Fordham and Bronx Park 199 

Route 2)2>- Throgg's Neck 203 

Route 33a. Westchester Village 205 

Route 34. City Island and Pelham Bay Park .... 209 

Route 34a. Eastern Morrisania, West Farms and Eastchester 212 

PART THREE— BOROUGH OF BROOKLYN .... 219 

Historical Sketch of Brooklyn {Excursion XII) . . . 225 

Route 35a. Williamsburg 227 

Route 35b. Greenpoint 229 

Route 35c. Bushwick 232 

Route 36. Brooklyn Heights to Borough Hall (Excursion 

VIII) 241 

Route Z7- Fulton Street, Fort Greene Park and the Navy 

Yard 243 

Route 38. Prospect Park 245 

Route 39. Flatbush 247 

Route 40. Flatlands 249 

Route 41. New Lots, East New York and Canarsie . . 253 

Route 42. Brooklyn Bridge to Fort Hamilton .... 257 

Route 43. New Utrecht 259 

xiv 



CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Route 43a. Gravesend and Coney Island 261 

Notes on Flatlands 263 

PART FOUR— BOROUGH OF QUEENS 269 

Historical Sketch of Queens (Excursion XI) 274 

Route z^4. Hunter's Point and Steinway to North Beach . 277 

Route 45. Astoria to Steinway 281 

Route 46. Maspeth and Laurel Hill 287 

Route 46a. South on Flushing Avenue 289 

Route 47. Hunter's Point and Woodside to 'Corona . . 291 

Route 48. Corona to Coe's Mill 294 

Route 49. Elmhurst (Newtown) 297 

Route 50. Middle Village 293 

Route 51. Flushing 304 

Route 52. Jamaica 310 

PART FIVE— BOROUGH OF RICHMOND 319 

Historical Sketch of Staten Island (Excursion X) . . . 32^ 

Route 53. St. George to Holland's Hook 327 

Route 54. St. George to New Springville 333 

Route 55. St. George to Arrochar ^^iS 

Route 56. New Dorp ^y) 

Route 57. Elm Tree Light 3-1 2 

Route 58. Richmond Village 3}3 

Route 59. Greenridge and Great Kills 345 

Route 59a. Rossville and Woodrow 347 

Route 60. Tottenville 349 

Route 6oa. Princess Bay 350 

PART SIX— SPECIAL ROUTES 355 

A. Routes for Children 357 

B. Water Routes 360 

C. Carriage and Automobile Routes 362 

APPENDICES 

A. The Milestones and the Old Post Road 371 

Milestones in Bloomingdale 375 

B. Historical Monuments, Statues and Tablets .... ^,77 

C. Notable Historic Buildings 391 

D. Museums, Collections and Libraries 395 

E. Historic Trees, Rocks and Other Objects 403 

Index 409 

XV 



LIST OF DIAGRAMS AND MAPS 

PAGE 

I. Key Map, Borough of Manhattan 2 

11. Duke's Map, 1661-5 to face 6 

III. The Lyne-Bradford Map, 1728 . . . to face 6 

IV. New Amsterdam, 1644 12 

V. Routes i, 2, 3, 4 . 13 

VI. Trinity Churchyard 24 

VII. Governor's Island 34 

VIII. Region of Fraunces Tavern, Showing Changes in 

Water Line 40 

IX. Holland Map, 1776 50 

X. Routes 5, 6, 7 . . 50a 

XI. City Hall Park . • . 52 

XII. St. Paul's Churchyard 58 

XIII. Part of Montressor Map of 1775 : Greenwich and 

Environs 70 

XIV. Routes 8 and id 74 

XV. Anneke Jans Farm yy 

XVI. Routes 8, 9 79 

XVII. Portion of Ratzer Map, 1767 86 

XVIII. BouwERiE Village 88 

XIX. Route ii 90 

XX. Routes 12, 13 96 

XXI. Routes 14, 15, 16 104 

XXII. Route 17 118 

XXIII. Route 18 122 

XXIV. Route 19, Battle of Harlem Heights . . . . 128 
XXV. Route 20 132 

XXVI. McGown's Pass and Vicinity, 1776 142 

XXVII. Route 22, Nieuw Haerlem 148 

XXVIII. Route 23 152 

XXIX. Routes 23, 24, 25 . . 160 

XXX. Fort Washington and its Related Fortifications 162 

XXXI. Routes 23, 26, 28a 166 

XXXI 1. Routes 27, 28a, 28b 168 

xvi 



PAGE 

XXXIII. Key Map to the Bronx 178 

XXXIV. Routes 29, 29a, 29b 180 

XXXV. Routes 30, 31. 32, 34a 186 

XXXVI. Routes 30, 30a, 30b, 32 188 

XXXVII. Routes 30b, 34a 192 

XXXVIII. Routes 31, 33, 34a 194 

XXXIX. Routes 32, 34a 200 

XL. Routes 33, 33a 206 

XLI. Route 34 208 

XLII. Key Map to Brooklyn and Queens 2J0 

XLI II. Battle of Long Island 224 

XLIV. Route 35 228 

XLV. Greenpoint 2,-,o 

XLVI. Route 35c 233 

XLVII. Route 36 240 

XLVIII. Route 37 . . . 24 ^ 

XLIX. Routes 38, 39 246 

L. Route 40 250 

LI. Route 41 252 

LII. Routes 42, 43 256 

LIII. Route 43a 261 

LIV. Old Tracts and Roads in Newtown .... 272 

LV. Routes 44, 47 276 

LVI. Route 45 282 

LVII. Route 46 286 

LVIII. Routes 47, 48, 50 290 

LIX. Route 49 298 

LX. Route 51 305 

LXI. Route 52 310 

LXII. Modern Jamaica 311 

LXIII. Key Map to Richmond 322 

LXIV. Route 53 326 

LXV. Route 54 33^ 

LXVI. Route 55 336 

LXVII. Routes 56, 57, 58 34o 

LXVIII. Route 58 343 

LXIX. Route 59 346 

LXX. Routes 60, 6oa 348 



LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 



Manhattan, 1606; 1909 Frontispiece 

The Fort in Kieft's Day 4 

The Block House and City Gate 5 

Broad Street Canal 6 

The Purchase of Manhattan 16 

Bowling Green and the Battery 18 

Bowling Green and the Custom House, 1909 . . .facittg page 18 

English City Hall and Trinity Church 27 

The Stadt Huys, 1679 facing page 31 

The Clermont, 1807 36 

Former Appearance of Fraunces Tavern 42 

Fraunces Tavern, 1909; Washington's Farewell . facing page 46 

Fraunces Tavern, 1904 47 

City Hall, 1909 facing page 48 

Croton Water Procession, 1842 56 

Sappokanican . 72 

St. John's Chapel ... % 

Minetta Street ( t„ :.. ^ 

95 Morton street ... [ facing page 72 

Hudson near Watts Street. ' 

Collect Pond 94 

Hamilton Grange, 1804 . 150 

Washington's Headquarters, 1909 ...... facing page 156 

Van Cortlandt Mansion facing page 180 

St. Paul's Church, Eastchester ) / • a o 

„ ^ X- „ y facing page 198 

Poe Cottage, Fordham • • f 1 & t s ^ 

Fulton Ferry, 1746 222 

Schenck House. Carnarsie Park ...» 

Van Nuyse-Magaw Homestead, Flatlands / ^ facing page 242 

Van Wyck House, Flatlands j* * 

Van Brunt House, New Lots . . . . ' 



Van Derveer Mill Wheel . 

Gerritsen Tide Mill, Flatlands , . . 

Lott Smoke House, Flatlands > focmg page 250 

Hand Made Shingles . 

King Mansion, Jamaica . 

Moore House, Elmhurst . . . ) , . ^ 

■D TT 1 A jj^ u- L . . . . facing page 274 

Bowne Homestead, rlushmg . . C 

Quaker Meeting House, Flushing / 

Guyon-Clarke House, New Dorp . 

Lake-Tysen House, Karles Neck . / . . ^ 

Christopher House, Willow Brook J ■ • • ■ /»"»« P^S'^ 3^4 
Moravian Church, New Dorp . / 

Billopp House, Tottenville facing page 348 

15 Milestone ... 

g Milestone . . . . I , . 

I Milestone . . . . [ '"""^ f"^' ^^3 

New Utrecht Milestone ^ 

Eleventh Milestone Unveiling, May 30, 1912 370 



XIX 



PART ONE 

MANHATTAN 

Excursions VII, VI, I, II, III, V and IV. 
Routes 1—28 




ATLANTIC OCEAN 



Plate I. Key for Manhattan Routes. C. K. 

Roman numerals refer to EXCURSIONS; arabic to ROUTES. 
2 



PART ONE: MANHATTAN. 
NEW YORK'S DEVELOPMENT 

AS SHOWN BY THE 

TRACES OF OLD ROADS AND STREETS. 

By Albert Ulmann. 
Author of " A Landmark History of New York." 

Tradition furnishes an account to the effect that the first habita- 
tions of white men on the Island of Manhattan consisted of four 
houses or huts erected in 1613 on a site now known as 41 Broadway 
where a bronze tablet commemorates this interesting circumstance. 
From this simple beginning the settlement grew until some thirty 
cabins, clustered near the southern end of the island, constituted the 
little town. Then a general conflagration took place and much damage 
was done. 

Before this first of the great fires that have visited Manhattan, in 
1626, the lines of a fort were laid out, occupying the site of the 
present Custom House, the work being completed in 1633-5. Iri those 
days the shore line was less extended than at present so that the fort 
easily commanded the entrance to both the Hudson and East Rivers, 
the water coming up to the line of the present State Street. Fort 
Amsterdam, as the work was called, built of earth and stone and hav- 
ing four bastions, rose proudly above the group of small houses and 
became the distinctive feature of New Amsterdam. In the earliest 
views of the settlement, such as that of Joost Hartger published in 
165 1, it stands forth as the dominating landmark of the little hamlet 
that occupied the southern end of the Island of Manhattan. The main 
gate of the fort opened on the present Bowling Green, which from 
the earliest days was maintained as an open space. It was, in fact, 
the heart of the old Dutch town. It provided a playground for the 
children, a site for the May-pole around which the youths and 
maidens danced, a parade ground for the soldiers and a place for the 
great market and the annual cattle show. Here, also, those great 
meetings with the Indians were held at which treaties were ar_ 
ranged and the pipe of peace was smoked. (Excursion VII.) 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




NEW YORK'S DEVELOPMENT 

The first streets were laid out in a haphazard manner and the town 
grew np in a random fashion, the first settlers placing their houses 
according to the dictates of their fancy. Thus footpaths and cow- 
paths gradually developed into thoroughfares and produced the tangle 
of streets that characterizes lower New York to this day. Naturally, 
roadways leading to the fort assumed shape at an early date, two main 
paths being established in this wise. One of these paths led to the 
ferry connecting the town with Brooklyn, the other passed north- 
ward in a general way along the center of the island. The first of 
these main roads was practically a shore path following the present 
line of Stone and Pearl Streets and terminating at about the present 
Peck Slip. The second fixed the line of lower Broadway, leading 
northward from the fort as far as Park Row (Tnnes says via Ann 
Street to Park Row), following this and the Bowery and passing on 
finally into the wilderness. A third pathway was developed when 
the palisade was erected along the present line of Wall Street. 




Block-House and City Gate. 

Reproduced by permission from Todd's " The Story of the City of New York 
G. P. Putnam's Sons. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Broad Street, 1663. 

Reproduced by permission from Todd's " The Story of the City of New York ": 
G. P. Putnam's Sons. 

Besides these primitive thoroughfares, two other pathways were 
laid out at an early date. Along the present Broad Street a canal 
extended as far as Beaver Street where it narrowed to a ditch and 
drained a swamp that extended northward to about Exchange Place. 
On either side of the canal because, no doubt, of the pleasant sug- 
gestions of similar scenes at home, the early settlers erected dwellings 
and a promenade was thus established. East and west of the Broad 
Street canal, and intersecting it, there was a second ditch which became 
a pathway and is now known as Beaver Street. 

The origin of Wall Street supplies another interesting chapter to 
the story of New York's old thoroughfares. The wooden wall that 
was erected along the line to which the name still clings was built in 
1653 to protect the town against a threatened invasion of New Eng- 
landers, " a lithe, slippery, aggressive race," whom the Dutch looked 
upon half in fear and half in scorn. The invasion never took place, 
but the wall remained for nearly half a century and succeeded nobly 
in keeping the town from growing beyond its useless barrier. 

6 



t>^€: 




. Ej 




Plate II; Duke's Map, 1661-5 



\l'l..Uol.l 


ir CiiN oTNiu ^oltk ii 


)lll .1 11 ,1 




ii. 


■T^^.^-^------,.- . 




' 



Plate III: Lyne-Bradford Map, 1728 
Photographed frovi H. D. Tyler's Reproductions 



NEW YORK'S DEVELOPMENT 

In the meantime, the Indians inadvertently became the cause of an 
important road development. In the early Dutch days several bouw- 
eries or farms had been established northward of the town, the most 
distant belonging to Governor Stuyvesant, located in the neighborhood 
of Tenth Street and Second Avenue. In 1655, the Indians made a 
number of attacks on the outlying settlers, killing several farmers and 
their wives. As a measure of protection against such atrocities, an 
order was issued commanding all settlers to abandon isolated farms 
and to concentrate in hamlets. This led to the formation of a little 
colony in the neighborhood of Stuyvesant bouwerie and to the devel- 
opment of the road that connected it with the town, called in those 
days the Bouwerie Lane and, subsequently, the Bowery. Three years 
later the murder of a prominent settler who had purchased the flats 
on which the Village of Haarlem was afterwards built, led to the 
establishment of a hamlet in that neighborhood and to the extension 
of the Bouwerie Lane outward to the northern end of the island. 

An interesting representation of New Amsterdam's outlines and 
main thoroughfares has fortunately been preserved in the form of a 
map generally known as " The Duke's Plan," being a draft made in 
1664 for the Duke of York upon the capture of the town by the Eng- 
lish and showing how it looked in 1661 ; the original of the map is in 
the British Museum. 

In course of time, new paths beyond the " Wall " were developed. 
One of these along a rippling stream was called by the Dutch " The 
Maiden's Path," which the English later translated into Maiden Lane. 
Whether this title was due to its service as a lover's lane or, as those 
of a more prosaic nature allege, to its use as a spot where maidens 
went to do the family washing, will remain in obscurity. 

The tendency of the city's growth, as shown by a study of a series 
of the early maps, was northeastward, the western section, together 
with Broadway, remaining undeveloped. A map of 1728 from a sur- 
vey by James Lyne and printed by New York's first printer, William 
Bradford, clearly exhibits the direction of growth. It appears that the 
shipping interests extended along the East River and this factor in- 
fluenced the location of warehouses in the neighborhood, as well as 
the establishment of all sorts of business places near the ferry, in order 
to capture the Long Island trade. Broadway was, in reality, a distant 
and unfrequented part of the town. Near Bowling Green there were 
some five houses, but north of Crown Street (present Liberty Street), 
there was merely a stretch of open fields. On the map this section 
appears as the King's Farm. The story of this farm is an interesting 

7 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

and important chapter in the history of New York and it remains a 
factor to this day. In Dutch days there was a tract between the 
present Fulton and Warren Streets, extending from Broadway west- 
ward to the river, known as the Company's Farm, which was set aside 
to be tilled for the benefit of the Company's civil and military serv- 
ants. When the English came into control, this property became the 
private land of the Duke of York. In 1670, additional land was 
bought from the heirs of Anneke Jans, the farm being then ex- 
tended to about Christopher Street. When the Duke of York be- 
came king this tract was called the King's Farm and subsequently, 
in the days of Anne, the Queen's Farm. In 1705, the entire estate 
was granted to the " English Church in the Island of New York," 
(now Trinity) which still retains possession of it. No doubt this 
very fact, namely that the land belonged to the church, helped to 
prevent the development of that section, the inhabitants naturally 
preferring to build where they could acquire title to the land. 

In the meantime, that portion of Manhattan known to this day as 
Greenwich Village was developing along lines of its own. The 
original village occupied the region between West Tenth Street and 
the present site of Gansevoort Market. Here in the earliest days was 
an Indian settlement selected by the knowing Red Men for its fer- 
tility, good fishing and hunting. The Dutch converted the section into 
a farm and farmers were easily attracted to the fertile spot. For a 
number of years it retained its Indian title of Sappokanican, but 
about the year 1720 the name was changed to Greenwich. It grew in 
popularity and in the course of time became the abiding place of a 
number of prominent people. Naturally, a line of communication was 
established between the town and the village, the Greenwich Road 
along the line practically of the present Greenwich Street being the 
most direct route. This became a fashionable driveway, but owing 
to the fact that it crossed Lispenard's Meadows and Minetta Water 
where there was a causeway, and that after a rain the road became 
very bad, people frequently gave preference to the Bowery, turning 
westward at Astor Place where there was a cross road. 

As has already been mentioned, Greenwich developed along lines 
of its own, the result being that when the city grew up to it and 
streets were joined, a hopeless tangle ensued causing such extraor- 
dinary and startling occurrences as the intersection of West Fourth 
and Tenth Streets. (Excursion II.). 

The picturesque Bloomingdale Road which yielded to the aristo- 
cratic title of Boulevard and subsequently became plain Broadway, 



NEW YORK'S DEVELOPMENT 

was opened in 1703, at which time it extended from about Twenty- 
third Street to One Hundred and Fourteenth Street. In 1795 it 
Was laid out to One Hundred and Forty-seventh Street where it 
formed a junction with the Kingsbridge Road. Bloomingdale, which 
bestowed its pleasantly suggestive name (vale of flowers) upon the 
roadway that traversed its tract of fine estates, covered the space 
from about Madison Square to the neighborhood of One Hundredth 
Street and contained a number of stately mansions nearly all of which 
have been supplanted by crowded modern structures. The name 
survives in the designation " Bloomingdale Square," conferred in 
1906 on the open space in front of the Bloomingdale Reformed 
Church at One Hundred and Sixth Street and Broadway. (Excur- 
sion V.) 

Kingsbridge Road was the old Post Road to Albany and to New 
England. It has disappeared from the modern map. As in the 
case of the Bloomingdale Road, which it joined at One Hundred 
and Forty-seventh Street, continuing northward along the western 
section of the island, its name has been supplanted by that of Broad- 
way. 

The unvarying rectilinear and rectangular plan of streets that con- 
signed Manhattan to its prosaic gridiron was the work of a Com- 
mission consisting of Gouverneur Morris, Simeon De Witt and John 
Rutherford, appointed in 1807. This Commission, after four years 
of prodigious effort, evolved the monotonous scheme that has ef- 
fectively prevented the realization of a city beautiful. Some of the 
remarks of the worthy commissioners are decidedly interesting. 
" Circles, ovals and stars," it seems, strongly tempted them, but they 
did not flinch from their sense of duty. Acknowledging that such 
fanciful forms would certainly embellish a plan, they remembered 
that the city, after all, was to be composed principally of the habita- 
tions of men and that straight-sided and right-angled houses were 
" the most cheap to live in," and the effect of this economic reasoning 
was decisive. 

Referring to another problem with which the commissioners 
A'restled and which disturbed their consciences to a considerable de- 
gree, a statement appears as follows : " It may to many be a matter 
of surprise that so few vacant spaces have been left, and those so 
small, for the benefit of fresh air and consequent preservation of 
health." " Had New York been situated near little streams like the 
Seine or the Thames," reasoned the far-seeing commissioners, " a great 
number of ample spaces might have been necessary, but Manhattan 

9 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

being embraced by large arms of the sea, neither from the point of 
view of health nor pleasure was such a plan necessary. Besides, 

considering the uncommonly great price of land," said the prudent 
commissioners, " it was along the line of duty to be economical." 
Another comment is worth repeating : " To some," they remarked, 
" it may be a matter of surprise that the whole island has not been 
laid out as a city. To others it may be a subject of merriment that 
the commissioners have provided space for a greater population than 
is collected at any spot on this side of China. They have in this 
respect been governed by the shape of the ground. It is not im- 
probable that considerable numbers may be collected at Harlem before 
the high hills to the southward of it shall be built upon as a city; 
and it is improbable that (for centuries to come) the grounds north 
of Harlem Flat will be covered with houses." This was just one 
century ago. Cautious commissioners ! " To have gone further," 
they explained, " might have furnished materials to the pernicious 
spirit of speculation." 



TO 



EXCURSION NO. VII.— NEW YORK CITY, SOUTH OF 
WALL STREET. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley. 

Corrected with the aid of Albert Ulmann, J. H. Innes and Charles 

Hemstreet. 

Capyright, 1898 and 1905, by the City History Club of New York. 
Revised 1908, 1909 and 1912 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate IV. Redrawn from Innes' Map of 1644. C. K. 



(From " New Amsterdam and Its People," by J, IT. Innes. Charles Scribner's 

Sons). 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate V. Routes i, 2, 3, 4. 



c. a; 



13 



BIBLIOGRAPHY 

•* The Dutch Founding of New York," by Janvier. 

" New Amsterdam and Its People," by Innes. 

"A Landmark History of New York," by Ulmann. 

" Nooks and Corners of Old New York," by Hemstreet. 

" When Old New York was Young," by Hemstreet. 

" Literary Landmarks in New York," by Hemstreet. 

"In Old New York" (articles on "The Evolution of New York" 
and "The Battery"), by Janvier. 

"New York Old and New," by R. R. Wilson. 

"The Story of a Street" (Wall Street), by Hill. 

" Felix Oldboy's Walks in Our Churchyards," by Mines. 

" History of Trinity Parish," Dix. 

Reports of the American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society 
(articles on " The Battery," " Castle Garden," " The Fort George 
Latitude Monument," etc.). 

" Historic New York," 2 vols, (papers on " Fort Amsterdam," 
"Bowling Green," "The Stadt Huys," "Old Wells," "Early Wall 
Street," " The New York Press," " Early Schools " and " Governor's 
Island"). 

This Excursion might be called " A walk through New Amsterdam," but for 
the fact that the section once known as New Amsterdam, and bounded by 
Greenwich, State, Pearl and Wall Streets, contains many English and Revolu- 
tionary traces as Vv'ell as those of Dutch interest. 

To complete a survey of Dutch traces, the journey should be continued up 
Broadway, Park Row and the Bowery to the region of Stuyvesant's Bouwerie 
(Excursion III.). 

Before taking this itinerary, read Mr. Ulmann's article, p. 3, 
•* New York's Development." 

See also "The Greatest Street in the World : Broadway," by Stephen 
Jenkins. 

Note. — The * refers to Addenda, 1912, on pages 37, 38. 



Bowling Green MANHATTAN i Route 

ROUTE I. 

SECTION I— AROUND BOWLING GREEN. 

(Figures refer to Plate V; compare with Plates II, III, IV, VI, 
VII, and VIII). 

Take Elevated R. R. or Broadway car to Battery Place, or Subway to 
Bowling Green. 

The original Hudson River Shore Line approximately followed Greenwich 
Street and the line of the Ninth Avenue Elevated Railroad to the vicinity of 
South Ferry Station. Greenwich Street (laid out about 1760) was the shore 
road to Greenwich Village (Excursion II). The niap of 1695 shows palisades 
along Greenwich Street connected at the north with the wall on Wall Street. 
Remains of old posts were dug up when the foundations of the Bowling Green 
Offices were laid. 

Battery Place was the western extension of Marketfield Street 
and derives its name from the battery erected here in English days. 
(Section IV.) Note the old buildings at the foot of Greenwich and 
Washington Streets.* i 

Go up Broadway. 

Broadway was called the Hcere Straat, the Heere Wcgh and the 
Broad Way, and extended to Ann Street where it turned east and up 
Nassau Street to Park Row. 

I. Tablet on the Washington Building, i Broadway, erected by 
the Sons of the Revolution to mark the site of the Kennedy House, 
built about 1760 by Captain Archibald Kennedy, R. N., a member of 
the Governor's Council and Collector of the Port, later eleventh Earl 
of Cassilis. It was occupied during the Revolution by Putnam, 
" King " Sears, Generals Clinton and Carleton, but not by Washing- 
ton, whose headquarters before September 14, 1776, were at Rich- 
mond Hill (Excursion II). Later it was owned by Nathaniel Prime 
and became the Washington Hotel. The Washington Building was 
erected by Cyrus W. Field and from its tower . and roof can be 
gained fine views of the harbor. Robert Fulton died in a house which 
stood just at the rear. 

9 and II Broadway are on the site of the tavern of Martin Cregier, a Dutch 
burgomaster, and of the King's Arms Tavern or Burns' Coffee House, where the 
Non-Importation Agreement was signed by New York merchants in 1766 (by 
some located at 113 Broadway). Benedict Arnold had his quarters here for a 
time. 

Note. So says Valentine, but Innes claims that Cregier's second house was 
on the site of 3 Broadway, and doubts whether he kept tavern here. There is 
also reason to doubt whether the name Burns' Coffee House applied to the 
King's Arms Tavern. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




v^ K 



rt n! 



;5 

Hog 



l6 



Bowling Green MANHATTAN I Route 

2. 17-19 Broadway (see stone lions) was once the British Consulate. 
Here for a time lived Daniel Webster. 

3. 21-27 Broadway, the Stevens House, was built about 1800 by 

Capt. Stevens as three dwellings, later used for business; then as a 

hotel, where Jenny Lind and P. T. Barnum stopped.* la 

Morris Street was the open way to Bayard's Brewery. South of it lay thes 
original Dutch burying ground. On the west side of Broadway were private 
residences during colonial days, and shops on the east side. 

4. Bowling Green, the heart of New Amsterdam and the center 
(north and south) of the Geater New York. Here some believe Peter 
Minuit purchased the Island of Manhattan in 1626. It was known as 
the Plaine and the Marckveldt in Dutch days and later as the Market 
Field and the Parade. Here were held the Dutch weekly market and 
annual kermess, and here the soldiers of the fort paraded. In 1732 
it was ordered fenced in and was leased at one peppercorn a year 
for eleven years to three citizens for a private BozvUng Green, the 
lease being renewed for a second eleven years, at 20 shillings per 
annum.* 2 

The Stamp Act Riot centered here in 1765, when Gov. Colden's 
coach, containing his effigy, was burned. Here, in 1770, was set up 
the gilded leaden equestrian statue of George III (made in London 
by Wilton, who also made a replica), which was torn down by the 
mob July 9, 1776, after the reading of the Declaration of Independence. 
The lead was converted into bullets for the patriots, but the stone 
cap of the pedestal and the tail and bridle of the horse may yet be 
seen in the rooms of the New York Historical Society. The stone 
cap was used as a tombstone to mark the remains of Captain J. 
Smith (see the inscription upon its face), and later was used as 
a doorstep by the Van Voorst family of Jersey City. The leaden 
pieces were dug up on a farm in Connecticut. The head of the 
statue was rescued by Cox, the proprietor of the tavern at Kings- 
bridge, and later given up to the British authorities. 

The iron fence was brought from England in 1771; the iron 
balls crowning the posts were broken off during the Revolution. 

Here the Federal Procession of 1787 was reviewed by Washington, 
and the Federal Ship of State, made and presented by the ship car- 
penters of New York, remained on the Bowling Green until 1789. 
Here, in 1794, occurred a riotous public meeting to protest against 
the Jay Treaty. About 1797 the Green assumed its present oval form. 
See the bronze statue of Abraham de Peyster, Mayor in 1691-5, and 
holder of many colonial offices 1685-1721. It was erected by John 
Watts de Peyster, George E. Bissell, sculptor. 

17 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




i8 



Bowling Green MANHATTAN i Route 

5. Custom House, site of Fort Amsterdam A traders' fort, 
the original log blockhouse of 1615, probably occupied this site. Fort 
Amsterdam was begun in 1626, by Minuit, and was completed in 
1633-5 by a structure of earth and stone with four bastions, the main 
gate opening on the Bowling Green. The fort contained the Director- 
General's house and the Church of St. Nicholas, or the Church in the 
Fort, erected in 1642, and mother of the Collegiate Dutch churches. 
To honor the rulers of the Colony the name of the fort was changed 
successively to James, William Hendrick, William, Anne and George. 

After the demolition of the fort in 1790 the Government House 
was erected here as a presidential mansion, but was occupied by 
Governors Clinton and Jay. Later it was used as a custom house and 
was burned in 1815, when the land was sold and private residences 
erected thereon, which afterwards became known as Steamship Row. 
In 1902-7 the present Custom House was erected, Cass Gilbert, 
architect. See in the Collector's Office an inscription over the fire- 
place stating the history of the site. The statuary on the building 
is by D. C. French and represents the continents and the great 
trading nations of ancient and modern times.* 3 See note p. 22. 

In Battery Park, opposite the west side of the Custom House, 
see the 

6. Fort George Monument, erected in 1818 by the City Cor- 
poration to mark the site of the southwest bastion of Fort George, 
This stone was unearthed during the excavation for the subway and 
was reinstated in 1907 through the action of the American Scenic 
and Historic Preservation Society and the New York Historical So- 
ciety. 

Go down State Street to Whitehall Street, passing 

7. Tablet at 10 Pearl Street, near State Street, erected by the 
Holland Dames of New Netherlands, incorrectly placed here to mark 
the site of the first city hall (see .33). 

8. 7 State Street, now a home for immigrant girls, one of 
the mansions of a century ago, on what was in 1800 one of the 
most fashionable residential streets. 

9 State Street is the site of the home of John Morton, the " rebel banker." 

19 



Route I HISTORICAL GUIDE Bowling 

g. Tablet, at 51 Whitehall Street, erected in 1904 by the 
Mary Washington Colonial Chapter of the Daughters of the Ameri- 
can Revolution, marks the site of Whitehall Ferry, where Washing- 
ton made his departure from New York in 1783. 

Schreyers' Hoek or Capske was the name given to the extreme end of the 
island, in commemoration of the Schreyers' Hoek in Amsterdam from which 
ships set sail for America, Capske Rocks lay just south, beyond the original 
shore line. They were uncovered during the recent excavation for the 
South Ferry subway station. 

Go north on Whitehall Street. 

Whitehall Street was named for 

10. Governor Sfuyrc'esanf's House, erected in 1658, later called the 
White Hall which stood on what is now the southwest corner of 
Pearl and Whitehall Streets. In Dutch times it was called the 
Marckveldt, later Beurs or Exchange Street.* 4 

Perel Straet in Dutch days extended east only as far as Whitehall 
Street, and was probably so called because of the " pearly shells " 
found near it on the beach. It was laid out in 1633 and some of the 
first Dutch houses were built along it, under the guns of the fort. 
Pearl Street east of Whitehall Street was here called the Strand. 
The site of the 

11. First (wooden) Dutch Church wac at 39 Pearl Street, not at 33, as is 
often stated. 

12. Tablet, at 23 Whitehall Street, erected in 1902 by the 
Knickerbocker Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, to 
mark the site of the house of Dominie Bogardus, whose wife, Anneke 
Jans, owned the farm which became the property of Trinity Church. 



Go east on Stone Street. 

Stone Street was first known as Brouwer Straet, because on it was the 
Company's brewery (at No. lo); it was called Stone Street from the fact that 
it was the first New York street to be paved (with cobblestones in 1657). 
Adam Roelandsen taught the first school of New Amsterdam in liis house on 
this street (about No. 7).* 5 

The West India Company's five stone shops were on the site of the Merchants' 
Building. 



Go through the Stone Street entrance of the Produce Exchange, 

20 



Green MANHATTAN i Route 

13. Tablet (on the rear wall of the Produce Exchange, facing 
the court), erected by the Huguenot Society of America to mark 
the site of the first Huguenot Church, built in 1688. 

The White Horse Inn was at the northeast corner of Stone and Whitehall 

Streets. 

14. Marketfield Street is the little street facing the court of 
the Produce Exchange and in Dutch days was known as Marckveldt 
Stccgie -(lane) when it connected with the Marckveldt proper. In 
English days it was called Petticoat Lane, possibly because it was a 
favorite shopping district for the ladies. 

Go north on New Street. 

New Street was so called because opened later than other 
streets in the vicinity (1679). 

Go west on Exchange Place and dozvn Broadway. 

Note the hill, a trace of VerJettenhcrgh (Verlett's Hill), corrupted 
to Flatten Barrack by the English ; once a favorite coasting place. 

15. Tablet, at 50 Broadway, erected by the Society of Archi- 
tecture and Ironmasters of New York, on the Tower Building to 
mark it as the earliest example of a skeleton-frame steel structure, 
originated and designed in 1888-9 by Bradford Lee Gilbert. 

16. Tablet, 41 Broadway, erected by the Holland Society, to 
mark the site of the first white men's houses in Manhattan. They 
were built in 1613 by Adrian Block who, when his ship, the Tiger, 
was burned, built the Unrest near this spot. 

Note. — So says Booth's " History of New York.'* Innes locates this at the 
foot of Roosevelt Street, East River. Tlie brook running to the foot of Roose- 
velt Street was long known as the Old Wreck Brook, and the cove at this part 
of the East River shore might well have furnished shelter to a small craft 
during winter storms. 

39 Broadway is the site of the McComb Mansion, where Washington lived 
in 1790. Note the irregular frontage of buildings north, authorized by the city 
government. 

17. Revolutionary cannon, 55 Broadway, forming part of the 
exterior railing. {Removed, 1912, to he }nountcd in Battery Park.) 

See the statues, by J. Massey Rhind, of Clinton, Wolfe, Stuyvesant 
and Hudson on Exchange Court, 52-56 Broadway. 

21 



Route I HISTORICAL GUIDE Bowling Green 

Go down 

Exchange Alley, by some supposed to be the old Tin Pot Alley 
{Tuyn Faat or Garden Lane), marked by a terra cotta tablet at the 
corner of Broadway. 

Valentine refers the name to 

i8. Edgar Street, connecting Trinity Place and Greenwich 
Street, one of the shortest streets in the city. See old residences and 
the Hotel Gruetli on the west side of Trinity Place. 

Edgar Street led to the Edgar Mansion on Greenwich Street, where April 
8, 1834, Daniel Webster made an address to the people on the inauguration 
of Cornelius VV. Lawrence, first elected Mayor of New York. 

The West India Comf^any's Orchard and Garden occupied the land north of 
Exchange alley and west of Broadway. 

Note (5, p. 19). In the Collector's Office see ten mural paintings 
(1912) by Elmer E. Garnsey of Colonial Ports of the Seventeenth Cen- 
tury; they include old Amsterdam, New Amsterdam and Fort Orange. 



22 



Trinity MANHATTAN a Route 

ROUTE 2. 

SECTION II —TRINITY CHURCH AND WALL STREET. 

19. Trinity Church. Original building 1696-7; burned in the 
great fire of 1776; rebuilt 1788-90; present building 1839-46, Richard 
Upjohn, architect. (See "The Church Farm" in Excursion II). 
The bronze doors designed by St. Gaudens (the gift of W. W. As- 
tor) representing Biblical and local historic scenes, and the Astor 
Reredos (the gift of J. J. and Wm. Astor), In a passageway at 
the north of the Chancel are the effigy of Bishop Onderdonck, me- 
morial windows to other bishops and some stones from the old 
building. In the sacristy at the south side are several pictures and 
memorial tablets including one to a party of Scotchmen who were 
shipwrecked off the coast of Sandy Hook in 1783. 

Among the Trinity tombs not indexed are those of Francis and 
Morgan Lewis, the English governors Sir Henry Moore, Osborne 
and Delancey and the wife of Governor Clarke. Note the elevation 
of the yard above Trinity Place, a trace of the original bluffs 
along the Hudson River shore at this point. 

The Lutheran Church (1671-1776) stood at the corner of Rector Street and 
Broadway, this spot afterwards being the location of Grace Episcopal Churchy 
1808-46. 



23 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




24 



TRINITY CHURCHYARD. 
Index to Monuments in Trinity Churchyard. 



^ 



o ^ 



O 









(U 


C 






^ 


Vi 






v_^ 


c;3 


^"^ 






<u 


B 
o 

H 




o 


£ 






£ 


'c5 


^ 


oJ 


■^ 


Vh 








ID 






o 


o 


■*^ 


« 


Pi 





c 


a 




o 


^ 










"b 


, 




C3 


:=! 




m 


C/5 

o 




Ui 


U 




(U 




/^ — V 


T3 




D 




X! 




rt 


^ 




OJ 

< 


"B 
Q 








o 






o 






c 






4J 






l-i 






^ 






rt 






J 






CO 






<u 




• 


s 




s 


oJ 






>— > 




rt 






^ 


■ .s 


c 




"rt 


rt 


G 






a< 


2 


^ 


a 


O 


o 


U 


U 



OJ 


o 










a 




















3 
_9J 




o 




^• 




(J 


OJ 

c3 












g 


CO 


o 

<-■ 

< 






c 

C 

c 


<u 
u 

^ o 

- 1 

2 S 

56 




to 


d 

C/5 
ID 

u 


o 

< 


OJ 

< 

c75 


60 

.£ 
in 


o 

J- 

< 


G 

o 


CO 

o 


CO 
-^ 



(U 

C 

o 


03 

c 




CO 

a 
Q 


^3 


3 


W 




h4 


^ 


;? 


6 


P^ 




a 


p^ 


CO 




H 


1^ 

CO 

O 


> 


Q 


O 


a; 












Wl 














•£ 


i 


>^ 




'-3 












<U 
















Xj 


^ 
















2 














o 


3 




P. 
1 

a. 

"o 
t— ^ 

1 

CO 


bo 

6 

C 

O 


o 

K 

> 

en 
ri 
in 

bo 
< 


Vh 

pq 

B 
.2 


<l5 

£ 

<u 

H 

4) 

u 


<v 

-g 

u 

u 

d 
< 


U 

5 


1 

<u 
> 

t-< 
bo 


PQ 

c 
•a 


1 

c 
o 

CO 

B 

Ui 




1 




'u 

o 
£ 

""co 


'o 

> 

Pi 
.£ 

bo 

c 


.s 

CO 

a; 

CO 

O 

1 




:<i 




w 





Q 


W 


p^; 




d 


ffi 




t-i 




»T> 




















25 





















Route 2 HISTORICAL GUIDE Wall 

Go east on 

Wall Street, so' called from the palisade built in 1653 by Stuy- 
vcsant to defend New Amsterdam, and removed in 1699 when some 
of the material was worked into the new City Hall. The Land 
Poort, or gate, was at Broadway and the Water Poort at Pearl Street 
where a Half Moon Battery was located. Bastions stood on the sites 
of the rear of Trinity Churchyard, 4 Wall Street, the Sub-Treasury, 
44 Wall Street and the head of Hanover Street. In 1673 the western 
line of the palisade was turned south to the shore at Rector Street, 
the wall was surveyed and Wall Street officially established in 1685 
by Governor Dongan.* 7 

20. Site of the First Presbyterian Church, just east of the head 
of New Street. Here Jonathan Edwards and George Whitefield 
preached. The building was used as a hospital by the British during 
the Rcvolntion. (Excursion II, 17, and Excursion V, Section i:io.) 

Note the jog in the sidewalk at the northwest corner of Nassau 
Street (old Picwoman's Lane or Kip Street) over which Federal 
Hall projected. 

21. The Sub-Treasury, on the site of the Colonial City Hall 
(i(>99-i8i2). riie old building contained the Court Rooms, Common 
Council Chamber, jail, a debtors' prison, accommodations for • the 
fire department and a library, the predecessor of the New York So- 
ciety Library. In front, at the head of Broad Street, stood the cage, 
pillory, stocks and whipping post. Here was won the Zenger Case 
securing the freedom- of the press, and here, in 1765, the Stamp Act 
Congress met. In 1785 it was used as the State Capitol and here the 
Continental Congress met. In 1788 the building was reconstructed 
by Major Pierre Charles I'Enfant (who later planned the City of 
Washington) and was known as Federal Hall. It was used by the 
first Congress under the Constitution. Here Washington took the 
oath of office on April 30, 1789. When the capital was removed to 
Philadelphia, this building became the State Capitol and so remained 
luilil 1797. 

Hero, in 1804. the New York Historical Society was founded. In 
.1812 the builduig was torn down and the present building erected 
as the Custom House which in 1862 was remodeled for a Sub- 
Treasury Note the statue of Washington by J. Q. A. Ward, erected 
in 1W3 by public subscription under the auspices of the Chamber 

26 



Street 



MANHATTAN 



2 Route 




27 



Route 2 HISTORICAL GUIDE Wall 

of Commerce At the foot of this statue there was formerly a great 
.I'lb of brown stone on which Washington stood while taking the 
oith of office. It has been enclosed in a bronze frame, covered with 
Plas. and placed upon the south wall of the interior of the buildmg. 
Part of the railing of the balcony from which Washington delivered 
his first inaugural address is in the building of the New York His- 
torical Society and a second part is in front of Bellevue Hospital. The 
tablet on the west front of the Sub-Treasury was erected in 1905 by 
the Ohio Company of Associates to commemorate the passage by the 
Congress here assembled in 1787 of the Ordinance of 1787, and the 
purchase by the Ohio Company of Associates of lands in the North- 
west Territory on which, in 1788, they made their first settlement at 
Marietta. 

The tablet on the east front represents Washington in prayer ,at 
Valley Forge (presented by John T. Clancy; J. E. Kelley, sculptor), 
erected February 22, 1907, by Lafayette Post, No. 140, G. A. R. 

22. The U. S. Assay Office, 32 Wall Street, built in 1823 pn 
the site of the Verplanck mansion, formerly used as the United Sta^s 
Rank and Treasury, is the oldest federal building now standing jin 
Manhattan. Alexander Hamilton's law ofifice stood at 33 (formetily 
57) Wall Street, on the site of the Mechanics' National Bank. 

23. Bank of the Manhattan Company, 40 Wall Street, the 
second oldest bank of New York, founded by the Manhattan Com- 
pany in i7oq which, by the aid of Aaron Burr, was chartered ostensibly 
to sui)ply New York with drinking water. Within the bank is a piece 
of the old wooden water pipe; the Manhattan water tank still stands 
on Centre Street, near Duane (Excursion 111:23). 

The Merchants' Bank, 42 Wall Street, is the third oldest bank, 
or>^.ini/.c(l ill 1S03. 

24. The corner stone ot' the Bank of New York is at the 
nf)riheast corner of Wall and William Streets and bears the followi'tig 
inscription : " This corner-stone of the Bank of New York was laid 
June 22, 1797, by Gulian Verplanck, Esq., the President, Geo. Doolett, 
Architect." This is the oldest New York bank and one of the oldest 
three iji the United States. It was founded by Alexander Hamilt«)n 
and otliers in 1784. at the Merchants' ColTee House.* 7 'I 

On the corner of Wall and William Streets (near Governor Tryon's 
house) stood the marble statue of William Pitt, erected: there in 
1770 to honor his defence of the rights of the colonists. It was 

28 



Street MANHATTAN 2 Route 

mutilated by British soldiers and may now be seen in the building of 
the New York Historical Society. 

At 52 Wall Street, in the Directors' Room of the New York Life 
Insurance and Trust Company, is the corner stone of the United 
States Branch Bank, which formerly occupied this site. The stone 
is dated June 13, 1797. 

25. Tablet, 56 Wall Street, erected by the Canadian Society 
of New York, in 1903, to commemorate Morris Robinson, first 
president of the Mutual Life Insurance Company of New York, who 
here established the business of modern life insurance on the American 
Continent. 

26. The old U. S. Custom House (now remodeled and the 
property of the National City Bank) occupies the site of the Mer- 
chants' Exchange (burnt in the fire of 1835) ; became the Custom 
House in 1862. 

27. Tontine Building, Wall Street, between Pearl and Water 
Streets, is on the site of the Tontine Coffee House (1793) where the 
Chamber of Commerce and many other organizations met. 

The Merchants' Coffee House was erected in 1740 on the southeast 
corner, and the region was known as Coffee House Slip. Here were 
held several important demonstrations by the patriots before the 
Revolution. 

28. Site of the Meal Market, also used as a city slave market, in 
the middle of Wall, near Water Street. Washington landed at Mur- 
ray's Wharf near by, April 23, 1789, when he came to be inaugurated. 

Note, 1912: The Assay Office (22, p. 28) is to be torn down in 1913 
to make way for a larger structure for the same uses. 



2Q 



Route 3 HISTORICAL GUIDE Pearl Street 

ROUTE 3 

SECTION III.-PEARL AND BROAD STREETS. 

This part of Pearl Street was in early days known as the Road to 
the Ferry. 

Go south on Pearl Street. 

29. At 119-121 Pearl Street lived Gen. Jean Victor Moreau, 
who tried to assassinate Napoleon Bonaparte. Captain Kidd lived on 
the same site about 1691. 

Hanover Square, named for George I of Hanover, was the 
fa~hi. .liable center, and "Printing House Square" of English New 
V'^rk. 

30. Tablet on Cotton Exchange, erected by the New York 
Historical Society, to mark the site of the first New York newspaper 
office, Bradford's New York Gazette, 1725. Other papers were pub- 
lished near by. 

William Street (named for William of Orange, later William 
III). I. el ween Stone and Pearl Streets, was Burger's Path. North of 
Stone Street it was Sniee or Smith Street, opened 1656-7. 

31. Marble tablet, 90 Pearl Street, commemorates the great 
fire of 1835, which destroyed $20,000,000 worth of property, between 
Wall Street (the old Merchants' Exchange) and Coenties Slip, and 
led to the more rapid completion of the Croton Aqueduct. 

32. Tablet, 81 Pearl Street, erected by the New York Historical 
Society, marks the site of Bradford's first printing press (1693). 

^:^. Tablet, 73 Pearl Street, erected by the Holland Society, to 
mark the site of Kieft's Stadt Herbergh or Tavern (1641-2), which 
1)1 came tlie Stadt Hitys, or first City Hall of New York (1653-4). 

Coenties Alley, or Sladt Htiys Lane, is the original street from 
the shore to Iloogh (Stone) Street. The Stadt Huys was used as 
a jail, debtors' prison, court house, city hall and public storehouse. 
Governor Lovelace had a tavern next door. A well, pillory and stocks 
were located on the river shore in front of the Stadt Huys. 

34. Coenties Slip is named for Conraet ("Coenties") Ten 
l.yck. who lived here. The "Slip" was not filled in until about 1835, 
iiid the site is occupied by Jeannette Park, named for the Herald 
Arctic K.xpedition .ship. Part of the Erie Canal fleet lies here.*S 

35. Fraunces Tavern, 54 Pearl Street, corner of Broad Street 
<^sec Excursion VI). 

Ale^" lJim*''"Eichair/c. "''"'''^ ^^'"*' ^"'^ ^''^"'^ Fraunces Tavern, was the first 

30 



Broad Street MANHATTAN 3 Route 

Opposite Fraunces Tavern, to the west, see the Bush Terminal 
Company's building; style, eleventh century Gothic, with gargoyles 
of old mariners' heads (as the upper floor is occupied by the " Jolly 
Mariners" dining club). 

Pearl Street was the original shore line from the east side of Whitehall 
Street north. At the foot of Broad (near Pearl) Street the Great Dock was 
located in Governor Dongan's time. Gradually the shore line was extended to 
Water, Front and South Streets, but the work was not completed until after 
the Revolution. 

Go Up Broad Street. 

" Blommaert' s Vly " was a swampy region, extending along Broad Street from 
Exchange Place to South William Street, originally imperfectly drained by a 
creek running through the present Broad Street, which the Dutch converted 
into a ditch in 1647 and the Heere Gracht or canal in 1657. A street was laid 
out on either side of the canal, and it became a favorite residence district. 
After becoming a public nuisance, it was filled in in 1676. Traces of the swamp 
are found during the construction of tall buildings, it being necessary to ex- 
cavate many feet to secure solid foundations. At Bridge Street a small bridge 
crossed the canal. Stone Street, east of Broad Street, was the Dutch Hoogh 
or High Street, in English days Duke Street, connecting with Pearl Street at 
Hanover Square, as part of the old Road to the Ferry. 

Beaver Street, called Bever Gracht, led to the swamp in Broad Street, and 
was drained by a small canal or ditch. 

Go east on South William Street. 

36. Site of the Horse Mill or Bark Mill, 32-34 South William Street. 
This was one of the first mills built by the West India Company (1626). In 
its upper story were held the first regular religious services (1628-33) of the 
Dutch Church. Here, August 29, 1664, '* by eight of the clock in the morning, 
at the Old Mill," took place the final exi:hange of the documents marking the 
surrender of New Amsterdam to the English (Innes). It was later used by the 
Jews until they erected their first synagogue on the opposite side of the street. 
For a time the building or a part of it was occupied by the negro slaves of 
the West India Company. 

2,7. Mill Stones in the rear of i8 South William Street (or of 
40 Beaver Street) supposed to have been used in this mill. Two of 
these stones have been placed in the foundation of the Temple 
Shearith Israel at 99 Central Park West, in commemoration of this 
first synagogue. 

Note. — So say some writers, but Innes states that the Jews never occupied 
Bark Mill and that their synagogue was on the north side of the street and 
several doors east of the old mill. He also believes that the present mill stones 
came from a later mill in this vicinity (see article on "The Bark Mill" in 
the " Quarterly Federation of Churches," Vol. Ill, No. 5, 1905). 

38. " Mill Lane," also known as Ellets' or Elliotts' Alley (con- 
necting South William with Stone Street), was opened in 1656-7 to 
connect Slyck Steegh with Hoogh Street. At 13 South William 
Street see house built in imitation of the old Dutch " crow-step " 
style. 

31 



Route 3 HISTORICAL GUIDE Broad Street 

Go west on Beaver Street 

39. Ancient marble columns (brought from Pompeii) at the en- 
•rance of the Dchiionico Building, South WiUiam and Beaver Streets. 

40. Marinus Willett Tablet, northwest corner of Broad and 
Beaver Streets, erected in 1892 by the Sons of the Revohition to 
mark the site of the seizure of arms by the Sons of Liberty from 
British soldiers, June 6, 1775. See representation on the tablet of old 
Broad Street and Federal Hall and the medallion head of Willett. 

Go north on Broad Street, passing 

41. Site of the New or South Dutch Church on Tuyen or Garden 
Street (now Exchange Place) between Broad and William Streets, 
built in 1691-3, adjoining the land of the widow of Dominie Drisius. 
The land just below Wall Street, between Broadway and Pearl Street, 
was used by the Dutch as the first common or Schaap Waytie. 

42. New York Stock Exchange, organized in 1792 by a group 
"f brokers who met first under a buttonwood tree in front of 70 
Wall Street, and held daily meetings a few months later at the 
Tontine Coffee House (see 27). 

After meeting in various places the present site, 10-12 Broad Street, 
was purchased in 1863. Traces of the old swamp made the con- 
truction of the present building (opened 1903) a difficult engineer- 
ing feat. 

The architect of the present building was George B. Post and the 
sculptor of the pediment (typifying the movement of American com- 
nurce) was J. Q. A. Ward. 



3^ 



i 



Battery MANHATTAN 4 Route 



ROUTE 4. 

SECTION IV— THE BATTERY AND GOVERNOR'S 

ISLAND. 

Take Elevated R. R. to Battery Place or Subway to Bowling Green 
and walk west. 

The original Battery was a line of cannon extending from the 
foot of Greenwich Street to the intersection of Whitehall and' Water 
Streets. The work was begun by Governor Fletcher (1693) *^nd 
strengthened about 1750. The land beyond this line was under water 
until after 1800. 

43, The Aquarium, built about 1807-11 as the South West Bat- 
tery, to defend New York, Land under water was ceded to the 
Congress by the city for this purpose. The fort, about 300 feet from 
shore, later called " Castle Clinton," was built on a mole and con- 
nected with the city by a bridge. The embrazures for the 30 heavy 
guns may still be seen. In 1822 it was ceded to the State and in 
1823 leased to the city and in 1824 was leased as a public amuse- 
ment hall, known as Castle Garden. It was roofed over, and was the 
scene of Lafayette's reception in 1824. In 1847 it became an opera 
house. Here Jenny Lind sang (1850) and Kossuth (1851) was re- 
ceived. In 1855 it became the Immigration Bureau (until 1891), and 
soon afterAvard the remainder of the Battery Park was filled in. 
In i8g6 the building was opened as an Aquarium, and was transferred 
in 1902 to the care of the New York Zoological Society. It is open 
free daily including Sundays (except Monday forenoons), from 10 
A. M. until 4 p. M. in winter and from 9 a. m. until 5 p. m. in summer. 

See within tablets, pictures of the orignal interior, bombproofs, 
the old fireplace in the cellar and the original casemates. LTpstairs see 
a blue platter presented by the Misses Earle, showing the fort in 
1815. Note the great doors and sentry's exit.* 9, 10 

44. Statue of John Ericsson (by Hartley, and presented by him 
to the city in 1903), the inventor of the Monitor, which defeated the 
Confederate ironclad Virginia (or Merritnac), at Hampton Roads on 
March 9, 1862, and thereby saved New York from bombardment. See 
the commemorative tablets on the sides, representing the chief in- 
ventions of Ericsson. 

33 



Route 4 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Governor's 



MAP OF 
G0/£/im/l5 ISLAND 



3ection4 Excursion V/l / 




£Ar£fyfS/OA/ TO &0y£/ZA/0^3 ISLA/Vn 



,.•>■ 



c*'' 



# 



s" 



Plate VII. Governor's Island. 



C. K. 



45. Flagstaff, a little south of the site where Van Arsdale tore 
down the British flag from the greased pole and raised the American 
Flag on h'vaciiation Day, November 25, 1783. During the tunnel 
excavation tliere have been found remains of the pier and plank 
road connecting with the original shore, built by Commodore Vander- 
bili for his steam ferry to Staten Island.* 11 

-1'.. Governor's Island. (Secure pass several days in advance 
from Commandant, h'ort Jay.) 

The Indian n.imc of the inland (about 65 acres, exclusive of the recently 
•' m.Kic l.iiul ") was I'dRgaiick. and tlie Dutch Nooten, or Nut Island: it was 
biJUKhf in 1637 from tht.- Indians by Woutcr Van Twiller. Here he built a 
Bawmill an<l pastured Roats. In 1698 it was set aside by the Assembly for 
llic benefit of the royal K..vernors, hence its present name. It was temporarily 
n quarantine station for C.crman Protestants or Palatines in 1710. In 1730 it 
teramc iwrt of New York City and in 1788 of the County of New York. In 
1755 Sir VNni. Pepi.(r« IPs rcKunent en route for Canada was quartered here. 
In April, 1776. C (ilontl IVcscott's Runker Hill repiment of Continental troops 
occupied the isl;:nd and threw up fortilications which they held until after the 

34 



Island MANHATTAN 4 Route 

Battle of Long Island, when all retreated in safety to Manhattan. The British 
held it from 1776 to 1783. Little remains of the old works except the well on 
the eastern side. In 1790 Columbia College was given jjossession of tlie island 
for a time with the right to lease it for a term of twenty-one years. The 
present fortifications were begun about 1794 and completed in 1812. Fort 
Columbus replaced part of the old works in 1809 and Castle Williams was com- 
pleted in 181 1. In 1800 the island was ceded by the State to the Federal gov- 
ernment, and in 1821 it became a military headquarters. In 1852 it was the 
chief depot of the United States Recruiting Service and military prisoners were 
confined here during the Civil War. In 1878 the island became the head- 
quarters of the Department of the East. 

Take Governor's Island Ferry, near the Barge OMce. 

After landing, take central path, passing on the left the department 
offices and on the right piles of old ordnance. The Military Museum 
contains many relics of former wars. 

Fort Jay (old Fort Columbus) has a well preserved moat, draw- 
bridge, parapet and guns. The barracks here are still in use. 

Castle Williams is used as a military prison.* 12 

Note the Saluting Battery on the south shore. Much land has 
been reclaimed from the bay. The South East Battery is a small 
work well preserved. 

The Chapel of St. Cornelius contains several trophies and com- 
memorative banners. The house of the Commander of the De- 
partment of the East is on the old Parade Ground, flanked by two 
cannon. 

Interesting water trips may also be made from the Battery to the 
Statue of Liberty (boats hourly, 25 cents), on Bedloe's or 
Liberty Island. This island was patented to Isaac Bedloe by Governor 
Nicoll when it was known as Oyster Island (called for a short time 
Love Island). Captain Kennedy became the proprietor after the 
death of Bedloe. In 1758 the island was purchased by the city for a 
small-pox hospital. About 1800 it was ceded to the United States. 
Fort Wood was built here as a defence for the city. Within the 
star-shaped fort is the Statue of Liberty, by Bartholdi, completed in 
1883 and presented by France. The pedestal was erected by popular 
subscription in the United States ; the statue was unveiled in 1886. 
Note the view from the head of the statue over the Bay, Staten 
Island, Long Island, Manhattan and New Jersey.* 13 

Ellis Island (pass secured from the Commissioner of Immigration; 
boats frequently from Pier i, North River). 

In Dutch days this was a favorite resort for oyster feasts, hence 
called Oyster Island. Later it was known as Gibbet Island from 
Ae fact that a pirate by the name of Gibbs was hung there. It was 
sold by the State to the National Government in 1808 and was long 
occupied by a magazine. In 1891 it became an immigrant station and, 
after a fire in 1897, the present buildings were erected. 

35 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




36 



MANHATTAN 



ADDENDA— 1912 

* I. (p. 15) No. 13 Greenwich Street was once the United States 
Hotel: see marble pillars. 

No. 15 Greenwich Street was the Punta Rossa House, the name of 
which may still be deciphered. 

No, 27 Greenwich Street was an old mansion of which the massive 
fiont door remains. 

* I a. (p. 17) The Stevens House was the original Delmonico's res- 
taurant. Burr is said to have occupied the old house. No. 5 Morris 

' Street. 

*2. (p. 17) A stained glass window in the Bowling Green Building, by 
E. A. Abbey, represents Dutchmen rolling ninepins here, but there are 
no records to prove that bowling was done here before 1732, when the 
English game was played. 

* 3. (p. 19) There are three tablets on the Custom House: 

(i) (on the west side of the entrance staircase), erected 19 12 by the 
Order of the Alhambra, to mark the site of the first mass said on the 
island of Manhattan, in the Governor's residence, in 1683, by the Rev. 
Thomas Harvey, S.J., chaplain to Governor Dongan. 

(2) (next to i) erected by the New York State Society of the Order 
of Founders and Patriots of America in 1909, to mark the site of Fort 
Amsterdam, later Fort George, the exploration of the Hudson River, 
the founding of New Amsterdam, and the establishment of American 
independence; on the tablet is inscribed an outline of Fort George from 
a plan made in 1774 by Gerard Bancker. 

(3) (within the rotunda) erected by the Holland Society of New 
York, originally placed in 1890 on a building in Steamship Row, to mark 
the site of the first substantial church edifice on the island of Manhattan 
and of Government House. 

* 4. (p. 20) Old buildings at Nos. i and 2 State Street, corner of White- 
hall, used until 1912 by the Seamen's Church Institute. These were 
residences of the Cole family before 1800 and are still owned by their 
descendants. 

The Eastern Hotel, one block below at No. i South Street, was a 
warehouse, originally two stories high, erected in 1796 by John Cole, 
flour merchant and captain of a packet ship. The beams are of solid 
mahogany brought over from South America in ballast. The building was 
reconstructed as a hotel and opened in 1822 as the Eagle Hotel under the 
management of Frank Foot, a relaf ve of Daniel Webster. Here were 

37 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

entertained Robert Fulton, Jenny Lind, Daniel Webster, Commodore 
Vanderbilt and other notables. 

* 5 (p. 20) 12' Tablet in the court of the Produce Exchange, facing 
Stone Street, erected 1910 by the New York Schoolmasters' Club to mark 
the site of the school of Adam Roelantsen, 1638. 

* 6. (p. 25) It is claimed that the body of Lord Sterling has been 
removed from this grave. The body of Fulton is to be removed, to the 
Fulton Water Gate on Riverside Drive. The body of Philip Kearny 
was removed April 11, 1912, to Arlington, Va., after lying in state in 
Trinity Church and City HaU. The Statues of the Evangelists in the 
tower were the gift of Mr. and Mrs. Whitehouse; see tablet erected in 
the porch of the tower in 1901. 

* 7. (pp. 26 and 28) 23' Tablet at 48 Wall Street, erected 1909 by 
Uie Society of Colonial Wars in the State of New York to mark a bastion 
of the WaU. 

* 8. (p. 30) Lantern and Memorial Tablet to commemorate the 
fidelity of the officers and crew of the steamer Titanic (destroyed 19 12 
by an iceberg) to be erected by public subscription on the new building 
of the Seaman's Institute at the foot of Coenties SUp in 1912-13 

Sec good specimens of early cannon at No. 61 Front Street, between 
Old Slip and Cuyler's Alley. An old cannon is set in the ground at the 
comer of Water Street and Old Slip. 

* 9- (p- 33) Tablet on the west wall north of the entrance, erected 
1909 by the New York Zoological Society to mark events of importance 
in ctmncction with the history of the Aquarium. 

Tablets within, erected by the City, to commemorate the acquisition, 
1896, f)f this building by the Park Department for an Aquarium, 

* ID. (p. 33) 43' Statue of Verrazzano, east of the Aquarium, 
erected I9(^, by Italian residents of New York City, to commemorate 
the visit of Veriazzano in 1524 to New York Harbor. 

* II. (p. 34) The present flagstaff was originally a steel mast from 
the yacht Constitulion. 

* '2. (p. 35) Castle Williams was built in 1809-181 1 by Gen. Jonathan 
Williams, Chief ICnginctr of the American Army, as a defence in the War 
of 18 1 2. Gen. Williams also built or supervised the construction of 
Castle Clinton and Fort Lafayette. 

* '3- (p. 35) Tablet witliin the entrance to the pedestal of the Statue 
of Lil)crty, erected by Georgina Scliuyler to the memory of Emma 
Lizarus, who in 1883 wrote The New Colossus. 

33 



EXCURSION NO. VI.~FRAUNCES TAVERN. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley. 

Corrected with the aid of Edward Hagaman Hall, Secretary of the 

American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society and 

Henry Russell Drowne, Secretary of the 

Sons of the Revolution. 

• Copyright, 1898 and 1905, by the City History Club of New Yorkc- 
Revised 1912 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




JJrauiTi hy 27<iuiarcl I[a</ttinein 2Ten7i jS03 



I'LAiK \ III. Mai- (»f thk City of New York Below Wall Street, 

SH(»\VIN(; AUTIKRL\L CiROWTH OF THE WaTER-FRONT. 



40 



MANHATTAN 3 Route 

FRAUNCES TAVERN SITE. 

The site on which Fraunces Tavern stands was originally on or nearly on 
the edge of the shore line of the East River, subsei|uently extended two or 
more blocks by the filling-in process. In or before 1671 it came into the i)os- 
session of Col. Stephen Van Cortlandt, son of Oloff Stevenson Van Cortlandt, 
a soldier of the Dutch West India Company, who arrived at New Amsterdam 
in 1637 and was appointed Commissary or Superintendent of Cargoes at the 
Port of New Amsterdam. In 1642 he married Annetje Loockerman, sister of 
the leading merchant of New Amsterdam and an Indian trader. He estab- 
lished a brewery on " Brouwer (brewery) Straat " now Stone Street, about 
1648, was Burgomaster 1655-65 and one of the Commissioners to arrange for 
the surrender of New Amsterdam. His descendants were lords of Van Cort- 
landt Manor. Col. Stephen Van Cortlandt built a cottage on the corner of 
Broad and Dock (later Queen), now Pearl Street, in 1671 and brought his 
young wife, Gertrude Schuyler, here to live. The "Gracht" or Canal lay in front 
of the house until it was filled up in 1678. In 1700 he deeded his property to his 
son-in-law, Etienne (or Stephen) DeLancey, a Huguenot nobleman and an active 
merchant in the city. 



INDEX TO PLATE VIII. 

4. I Broadway, site of the Kennedy House. 

5. Site of gilded equestrian statue of George HI. 

6. Site of Governor Stuyvesant's house, erected 1658, later called 
the " White Hall." 

7. Head of Whitehall Ferry slip, as shown on Ratzer's map, 1767. 

8. Head of Whitehall Ferry slip, as shown on Hill's map, 1782; 
place where Washington embarked after his farewell in Fraunces 
Tavern, 1783. 

9. Fraunces Tavern. 

10. 73 Pearl Street, site of Stadt Huys. 

11. 81 Pearl Street, site of first printing press In the Colony of 
New York. 

12. Scene of capture of British arms by Marinus Willet, June 6, 

1775- 

13. Site of publication of first newspaper in New York. 



Route 3 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Fraunces 




1'Okmek Appearance of Fraunces Tavern. 

Copied from Valentine's Manual of the Corporation of New York of 1854. 



Fraunces Tavern is one of the oldest buildings in New York City 
and was tlie scene of many stirring events during the Revolutionary 
Period. It divides honors with St. Paul's Chapel, Washington's 
Headquarters, and the Van Cortlandt Mansion in its connection 
with memories of Washington in New York. The building has 
recently been restored to its original proportions and is now open 
daily U) tile public. 

Location: Southeast corner of Broad and Pearl Streets, en- 
trance on I'earl Street. Take Subway or surface cars down Broadway 
to the lUnvliuu Green; walk east to Broad Street and south to the 
Tavern; or take west-side lUerated lines to Battery Place and thence 
cast to liroad Street. 

See tablet on the P.roa<l Street side, a memorial to Frederick 
Sanuii'l Talhnadge, through whose beneficence the restoration by the 
St'iiN of the l\i\ (.luticiii \v;is made possible. 

4^ 



Tavern MANHATTAN 3 Route 

CHRONOLOGY. 

1719. — Built by Etienne DeLancey as a residence. It descended to his 
son, Judge and Governor James DeLancey, and to his son, 
Oliver DeLancey. At some time before 1757, it became the 
residence of Col. Joseph Robinson, partner of Oliver DeLancey, 
James DeLancey having moved to his mansion on site of 
present No. 113 Broadway. (Excursion I, 25.) 

1757. — It became the store and warehouse of DeLancey, Robinson & 
Co., who announced in Gaines' Mercury, May 28, 1757, that 
they had " moved into Col. Robinson's late dwelling next to 
the Royal Exchange, and should there continue to sell all sorts 
European and East Indian goods — shoes, shirts, white and 
checked, for the army, with a variety of other goods." 

1762. — January 15. — Purchased by Samuel Fraunces, called *' Black 
Sam," from his swarthy appearance, he being a West Indian. 
Fraunces had been made a " freeman " of New York while 
an innkeeper in 1755. He opened here the Queen's Head or 
Queen Charlotte Tavern, named in honor of the young consort 
of George III. 

1765. — Leased to John Jones as a tavern, while Fraunces for a time 
took charge of Vauxhall Gardens. (Excursion I, 21.) 

1766. — Leased by Bolton & Sigell (Sigel). 

1768. — April 8. — The Chamber of Commerce, composed of twenty- 
four importers and merchants, organized, with John Cruger as 
President, in the Long Room, so called in imitation of the long 
Indian lodges used for tribal meetings. Monthly meetings of 
the Chamber were held for some time "at Bolton & Sigel's, 
precisely at the usual hour, six-thirty." 

1769. — Richard Bolton alone in charge. One or more meetings were 
held to consider the passagei of a second Non-Importation Agree- 
ment. (Wilson's Memorial History, II, 39I-7-) 

1770. — Fraunces again In possession of the Queen's Head Tavern, 
" refitted in the most genteel and convenient manner for the 
reception and entertainment of those gentlemen, ladies and others 
who used to favor him with their company," dinners and suppers 
being served "not only to lodgets but to those who live at a 
convenient distance." The Long Room was also used for a 
series of lectures. 

43 



Route 3 HISTORICAL GUIDE Fraunces 

,-7,_ Vprii_Thc Sons of Liberty and the Vigilance Committee met 
' here to protest, as the ship London had just docked at the wharf 
of the East India Company in the vicinity of Fraunces lavern 
with a cargo of tea. The meeting resuhed in those who partici- 
pated marching to the dock, where the entire cargo was thrown 
t)verbuard. 
,774._May 14.— A meeting of merchants was held here to organize 
the "Committee of Correspondence," to whose firm and coiv 
sistent adherence to the idea of union, the Continental Congress 
owed its origin. (Wilson, II, p. 434-) It was also the head- 
quarters of the Social Club, among whose members were John 
Jay, Gouverneur Morris, R. R. Livingston and Morgan Lewis. 

l775._Thc Massachusetts delegates to the Second Continental Con- 
gress stopped here on their way to Philadelphia. 

l775._August 23.— The building was struck by a shot from the man- 
of-war Asia, giving rise to the oft-quoted lines of Philip Freneau : 

" Scarce a broadside was ended till 'nother began again, 
By Jove,! It was nothing but fire away, Flanagan! 
Some thought him saluting his Sallys and Nancys, 
'Till he drove a round shot through the roof of Sam Francis." 

TA. of 1786 reads: 

" At first we supposed it was only a sham. 

Till he drove a round ball through the roof of black Sam." 

1776. — Fraunces' daughter Phoebe revealed the plot to assassii ate 
Washington, leading to the execution of her lover, Hickey, who 
was a British deserter and had become one of Washington's 
bodyguard. At the time Phoebe was acting as housekeeper 
for the Commander at his headquarters in the Richmond Hill 
Mansion (Excursion II). Fraunces joined the American army, 
and it is supposed that he had to give up the Tavern during the 
British occupancy of New York, but he assumed ownership im- 
mediate'' v after the war and continued in possession for some 
years, in jtS*; he became Washington's steward. 

1783-— November 25.— Governor George Clinton gave a banquet on 
Evacuation Day to General Washington, the French ambassador, 
Chevalier de la Luzerne, and many Revolutionary officers and 
civilians. Thirteen toasts were given, beginning with "The 
United States of America" and ending with "May This Day 
Be a Lesson for l*rinces." JMieworks followed on the BowHng 
Green. 

44 



Tavern . MANHATTAN 3 Route 

1783. — December 4. — Washington's Farewell to forty-four officers, in- 
cluding Generals Greene, Knox, Wayne, Steuben, Carroll, Lincoln, 
Kosciusko, Moultrie, and Hamilton, Governor Clinton, Colonel 
Tallmadge and others. Says Colonel Tallmadge, in original jour- 
nal, now at Fraunces Tavern : 

" We had been assembled but a few minutes when His Excellency entered the 
room. His emotion, too strong to be concealed, seemed to be reciprocated by 
°very officer present. After partaking of a slight refreshment amid almost 
b/eathless silence, the General filled his glass with wine and turning to his 
officers said: 'With a heart full of love and gratitude I must now take my 
leave of you. I most devoutly wish that your latter days may be as pros- 
perous and happy as your former ones have been glorious and honorable.* 
Atler the officers had taken a glass of wine, the General added: 'I cannot 
come to each of you to take my leave, but shall be obliged to you if each will 
come and take me by the hand.' General Knox, being nearest to him, turned 
to the Commander-in-Chief, who, suffused in tears, was incapable of utterance, 
but grasped his hand, when they embraced each other in silence. In the same 
affectionate manner every officer in the room marched up to, kissed and parted 
with his General-in-Chief. Such a scene of sorrow and weeping I had never 
before witnessed, and hope I may never be called upon to witness again. Not 
a word was uttered to break the solemn silence that prevailed, or to interrupt 
the tenderness of the occasion." 

Thence Washington proceeded to the Whitehall Ferry (Excursion 
VII :g) and took his departure from the city. 

1785. — The Tavern was sold by Fraunces and came into various 
hands. After the Revolution the St. Andrew's Society, the 
Governors of the New York Hospital, the New York Society 
and the Society for Promoting Arts and Agriculture, all met 
here. Balls were also held in the Long Room. 

183 . — Interior partly burnt out and a flat roof added. 

1837. — Leased by John Gardner, a hotel proprietor who had been burnt 
out in the great fire of 1835. 

1844. — The New York Yacht Club was founded here. 

1852, June 15.— While called the Broad Street House and kept by E. 
Beaumeyer, the Tavern was visited by a very disastrous fire, 
after which two stories were added, making it five stories high. 
Further alterations were made about 1890, when the taproom 
was lowered to the level of the street and the ground floor win- 
dows modernized. 

1883, December 4. — On the looth anniversary of Washington's 
Farewell the Society of the Sons of the Revolution was formally 
organized in the Long Room and met here annually for many 
years. ^ 

45 



Route 3 HISTORICAL GUIDE Fraunces 

THE PRESERVATION OF FRAUNCES TAVERN. 

1889-1903.— At the time of the centennial celebration of Washington's 
inauguration (1889), attention was directed to the interesting 
associations of the building, and during the next thirteen years 
the Sons of the Revolution made 'several efforts to purchase 
the property in order to preserve and restore it. Efforts were 
also made by patriotic individuals and societies to insure its 
preservation. These finally resulted, in 1903, in the passage of 
an ordinance by the Board of Estimate and Apportionment to 
buy the Tavern and half a block on which it stands for a Revo- 
lutionary museum and park. In the spring of 1904 Messrs. 
Alexander R. Thompson, James Mortimer Montgomery and Robert 
Olyphant, on behalf of the Society of the Sons of the Revolution, 
successfully negotiated a contract for the purchase of the prop- 
erty. At the same time these gentlemen induced the city to 
rescind the resolution authorizing the taking of the property by 
condemnation. The mayor told them that they were the only 
delegation which had called on him for the purpose of saving 
the city's money. Thus the City of New York was saved the 
expense of acquiring the property, preserving and maintaining it, 
and yet the restoration of this shrine of patriotism was assured. 
At the time the property was purchased it was subject to a 
lease with several years to run. Before the lease expired Mr. 
Frederick Samuel Tallmadge, late president of the society, died, 
leaving a large bequest to the society. This furnished ample 
funds for the restoration of the Tavern, which was planned with 
the greatest care. 

i'/)4.- July 30.— Transfer of the property to the Sons of the Revo- 
lution recorded in the Register's Office. 

100A7.- Restoration of the building. 

!-;••/. May I. -Office of the Sons of the Revolution opened here. 

1907.— December 4._ForMial occupation and dedication (on the 124th 
|innivcrsary of Washington's "Farewell" here) of the building 
by the Sons of the Revolution. 

46 




^M . JL 



Tavern 



MANHATTAN 



3 Route 




Fraunces Tavern in 1904. 

The Society of the Sons of the Revolution has been instituted 
to perpetuate the memory of the men who achieved American inde- 
pendence, to promote and assist in the proper celebration of Washing- 
ton's Birthday, the Fourth of July, and the battles and prominent events 
01 the War of the Revolution; to collect and preserve records and 
memorials relative to that war; to inspire among the members and 
their descendants the patriotic spirit of their forefathers, and respect 
for the principles for which the patriots of the Revolution contended. 
The Society now has over twenty-two hundred members in the State 
of New York. 



Note. — For other historic events in the neighborhood of Fraunces 
Tavern (Map, p. 40), see Excursion VII, New York City South of 
Wall Street. 

47 



2 Route MANHATTAN Fraunces Tavern 

THE BUILDING AND ITS RESTORATION 

There is no known view of Fraunces Tavern before 1854. Fraunces' 
own description when he offered the building for sale in 1776 reads as 
follows: "The Queen's Head Tavern is three stories high, with a 
tile and lead roof, has fourteen fireplaces, a most excellent large kitchen, 
tine dry cellars, with good convenient offices, etc." 

The view of New York from Brooklyn Heights, in 1798, shows its 
top as gambrel-roofed and hipped. See Hollyer's print of its proposed 
restoration in Mrs. Pierce's " Landmark of Fraunces Tavern." Also 
see views in the Magazine of American History, Vol. VIII, p. 144, 
and in Bryant and Gay's " Popular History of the U. S.," showing 
alterations in the first story. 

The architect of the restored building was William H. Mersereau 
and the contractor S. A. McGuire. Mr. Mersereau has endeavored 
to restore the building so far as possible to its original form. When 
the added stories were taken down he studied and followed the old 
roof-lines and rafters. The modern bricks and stone were removed 
and yellow bricks to match the originals were imported from Hol- 
land for the Broad Street side, and on the Pearl Street side the 
old style red bricks were matched with bricks from old dwellings in 
the vicinity of Baltimore, Md. The first floor was raised to its former 
level, the windows changed to conform with the original ones and the 
Long Room restored to its old dimensions. All the original timbers 
were retained above and below the Long Room and every brick and 
piece of lumber, so far as possibL, of the original building was left 
in place. The present appearance of the building is believed to be 
practically the same as during the Revolutionary period. 

The first floor is still used as a restaurant.* 

On the second floor is the celebrated Long Room; note the 
portraits of Frederick Samuel Tallmadge and John Austin Stevens, 
the table made from old timbers of the building and the tablets. 

In the Museum on the third floor are cases holding Revolutionary 
relics— flags, china, coins, medals, military commissions, letters, deeds 
and other old documents, including the original deeds of the Tavern, 
showing the transfer of the property from the De Lanceys and subse- 
quent owners. The Library is devoted mainly to American History and 
the men and events of the Revolution. 

The top floor is used as a dining-room for members of the Society, 
and on the walls is a collection of engraved portraits of Washington. 

A caretaker dressed in the style of the Revolution explains the 
exhibits to visitors. 

•Select reitaurant for ladies and scntlcnu-n. .1 la carte, Emil Westerburg, proprietor. 

48 



NOTES 



NOTE BY ASA BIRD GARDINER 



The Gardner family, who acquired the Tavern in 1837, came from 
Fifeshire, Scotland, about 1760, and had no connection with the Gardiner 
family. The name of the lessee was Robert, not John, and he had not 
been a hotel proprietor. The property descended in the female line to 
the Keteltas family, from whom the Sons of the Revolution purchased 
the property. 

The Story of Phoebe Fraunces (p. 44) is of doubtful origin; it is 
also doubtful whether Samuel Fraunces ever served in the American 
Army. He was probably a mild Tory, and continued to keep the tavern 
for British Officers during the Revolution. 



48a 



NOTES. 



48b 



EXCURSION NO. I.— CITY HALL TO WALL STREET. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley 

Corrected with the aid of Albert Ulmann and Edward Hagaman 

Hall. 

Copyright, 1902, by the City History Club of New York. 
Revised 1905, 1909 and 1912 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




HISTORICAL GUIDE 




50a 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



INDEX TO HOLLAND iMAP (p. 50) 



G Meat Market. 

H Fly Market. 

I Peck's Market. 

K Oswego Market. 

O St. Paul's. 

P Trinity. 

Q St. George's Chapel. 

S New Dutch Church. 



T Lutheran Church. 

V Calvinist Church. 

W French Protestant Church. 
X Quaker Meeting. 

Y Presbyterian Meeting. 
Z Baptist Meeting. 

a Moravian Meeting. 

b New Lutheran Meeting. 



50b 



MANHATTAN 5 Route 

Bibliography 

Works by Janvier, Ulmann, Hemstreet, Wilson and Hill mentioned 

in Excursion VII. 
" Historic New York ;" papers on " King's College," " Old Wells," 

" Old Prisons and Old Taverns." 
"Reports of the American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society: 

articles on " The Centenary of City Hall," and " The Old 

Martyrs' Prison"; "A Brief History of City Hall Park" (1910 

Report). 
"Works of Art Belonging to the City of New York," compiled by 

the Municipal Art Commission. 
"St. Paul's Chapel," by Charles F. Wingate, and "The Montgomerie 

Siege," by T. U. Harper (pub. by A. B. King & Co.). 

This part of New York was not settled until long after the Dutch flag 
ceased to wave over New Amsterdam, City Hall Park was the old Dutch 
Vlacte (Flai) or pasture, later called the Common, granted to the city cor- 
poration in 1686 by the Dongan charter. During the later English period 
and the days of the Revolution it was a place for public demonstrations, mass 
meetings, etc. It was fenced in about 1785, and an iron rail fence was pro- 
vided in 1821, with gates on the south, west and east sides. 

The main thoroughfare was lower Broadway, Chatham Street (now Park 
Row) and the Bowery. The shore line has been extended two or three blocks 
on either side. The King's Farm, which lay west of Broadway, between Wall 
and Warren Streets, originally belonged to the West India Company and was 
later granted, together with the Jans or Bogardus Farm north of Warren 
Street (Excursion II) to Trinity Church. Many of the street names have a 
direct connection with early residents. 

Note. — The * refers to Addenda, 1912, pp. 65-6. 



Ss 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 5. 

SECTION I.-CITY HALL PARK AND VICINITY^ 

(Figures refer to Plates X and XI; see also IX and XII). 

Take Subzi'ay to Brooklyn Bridge or City Hall. 




<fl® 








DIA&/ZAM OF 

c/ry///iiL PAR.H 
AND v/cj/v/rr. 



i'LATK XI. Route 5. C. K, 

52 



City Hall MANHATTAN 5 Route 

I. City Hall, a fine example of the Italian Renaissance, John 
McComb, Jr., architect. The foundation stone was laid on the site 
of the old almshouse by Mayor Edward Livingston, September 20, 
1803. The front and sides are of Stockbridge (Mass.) marble, the 
rear built of brownstone from motives of economy; the common 
assertion that it was due to the idea that the city would not extend 
north of the building being untrue, as the city had already advanced 
beyond Chatham Square. The building was first occupied by the city 
government on Aug. 12, 181 1, although it was not completed until 1812, 
in the mayoralty of DeWitt Clinton. Among the important events 
celebrated here were the 200th anniversary of the discovery of Man- 
hattan by Henry Hudson, Captain Hull's victory over the British 
ship Guerriere, the visit of Lafayette in 1824, the opening of the Erie 
Canal, November 4, 1825; the Croton Water opening, October 14, 
1842; the laying of the Atlantic Cable, 1858 (at which time the 
building caught fire and was badly injured) ; the funeral of General 
Worth, 1857; the visit of Albert Edward, Prince of Wales, i860, and 
the 250th anniversary of the City Charter, 1903. The building is open 
from 10 to 4; Saturday 10 to 12. 

Ascend the spiral staircase to the Governors* Room; see por- 
traits of Washington and General James Clinton by Trumbull, Peter 
Stuyvesant, Alexander Hamilton and governors from 1777; busts of 
DeWitt Clinton and Henry Clay; a copy of Lincoln's Gettysburg 
speech ; a section of Stuyvesant's pear tree ; punch bowl used at the 
Erie Canal celebration; portraits of Hudson and Stuyvesant; 
two desks of Washington and the furniture used in the former City 
Hall by the Federal Congress (Excursion VII, 21). A good view 
of the park and its surroundings may be obtained from the balcony.* i 

The Aldermanic Chamber contains some portraits and a paint- 
ing symbolic of New York City's commercial greatness. In the ad- 
joining Committee Room are portraits of Harry Howard in the uni- 
form of a Volunteer Fireman and of General McClellan. The old 
Council Chamber, now used by the Board of Estimate and Apportion- 
ment, contains portraits of national celebrities. 

On the ground floor are the Mayor's Reception Room contain- 
ing portraits of Lafayette and of former mayors, and on the ceiling 
plaster reproductions of seals of the United States, of New York 
State and City from early days; the City Library, comprising 7,000 
volumes, some of great value, and the Bureau of Marriage Licences. 

S3 



Route 5 HISTORICAL GUIDE City Hall 

In the corridor see a marble tablet, erected in 1903, between md 
descriptive of two tablets (originally on the roof) containing the 
names of the architect, sculptor and of the building committee. 
Oil the opposite wall note the Dutch and Federal standard yard 
measure. 

In ihe basement are the Marriage Room, Bureau of Licenses and 
some rooms once used as prison cells when the Police Headquarters 
were here. 

Outride, beneath the Mayor's Window, see the tablet commemorat- 
iui? the reading of the Declaration of Independence to the army here, 
in Washington's presence, July 9, 1776. (See painting of this event 
in the New Amsterdam Theater, 214 West Forty-second Street). 

A tablet in the sidewalk in front of the building marks the first 
excavation for the Rapid Transit Tunnel in 1900; another tablet 
in tiu- City Hall Subway Station commemorates the opening of the 
Turiul in 1904. A portion of the tunnel of the once proposed Pneu- 
matic Rapid Transit Railway, constructed in 1868, still remains un- 
der Broadway along the Park. 

The Biiiiczi'dl or common jail, built in 1775, and used by the 
r.ritish as a prison, stood between Broadway and the site of City 
Hall. It was torn down in 1838, the stones being used to build the 
old Tombs Prison. Its great lock and key are in the building of the 
New York Historical Society. 

2. The Statue of Nathan Hale, by Mac Monnies, near Broad- 
way, opposite Murray Street, was erected by the Sons of the 
Revolution. ( b:xcMrsion V. Section 7.) Now near E. wing of City Hall. 

3. New York Post OfBce, the third building used in the city for 
the purpn.sc, built in 1875 on part of City Hall Park ceded in 1867 
by the City to the National Government. Within the corridor, near 
the western entrance, is a tablet erected in 1897 by the Mary Wash- 
ington Colonial Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolu- 
tion to commemorate the erection of the Liberty Pole and the Battle 
of (Jojden Hill (see 33 and 38). One Liberty Pole stood on the City 
Conmion about the middle of Mail Street and another stood near 
Ilroadway at Warren Street. 

lu the southeast corridor is a bust and memorial tablet in 
honor of Postmaster IVarson for his services in reforming the 
postal .system. 

54 



Park MANHATTAN 5 Route 

4„ Fountain, erected about 1873 j^ist north of the site of the 
original fountain of 1842 which celebrated the opening of the 
Croton Aqueduct. 

Go north through the Park to 

5. The County Court House, on the site of the second Almshouse, 

Scnddcrs Museum, American Institute, etc. 

Chambers Street marks the line of the fortifications and British barracks during- 
the Revolution ; a negro burying ground occupied the site of the Stewart and Dunn 

Buildings. 

6. Brown Stone Building, now the City Court, built 1852. The 
Rotunda (1818-1870) lay east of this and was used for the Post Office 
(1835-45) and later as an art gallery. 

7. The new Hall of Records at Centre and Chambers Streets. 
See the statues of Duane, Colden, Hone, Heathcote, Stuyvesant, De 
Vries and Clinton by Philip Martiny ; allegorical statues by Martiny 
and Bush-Brown ; groups representing the recording of the purchase 
of Manhattan in 1626 and the consolidation of Greater New York, 
1898, by Albert Weinert. The interior of the building is well worth a 
visit. The Register will allow visitors to inspect the old city records 
and maps dating back to Dutch days.* 2 

8. Site of the iirst Free School building of New York City in Ot- 
tendorfer Square. It was erected in 1809 on what was then called 
Tryon Row, corner of Chatham Street, near the new terminal of the 
Brooklyn Bridge. 

Go south along the edge of the Park to the 

9. Tablet, erected in 1907 by the Mary Washington Colonial 
Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution, on a granite 
monument in the Park, nearly opposite the Brooklyn Bridge terminal, 
marking the site of the old Register's Office which was built in 1758 
as a debtors* prison. It became the Provost or British military prison 
during the Revolution and was the scene of great brutality to prison- 
ers on the part of Provost-Marshall Cunningham. On the second 
floor (called derisively " Congress Hall ") were confined prisoners of 
note, among them Ethan Allen. Beneath the building were four 
gloomy dungeons. The building was torn down in 1903 to make way 
for the Subway. During its demolition coins, buttons and human 
bones were found in the excavation. 

Go down Park Row 
on the line of the early road to Stuyvesant's Bowery (Excursion III., 
Section 2), and later forming a portion of the Post Road. 

55 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




^ 


tn 


oT 


^r'. 




^ c 


^ 


.2 i? 


V, 




o 


F o 


in 


fnU 




S. 






Q 


" o 


Ph 




^ 


rn >. 


< 


& = 


^ 


16 


^ 




o 


Xi 


H 


CM 




O' 


Di 




o 


.23 



56 



Park Row MANHATTAN 5 Route 

10. The Sun Building, originally the first permanent building of 
Tammany Hall (erected 1811), which had been organized at Borden's 
Tavern in lower Broadway in 1789 and moved to " Martling's " (cor- 
ner of Spruce and Nassau Streets) in 1798. In Tammany Hall the 
political term " Loco foco " originated in 1834. 

Frankfort Street, " Newspaper Alley," was named for the birth- 
place of Jacob Leisler who was executed for treason in 1691 on 
his own farm near by.* 3 

A fine view of all lower Manhattan and the Bay may be obtained 
from the top of the tower in the World Building. 

11. Statue of Benjamin Franklin, designed by Plassman, and 
presented in 1867 by Captain Albert de Groot to the printers and 
press of New York. 

12. Statue of Horace Greeley, founder of the " New York Tri- 
bune " (designed by Ward and presented to the city in 1890) near 
the Tribune Building. 

13. Statues of Franklin and Gutenberg on the front of the 
" Staats Zeitung" Building, Spruce and William Streets. 

14. The Vineyard Lot occupied the block between Park Row, Nassau and 
Beekman Streets, and the block below was called the Governor's Garden be- 
cause purchased by Governor Dongan in 1685. 

The old Times and Potter Buildings are on the site of the Brick Presby- 
terian Church, built in 1768; used during the Revolution as a British prison 
and moved about 1858 to Thirty-seventh Street and Fifth Avenue. (Excursion 
V, Section 4:2). 

On the block directly south is the site of the first Clinton Hall (1830), an 
early home of the Mercantile Library. (Excursion III, Section i). 

15. Dolan's Restaurant, ZZ Park Row, contains a model of the 
buildings on this block as they stood about 1800, including the 
present structures at 33, 34, 35 Park Row, the corner being then 
known as Love joy's Hotel. It also SnOWS the Park Theatre just be- 
low, the site in part that of the Park Row Building, 21-23 Park 
Row. The theatre was erected in 1798, burned in 1820, rebuilt in 
182 1 and again burned in 1848. In 1842 a ball was given here in 
honor of Charles Dickens. 

16. Theatre Alley, joining Beekman and Ann Streets, was the 
stage passage to the Park Theatre. The restaurant kitchen here was 
the laundry of Love joy's Hotel. 

17. Site of Barnum's Museum, built in 1842 and burnt down in 1865, was 
where now stands the St. Paul Building at Broadway and Ann Streets. The 
Loew Bridge was erected across Broadway at Fulton Street in 1867 to aid 
pedestrians, but was taken down the next year by court order. Stewart's Cafe 
at 161 Fulton Street contains a number of rare prints of old New York. *4. 

57 



Route 6 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ROUTE 6. 

SECTION II.— ST. PAUL'S TO WALL STREET. 

i8. St. Paul's Chapel, corner of Vesey Street, the oldest church 
structure in Manhattan, built by McBean, 1764-66 (the steeple not 
until 1794). The interior was modeled after that of St. Martins-in- 
the-Fields, London. Note on the pediment the statue of St. Paul. 

See within the church the pews of Washington and Governor 
George Clinton, the original sounding board over the pulpit and 
several tablets. In the Trinity Corporation Building at the foot of 
the yard may be seen a number of interesting historical relics and 
pictures. 





Z 


H 

U- 




1- 
10 

>- 

Ui 

in 
u 

> 






' ^ 


(K) 


© 


® 

w 


(D 




(S) 
(D 




® ® 

St Pauls Chapel 










Broadway 




Com, 
orN 


»MforT 

(xYoUK 


t Cm History C 


C£ 









Plate XII. 
ludcx to Monuments, St. Paul's Churchyard 



General Ricliard Montgomery. 

Dr. Win. James McNeven (cenotaph). 

( ..nkc. till- actor. 



Situr (U- Koclie Fontaine (aide to Rochambeau). 

Irancis DrinK (earliest inscription, 1767). 

J^^lioni.;is A.ldis Kmmett (see west face of cenotaph, latitude and longitude of 



WashiiiKton's pew. 
Cdvcrnor (leorge Clinton's pew 
Da ■ ■■ '■ 



IS. Jamrs Davis, smith to Royal Artillery, 1760 (a brown stone near gate). 

1.. .'>..in 1 ur.ly, an old jockey who rode ^'Eclipse," May 27, 1823, winning a 

piii-Hc of ?..o.ooo: a race of North vs. South (stone on four pillars). 

i vJ 'I • ''-.'"T **« ^\ ^V'.*'-'' *'^'tor of Nciv York Gazette, Post Boy; etc., 
N ']-|.li Iv ^'IV'-M''' ',r«4. by his widow (square box over grave). 
N Charles Nordeck. Harou de Rabenau, captain in a Hessian Regiment, 1782. 

Note. —.4 comf^lctc list of ins ' 
the vestry room. 



:nt^tions and epitaphs zvith a map may be seen tit 



58 



King's College MANHATTAN 6 Route 

19. Astor House, north of St. Paul's, one of the oldest New 
York hotels, built 1834-38 and the temporary home of many famous 
men. It is opposite the site of the old Spriiii; Garden and on that of the 
Drover's Inn or Bull's Head Tavern and was once the property of 
J. J. Astor, J. C. Coster and David Lydig. It is still in the Astor 
estate. 

The first substantial sidewalks of New York were laid on the 
west side of Broadway between Vesey and Murray Streets about 1787. 

Go west on Barclay Street to 

20. St. Peter's Church, southeast corner of Church Street, the 
oldest Roman Catholic Church building in Manhattan, established in 
1786; rebuilt 1838-g and recently remodeled. Note the Latin inscrip- 
tion under the cornice and the statue of St. Peter. * 5 

Go up Church and west on Murray Street to 

21. Tablet at the southeast corner of Murray Street and West 
Broadway, marking the site of King's College tract which extended 
west of Broadway, between Murray and Barclay Street and sloped 
down to the river which then came up to Greenwich Street. The 
college grounds proper covered much less territory (Plate IX). This 
large open space aided in stopping the progress of the great lire of 
1776. King's College was chartered in 1754, sessions beginning July 
of that year in the school-house of Trinity Church, Dr. Samuel 
Johnson, the President, being at first the sole instructor. The cor- 
ner stone of the building was laid in 1756 and the college was first 
occupied in 1760. During the Revolution the building was dismantled 
and used by both armies as barracks and a hospital. In 1784 it was 
reopened as Columbia College, DeWitt Clinton, nephew of the Gov- 
ernor, entering as the first student. 

Dr. Anthon's Grammar School, . founded in 1764 as the preparatory depart- 
ment,* after the Revolution occupied the Murray Street side and the main 
entrance was from Robinson Street (Park Place) which was cut through the 
grounds in 1856, the year before the College moved up town. (Excursion V, 
Section 4:7). 

Greenwich Street was the shore line until about 1760 and a road ran north 
from it to Greenwich Village, passing Vauxhall, a favorite public garden of 
the English period, lying between Warren and Chambers Streets. The first 
elevated railroad in the world was built on this street in 1866-7, running from 
the Battery to Thirtieth Street, The experimental power was a cable. 

Go south on West Broadway to Vesey Street. 

West Broadway, College Place or Chapel Street was widened and cut 
through to Vesey Street in 1892 and lower Church Street was widened and 
called New Church about 1875. The line of the former sidewalk may be 
determined by the Elevated R. R. pillars on the west side. The horse cars 
formerly ran under the houses between Barclay and Vesey Streets. 

39 



Route 6 HISTORICAL GUIDE W. of Broadway 

Washington Market, successor to the Bear Market, corner 
of'Vesey and Washington Streets. West Washington Market, formerly 
on the river front, is now part of Gansevoort Market. The high 
lands nearby were leveled and the shore line filled in about 1787 to 
1790. See old houses on Vesey Street opposite the market. *6 

Go south on Greenwich to Thames Street. 

On Cortlandt Street and Broadway was a Dutch windmill in early days, 
hence its old name of Windmill Lane; and at the foot of Cortlandt Street was 
the slip of Fulton's first steam ferry (1812) to Paulus Hook. 

Sec old buildings near Albany and Carlisle Streets. *7 

Go cast on Thames Street and north on Trinity Place to Cedar 
Street, passing 

old house at 17 Thames Street and 

23. An old city well on Trinity Place, corner of Thames Street. 



Return to Thames Street and go east to Broadway, passing 

25. Tablet, Thames Street side of 113 Broadway, site of the 
de Lanccy House, built in 1700, later the Province Arms, or Burns' 
Coffee House, and replaced by the City Hotel in 1806. This is said to 
have been the scene of the signing of the Non-Importation Agree- 
ment, October 31, 1765, but there is authority for believing that this 
took place at 9 Broadway. (Excursion VII :i). 

Thames Street was the carriage way to the de Lancey stables. 



<^ 



MANHATTAN 7 Route 

ROUTE 7. 

SECTION III.-WALL STREET TO FRANKLIN SQUARE. 

Take Subway to Wall Street. Go east on Cedar Street, passing 

26. The site of the Scotch Presbyterian Church, built about 1760, nearly 
opposite the Clearing House, between Broadway and Nassau Streets. The 
latter street was first at Teunis de Kay's cartway from Wall Street, passing 
around Federal Hall; it was opened in 1696, and the upper end was called 
Kip Street for Jacob Kip. Note copies of the City, State and National Seals 
on the Clearing House. 

27. The tablet on the Mutual Life Building, northeast corner 
of Nassau and Cedar Streets, marks the site of the Middle Dutch 
Church, built 1727-32; this was used by the British as a riding acad- 
emy and prison and served as a post office from 1845 to 1875. The 
old bell, made in Amsterdam and given by de Peyster, is now at the 
Collegiate Church, at Fifth Avenue and Forty-eighth Street. (Ex- 
cursion V, Section IV :5). It is said that Franklin tried some of his 
kite experiments from the belfry of the old building. Just behind, 
at 34 Liberty Street, stood the Livingston Sugar House, another 
Revolutionary prison. 

28. Site of the French Church du St. Esprit (Excursion VIT, 13 and Ex- 
cursion V, Section 11:39), erected 1703-4 at 18-20-22 Pine Street and also 
used as a military prison. 

Go north on Nassau and west on Liberty Street 

29. The Chamber of Commerce, 65 Liberty Street (admission 
only through a member's card), contains a fine collection of portraits 
of old New York merchants, a Stuart portrait of Washington and 
many interesting relics and curios. Note in front the statues of 
Alexander Hamilton, John Jay and De Witt Clinton. On this site 
once stood the Friends' Meeting House. 

Go up Liberty Place, formerly called Little Green Street, then 
descend the hill to Maiden Lane and ivalk east 
to Pearl Street^S 
Aaron Burr's law office was at 73 Nassau Street. 

Maiden Lane, Maagde Paatje, was one of the three oldest streets north 
of the Wall, being the route between Road to the Ferry and Broadway. The 
streets between it and Broadway were laid out about 1690. A brook ran 
along the line of this street from the vicinity of Broadway, as may still be 
seen by the hollow marking the neighborhood and by the old arches in base- 
ments near Nassau Street, built over a drain to carry off the water. Some 
say the banks of this brook were a favorite bleaching ground of the Dutch 
maidens, others that Maiden Lane was an old lover's path. At the edge of 
the East River, near Pearl Street, in Dutch days was the smithy of Cornelius 
Cloppers, giving the name Sniit's Vly (valley) to this locality. Note the modern 
house with a crowstep roof at 57 Maiden Lane, on the site of Thomas Jef- 
ferson's New York home. *9. 

61 



Route 7 HISTORICAL GUIDE East o! 

,o The Fh Market once occupied the block east of Pearl. Street, and after 
.1 ^^ V,!Iin/in i.rocess was complete two other markets occupied the additional 
itVks "f the' ?ast AH were^ torn down about 1821. Its successor is the 
iii.Mlcrn Fuitun Market. ^ , ^ i ox * 

Go down Pearl Street 

Pearl Street de Perel Straat, the Stratid or the Road to the Ferry (some- 
x\:L^\al\cd Dock and Queen Street) marks the former shore line on the East 
Kiver and was the roa^ from the Fort to the Brooklyn Ferry, near Fulton 
Street, j t»- 

31. Revolutionary cannon, northeast corner of Pearl and Pine 
Streets. Aaron Burr once lived at 10 Cedar Street. The old De 
rcysti-r house, at 168 Pearl Street, was the residence of Governor 
(leorge Clinton in 1789. 

Rrturn to Liberty and north on Gold Street, climbing old Rutgers 

11 ill and parsing some quaint old buildings. Go east on 

I'lalt Street to see an old house at 208 Pearl Street. 

Return on Piatt Street to JViUiam Street, passing 

32. The Jack-Knife, northwest corner of Piatt and Gold 
Streets, an old house once used as a tavern which was so changed 
ill shape by the cutting through of Piatt Street (by Jacob S. Piatt in 
1S34) as to merit its name. It is best seen from near the William 
.Street corner. 

Go up William Street to 

S3. Golden Hill Inn, 122-4 William Street, built over 150 years 
ago of liriek from Holland. It was the favorite meeting place of the 
Sons of Liberty (see 38). Washington Irving lived at the site of 
126 (or 131) William Street, and Lafayette at 90 William Street. 
Go zvest on John Street to 

34- John Street M. E. Church, the oldest Methodist Church 
in New York. The original building occupied the same site and was 
erected in 1768; rebuilt in 1817 and 1841. The church was organized 
in a sail loft at 120 William Street by Barbara Heck, Philip Embury 
and Captain Webb. Within may be seen a number of interesting 
relics, inchuling a clock given by Charles Wesley and tablets to 
Captain Wil.b, S. 11. liadley and others. The tablet outside gives 
the dates of the several structures. * 10 

35. The site of the John Street Theatre (called the " Royal " in the 
Revolution and the "National" afterward) was at 15-21 John Street. 
It was built between 1750 and 1760 and here Major Andre performed 
oripinal plays during the Revolution. "Hail Columbia" was first 
played here in the presence of Washington by Fyles, its composer, 
and in this theatre Joseph Jefferson made his first appearance. See 
the arcade at 17 John Street, once an entrance to the theatre. 

62 



Broadway MANHATTAN 7 Route 

Go north on Nassau to Fulton Street; then west to 

26. Tablet, 136 Fulton Street, erected in 1883 by veterans of 
the Seventh Regiment to commemorate the Shakespeare Tavern, built 
before the Revolution, a favorite headquarters for actors and the 
scene of the organization of the Seventh Regiment, August 25, 1824. 

Go east on Fulton Street. 

37. Fulton Street Prayer Meeting (No. 113) site of the 

North Dutch Church, built in 1769 and used as a British prison. The 

bell once hanging in the North Church tower now stands in the 

churchyard at Twenty-ninth Street and Fifth Avenue. (Excursion V., 

Section 2: 41). 

The first Firemen's Hall, built in 1788, was east of the church, at the cor- 
ner of William Street. 

Go up William to Ann Street. 

38. Tablet, northeast corner of Ann and William Streets, 
marks the site of the street fight of Golden Hill (so called from a 
wheat field here) between the Sons of Liberty and British soldiers, 
in defence of the Liberty Pole, January 17, 1770, — the first bloodshed 
of the Revolution (see 3 and 33). Note the old building opposite 
and the court and old style rear buildings at 59 Ann Street. * 11 

Return to Fulton Street and go east. 

39. Ryder's Alley, connecting Fulton and Gold Streets, is a 
relic of the old days. The old United States Hotel ("Holt's Folly"), 
corner of Fulton and Pearl Streets, on the site of the United States 
Arcade, has been recently demolished. Several old houses may be seen 
near the ferry, at the foot of Fulton Street. 

Go north on Cliff Street to 

40. The St. George Building on the northwest corner of Beek- 
man Street, on the site of the first St. George's Church (1748-1852), 
now on East Sixteenth Street. The original desk, pulpit and chancel 
rails are now in the church at Manhasset, L. L 

The old shot tower, erected 1858, was taken down in 1907. 

41. Tablet at Cliff and Ferry Streets, (Schieren Building) 
erected Oct. 27, 1906, under the auspices of the Hide and Leather 
Association of New York to commemorate the old Swamp. In ex- 
cavating for the building old tan-vats were found in a good state of 
preservation. 

63 



Route 7 HISTORICAL GUIDE East of 

John Ilaberding (or Harpendinck) with some fellow tanners 
bought in 1695, "The Shoemaker's Pasture," a district covering 
several blocks between Maiden Lane and Ann Street, east of^ Broad- 
way Here they carried their tanneries from the old tan pits near 
Beaver Street; later Haberding, having given his share of the Pasture 
to the Middle Church, they removed to the " Leather Swamp " above 
Bcekinan Street, near Gold Street, which district still retains the name 
of "The Swamp." The Vandercliff Farm lay northeast of Shoe- 
maKer's Pasture and gave the name to Cliff Street. 

Go cast on Ferry Street to Peck Slip. 

42. Tablet at 8-10 Peck Slip, erected by General Society of 
Mayflower Descendants in 1904 to commemorate the warehouse of 
Isaac Allerton, a Mayflower Pilgrim who was Governor Bradford's 
assistant at Plymouth. 

4.^. Revolutionary cannon at southwest corner of Water Street 
and Peck Slip. 

Go north on Pearl Street to 

44. Site of the IValton House, 324-326 Pearl Street (built 1754, torn down 
1881), the magnificence of which is said to have led to the enactment of the 
Stamp Act. 

45. Tablet, on Brooklyn Bridge pier at the east side of Frank- 
lin Square, erected in 1899 by the Mary Washington Colonial Chap- 
ter, Daughters of the American Revolution, to mark the Franklin 
House, home of Walter Franklin, a merchant, at i Cherry Street, 
built 1770, and occupied as the first presidential mansion by Wash- 
ington. Another prominent resident was Samuel Osgood, first Post- 
master General, who had married Franklin's widow. The house was 
torn down in 1856. 

Franklin Sqiuire was named in 1817 by the Board of Aldermen for 
Benjamin Franklin. 

Thin district w.ns formerly called Cherry Hill, named for the cherry orchard 
of Mayor Ihos Dclanccy, 1666-71, or for the Cherry Garden, established about 
A. * V^i '^"■"■''T'' ^•'"■■'^V'* ^^ ^ '■'^»' *o the Dutch garden at Chatham Square. 
At 5 CMcrrv Strict J(.hn Hancock once lived, and here Wm Tweed carried on 
the trade ot a ciRar-makcr. 

At 7 Cherry Street stoo.l the house of Samuel Leggett, president of the 
wcw Vork (.asliRht Comi.any, where gas was first used in the city in 1835. 
n^'^r.i"^ ■^•'''*'! '•'''■''. ^''""''"' <^'- l<^if1. who designed the present American 
fl.iK. (."iham CoMr/ (19 Cherry) and Blindman's Alley (26 Cherry) were in 
in Ibc'' cit " '°" '^ ""^" *'*^ "^"'^^ crowded and poorly housed districts 

64 



Broadway MANHATTAN 7 Route 

Go up Cherry to Roosevelt Street. 

Through Roosevelt Street once ran Old Wreck Brook, thought by 
Innes to have been named for the wreck of Adrian Block's ship, the 
Tiger. (Excursion VII :i6.) This brook led from the Collect Pond 
(vicinity of the Tombs) to the East River. (See page 95.) The 
bridge crossing this brook at Park Row was one of three " Kissing 
Bridges." See old houses at 98-96 and 88-86 Roosevelt Street. 

Pass under the Elevated Railroad to New Chambers Street and south 
on Rose Street. 

46. Tablet and barred window on the Rhinelander Building, 
the latter once in the old Cuyler, later Rhinelander Sugar House 
which was built in 1763 and torn down 1892. Some of the original 
blocks of stone surround the doorway. It is claimed that the old 
building was used as a Revolutionary prison (disproved by J. A. 
Stevens) . 

Go west on Diiane Street to Park Row and back to City Hall. 

Chatham Garden once fronted on Park Row (old Chatham Street) and ex- 
tended north from New Chambers Street. The high ground in the vicinity 
was once called Catimut's Windmill or Fresh Water Hill. There was a wind- 
mill here in 1662, north of Duane Street. *I2. 



ADDENDA— 1912 

*i (P- 53)- Since the restoration of this room through the gift of 
Mrs. Russell Sage the name was changed to the "Trumbull Room," as 
nearly all the portraits not executed by Trumbull were removed and 
others of his work hung here. The Erie punch bowl was recently re- 
moved for greater security to the Metropolitan Museum. 

*2 (p. 55). The new Municipal Building (erected 1911-13) will 
have shields above the great pillars representing the arms of the present 
city, and state, New Amsterdam, New Netherland and the province of 
New York 1664 (corresponding with the arms of the Duke of York). 
Allegorical figures represent city departments : "Executive Power," 
"Guidance," "Civic Duty," "Progress," "Civic Pride," "Prrdence," 
etc., and the large copper figure surmounting the tower stands for 
"Civic Fame." 

*3 (p- 57)- See the oaks in the Park opposite, brought from Frank- 

65 



Route 7 HISTORICAL GUIDE East of 

,-..rt Germany, and planted here with public ceremonies, April 23, 191 1, 
l.y German Americans. Christ's Church (known as the ''Swamp 
Church") was dedicated in 1767 by the German Lutherans at the east 
corner of Frankfort and William streets. During the Revolution 
chaplains of the German regiments officiated. In 1830 the building was 
sold, most of the congregation going to the new English Lutheran 
Church in Walker Street. 

*4 (P- 57)- See also paintings, old prints, etc., in Stewart's taverns 
at S Warren and 4-6 John Street, both near Broadway. 

"Ye Olde Tavern," 161 Duane Street near West Broadway, was 
built over one hundred years ago, and the upper floor was used prior to 
1S49 by the Public School Society for a primary school for colored 
children: it has been fitted up to resemble an XVIII century tavern. 
Another old building remains at the S. W. corner of Duane and 
Greenwich streets. 

*5 (p. 50). Tablet on pillar in front of St. Peter's Church, erected 
KHi. by the Knights of Columbus in memory of Governor Thomas 
Dongan. ^ 

♦6 (p. 60). See the original Memorial Stone, N. W. corner of 
Washington Market, presented by the N. Y. Historical Society at the 
celebration of the Centennial of the Market in October, 1912. On it are 
inscribed the names of the first superintendents of the market. 

*7 (p. 60). Planters' Hotel, N. W. corner Albany and Greenwich 
trects, now used as a drygoods store; the name remains almost obliter- 
ated, on the south side; also marks of the former entrance. It was 
j)atronizcd by Henry Clay and other celebrities, and Edgar Allan Poe is 
aid to have lo(lge<l hero for several weeks after his arrival in New York. 
*8 (p. 60- Inscription at 6 Liberty Place as follows: 

History of Liberty Place 
Up to the English conquest (1664) a country lane beyond New 
Xinsterdam leading to a brookside path, called "Maagde Paatje"— 
After ir/)4 named Green Alley and later called Green Street. From 
1704 to 1740 the first Quaker Church was on this alley. Up to 1844 the 
name was (;rcen Street; in 1844 name was changed to Little Green 
Street, in iS4<). rijrain cliangcTl to Liberty Place. 

I-reeted by Liberty Place Historical Society. 
*9 (p.fn). Tablet erected 191 1 by the Maiden Lane Historical 
Society and donated by lulward Holbrook. 

Inscription: Called Maagde Paatje in the days of New Amsterdam, 
b< i«H' .1 nual path beside a stream still marked by the curved line on 

66 



Broadway MANHATTAN 7 Route 

the present street. Known during the early English period as both 
Green Lane and Maiden Lane. Laid out as a street in 1691. Began to 
assume the character of a jewelry district about 1840. See p. 390. 

*io (p. 62). Tablets within the church, erected 1912 to Bishop E. G. 
Andrews, Dr. W, H. DePuy and B. M. Tilton. There are also tablets 
to the memory of Bishop Asbury, Barbara Heck, Philip Embury and 
others (illustrated "Historical Sketch, Old John Street," may be ob- 
tained). 

*ii (p. 63). The tablet for Golden Hill has been removed and de- 
stroyed, as no documentary proof can be found locating the exact scene 
of the fight. 

*I2 (p. 65). See other old houses at 139-141, 157-163, 185-187 and 
207 Park Row. (See also p. T02 *io.) 



b7 



NOTES 



6S 



EXCURSION NO. II.— GREENWICH VILLAGE AND LISPEN- 
ARD'S MEADOWS. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley. 

(Corrected with the aid of Mr. Thos. J. Burton, Life Member, 
New York Historical Society.) 



Copyright, 1902, by the City History Club of New York 

Revised 1906, 1909 and 1912. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




YoaK 



B^ JoKnMontrcfior En^r 177^' 



i'LATL XI 11. RlUKAW N FROM OlD MAP. 

70 



C. K. 



Greenwich MANHATTAN 8 Route 

GREENWICH VILLAGE AND LISPENARD'S MEADOWS. 
Bibliography. 

Works by Ulmann, Hemstreet and Wilson mentioned in Excursion 
VII. 

"Historic New York," (papers on " Annetje Jans' Farm," ** Old 
Wells," and " Old Greenwich") 

" In Old New York," (chapters on " Greenwich Village," and 
" Lispenard's Meadows") by Janvier. 

" When Old New York was Young," (chapters on " Greenwich 
Village," "The Inland Road to Greenwich," and "The Mouse Trap,") 
by Hemstreet. 

"Greenwich Village and Landmarks in its Vicinity," a paper read 
before the N. Y. Historical Society by Thomas J. Burton. 

Note. — The. * refers to Addenda, 1912, p. 83. 

ROUTE 8. 

SECTION L— GREENWICH VILLAGE. 

West Fourteenth Street to Spring Street. 
(Figures refer to Plates XIV, XVI; see also Plate XIII). 

Greenwich Village is the site of the oldest settlement of white men on Man- 
hattan after that formed around Fort Amsterdam. Its boundaries are, roughly, 
the North River, West Fourteenth Street and the line of the old Minetta 
Brook, the east branch of which rose in Madison Square, crossed Washington 
Square, ran through the line of Minetta and Downing Streets, and flowed into 
the North River just north of Charlton Street (see Plate XXI). 

The original Greenwich was of much smaller compass, consisting of a few 
houses located between the old Indian village of Sappokanican (east of the 
present (jansevoort Market) and the present Christopher Street, and was built 
up chiefly around the foot of the latter street. 

Sappokanican was called the Bossen Bouwerie (Farm in the Woods) in 
1633, when Governor Van Twiller established a tobacco plantation often called 
by its old Indian name. It is mentioned in the Journal of Bankers and 
Sluyter in 1679. Because of its healthfulness and fertility, it was a popular 
place of settlement. It received the name of Greenwich in the early part of 
the eighteenth century. Among the early residents of prominence were Cap- 
tain, later Admiral, Sir Peter Warren, Oliver De Lancey (Warren's brother- 
in-law). Commissary Mortier, William Bayard, James Jauncey and George 
Clinton. 

During the early part of the nineteenth century this section of the city 
became a refuge from the plagues of yellow fever and cholera, and was rapidly 
built up. 

The dovetailing of the new city plan of 1807-11 on the old line of streets 
in Greenwich Village gave rise to some curious complications, such as the 
crossing of Tenth and Eleventh Streets by Fourth Street, etc. This new plan, 
together with changes about Washington Square, brought Greenwich into closer 
union with the rest of the city, although its individuality is still very marked. 
It is often called the Old Ninth or the American Ward. . . c? 

The original shore line of this section was just west of Greenwich 5=>treet, 
which was a shore road to Greenwich Village, possibly succeeding an old 
Indian path. 

71 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




72 



Greenwich MANHATTAN 8 Route 

Start at West Fourteenth Street and Tenth Avenue; walk south. 

1. Gansevoort Market, just west of the site of Sappokanican 
("carrying place"), the Indian village where Hudson is supposed 
to have stopped to trade in 1609. 

The market occupies filled-in ground, the original shore-line making a shar^ 
turn to the east at Bank Street, forming a bay into which projected a point 
of land on which Fort Gansevoort was located. The fort, which was named in 
honor of General Peter Gansevoort, an officer in Washington's army, was built 
in this vicinity to protect the river front during the War of 18 12 and was 
torn down in 1851. 

See the Sign of the Goose facing Gansevoort (" goose ") Mar- 
ket at 819 Washington Street. 

West Washington Market was moved here from Vesey Street. 

2. The old Oyster Market lies just west along the river front, 
which is usually lined at this point with antiquated river craft.* i 

Go up Horatio Street to Jackson Square. 

Pass old houses at 35, 19-13 and 7 Horatio Street and 345 West 
Fourth Street. 

3. 126 Greenwich Avenue, opposite Jackson Square; see C. H. 
Britting's large and unique collection of theatre posters, pro- 
grams, etc., dating back to 1805. 

Go down Eighth Avenue to Abingdon Square. 

82 Jane Street is the site of William Bayard's house in which Alexander 
Hamilton died. 

Abingdon Square was named for the Countess of Abingdon, Admiral War- 
ren's daughter. 

5. The Warren Estate embraced much of the land in this vicinity. The site 
of the Warren House (home of Admiral Sir Peter Warren, who aided in the 
capture of Louisbourg in 1745) was on the block bounded by West Fourth, 
Charles, Bleecker and Perry Streets. This property was purchased by Mr. Van 
Nest in 1819 for $15,000. In 1865 a row of brownstone houses was built here and 
remains on what is called Vannest Place (Charles from Bleecker to West 
Fourth Street). 

Christopher Street was called Skinner Road for one of Sir Peter Warren's 
sons-in-law. 

100 yards east of Eighth Avenue was the original Fitzroy Road, named for 
another son-in-law. Lord Fitzroy, created Baron Southampton in 1780. Ganse- 
voort Street was once called Southampton or Great Kill Road. (Plate XXI and 
Route 16.) 

4. The Barracks, a building at the southeast corner of Bank 
and Bleecker Streets, the upper part being the original prison for 
sailors taken from the captured British man-of-war Peacock during 
the War of 1812 (for brief account see framed clippings in the 
building) . 

Go west on Bank to West Street. 

Bank Street was so called from the banks which removed from downtown 
and located here during the yellow fever epidemic of 1799. Governor George 
Clinton lived at the site of no Bank Street, the grounds then sloping to the 
river. (Banks were on block bounded by Bank and West nth Sts., W^verly Plage 
and Greenwich Ave.) 

73 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



nzro 

nnar 



Ezra 



□□DCnac 
nOac 




Plate XIV. Routes 8, lo, 
74 



Greenwich MANHATTAN 8 Route 

6. Tablet on west side of West Street in front of Piers 49-50, 
marking the widening and general iriiprovement of West Street 
in 1897. 

Go down West to Tenth Street. 

7. Site of the first New York State Prison (near foot of West Tenth Street), 
built in 1796; removed to Sing Sing 1829; the foundation stones are incor- 
porated in the walls of the brewery now occupying the site (just inside and 
east of the Tenth Street driveway). In 181 1 Greenwich Hotel was on Green- 
wich Street near the prison; stages went from this point to the City Hall on 
Wall Street five times a day. 

Log rafts were formerly anchored off shore, and a market was lo- 
cated here in 1804. On November 4, 1825, the procession of vessels 
brought through the Erie Canal stopped at the dock near the Prison 
where it was met by the city officials and proceeded to the navy yard, 
where national officials were taken on board and the fleet continued 
to the Lower Bay, where was performed the ceremony of wedding the 
lakes to the sea. *2 

8. Old houses on Weehawken Street, possibly built before 1767 
and plotted on the Ratzer Map of 1766-7 (Plate XVII.) One of 
the houses was once the station of the N. Y. C. and H. R. R. R. 

Go east on West Tenth Street, passing 

Old houses at 248 (rear alley) and 246 West Tenth Street. 

Go back to Hudson Street and south to Grove Street. 

9. St. Luke's (a chapel of Trinity) was built here 1821-4 (see 
tablet); the building next door to the old chapel was a Home 
for Aged Couples, now at West One Hundred and Twelfth 
Street. 

10. The old Grove Street School (P. S. No. 3) is the third 
oldest public school in New York. It was destroyed by fire in 
1905. The new building is marked by a tablet (the gift of C. R. 
Lamb, one of the old " boys ") to commemorate Lafayette's visit 
in 1824 to the original school, which had been " selected as the best 
example of the public school system as established by the Free 
School Society of the City of New York." Grove street (called 
successively Cosine, Columbia and Burrows Street) was widened and 
partly straightened in 1836. 

Go east on Barrow and through Commerce Streets to Bedford Street. 

11. The Broderick House is at the southwest corner of Bar- 
row and Commerce Streets. * 3 

Washington Irving's sister lived at 15 Commerce Street. 
Go down Bedford to Morton Street. 

75 



Route 8 HISTORICAL GUIDE Greenwich 

,, The old Bedford Street Methodist Church, corner of Mor- 

r^r^^AXrrind-Ffeeborn Garretson preached in U.s 
chtch. Note several old buildings near by on Bedford and 

Morton Streets. 

n 95 Morton Street is the former country house of General 
Murion cnn-site wlucli was "Mr. WilHamson's garden mentioned 
in Washington's diary. Demolished, igu. 

Go back to Hudson Street and south to 

14 Hr.dson Park, occupying the site of St. John's Cemetery, 
which was converted into a park (formerly called St. John s) ni 
189S See the Firemen's Monument and tablets; the pool and 
fountain are in the French-Italian style of the 17th Century. 

Cross the Park to Carmine Street. 

It is a neighborhood tradition that during the Draft Riots negroes were 
han^;od from the lamp-post on Clarkson, near Carmine Street. 

15. See old-time houses at 54, 59 and 61 Downing Street. 

Return to Varick Street and go south. 
Many old-fashioned houses remain on Varick Street, between 
Charlton and Carmine Streets, on Charlton, Van Dam and Spring 
Streets, and on Hudson at Watts Street. * 4 

Tlie Zandtberg or Richmond Hill originally occupied this region (see Plate 
Xlll). Tiie Indians called this Ishpatanau or Bad Hill. 

16. The site of Richmond Hill Mansion is on the block bounded by King, 
X'arick, Charlton and McDougal Streets, but the house was hnally removed to 
ri-38 Charlton Street. It was built by Abraham Mortier, Commissary ot the 
V.ritish Armv in 1760 and occupied by Lord Amherst, Sir William Carleton, 
(-..neral Washington (1776), Vice-President Adams (1789) and Aaron liurr; 
later it was used as a theatre and then became a roadhouse. 

17. The Spring Street Church, at Spring and Varick Streets, 
was erected in 1835, its predecessor of i8it having been built of 
material from the old First Church in Wall Street (Excursion 
\II:jo). Spring Street (formerly Brannon Street) was so called 
fr..in the natural well which was the scene of an early tragedy. 

18. Tn 1755 Brannon Garden occupied the corner at Spring and Hudson 
Sticits, tiie neighborhood being known as Lower Greenwich. 

Co east on Spring Street and return by Sixth Avenue Elevated R. R. 
from Crand Street^ or continue on Excursion, following Route 9. 

76 



Lispenards's 



MANHATTAN 



Meadows 




(Redrawn) C. K. 

Plate XV. Jans or Bogardus Farm; Later the Church Farm 
From " In Old New York." By permission. Copyright, 1894, by 
Harper & Bros. 

ROUTE 9. 

SECTION II. LISPENARD'S MEADOWS. 

Broadway and Canal Street to the North River. 

(Figures refer to Plate XVI; see also XV). 

The Annetje Jans Farm, granted in 1635 to Roelof Janssen, consisted of 62 
acres lying between the present Warren and Canal Streets, west of Broadway. 
Roelof 's widow, Annetje, married Dominie Bogardus, whence the later name 
—the Bogardus Farm or the Dominie's Bouwerie. It was sold to Governor 
Lovelace in 1670, confiscated by the Duke of York in 1674. and called suc- 
cessively the Duke's Farm, the King's Farm and the Queens 1< arm, until, in 
1705, Queen Anne granted it in perpetuity to Trinity Church, when it was 
called the Church Farm. Most of it is still Trinity property except the portions 
ceded by the corporation to the city for streets and St. John s lark. irinity 
received other grants north to Christopher Street, including the Old Jans tarm 
of Jans Celes, north of Canal Street. Just beyond was the Zandtberg (or sand 
hills) known in English days as Richmond Hill. (16 above.) 

77 



Route 9 HISTORICAL GUIDE Lispenard's 

The Kalch Hoek was a promontory projecting int9 a swampy region just 
east and northeast of the Farm, which was finally drained in 1730 by Anthony 
Rutpers His daughter married Leonard Lispenard whence the names Lis- 
nenard's (Lenner's) Meadows, Lispenard and Leonard Streets. , ^ ,, ^ 

^ The RtitgZ Mansion was at Thomas Street and Broadway, and af>out the 
middle of the i8th Century became the center of Ranelagh Garden. The New 
Vr^r\r HnQnital comoleted i77S, occupied about the same site. 

f c"naT constrrtcd throui^^ these meadows, on the line of Canal Street, 
after the City Plan of 1807 was adopted, drained the Collect Pond, which was 
at Cen re Street (see Route 12). A sewer now carries the drainage of the 
origiiS springsin the middle of the island. A stone bridge crossed the canal 

^*The°Srpark at West and Canal Streets was once called Suicide Slip. 

Go east on Canal Street to West Broadzvay and north to 

19. St. Alphonsus' Church, near Grand Street, 312 West Broad- 
way (formerly Laurens Street), on the site of the Lafayette Amphi- 
theatre, built in 1826 and named in honor of Lafayette after his sec- 
ond visit to America. In the Amphitheatre was held the celebration 
ball of the Erie Canal opening. 

Continue west on Canal to Laight Street, thence west on Laight to 
Varick Street. 
See old houses on the triangular block bounded by Canal, 
Laight and Varick Streets. 

20. St. John's Chapel, 46 Varick Street, built in 1803-7, called 
St. John's in the Fields was once the center of a fashionable neigh- 
borhood. St. John's is the third oldest church edifice yet standing on 
Manhattan, being antedated by St. Paul's Chapel (1764-6) and St. 
Mark's Church (1795-9). The key of the chapel may be obtained from 
the sexton at the house on the south. The galleries, columns and 
pulpit are original. The bell, clock and iron fence were brought 
from London. On Saturday morning may be seen the Leake Dole of 
Bread, established in 1800. 

It faces the site of St. John's Park, laid out as a private park in 1823, but 
sold Xo the N. Y. and Hudson River R. R. Co., for a freight station in 1865. 
Around the Park lived a number of well-known citizens, including Alexander 
Hamilton and General Schuyler. 

See quaint old St. John's Lane and York Street behind the 
church. 

Go down Varick and west on Beach Street. 

21. The small triangular Park at Beach Street and West 
Broadway is a reminder of the Annetje Jans Farm. 

22. Home of John Ericsson, 36 Beach Street. On the roof 
may be seen a small house in which he carried out experiments. 

Co n/y JIudson Street, passing 
. vtr.il old houses with high stoops, iron railings and newel nosts. 

78 



Meadows MANHATTAN 9 Route 

23. Commemorative pediment in the Hudson Street front of 
the N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. freight station, to honor the railway 
achievements of Vanderbilt. 

Go west on Hubert to West Street. 

24. The North Fort, erected during the War of 1812, was located at the foot 
of Hubert Street. 

The site of Washington's landing in 1775 was on West Street, south of 
Laight Street, formerly marked by a bronze tablet. 




nnuD 



DQD 
Dm 

DDI 



^ECTlOMS'ta- 



Plate XVI. Routes 8, 9. 



a K. 



79 



HISTORICAL GUIDE Washingtori^ 

ROUTE 10. 

SECTION III— WASHINGTON SQUARE AND VICINITY. 
(Figures refer to Plate XIV). 

Take Fifth Avenue bus to Washington Square; or Eighth Street car 

west from Astor Place Subway Station to Fifth Avenue 

and walk south to 

25. Washington Square (9 acres); the Potter's Field, 1789- 
1823; made a park in 1827 and improved 1870-1. Art Street (Astor 
Place) and Monument Lane (named for an obelisk to the memory 
of General Wolfe, hero of Quebec, 1759, erected at a point near 
Fifteenth Street and Eighth Avenue), now Greenwich Avenue, met 
just north of Washington Square. These streets are the only remain- 
ing parts of the Inland Road to Greenwich, connecting with the Bow- 
ery. The Greenwich Avenue portion was the line of retreat of Sulli- 
van's Brigade and Knox's Artillery, September 15, 1776, Aaron Burr 
being their guide (Route 19, Battle of Harlem Heights.) Note on 
map difference in the method of laying out and designating the 
streets north, south and west of Washington Square (see introduc- 
tion to Route 8). *5 

The Washington Memorial Arch replaced a temporary arch 
buih in i.SSg at the time of the centennial of Washington's inau- 
guration. The present arch, designed by Stanford White, was erected 
1890-5 by popular subscription at a cost of $128,000. * 6 

The heroic Statue of Garibaldi, by Giovanni Turini, was pre- 
sented in 1888 by Italian residents in New York. The colossal 
bust of Alexander L. Holley, inventor of Bessemer steel, by J. Q. 
A. Ward, was erected in 1890 at the expense of Engineers of 
Europe and America. 

The New York University Building, facing the Square at the 
cast, stands on the site of the original Gothic structure built 
18.32-5 and torn down 1894-5 to make way for the present building 
which is used by the Schools of Law, Pedagogy, Commerce, etc. 
In the old building Morse painted and experimented with his tele- 
graphic ai)paratus. Draper wrote and perfected his invention of 
the daguerreotype and Colt invented the revolver named for him* 7 

Go dozvn West Broadway to West Third Street. 
^^ Sec f.ld buildings at 60-58 West Third Street and the sign of 
"The Black Cat" (formerly designating a popular French res- 
taurant) at 551 West Broadway. {Siqn removed 1911.) ' 

80 



Square MANHATTAN lo Route 

Go west on West Third Street. 

West Third Street, originally Amity Street, was an old-time 
fashionable thoroughfare, among the residents on which were 
Governor Lucius Robinson and Judge Grosbeck. See several old 
residences with ornamental doorways, iron railings and newel posts, 
now Italian and negro tenements. 

26. St. Clement's Church, 108 West Third Street, contains an 
organ built for St. John's Chapel in 1814. It was captured by the 
British and ransomed for $2,000. In 1851 it was rebuilt and placed 
here. The only vault in St. Clement's is that in which ate the 
remains of John Pintard, the founder of the New York Historical 
Society, and those of all his kinsmen removed by him from the 
old French graveyard on Pine Street. {Demolished 191 1.) 

Go down McDougal Street one block, east on Minetta Lane and down 
Minetta Street. 

27. Through Minetta Street once ran Minetta Water, or Brook, 
called by the Dutch Bestavaar's Killetje, " Grandfather's little creek " 
(see Plate XXI, Route 14). Note the curious old houses and angles 
here and on Minetta Place. 

Go west on Bleecker to Christopher Street. 

Bleecker Street was originally called Herring Street for the old 
farm of the Herring family. Pass several rows of old dwellings on 
Bleecker and Carmine Streets. 

28. Home of Tom Paine, at 309 (some say 293) Bleecker Street, 
where he lived with Mme. Bonneville. He died at the site of 59 
Grove Street. Barrow Street was called Reason Street (later 
Raisin Street) for Paine's " Age of Reason " by the Commission- 
ers who designed the City Plan of 1807. 

29. The Commissioner's OiHce was at the northeast corner of 
Christopher and Bleecker Streets. The original building, slightly al- 
tered, still remains. 

Go east on Christopher Street to West Fourth Street. 

30. St. John's Lutheran Church, 81 Christopher Street, was 
built in 1821 as the Eighth Presbyterian Church. 

The site of the Spencer Mansion is at the east side of West Fourth, near West 
Tenth Street; it was used in 1822 as a city post office during the yellow fever 
period. 

81 



Route 10 HISTORICAL GUIDE Jefferson Market 

Go east on West Fourth Street to Sheridan Square. 

West Fourth Street was called Asylum Street, as the New York Orphan 
Asylum was established here. 

31. Old house, 135 West Washington Place, facing on Sheri- 
dan Square. 

Return and continue east on Christopher Street. 

2>2. Christopher Street Square; the meeting point of eight 
streets, in the center of what Hemstreet calls " The Mouse Trap." 
See at. the end of Square the Northern Dispensary instituted in 
1827, present building erected in 1831; note the tablet. 

Return and continue east on Christopher Street. 

Z2. The houses at 11 Christopher Street, opposite Gay Street, 
were occupied a century ago by Scotch weavers. The gardens 
extended down to Greenwich Avenue. 

34. Jefferson Market {New Greenwich Market) : market, court, 
prison, the site originally a pond. The building is the home of 
the Exempt Firemen's Organization (entrance at No. 10 on the 
Grt'tMuvich Avenue side), in whose rooms may be seen an in- 
teresting exhibit of old fire apparatus, pictures, etc. (visitors wel- 
cviinc-. ) 

See the old houses at 129-131 West loth Street, covered with 
wistaria vines. 



82 



MANHATTAN 



ADDENDA— 191 1 

*i (p- 73)- This market was at the foot of W. loth Street until 
Gansevoort Market was opened. 

*2 (p. 75). The keg used at this ceremony is now in the building of 
the N, Y. Historical Society. 

At Christopher and Canal streets were stations of the N. Y. Central 
R. R., Chambers and Hudson streets being the terminal. 

The cars were drawn by horses to 30th Street, where locomotives 
were attached. 

In the early "forties" David C. Broderick had a home on the corner 
of Commerce and Barrow streets. He went to California during the 
gold fever, and being very popular was elected U. S. Senator. 

*3 (P- 75)- Senator Broderick was later shot in a duel by Judge 
Terry. It is said that he and General Winfield Scott used to frequent 
the tavern once called "the Barracks" (see 4, p. 73). 

*4 (p. 76). At 113^ Carmine Street Poe lived and wrote Arthur 
Gordon Pym. No. 4 Charlton Street, now occupied by an Industrial 
School, was the first home owned by William Astor, brother of the first 
John Jacob Astor. When the Astors moved uptown on Lafayette Place 
the house became a tenement, the basement being used for a time as a 
tobacco manufactory. 

On Clark Street (below the foot of McDougal Street) is an old- 
fashioned, out-door smithy. 

*5 (p. 80). McDougal Alley, formerly called "Washington Mews," 
because used for stables of the houses of the Square, is a famous resort 
for artists, whose studios occupy the reconstructed upper floors of the 
former stables. 

*6 (p. 80). A temporary arch was first built across Fifth Avenue, 
running from corner to corner opposite the north side of the Square, 

*7 (p. 80). Tablet to Adam Roelantsen and other early school- 
masters, on the north side of the University building. 



83 



NOTES 



84 



EXCURSION NO. III.— THE BOWERY AND EAST SIDE. 
By Frank Bergen Kelley. 



Copyright, 1905, by the City History Club of New York. 
(Revised 1909 and 1912.) 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




PLAiii XVII, Redrawn from the Ratzer Map. 



86 



THE BOWERY AND EAST SIDE 

Bibliography. 

Works by Ulmann, Hemstreet, R. R. Wilson, Innes and Janvier 
mentioned in Excursion VII. 

"When Old New York was Young'* (chapters on "The Story of 
Chatham Square," " Old Time Theatres," " Bouwerie Village," and 
"Around the Collect Pond") by Hemstreet. 

" Historic New York " (papers on " The 14 Miles Round," " The 
Bowery," and "Old Wells and Water Courses"). 

" Charlotte Temple," by Mrs. Rowson ; with an historical and bio- 
graphical introduction by Francis W. Halsey. 

" The Evolution of Stuyvesant Village," by A. A. Rikeman (pub- 
lished by G. C. Peck). 

" Annals of New York Methodism," by Seaman. 

"Memorial of St. Mark's Church" (published by the Vestry). 

The East Side is to-day chiefly interesting for the great field it 
ofifers to the sociologist and the philanthropist. Attempts are now 
being made to solve many difficult problems in the city administra- 
tion such as the public provision of parks, baths, playgrounds and 
recreation piers. The diversified characteristics of the people, many 
of whom talk, dress and live after the manners of the Fatherland, 
make the East Side particularly attractive to the casual visitor. 

N. B. " Social Settlements," by Henderson and " The Better New 
York," by Tolman and Hemstreet, are recommended as special works 
of reference. 

* refers to Addenda, 1912, p. loi. 

See also : 

" History of St. George's Church in the City of New York," by 
Rev. Henry Anstice; Harper, 191 1. 

" Peter Stuyvesant," by Bayard Tuckerman. 

" A Brief Account of an Historic Church : the Reformed Church : 
the Collegiate Church of the City of New York," published by the 
Consistory, 



87 




THE BOWEU VILLAGE, 




Tmh GovcRN&BiHoviC 
(No3) 



-MopCHM •TVECTS 

-MLUAdC STREET^ 



• — -RcrERCNCES. 

• 1 St Mark's CEKETERr 
i i St Mae K'3 Church 
^ 5Gov 5ryirvt.s^ursHov3Z. j 

• 4 5t Mark's B^k soua. gc . 
I SSrvYvxaANT'sRiARTkxi:. 




KoKBia Vftu.lAM Ek«uc 



Plate XVIII. Bowery Village. 
38 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE II. 

SECTION I— BOWERY VILLAGE. 
Between Second and Sixteenth Streets. 
(Figures refer to Plate XIX; see also XVII, XVIII). 

Peter Stuyvesan* purchased from the West India Company the Great Bouwerie 
(farm) for a country seat, and here he came to live after the surrender of 
New Amsterdam. Bouwerie Lane connected his farm with the City and with 
Harlem, and formed part of the Old Post Road. 

The oldest settled portion of this part of Manhattan was in the vicinity of 
Stuyvesant's Bowery House, around which a little hamlet grew up. The old 
street plan of Bowerie Village may be seen in Plate XVIII, but the original 
streets and names have all disappeared, with the exception of the Bowery and 
Stuyvesant Street. In 1807 was inaugurated the new City Plan of numbered 
streets and avenues arranged at right angles to each other, but there could be 
no regularitv until Thirteenth Street was reached, above which the " checker- 
board plan ' has prevailed. 

Since the early days the shore line has been extended, largely by the redemp- 
tion of great salt meadows, including Tompkins Square. 

Manhattan Island (to be distinguished from the Island of Manhattan) was 
a height covering the blocks between Houston, Lewis and Third Streets and the 
East River. This was formerly surrounded by swamps and became an island 
at high tide. The region was once known as Dry Dock Village. 

The Third Street Recreation Pier was built here in 1897 to provide fresh air 
and good music for the crowded neighborhood. 

From Astor Place Subway Station or the Ninth Street Station of the 
Third Avenue elevated R. R. go east on Stuyvesant Street. 

1. Former home of Nicholas Stuyvesant, 21 Stuyvesant Street, 
.vv^here Hamilton Fish was born. See old-fashioned houses on 
south side of the street. 

2. St. Mark's-in-the-Bowery, Second Avenue and Eleventh 
Street, the second oldest church edifice (on the oldest church 
site still occupied by a church) in Manhattan, erected 1795-99 on 
the site of the early chapel built by Peter Stuyvesant. Judith 
Stuyvesant left the chapel to the Dutch Reformed Church on 
condition that the family vault be preserved. Peter, the great- 
grandson of Governor Stuyvesant, gave the land, chapel and $2,- 
ooo, to which Trinity added $12,500, and the present church was 
built, the steeple being added in 1829 and the porch in 1858. 

Stuyvesant's Tomb is beneath the tablet erected to his memory 
under the southeast end of the church. In the same vault are the 
remains of Governor Sloughter (died 1691), and across the walk, 
in the Minthorne vault, Governor D. T. Tompkins is buried. 

In the churchyard may also be seen the graves of A. T. Stewart 
(whose body was stolen about 1878), Mayor Philip Hone, Dr. 
Harris, first rector of the church and ex-president of Columbia, 
and Thos. Addis Emmett (in Chancellor Jones' vault). Within 

89 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XIX. Route ii. 



C. K. 



90 



Bowery Village MANHATTAN ii Route 

the church may be seen some of the original furniture (the com- 
munion cloth of 1799 and the communion plate of 1845) and a 
number of memorial tablets to prominent New Yorkers. See also 
Stuyvesant Memorial Windows, erected by the Daughters of Hol- 
land Dames. * i 

The old Bowery Village graveyard was in the block bounded by Eleventh and 
Twelfth Streets and First and Second Avenues. 

Stuyvesant's Bouwerie House was just northwest and is said to have been 
the place where the terms of surrender to the English were signed in 1664. 
The house was burned in the early part of the Revolution. PetersHeld, 
another home of the Stuyvesants, was on the East River shore between Fifteenth 
and Sixteenth Streets. Nicholas Wm. Stuyvesant's house was between First 
and Second Avenues, Eighth and Ninth Streets, with an approach from Sixth 
Street and Bowery Lane (see Plate XVIII). 

The former home of the New York Historical Society (now at Central Park 
West and Seventy-sixth Street) stands at 170 Second Avenue, facing the 
church. 

Go north on Second Avenue, passing 

3. An old Stuyvesant residence remodeled as an apartment 
house at 175 Second Avenue and, at 180 Second Avenue, a former 
home of President Buchanan. * 2 

Go west on Thirteenth Street to Third Avenue. 

4. Tablet (northeast corner Thirteenth Street and Third Av- 
enue) marks the site of Peter Stuyvesant's pear tree, brought 
about 1647 or 1665 to his Bouwerie, where it bore fruit for over 
two centuries. A picture of the tree and a branch of it may be 
seen in the Governor's Room in City Hall. A cross-section is in 
the New York Historical Society building. 

Go up Third Avenue. 

5. Second Mile Stone, Third Avenue, between Sixteenth and 
Seventeenth Streets, marks the distance from the present City 
Hall, originally placed near the site of Cooper Union. * 3 

Go east on Sixteenth Street to 

6. Stuyvesant Square, part of the Stuyvesant estate, once a 
private park. 

St. George's Church, built 1845-8 (successor to St. George's 
Chapel, on Beekman Street), and the Friends' Meeting House 
and School (successor to the Meeting House on Pearl and Rose 
Streets), face it on the south.* 4 

Take car south on Second Avenue to 

7. The Middle Dutch Church (Second Avenue and Seventh 
Street), successor to the Church of St. Nicholas in Fort Amsterdam 
and to the Middle Church at Nassau and Cedar Streets. See the 
tablet on the Second Avenue side. Within (entrance at 50 East 

91 



Route II HISTORICAL GUIDE Bowery Village 

Seventh Street) may be seen pictures of the old buildings and four 
memorial tablets in memory of (i) Peter Minuit, first Director- 
General and elder of the original church; (2) Sebastian Janseii Krol 
and Jan Huyck, kranken besoekers (visitors of the sick) ; (3) Rev. 
Jonas Michaelius, the first minister and (4) J. C. Lanphier, founder 
of the Fulton Street prayer meeting. 

See also tablet to victims of the Slocum disaster, 1904, and the 
coat of arms of John Harpendinck (Excursion 1:41). 

A monument in the southwest corner of Tompkins Square 
also commemorates the burning of the Slocum in the East River, 
the victims being chiefly children living in this neighborhood. 

8. The Seventh Street M. E. Church, 24 Seventh Street, erected 
in 1836-7, succeeded the Bowery Village Church which was built in 
1795 at the Two-Mile stone on the site of Cooper Union (see 14).* 5 

9. New York Marble Cemetery (gate at 41 2 Second Avenue), 
established in 1830, now almost forgotten, although there are over 
150 vaults here of the Judson, Lorillard, Grosvenor, Oates, Hol- 
land, Wyckoff and Bloodgood families, and 1,500 burials are re- 
corded. According to a scarcely decipherable inscription on the 
wall it was intended as a "place of interment for gentlemen." It 
is hftpcd that this old cemetery may be converted into a play- 
ground. 

10. New York City Marble Cemetery, Second Street, east of 
Second Avenue, incorporated in 1832. Here are buried James 
Lenox and two of the Dutch dominies, and here for a time were 
the remains of John Ericsson, President Monroe, and Mrs. Paran 
Stevens, and Preserved Fish. See old sun-dial. 

The playground of the school on Second Street, between Av- 
enue A and First Avenue, occupies the graveyard of the Second 
Street M. E. Church, which was built in 1832, at 276 Second Street 
(sec tablet). 

Hamilton Fish Park, between Pitt and Sheriff Streets, south of 
Houston Street, opened in 1896-8, two blocks of foul tenements, 
which included the notorious Bone Alley, being razed. See the open 
air g>'mnasium, playground, public baths and rest house. 

Go zvest on Second and north on Lafayette Street. 
Thv names of Flm Street, New Elm Street, including part of 
Marion Street, and Lafayette Place were changed in 1905 to Lafayette 
Street after the various divisions had been widened and improved. 

93 



Cooper Union MANHATTAN ii Route 

IT. Colonnade Row, partly demolished, now at 428-434 La- 
fayette Street, formerly called La Grange Terrace, in honor of Gen- 
eral Lafayette's home, was built in 1827, and was for a time the 
home of Washington Irving and John Jacob Astor. From one 
of the houses in the row President Tyler was married to Julia 
Gardiner, of Gardiner's Island. 

12. Astor Library, built by John Jacob Astor, incorporated 
1849, opened 1854, and now part of the New York Public Library, 
contains many rare and very valuable books and prints. *6 

On this site, in the latter part of the Eighteenth century, Sperry, a Swiss, 
kept a fruit and flower garden, selling it in 1803 to Astor, who leased it to 
Delacroix. The latter here established his new Vauxhall Garden, which was a 
fashionable resort until 1855. Lafayette Place was opened through the Gar- 
den in 1826. Madame Canda's famous private school for young ladies was 
located here. 

13. Clinton Hall on Astor Place (home of the Mercantile Li- 
brary), successor of the original Clinton Hall on Beekman and Nas- 
sau Streets, was named for Dewitt Clinton, who in 1820 helped es- 
tablish the Mercantile Library. On this site was the Astor Place 
Opera House, the scene of the Forrest and Macready riots in 1849. 

Astor Place, originally called Art Street, connected the Bowery with Green- 
wich Avenue, forming part of the Inland Road to Greenwich, opened 1768 
(Excursion II, Route 10). 

See the statue of Samuel Sullivan Cox ("Sunset Cox"), the 
" Letter Carriers' Friend," in the public square created in 1836. 

Charlotte Temple is supposed to have lived for a time near the southwest 
corner of Astor Place (Art Street) and Fourth Avenue (Bowery). 

14. Cooper Union, devoted to " Science and Art," by Peter 
Cooper, in 1854, on the site of the "Two-Mile Stone" (see 8), 
where was held one of the first New York Sunday-Schools, Peter 
Cooper' acting as Superintendent. See the free reading-room, li- 
brary, Cooper Union Museum for the Arts of Decoration. *7 

In the triangular place south, is the statue of Cooper (by St. 
Gaudens, 1896), on the site of which was a great hay-stand con- 
nected with Tompkins Market. The Seventh Regiment marched 
from this point in 1861. 



93 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




94 



MANHATTAN 



ROUTE 12. 



SECTION II— THE BOWERY, CHATHAM SQUARE AND 
COLLECT POND. 

(Figures refer to Plate XX; see also XVII). 

The Bowery Lane be)?ins at Chatham Square and originally continued up 
Fourth Avenue to Madison Square (see Excursion V, Section 2). In English 
days it was called Bowery Road, shortened in 1807 to The Bowery. Chatham 
Street (now Park Row) and the Bowery formed the chief and, in fact, the 
only important thoroughfare northward until long after the Revolution. 

The Bayard Farm, owned by a nephew of Peter Stuyvesant, lay on the west 
side of the Bowery, between Bleecker and Canal Streets, extending west to 
McDougal Street. Hester Street was namd for Hester Bayard. North of this 
lay the Bleecker farm. 

On Grand Street was a line of British earthworks in the Revolution; 
Bunker Hill or Bayard's Mount was at Grand Street, between the Bowery and 
Broadway. The Bayard Mansion stood on the site of the block bounded by 
Grand, Broome, Crosby and Lafayette Streets, and was approached by Bayard 
Lane, on the line of Broome Street. 

Delancey Street was originally a lane from the house of James Delancey, 
Chief Justice, 1733, at the corner of Chrystie Street, about the site of the 
Mills Hotel No. 2. It has recently been widened and is to be parked as an 
approach to the Williamsburg Bridge. The Delancey Farm stretched along 
the Bowery to Division Street and east to the river. The estate was sold under 
forfeiture after the Revolution, the De Lanceys being loyalists. Division Street 
was so called because it marked the division between the above and the Rutgers 
farm. Great or Delancey Square, as planned in the Ratzer Map of 1767, would 
have been bounded by Broome and Hester, Eldridge and Essex Streets. Oliver 
and James Streets are named for members of the family (see Plate XVII). 

The Collect or Fresh Water Pond, 60 feet deep, once covered 70 acres 
bounded by Lafayette, White, Mulberry and Leonard Streets. In 1626 the 
murder of an Indian here led to a massacre in Governor Kieft's day. The 
execution of criminals took place here in early Colonial days and the supply 
of gunpowder was stored in a house at the back of the Pond. This was a 
favorite resort for fishermen and skaters, and here Fitz-Greene Halleck's father 
is said to have saved Prince William (later William IV of England) from 
drowning in 1781. In 1774 Christopher (Tolles built a pumping station at Pearl 
Street and Broadway and a reservoir at Broadway and White Street, in order 
to supply the city with water from the pond. The Little Collect was between 
Lafayette, Worth, Duane and Park Streets and joined with the Collect. In 
1796 John Fitch experimented with his steamboat on the Collect Pond which 
later became a menace to the health of the community and was filled in about 
1821, its water being drained off by a cut made to the North River through 
Canal Street which then received its present name. 

Note: The usual explanation of the word Collect is that it comes from the 
Dutch " Kalch Hoek " or " Lime Shell Point," supposed to be derived from 
the Indian shell heaps discovered here, but Mr. Edward Hagaman Hall found 
that *' Kolk " is a common term used in Holland to designate an enclosed 
portion of a canal, or little pond. (See 1912 Report, Am. Scenic and Hist. Pres. Soc.) 



95 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




" ^i^gr-if 



Tlate XX. Routes 12, 13. 
f>6 



C. K. 



The Bowery MANHATTAN la Route 

Take Third Avenue car down the Bozvery to Chatham Square, passing 

15. First Mile Stone, Bowery, opposite Rivington Street, and 
One Mile House, across the way. *3 

16. The Thalia Theatre (so called in 1879), just south of Canal 
Street, originally Bowery Theatre, and the fifth of that name and on 
the same site. The old Bowery Theatre (built 1826) was the first 
theatre in New York lighted by gas, and here Charlotte Cushman 
played to fashionable audiences. On the same site, in 1760, stood the 
Bull's Head Tavern, where drovers traded and where Washington 
rested on his entrance to the city in 1783. 

Forsyth Street Methodist Church, 8 Forsyth Street, near Canal 
Street, recently sold and turned into a Jewish playhouse. The orig- 
inal church was erected in 1789 and rebuilt 1833; remodeled in 1872-4. 

17. Chatham Square, called by the Indians Warpoes or Small Hill, a clear- 
ing in the woods fenced off for cattle in 1647, and granted to twelve old 
freedmen of the West India Company. Wolfert Weber's Tavern was located 
here. According to tradition, Charlotte Temple died in a house at the corner 
of Pell Street and Chatham Square. Chatham Square, Chatham and Pitt 
Streets were named for Wm, Pitt, Earl of Chatham. 

18. " The Jews' Burial Ground '* (Oliver Street and New Bow- 
ery), as it is called on old city maps, granted in 1656 and deeded 
to the Jews in 1729-30, is the oldest Jewish cemetery in New 
York. In 1902 it was marked by a tablet erected under the aus- 
pices of The American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society 
and The Jewish Historical Society. It was a fortified hill during 
the Revolution.* 8 

The Tea Water Pump, one of the chief sources of the supply of drinking 
water in early days, was located at 166 Chatham Street (Park Row), just south, 
of Chatham Square. Diagonally across the street was The Chatham or Purdy's 
National Theatre in which Uncle Tom's Cabin was first produced in 1852. 

The first Kissing Bridge crossed Old Wreck Brook at Roosevelt Street (Ex- 
cursion 1:46). This is the center of a Greek settlement. 

Go east on Henry Street. 

19. Mariners' Temple, Oliver and Henry Streets, now used as 
an Italian Church, was built in 1843 on the site of the old Oliver 
Street Baptist Church; see tablet. * 9 

P. S. No. I, opposite 19, is the successor to the first 
Free School of New York. (Excursion 1:8). 

20. Church of the Sea and Land, built in 1817, stands on 
Henry Street, southwest corner of Market Street; see tablet. 

Return on Henry Street to Chatham Square and go north on Mott 

Street. 

97 



Route 12 HISTORICAL GUIDE Five Points 

21. Roman Catholic Church of the Transfiguration, corner of 
Mott and Park Streets, is successor to Zion Lutheran, later an 
Episcopal Church, built in 1801, rebuilt in 1818. This is the cen- 
ter of Chinatown. 

Go west on Park Street, crossing 

Mulberry Bend Park, made by the demolition of crowded blocks 
of tenement houses, giving light, air and recreation to the neigh- 
borhood. * 10 

22. The Five Points, once a most dangerous part of the slums, 
now the site of Paradise Park, which is faced by the Five Points 
Mission, incorporated in 1850 (on the site of the notorious Old Brav- 
ery), and the Five Points House of Industry. In 1740 fourteen 
negroes were burned here during the Negro Insurrection. Here the 
"Dead Rabbits" had their headquarters and fought the "Bowery 
lioys." The Seventh Regiment was called out July 3, 1857, to quell a 
riot here. 

Continue west on Park Street to Centre Street. 

23. The Manhattan Water Tank (consisting of iron plates fas- 
tened by metal pins), northwest corner of Reade and Centre 
Streets, now enclosed but visible through the windows. This tank 
was built by the Manhattan Water Company which was headed 
by Aaron Burr, whose real aim was to get a charter in 1799 for 
the Manhattan Bank, now at 40 Wall Street. (Excursion VII 123). 
The source of the water supply is the same springs which orig- 
inally filled the Collect Pond. Wooden pipes, made by boring 
logs, were laid through the streets. It is known to the nearby 
residents as " the old well." Good specimens of the pipes may be 
sfcn in the Manhattan Bank and in the New York Historical 
Society building. 

24. Cobweb Hall at 80 Duane Street, an old road-house, the 
framework of the building dating back to about 1780. See within 
the cfjhwchs and old pictures, theatre programs and curios. 

Go up Centre Street. 

25. The Tombs and the Criminal Court Building, joined by the 
lUidi^c of Sifihs. IMic original Tombs was erected in 1838 of stone 
brought from the Bridezvell in City Hall Square. The site is near the 
t tntrc of the Collect Pond. 

q8 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE 13. 

SECTION III— CORLAER'S HOOK PARK, AND GRAND 

STREET TO BROADWAY. 

(Figures refer to Plate XX). 

Take Canal Street car east to Scammel Street, passing 

through the Ghetto, so called from the large Jewish population. 

26. Wm. H. Seward Park and open-air playground made by the 
removal of several blocks of tenements. 

Go south on Seammel Street. 

27. All Saints* Church (built 1828), southeast corner of Henry 
and Scammel Streets. 

Go south on Scammel and east on Cherry Street to 

28. Corlaer's Hook Park which, with the adjacent territory, was 
part of Jacob Corlaer's lands in early Colonial days. The Indians 
named this Naig-ia-nac or Sand Lands, and here they had a village 
from which -a trail ran on the line of Grand Street across the island 
and up to Sappokanican. Here, in 1643, a number of defenceless 
Indians were slaughtered by order of Governor Kieft. 

Go north to Grand Street and take car west on Grand Street to La- 
fayette Street, passing 

29. The statue of Gutenberg, inventor of movable type (by 
Ralph Goddard), on the Hoe Building, Grand and Sheriff Streets. 
An interesting old press may be seen within. Willett and Sheriff 
Streets were named for Colonel Marinus Willett of Revolution- 
ary fame. Sheriff and Mayor of New York about one hundred 
years ago. 

Mount Pitt was an eminence at Grand and Pitt Streets. 

30. St. Mary's Roman Catholic Church, at Grand and Ridge 
Streets, contains the oldest bell in a Catholic Church in Man- 
hattan. 

31. Old Essex Market (built 1818) and Police Court (1856), 
Essex and Grand Streets. Ludlow Street Jail, north of Essex 
Market, is the jail of New York County. It was used as a prison 
for debtors and, until recently, for Federal prisoners in New 
York City. It was built in 1859-60, succeeding the Eldridge 
Street Prison; see tablet. * 11 

32. First building of the Board of Education, northwest corner 
of Lafayette Street, now used as a High School annex. See tab- 
let. 

99 



Route 13 HISTORICAL GUIDE St. Patrick's 

Go north on Lafayette to Prince Street. 

22,- Monroe House, 62 Prince Street, home of Samuel Gouver- 
neur when liis father-m-law, ex-President Monroe, died there in 
1831. See the tablet erected in 1905 by the Woman's Auxiliary 
to the American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society. 

Go east on Prince Street to 

34. St. Patrick's Roman Catholic Church, between Mott and 
EHzabcth Streets, once the cathedral, built 1809-15. Vicar-Gen- 
eral Starr, the first resident Bishop Connelly and " Boss " John 
Kelly are buried here. * 12 

Go west to Broadway. 

Site of Niblo's Garden and Theatre, northeast corner of Broadway and Prince 
Street, opposite which lived James Fenimore Cooper. 

The Garden later contained the famous Metropolitan Hotel (1852-94). 

Go north on Broadzvay. 

36. Hotel Raleigh, known once as the Tremont House, oppo- 
site Bond Street, consists in part of the first houses constructed 
with marble fronts in the city, built in 1825. * 13 

C24 Broadway, site of Laura Keene's Theatre, later the Olympic. 
677 Broadway, site of Tripler Hall and the first Metropolitan Opera House 
where Patti first sang in New York. 



100 



MANHATTAN 



ADDENDA— 1912 

*i (p. 91). Tablets: (i) erected 1903 by the Daughters of Holland 
Dames in Commemoration of the 250th anniversary of the granting of 
the Charter and the 256th of the landing of Peter Stuyvesant in New 
Amsterdam; (2, 3) for Lt. Col. Nicholas Fish and his wife Elizabeth, 
a daughter of Petrus Stuyvesant ; (4) for Sergeant Hamilton Fish, who 
died in the Spanish-American War ; the Sons of the Revolution in 1904 
added a memorial window by Tiffany (as are also the Stuyvesant 
windows) in memory of Col. Tallmadge (u. 45). 

*2 (p. 91). The birthplace of Augustus Van Horn Stuyvesant. on the 
site of another Peter Stuyvesant's farm house, is at 126 Second 
Avenue: it is now remodeled for a motion picture theatre. The 
Keteltas Mansion stands on the N. W. cor. of St. Mark's Place and 
Second Avenue. It is about to be remodeled for a motion picture 
theatre. The Rutherford Mansion, now an apartment house at 175 
Second Avenue, was the home of Lewis M. Rutherford, the astronomer. 
His son became the heir of Peter Gerard Stuyvesant, his uncle, chang- 
ing his own name to Peter Gerard Stuyvesant. 

The Presbyterian Church at Second Avenue and Fourteenth Street 
is now used as a "Labor Temple" by the Presbyterian Board of Home 
Missions, and for Hungarian services. 

*3 (PP- 91- 97)- These milestones are soon to be marked with tablets 
by the City History Club (see Appendix A, p. 371). 

*4 (pp. 91). A large bell set in the garden on the i6th Street side 
bears the inscription "Presented by Thomas H. Smith, Esq., to the Cor- 
poration of St. George's, New York. 1818." 

*5 (p. 92). This building is now used as a Ruthenian Greek Catholic 
Church, and has been slightly altered like Oriental architecture. 

*6 (p. 93). All the books and prints have been removed (1911) to 
the new Public Library at 40th Street and Fifth Avenue (No. 3, p. ii7- 
and appendix D, p. 395). 

*7 (P- 93)- In the Great Hall of Cooper Union. Freeborn Garretson, 
Henry Ward Beecher and Wendell Phillips spoke against slavery and 
secession. Popular mass meetings and lecture courses are held here. 
See memorial tablets and testimonials to Peter Cooper, Abraham 
Lincoln and Charles Sprague Smith, the founder of People's Institute, 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Old Tompkins Market, once the Sixty-ninth Regiment Armory, oppo- 
site on Third Avenue, has been torn down and an annex erected (1911- 
12) to accommodate the classes of Cooper Institute. 

*8 (p. 97). The tablet was presented by Isidor Straus and erected 
April 20, 1903. On the building at the N. E. corner of Oliver and Oak 
streets are several curious figures on the Oak Street side: disks, field 
guns, mortars, etc. The owner of the building transferred them from 
the building formerly on this site. Tradition connects them with an 
event in a tavern here at the close of the Revolution-, but this appears 
impossible, as the site was then under water. 

*9 (P- 97)- The tablet states that the original church was erected in 
1705, rebuilt in 1800 and 1812, and that the present building was com- 
pleted in 1844. It is now used for services in the English, German, 
Italian and Greek languages. 

See tablet on the wall of P. S. 2, 116 Henry Street between Pike and 
Rutgers streets, erected by the Alumni Association, to commemorate 
the one hundredth anniversary of the founding of this school, organ- 
ized in 191 1 by The Free School Society on land donated by Col. 
Henry Rutgers. 

*io (p. 98). On October 12, 1911 (Columbus Day), the name was 
changed to Columbus Park. See old houses at 466 Pearl and 173 
Worth streets. 

*ii (p. 99). Essex Market building is now used for a public school 
and the Police Court has been removed from the old building. 

*i2 (p. 100) 35. "House of Lords," an old tavern, S. W. corner of 
I^ast Houston and Crosby streets. 

There are several quaint old houses on Mott between Grand and 
Canal streets. 

*I3 (p. 100). The Raleigh was torn down in 1911. See tablet at 719 
Ikoadway, marking the site of the New York Hotel, i843-'44. 

Tablet on granite shaft, Delancey Street and Bowery, to Timothy D. 
Sullivan, erected by his friend, John J. White. 



IQZ 



EXCURSION v.— THE NINETEENTH CENTURY CITY. 
TENTH TO ONE HUNDRED AND TWENTY-FIFTH STREET. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley, 

Corrected (1909) with the aid of Hopper Striker Mott. 

Copyright, 1902, by the City History Club of New York. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XXI. Routes 14, 15, 16. 



C. K. 



104 



THE NINETEENTH CENTURY CITY. 



Bibliography. 

Works by Ulmann, Janvier ("Down Love Lane"), R- R- Wilson, 
Hemstreet (particularly in "When Old New York was Young") 
mentioned in Excursion VII. 

"Felix Oldboy's Tour Around Old New York," by Colonel IMines. 

" Old New York," by Greatorex. 

Valentine's Manual of the Common Council of New York. 

" The New York of Yesterday — Bloomingdale," by Mott. 

"The Greatest Street in the World — Broadway," by Stephen Jenkins.. 

1912 Report, Am. Scenic and Historic Preservation Soc, pp. 128, 130. 

Battle of Harlem Heights. 

" Battle of Harlem Heights," by Shepard in " Historic New York," 

Vol. II. 
"The Battle of Harlem Heights," by Johnston. 
" The Campaign of 1776," by Johnston. 

"Field Book of the Revolution," Vol. II., p. 816, by Tossing. 
" History of Attacks on New York," by Stedman. 
"Memorial History of New York," Vol. II, by Wilson. 
"History of New York," Chap. VII, by Stone. 
"Transactions of the Long Island Historical Society," Vol. IIL 
"Nathan Hale," by Prof. H. P. Johnston. 



N. B.— -* refers to Addenda, 1912, on pages 138, 139. 



105 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ROUTE 14. 

SECTION I.— UNION SQUARE TO GRAMERCY PARK. 
(For Sections I, II and III, figures refer to Plate XXI.) 

General Viele's Map in Wilson's Memorial History, Vol. IV, and 
the Commissioners Map of 1807 are .useful in showing early houses, 
lanes and roads. 

Take Subway to Fourteenth Street. 

I. Union Square, designated as Union Place by the Commissioners of the 
Citv Plan, who in 1807-11 laid out Manhattan on the "checker-board system." 
Because of the intersection of the Bowery and Broadway, this was left an 
open sduarc, but not formally laid out until 1832, when Samuel B. Ruggles 
was instrumental in planning the park of three and one-half acres. Lower 
Broadway was made to bend at Tenth Street to avoid the demolition of the 
Brcvoort homestead and it connected with the Road to Bloomingdale, which 
ran diajionally across the Square from Bowery, or New York Lane. 

Hendrick Brcvoort's farm was bounded as follows: the southwest corner 
began at the middle of Fifth Avenue, between Eighth and Ninth Streets, ran 
north along Minetta Water, which was the westerly boundary, to a point about 
fifty feet north of Twelfth Street; thence east in a straight line to the west 
side of I'"ourtli ,\venue in Fourteenth Street, thence south along the west side 
of Fourth Avenue to a point about seventy-five feet north of Tenth Street, 
and tlicnce west in a straight line to the point of beginning. Because of the 
o[ipr)sition of Brevoort, who wished to save a favorite tree, Eleventh Street 
was not cut through between Broadway and Fourth Avenue. 

The Minto Estate, once owned by Lieutenant-Governor Elliott, then by 
Baron I'oolnitz, and later part of the Randall Farm, lay south. The ground 
rents from this property to-day support the Sailors' Snug Harbor on Staten 
Island. 

The Spingler Estate, bought from Elias Brevoort in 1788, adjoined the 
Brevoort l-'arm on the north and was bounded as follows: the west dne was 
MiiKita Water, the cast line Fourth Avenue and a prolongation of Blooming- 
dale Rf.ad. the north line ran from a point now in Union Square at a point 
about etjuidistant between Fifteenth and Sixteenth Streets in a straight line 
to a point about fifty feet north of the north side of Fourteenth Street and 
two hundred feet cast of the easterly side of Sixth Avenue, and the south line 
bordered on the T.revoort F'arm. 

The large fountain in the center of Union Square dates from 
184.' when Croton water was introduced into the city. The small 
fountain facing Broadway at Sixteenth Street was donated to the 
city by I). Willis James and erected in 1881. It was designed by 
Adclf Donndorf of Stuttgart and founded in bronze in Brunswick, 
Gorniany. 

The bronze equestrian statue of Washington, copied from Hou- 
don, was erected by city merchants at the spot where Washington 
was received by the citizens on Evacuation Day, November 25, 
I7«?. and was dedicated Jidy 4, 1856. This is the oldest public 
statue m the city which stands in its original place, and was the 
work of Henry K. Brown. 

106 



Union Square MANHATTAN 14 Route 

Near the statue there was held in 1861 a great war meeting in 
response to Lincoln's call for troops. Facing it is the statue of 
Lafayette, modelled by Bartholdi and presented in 1876 to the 
city by French residents as a token of gratitude for American 
sympathy in the Franco-Prussian War. 

At the southwest corner of the Square see the bronze statue of 
Lincoln, by H. K. Brown, erected by popular subscription under 
the auspices of the Union League Club about 1866. 
Go west on Sixteenth Street 

2. Home of William Cullen Bryant, 24 West Sixteenth Street. 
Pass the Church and College (opened in 1847) of St. Francis 
Xavier. 

3. Paisley Place or Weavers' Row, a double row of rear 
wooden houses entered by alleys at 115-117 West Sixteenth Street 
and 112-114 West Seventeenth Street. They were built about 1822 
to accommodate Scotch weavers from Paisley who fled to this part 
of the city to escape yellow fever. 

Go dozvn Sixth Avenue and west on Fourteenth Street. 

4. Cruger Mansion, 126-130 West Fourteenth Street, between 
Sixth and Seventh Avenues, once the home of the Metropolitan 
Museum of Art. In the Metropolitan Temple at Fourteenth 
Street and Seventh avenue are Memorial windows to ex-Presi- 
dents McKinley and Roosevelt.* 1 

Go east on Fourteenth Street. 

5. The Van Beuren House, 21 West Fourteenth Street (built 
about 1855), one of the last private residences on this block and the 
second homestead of the Spingler Estate. This family is distinct 
from that to which President Van Buren belonged. 

Go dozvn Fifth Avenue and west on Thirteenth Street. 
At 36 West Thirteenth Street (Steeple Building) and 43-45 West 
Twelfth Street, see in the oblique walls of the buildings traces of the 
old Union Road which originally connected Skinner Road (the con- 
tinuation of Christopher Street) with the Southampton Road at 
Fifteenth Street and Seventh Avenue (Section III, A). Note the 
lines of these roads and of Minetta Brook on Plate XXI. 

6. 60 West Thirteenth Street (occupied 1897-1905 by the De- 
Witt Clinton High School), famous as the "old Hliirteenth Street 
School," once under the principalship of Dr. Hunter (^ founder of the 
Normal College) whose graduates have formed the Hiomas Hunter 
Association. 

107 



Route 14 HISTORICAL GUIDE Union 

Go down to Sixth Avenue. 

7. Miiiigan Place (old Milligan's Lane), west side of Sixth 
Avenue, between Tenth and Eleventh Streets, once connected Amos 
(West Tenth) Street with the Union Road. Note the slant of the 
building on the north side marking the original direction of the 
Lane. 

Go zvest on Eleventh Street. 

8. The "Grapevine" (Sixth Avenue and West Eleventh Street) 
was once a popular roadhouse on the old Union Road. 

9. The second "Beth Haim " (House of Rest), a Jev^ish Ceme- 
tery, was established here 1804-5 (the early cemetery being still 
visible at Oliver Street and New Bowery. (Excursion III:i8.) It 
was used as a burial place for strangers, but became the regular 
cemetery of the congregation in 1882. In 1829, Eleventh Street east 
of Sixth Avenue was opened by the City Commissioners, encroaching 
largely on the cemetery, whereupon a third site was purchased in 
1830 at the southwest corner of Sixth Avenue and Twenty-first 
Street (Section II:3i). 

At 33 West Eleventh Street, note the building in the rear (cistern 
and chimney), which was near the line of the Union Road. 

Go north on Fifth Avenue. 

10. The Old First Presbyterian Church, Fifth Avenue, between 
Llcveuth and Twelfth Streets, successor to the early church on 
Wall Street founded in 1719. See tablet (Excursion VII :2o). 

Gj east on Thirteenth Street to University Place, then east on West 
Twelfth Street. 

11. Tablet, southeast corner of Thirteenth Street and Univer- 
sity Place, erected in 1908 by the officers and veterans of the Ninth 
Regiment, National Guard, State of New York, organized in 1799, 
acting as the Eighty-third New York Volunteers in the Civil War. 
I'Vom their headquarters, site marked by the tablet, "they marched 
away 850 strong, May 27, 1861. They returned home June 11, 1864, 
with 17 officers and 78 enlisted men after having gone through 24 
battles." 



108 



Square MANHATTAN 14 Route 

12. New York Society Library at 109 University Place, the 
oldest public library in America, established in 1700 in the English 
City Hall by Governor Bellomont, incorporated in 1754 as the City 
Library and chartered by George III in 1772 as the New York 
Society Library. The present building was erected in 1856. See within 
many rare prints of old New York; complete files of local news- 
papers, all the well-known histories, guide books, directories, etc., of 
New York. 

13. Old Twelfth Street School, once under the principalship of 
Lydia Wadleigh who did so much to promote free education for 
girls. 

Go down Broadway to 

14. Grace Churchyard. See the sun dial, doliola and marble 
seat. The doliola, made to hold grain, was found while digging for 
the foundation of St. Paul's on the Via Nationale in Rome, and was 
presented by the late Dr. Nevin of that church. Two like it re- 
main in St. Paul's Church garden. Grace Church originally stood 
at Broadway and Rector Street. (Excursion VII iiq). The present 
building was erected in 1845. 

Go east on Tenth Street to Fourth Avenue, north to Fourteenth 

and then east. 

15. The Academy of Music, corner of Irving Place, the first 
building erected in 1854, rebuilt 1868, the home of opera in New 
York until 1883. 

16. Tammany Hall, fourth building of the Tammany Society, 
Columbian Order, established in 1786. See on the front " Tammany 
Society, 1789-1867 " and the figure of St. Tammany, the Indian 
Chief. Within the building may be seen some valuable historical 
paintings and prints. The " Wigwam " on the top floor contains the 
emblems of the Society. 

Go north on Irving Place. 

17. House of Washington Irving, southwest corner of Seven- 
teenth Street, opposite the new Washington Irving High School.*2 

Go east on Eighteenth Street. 

18. Bayard Taylor's Home, " the Stuyvesant," 142 East Eigh- 
teenth Street, one of the oldest apartment houses in New York; 
built in 1869 on the French model by Rutherford Stuyvesant whose 
family still owns it. 

109 _ 



Route 14 HISTORICAL GUIDE Gramercy Park 

Go north on Irving Place to 

19. Gramercy Park. Innes says that . the name was derived 
from " Krom merssche " or " Krom moerasje " (crooked little swamp), 
formed by the shape of Cedar Creek which flowed from Madison 
Square and emptied into the East River at Eighteenth Street. In 
1780 Gramercy Seat was the 20-acre farm of James Diiane (Mayor 
I78.v88), and later became the property of Samuel B. Ruggles, who 
in December, 1831, set apart to trustees 42 lots for the creation of 
Gramercy Park. According to the deed, they were to surround the 
plot with an iron railing with ornamental gates, and by January i, 
1834, to lay out the grounds and plant trees. The tenants occupying 
the 66 lots bounding it were to have the right of access thereto as 
a place of common resort and recreation, providing each contributed 
ten dollars per year for its maintenance. The work was completed 
in 1840. See tablet set in the sidewalk near the west gate. 

20. The Samuel J. Tilden House (now the National Arts Club) 
is at 14-15 Gramercy Park South. It is noted for its sculptured 
front. See the medallion heads of Shakespeare, Milton, Dante, 
Goethe and Franklin. 

Go west on Twentieth Street, passing the 

21. Home of the Cary Sisters at 53 East Twentieth Street and 

22. Tlie birthplace of Theodore RooseveP, 28 East Twentieth 
Street. 

23. Horace Greeley lived at 35 East Nineteenth Street>'3 

In the Players Clubhouse, 16 Gramercy Park South, is a collection 
of old theatre programs, etc. 



no 



MANHATTAN 
ROUTE 15. 

SECTION II.— MADISON SQUARE AND VICINITY. 

24. Madison Square (6.84 acres) was originally planned and used as a 
*' Parade Ground " to extend from Twenty-third to Thirty-fourth Streets and 
from Third to Seventh Avenues. The territory it covered was bounded on the 
west by the Bloomingdale Road and was crossed by the Old Post Road. The 
double ROW of trees seen from the fountain, looking north to Madison Avenue, 
denotes the bed of the Old Post Road which was closed April 27, 1844, by 
resolution of the Common Council. (See Appendix — " The City Milestones and 
the Old Post Road.") To Mayor Harper (1844) must be given the credit for 
the improvement of the Square. The triangle south of the Post Road, a part of 
the Common Lands, belonged to the city; that part thereof to Twenty-sixth 
Street was purchased in 1845, largely from General Theodorus Bailey, the City 
Postmaster. Such part as the city owned was legally opened as a park on May 
10, 1844. Proceedings to acquire title to that part not purchased of General 
Bailey were confirmed May 3, 1847, 3t a total cost of $65,952. Fifth Avenue, 
from Twenty-third to Twenty-eighth Streets, was ordered filled in and regu- 
lated in March, 1845. The park was ordered lighted by gas in 1852 and was 
limited to its present dimensions by Chapter 177 of the Laws of 1837. 

The Potter's Field was in Madison Square between 1794-7. 

See the statues of Wm. H. Seward, by Rogers, 1876; Roscoe Conk- 
ling, by J. Q. A. Ward, 1893; Admiral Farragiit. by St. Gaiidens, 
erected in 1881 by the Farragnt Memorial Association, and Chester A. 
Arthur, by Bissell, 1899. The small drinking fountain was given by 
Miss Catherine Wolfe and the large one by Mrs. O. E. P. Stokes. 

25. The Worth Monument (of Quincy granite, 51 feet high) 
by James C. Batterson, erected in 1857 at the junction of Fifth 
Avenue, Broadway and Twenty-fifth Street by the corporation of the 
city, to honor Major-General Worth, who distinguished himself in 
the Mexican War, His body rests beneath the monument. See the 
equestrian figure of Worth in high relief on the south face of the 
monument. 

The United States Arsenal stood near the site of the Worth Monument from 
1808 to 1824. The deed of the City authorities to the general government of 
land for the site of the arsenal, or magazine (as the old maps have it), was 
dated November 17, 1807. The possibility of the War of 181 2 caused its con- 
struction as a defensive measure. The United States conveyed the building and 
its rights to the site to the Society for the Reformation of Juvenile Delinquents, 
July 21, 1824, for $6,000. Two wings were added by the Society, one for each 
sex and the remodeled edifice opened January i, 1825. After its destruction by 
fire in 1839, a new building was erected at Bellevue in October of the following 
year, and the inmates, on its abandonment in 1854, were removed to Randall's 
Island. 

Go east through the Square to 

26. Madison Square Garden, opened in 1890, on the site of the 
old Harlem R. R. Station and later the site of a Hippodrome opened 
by Barnum in 1873. It was first called by its present name on May 

31, 1879. 

27. The Appellate Court House, Twenty-fifth Street and Madi- 
son Avenue, James Brown Lord, architect. The symbolic mural 
paintings in the main entrance and the Court Room are by well-known 
American artists and of special interest. 



Route 15 HISTORICAL GUIDE Madison 

Cross Madison Square to Twenty-Third Street and Fifth Avenue. 

28. Site of the Fifth Avenue Hotel. The farm on which this famous hostelry 
stood belonged to John Horn, whose homestead was in the center of Fifth Av- 
enue, just south of Twenty-third Street. This " House of John Horn " was 
designated in the Law of 1703 as the starting point of the Bloomingdale Road. It 
was' occupied bv Christopher Mildeberger (who married Horn's daughter) when 
Fifth Avenue was opened in 1837. On petition, the Common Council granted 
that it should remain on its site until November, 1839. After its removal to the 
site of the Fifth Avenue Hotel in that year, it was a tavern kept by Thompson, 
known as the "Madison Cottage." Here it .stood until 1853 (14. years) when it 
was torn down to make way for Franconi's Hippodrome which was opened 
in 1853 and occupied the entire block front. The hotel, which was razed in 
1908, succeeded this building. In this hotel was erected in 1859 the first pas- 
senger elevator. 

Go down Fifth Avenue to West Twenty-first Street, passing 

29. Tablet at 5 West Twenty-second Street, marking the site 
of the home of S. F. B. Morse.*4 

The Buckhorn Tavern was on the southeast corner of Broadway and Twenty- 
second Street. 

The Union House stood at the corner of Love Lane (Twenty-first Street) 
and Bloomingdale Road. On its second floor the Civil District Court was held 
for many years. This building was the residence of Jacob, son of John Horn, 
and was built by him. 

Go west on Twenty-first Street, the line of Abingdon Road. 

30. The Home o£ Chester A. Arthur, 34 West Twenty-first 
Street, shortly l)efore his accession to the presidency. 

31. Beth Haim, the third Jewish Cemetery, best seen from 
the staircase at the rear of O'Neill's store, at the corner of Twenty- 
first Street and Sixth Avenue. A cemetery was established here in 
1830 (Section l:g). 

Go north on Sixth Avenue to Twenty-third Street. 

32. Bust and tablet of Edwin Booth at 70 West Twenty-third 
Street, marking the site of Booth's Theatre. 

3^. Schermerhorn Mansion. 40 West Twentv-third Street, the 
last private residence on the block. When erected, the population 
of New York was 700,000; stages ran on Broadway; horse cars 
were in common use; Harlem trains ran to White and Center Streets 
and Hudson River trains to Varick and Beach Stre.-ts (demolished igii). 

Take Tivcnty-third Street Cross Town ear east, passing 

thinl sS^andMl^'^nS"'^ i ^'"^ .i'or^, established at the corner of Twenty- 
\ca.cmv but in \'^^'"eton Avenue in 1848-9. It was then known as the Free 
West O^lc un. Vm n.l/^-n'w'^ its charter as a college. The new buildings on 

1? ^'^thundr , and ih.rty^eighth Street were formally opened in 1908. 
Twenty furtStrpi ♦jf^'^l'/^- J'''/'■^ "o^thwest corner of Third Avenue and 
bu It al,o s'^/, l?v' T^'^ third of the name (See Excursion I: 19 and III: 16), 

I) el o ^tea ;.1> -It ^famo""'Tf ^^^'^^^ and owned for years by "Uncle Dan'l '' 
of Now Vo?k muil R?R ,1 "^^^.^^^ headquarters of the drovers and butchers 
Street Tic reiio hell.o.^^'r ^^! "P^^'j "^^/^^^^ ^^^ "^o^ed to Forty-second 
and VoJZ A"^i::i.^::Z"ZosZ'^^^^ 53V?r"*^ Streets,'second 

the old Hose Hill Farm. "^^" ^^ ^"^ tinll s Head Village and was part of 

112 



Square MANHATTAN 15 Route 

36. Gate and wall of the old House of Refuge at the entrance 
to a storage yard on the north side of Twenty-third Street, between 
First Avenue and Avenue A, to which site the institution was re- 
moved in 1839. 

Go north on Avenue A and through the grounds of the Department 
of Charities to Twenty-sixth Street. 

2,7. Bellevue Hospital, on what was the Belle Vue Farm. 
The City hospital was moved here in 1810 from the neighbor- 
hood of City Hall Park, together with the penitentiary and alms- 
house, the last two being later removed to Blackwell's Island. 
The first ambulance service in the world was inaugurated in i860 
by tliis hospital. See on the portico at the entrance to the main 
building a bit of peculiarly wrought iron railing, beneath which is 
a tablet stating that this formed part of the balcony of Federal 
Hall where Washington delivered his first Inaugural Address. 
Another portion of the railing is in the New York Historical 
Society Building. (Excursion VII :2i). The main or gray stone 
building was the original Bellevue Hospital, the corner stone of 
which was laid in 1812. 

Walk zvest on Tzventy-seventh Street 

38. The Peter Cooper House, moved in 1820 from the site of the Bible 
House to Twenty-eighth Street and Fourth Avenue, remained here until 1909. 

39. The Church dli St. Esprit (45 East Twenty-seventh Street), 
the successor to the original Huguenot Church, built in 1688 in 
Petticoat Lane. (Excursion VII :i3 and 1:28). See tablet in the 
vestibule, erected in 1902 by the Huguenot Society of America. 

Go north on Fifth Avenue to Twenty-ninth Street. 

40. Church of the Transfiguration (5 East Twenty-ninth 
Street), often called "The Little Church Around the Corner," 
from the remark of the curate of a near by church who, on being 
asked to officiate at the funeral of Holland, the actor, refused, 
adding that " perhaps the rector of the little church around the 
corner might be willing to serve." The church was opened in 
1856. From it have been buried Wallack, Booth and Boucicault. 
See the Lich Gate and memorial window to Edwin Booth. 



113 



Route 15 HISTORICAL GUIDE 

41. Marble Collegiate Reformed Church, Twenty-ninth Street 
and Fifth Avenue, dedicated in 1854. See tablet commemorating 
its succession to the " Church in the Fort " and, in the yard, the 
bell which originally hung in the North Church. (Section IV: 
5 and Excursion 1:37). 

Go west on Twenty-ninth Street to Sixth Avenue and south to 

42. Mouquin's Restaurant, located on the old Varian Farm, the 
homestead of which family stood on the west side of Bloomingdale 
Road, near the corner of Twenty-sixth Street (just north of it). 
In the homestead were born, 1793, Isaac Leggett Varian, Mayor 
1839-40, and his brother William. The latter inherited the portion 
of the farm on which the building on Sixth Avenue is located, and 
he built and lived in the house. It was known for years as the 
" Knickerbocker Cottage," the Varians being a Knickerbocker family. *5 



IT4 



MANHATTAM 

ROUTE i6. 

SECTION III— LOVE LANE AND CHELSEA VILLAGE. 

Fourteenth to Twenty-fourth Streets; Sixth to Tenth Avenues. 
A. LOVE LANE AND TRACES OF THE OLD ROADS. 

The Abingdon Road (named for the Earl of Abingdon, son-in-law of Sir 
Peter Warren), or "Love Lane" originally followed the line of West Twenty- 
first Street from the Bloomingdale Road to a point east of Eighth Avenue 
where it turned slightly northwest to Chelsea (traces at 318 and 342-346 West 
Twenty-first Street and the southwest corner of Eighth Avenue and Twenty-first 
Street). It was met just east of Sixth Avenue by the Southampton Road 
(traces at Paisley Place. Section 1:3); east of Seventh Avenue by the War- 
ren Road (traces at 148 West Nineteenth Street and 154 West Seventeenth 
Street); east of Eighth Avenue it crossed the Fitzroy Road (running from 
Fifteenth to Forty-second Streets; traces remaining at 254 West Twentieth 
Street, 256 West Eighteenth Street and 246-250-252 West Seventeenth Street) ; 
and east of Ninth Avenue by a Fourth road (traces at 339 West Twenty-first 
Street, 346 and 368-370 West Eighteenth Street, 352-356 West Seventeenth 
Street, 352-354 West Sixteenth Street, 2^7 West Fifteenth Street and 112 
Ninth Avenue). 

These four roads connected Love Lane with the Great Kill Road which fol- 
lowed the line of Gansevoort Street, extended to Sixteenth Street east of Seventh 
Avenue (traces in oblique wall of St. Joseph's Home, northwest corner of 
Fifteenth Street and Seventh Avenue). 

Quaint houses, some with oriel windows and newel posts, many of them 
reached through alleyways, survive on Twentieth Street between Eighth and 
Ninth Avenues, on Eighteenth Street between Eighth and Ninth Avenues and 
Sixteenth and Seventeenth Streets between Seventh and Eighth Avenues; also 
along Seventh and Eighth Avenues between Fifteenth and Twenty-third Streets. 

B. CHELSEA. 

Chelsea is the name applied to that part of the city between Eighth Av- 
enue, the Hudson, Nineteenth and Twenty-fourth Streets, and was so called for 
the homestead of Captain Clarke, a veteran of the French and Indian Wars. 
His house, (43 in map) named for the Soldiers' Home near London, was 
built in 1750, about 200 feet west of the present Ninth Avenue between 
Twenty-second and Twenty-third Streets, the grounds running down to the 
river which then came nearly to Tenth Avenue. It was rebuilt by " Mistress 
Molly Clarke," who lived here until 1802. Her daughter married Bishop 
Moore, whose son, Clement C. Moore, lived here until 1850. Here, in 1822, he 
wrote the familiar poem " A Visit from St. Nicholas," 

" 'Twas the night before Christmas," etc. 
Through his agencv streets were opened through this property in 1823. The 
old house was torn down in 1852-3 when the bluffs along the river shore were 
leveled and the shore line extended west. 

The whole shore line is being improved, entire blocks of buildings having been 
demolished to make way for modern warehouses and the new streets which are 
being constructed along the river front. 

Tablet on Red Star Dock at Twenty-second Street and Twelfth 
Avenue marks the " Chelsea Improvement," a great system of new 
docks not yet completed and meant to accommodate the largest 
merchant vessels afloat. 

Take Ninth Avenue Elevated R. R. to Twenty-third Street or Twenty- 
third Street car to Ninth Avenue. 

43. Site of Chelsea, original homestead of Captain Clarke and Clement C. 
Moore (see above). 

115 



Route i6 HISTORICAL GUIDE Chelsea 

44. London Terrace, the familiar row of tall pilastered houses 
with deep front yards on Twenty-third Street between Ninth and 
Tenth Avenues, erected in 184S by Wm. Torrey when this was a 
fashionable residence quarter. 

At 436 West Twenty-second Street is the old mansion once the 
home of Edwin Forrest and little altered since his time. 

45. Chelsea Cottages, a row of small houses with little front 
yards on West Twenty-fourth Street between Ninth and Tenth 
Avenues, built 1845. 

Go down Ninth Avenue to 

46. Chelsea Square, the block between Twentieth and Twenty- 
first Streets and Ninth and Tenth Avenues, on which are the 
buildings of the General Theological Seminary. The land was 
given by C. C. Moore and the West Building (still standing) was 
erected in 1835. The Square with its green lawns, quadrangles 
and ivy covered buildings, the library, chapel and refectory, is 
well worth a visit. 

47. St. Peter's Church, on Twentieth Street, east of Ninth 
Avenue, was built in 1836-8 on land given by C. C. Moore. See 
within tablets to Moore and Dr. Hugh Smith. The rectory, just 
west, was the original St. Peter's Chapel. 

48. 114 Ninth Avenue, between Seventeenth and Eighteenth 
Streets, an old house wnth outside stairs and gambrel window 
reached through a rear alley which originally faced a road used as a 
short cut from Greenwich Village to Chelsea. See also the old 
house at 112 Ninth Avenue. 

49. Old House at 346 West Sixteenth Street, with gambrel 
roof and outside stairs. 

Many other old houses may be seen between Ninth and Seventh 
Avenues along Twentieth to Fifteenth Streets (see A above). 



116 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE 17. 

SECTION IV— MURRAY HILL TO CENTRAL PARK. 

(Figures refer to Plate XXII.) 

Take Subway or Madison Avenue car to Thirty-third Street; go up 

the steps to Thirty-fourth Street. 

Murray Hill is the height between Thirty-fourfh and Forty-second Streets, 
Third Avenue and Broadway, and was named for Robert Murray, a Tory whose 
wife, Mary Lindley, by a clever stratagem delayed Howe (September 15, 1776) 
in his pursuit of Washington. The cornfield where Washington tried to rally 
the American troops was on the Murray farm, somewhere between the sites of 
the Grand Central Station and Bryant Park. The Murray estate was called 
Incleberg, and extended between Thirty-third and Thirty-seventh Streets, from 
the Boston to the Bloomingdale Road. 

The Park Avenue Tunnel was built under Murray Hill in 1837 to accom- 
modate the first horsecar line in the world, running from H'arlem_ to Chambers 
Street. Later it was used by the Harlem Railroad, the terminal being at 
White and Centre Streets. 

Go up Park Avenue to 

1. Tablet, erected by the Knickerbocker Chapter of the Daugh- 
ters of the American Revolution, to mark the site of the Mur- 
ray House, on a boulder in a park space at Thirty-seventh Street 
and Park Avenue, where the house stood until 1834. 

Go west on Thirty-seventh Street to 

2. Brick Presbyterian Church, at the corner of Fifth Avenue, 
organized in 1767, the original building in Park Row (Excursion I: 
14). See in the lecture room (open all day) interesting collection of 
historical portraits and relics of the old church. 

Go up Fifth Avenue to Fortieth Street and then west, passing 

3. New York Public Library, erected 1902-10 on the Astor- 
Lenox-Tilden foundation. 

4. Bryant Park (so called in 1884, but originally known as 
Reservoir Square) was bought by the city in 1822 and used as a 
Potter's Field until, in 1842, it became the site of the first dis- 
tributing reservoir of the Croton Aqueduct, now torn down to make 
way for the Library. See portions of the reservoir walls. In the 
western part of the Park stood the Crystal Palace, where the first 
World's Fair in America was held iu 1853. In 1858 an ovation was 
given here to Cyrus W. Field, on the completion of the Atlantic Cable 
and soon after the building was destroyed by fire. 

Go through the Park to Forty-second Street, passing 
The colossal bust of Washington Irving (unveiled 1866) op- 
posite the Fortieth Street entrance and the statue of Dr. J. Marion 
Sims, on the north side of the Park.*6 

Go north on Fifth Avenue, 
117 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Murray Hill MANHATTAN 17 Route 

5. The Collegiate Dutch Reformed Church, at Forty-eighth 
Street. Note the tablet to commemorate its connection with the 
*' Church in the Fort." Within may be seen a tablet erected by 
the Daughters of the Revolution, State of New York, to honor 
the soldiers and sailors of the Revolution. In the lecture room is 
an interesting collection of historical pictures and books, includ- 
ing the portraits in oil of its ministers since 1699. The bell 
which hangs in the steeple was cast in Amsterdam in 1728. It 
was bequeathed by Abraham De Peyster, whilom mayor of the 
city, a son of Johannes, the founder of the family in America, 
to the Middle Dutch Church on Nassau Street, between Cedar 
and Liberty Streets. (Excursion 1:27). When the edifice was 
used as a City Post Office, the bell was removed to the church 
at Ninth Street near Broadway, thence to the church on Lafayette 
Place and later to its present location. 

6. St. Patrick's Cathedral, projected by Archbishop Hughes in 
1850 and costing $2,500,000. See within the vestibule at the south 
end a framed account of the title of the property, acquired by the 
trustees of St. Patrick's in 1852 for $59,500- 

Go east on Fiftieth Street. 

7. Tablet on the east side of Madison Avenue, between Forty- 
ninth and Fiftieth Streets, marking the site of Columbia College 
which was moved here from College Place in 1857 (Excursion I, 
21). The Elgin Botanical Garden, founded in 1801 by Dr. Hosack, 
Professor of Botany in Columbia, occupied the blocks between 
Forty-seventh and Fifty-first Streets and west nearly to Sixth Avenue, 
on land given Columbia by the State, to make good the claims of 
the college to a New Hampshire township. Two English yews once 

, in the garden were transplanted to the new site at Morningside 
Heights. 

Return to Fifth Avenue and take electric bus to the Metropolitan 
Museum of Art, passing the 

8. Sherman Statue at the Plaza, designed by St. Gaudens and 
erected in 1904. Three blocks west on Fifty-ninth Street is the 

0. Columbus Column at the Circle, presented to the city by 
Italian citizens at the celebration of the 400th anniversary of the 
discovery of America. 

Central Park was planned in 1851 and laid out by "the Com- 
missioners of Central Park" in 1859, Frederick Law Olmstead 
and Calvert Vaux executing the plans. The Park contains many 
statues of famous men. 

119 



Route 17 HISTORICAL GUIDE Central Park 

Statues in and near Central Park (see Appendix B, p. 2>71, for exact 
locations, sculptor, etc.) : West Drive— Hamilton, Mazzini, Webster, 
Seventh Regiment soldier ; West Eighty-first Street entrance— Bolivar ; 
near East Seventy-second Street entrance— the Pilgrim, Morse and 
R. M. Hunt; the Mall— Columbus ; another of Columbus is at 
]\IcGo\vn's Pass Tavern. 

Nat. Maine Monument, at the Circle, erected 1911-13. in commemora- 
tion of the loss of this battleship in Havana Harbor, in 1898. 

In the Hotel Netherland, Fifth Avenue and Fifty-ninth Street, are 
the paintings, "The Purchase of Manhattan" and "Stuyvesant Receiving 
the English Terms of Surrender." 

The Board of Education Building, Fifty-ninth Street and Park 
Avenue, contains portraits of De Witt Clinton and former members of 
the Board of Education. 

The Volunteer Firemen's Association, 220 East Fifty-ninth Street, 
has a collection of old fire apparatus and pictures, open to the public. 

The Arsenal, in the Park, near East Sixty-fourth Street, vvas erected 
by the State in 1848, and used as an arsenal until 1856, and again during 
the Civil War, when troops were quartered and drilled here. It became 
city property in 1856, and is now used by the Park Department. 

In the Metropolitan Museum of Art (near Eighty-first Street), 
may be seen a fine collection of historical relics. 

Cleopatra's Needle, near by, was presented in 1877 by the 
Khedive of Egypt, the expense of its transportation from Alex- 
andria to New York being paid by William H. Vanderbilt. 

In the American Museum of Natural History at Seventy-seventh 
Street and Central Park west, is a large collection of Indian relics 
excavated at Inwood, the Bronx, Long and Staten islands. 

N. B. For historic points in the northern part of Central Park 
see Excursion IV, Section I. 

For a complete account of Central Park see "Central Park in the 
City of New York," by E. H. Hall, in the 191 1 Report of the American 
Scenic and Historic Preservation Society. 

The New York Genealogical and Biographical Society, 226 West 
Fifty-eighth Street, has a large collection of books and records (see 
P- 399). 

Tablet in the West Side Branch, Y. M. C. A., 318 West Fifty-seventh 
Street, conimoniorating Washington at Valley Forge. 

New York Historical Society, Central Park West, between Seventy- 
si vth and Seventy-seventh streets, has a fine collection of local historical 
rehcs. prmts, etc., in addition to a large number of books, manuscripts. 
oaintings and ancient relics (see p. 397). 

120 



I 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE i8. 

SECTION V— BLOOMINGDALE. 
(Figures refer to Plate XXIII and letters to Plate XXil.) 

Sometime after the settlement of tlie Island of Manhattan, the middle west 
section received the name Blocincndael (vale of flowers) from the Dutch town 
of that name. In early times the only access to the region was by water and 
by a few farm roads. Later it was bisected by the Road to Bloomingdale 
which ran its length through the Bloomingdale District, the name given it by 
the Law of 1703 under which the road was opened from Twenty-third Street 
and Broadway to One-hundred and Fifteenth Street and the present Riverside 
Drive. This road in a large measure followed the line of present Broadway. 
In 179s it was extended to One-hundred and Forty-seventh Street, where it 
was merged in the Kingsbridge Road. In the territory which it traversed were 
a number of hamlets, cue being at the Great Kill, the longest and deepest 
stream which indented the west shore of the island, with an outlet at Forty- 
second Street. The settlement at this spot extended into the fifties, Harsenville 
was located in the seventies. Striker's Bay in the nineties and Bloomingdale 
Village centered at One Hundredth Street. Each of these was a distinct lo- 
cality and up to the opening of the Civil War had yet a semblance of village 
life. In Dutch times, the entire territory from Fourteenth Street to Claremont 
was known as Bloomingdale, — Greenwich and Chelsea being names of later 
English derivation. It was a favorite suburban section. Some few old man- 
sions survive, but none of Revolutionary date. 

Take Subway to limes {Longacre) Square *7 

In 1872 LoNGACRE Square became the New York center of the carriage in- 
dustry begun by Brewster and others and one of the trade journals likened it to 
London's Longacre Street in which the carriage trade was centred. The square 
having, at the time, no name the city authorities gave it that of Longacre. 

A. Tablet over doorway at 1493-1505 Broadwaj', between 
Forty-third and Forty-fourth Streets, erected in 1893 by the Sons 
of the Revolution to commemorate the meeting of Washington 
and Putnam on September 15, 1776. 

B. In the basement of the Hotel Astor may be seen a valuable 
collection of pictures of old New York. In the barroom is a 
painting showing the house of Medcef Eden, an Englishman who 
owned the neighboring property originally, and died of yellow 
fever in one of the early epidemics. 

Take Forty-second Street-Tenth Avenue cars to Fifty-third Street. 

C. DeWitt Clinton. Park, between Fiftj^-second and Fifty- 
fourth Streets, Eleventh and Twelfth Avenues; note the play- 
grounds, pergola, children's farm gardens and the recreation pier 
(foot of Fiftieth Street). The site was part of a farm which had 
remained in the Hopper family for 200 years. 

In the center of Fifty-third Street, as laid out, stood the mansion 
of General Garrit Hopper Striker (Section VI 14) which was built 
in 1752 and was one of the oldest landmarks in the city when torn 
down in 1896. The Mott Homestead stood at Fifty-fourth Street 
on the river bank from 1796 until demolished in 1897. Both these 
residences, as well as Striker's and Mott's Lanes, were obliterated 
by the laying out of the Park. 

12 1 



Route i8 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



DeWitt Clinton 




Plate XXIII. Route i8. 



C. K. 



T). In the DeWitt Clinton High School at Fifty-ninth Street 
and Tenth Avenue are two large mural paintings illustrating scenes 
in connection with the completion of the Erie Canal. 
Take Tenth Avenue car to Eighty-ninth Street; pass en route the 

site of 

M\cl\^Z^A.^^^W"I^'^?\\^ H-om:?^, northwest corner of Seventy-fifth Street and 
i.n^?r h; f ./^oad (Broadway), Here Louis Philippe lived and taught school 
ut*o "^ ^*"<^- It was occupied by Hessians during the Revolution and razed 



111 1868 



2. The Collegiate School at 241-243 West Seventy-seventh 
Strtft, a direct descendant of the first Dutch school (1633) on Stone 
Street (Excursion VII :i2; see H. W. Dunshee's history of thq 
bchool). 



I?? 



Bloomingdale MANHATTAN i8 Route 

3. Van den Heuvel Mansion, torn down 1905, in the block between Broad- 
way and West End Avenue, Seventy-eighth and Seventy-ninth Streets. It was 
built about 1792 by Cornelius Van <fen Heuvel, the Covernor of Demarara, and 
after 1839 was used as a tavern and known as Burnham's Mansion House. 
Burnham's original tavern, a favorite resort for driving parties, was at Seven- 
tieth Street and the Road. 

4. Poe Cottage, Eighty-fourth Street, on the east side of Bloomingdale Road. 
Here Poe and his wife Virginia boarded with a family named Brerman during 
the summers of 1843 and 1844. During this time he wrote "The Raven 
which first appeared in print in the New York Mirror in January, 1845. 

Walk west on Eighty-ninth Street to 

5. The Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument, erected in 1900-2 by 
the city to honor the heroes of the Civil War. Note view of 
Palisades, Ft. Washington Point, etc. 

Go north on Riverside Drive. 

6. The site of Oak Villa, between Ninetieth and Ninety-first Streets, west of 
West End Avenue, the country seat of Brockholst Livingston, grandson of 
Philip, second Lord of the Manor in Columbia County, New York. He was a 
Colonel of the Revolutionary Army, Judge- of the Supreme Court and Associate 
Justice on the Federal Supreme Bench. He died in 1833 and was buried in 
the family vault in the yard of the Wall Street Presbyterian Church. The 
massive oaks standing in the Park at Ninety-first Street were on the Living- 
ston property and gave the name " Oak \'illa." 

7. The site of the Apthorp Mansion, built in 1764 by Charles Ward Apthorp, 
a member of His Majesty's Council, between Ninety-first and Ninety-second 
Streets, just west of Columbus Avenue. It was the headquarters of Generals 
Howe, Clinton, Carleton and Cornwallis at successive stages of the British 
occupation. A rich English merchant, William Jauncey, (after whom 
Jauncey Court in Wall Street was named), bought the property in 1799 and 
the Cross Road to Harlem, afterward Apthorp Lane, leading to the house was 
known by his name for many years, and is so carried to this day on old maps. 

8. Site of the Striker's Bay Mansion, at Ninety-sixth Street, on hill east of 
viaduct. An old elm on the property inspired George W, Morris in 1837 to 
write " Woodman, spare that tree." As a result, the tree was spared and 
in 1862 Morris testified that it was still standing. The mansion occupied the 
west line of the British outposts during the Battle of Harlem Hicights. 

Other well-known families who had permanent residences or country seats in 
Bloomingdale were the Bayards, Beekmans, Bownes, Leggetts, Danas, Have- 
meyers, Howlands, Lawrences, Schuylers, van Nordens, Rikers, de Peysters, De 
Lanceys, McVickars, Strikers, Hoppers, Posts, Schieffelins, Meiers, Whitlocks, 
Weymans, Webbers, Cozines, Dyckmans, Harsens, Cuttings, Rogers, Wilkes, 
Wells, Clendinings, Jumels and Motts. 

9. St. Michael's Episcopal Church at Ninety-ninth Street and 
Amsterdam Avenue stands on the site of the old wooden church, 
erected in 1806. ("Annals of the Parish," by Dr. John P. Peters). 

10. The Furniss House, on Riverside Drive, between Ninety- 
ninth and One Hundredth Streets, was erected by William P. Furniss 
in 1843. Just north of it was the (Furniss House, demolished 1912). 

11. Humphrey Jones House, on the river bluff, between One Hundred and 
First and One Hundred and Second Streets. (See Johnston's " History of the 
Battle of Harlem Heights" and Mott's '*' The New York of Yesterday"). In 
1798 Robert T. Kemble bought the property and in 181 1 it was acquired by 
William Rogers and was known for years as the " Ann Rogers House." It 
was struck by lightning and burned in 1859. 

Go East on Ninety-ninth Street a/u/ *8 north on Broadway. 

12. The Bloomingdale Dutch Reformed Church, recently com- 
pleted at One Hundred and Sixth Street and Broadway, on the 
site of Nicholas Jones' stone house near which began and ended 

123 



Route i8 HISTORICAL GUIDE Weehawken 

the Battle of Harlem Heights. The church, which celebrated its 
looth anniversary in December, 1906, was incorporated as " The 
Church at Harsenville," and was founded in the Dutch mansion 
of Jacob Harsen, at Seventieth Street and Amsterdam Avenue, near 
which site it stood for a century. The open space in front of 
its present location was named " Bloomingdale Square " in 1907. 



Notes, 1912: The name "Bloomingdale Square" was changed in 1912 
by the Board of Aldermen to "Straus Square" in honor of Isidor Straus, 
who perished on the Titanic. 

The Firemen's Memorial Monument was erected in 1912-13 on 
Riverside Drive and One Hundredth Street by the City of New York. 



SIDE TRIP TO THE HAMILTON-BURR DUELLING 
GROUND. 

By Edward Hagaman Hall. 

Take West Forty-second Street ferry to IVeehazvken. Walk to 

the steam railroad track and then south along the shore (5 or 10 
minutes) to a little point of land projecting into the river and 
marked by a scrubby tree. The duelling ground (now blasted away) 
was on a level spot near the shore about on the line of the railroad 
track at this point. 

To see the bust of Hamilton take the trolley from the ferry 
to the top of the bluff, or mount the stairs and walk south and 
then east of the fence running along the cliff. See inclosure con- 
taining a pedestal and bust of Hamilton overlooking the scene of 
the encounter. 

An inscribed slab of the original monument (placed here in 1806 
by the St. Andrew's Society and broken because it seemed to en- 
courage duelling) is now in the New York Historical Society building. 



T24 



MANHATTAN 
ROUTE 19. 

SECTION VI.— MORNINGSIDE HEIGHTS AND 
MANHATTANVILLE. 
One Hundred and Tenth Street to One Hundred and Thirty-fifth 

Street. 

(Figures refer to Plate XXIV; see also XXVI and XXX.) 

Take Broadway Subway to Cathedral Parkway; see to the east the 

partially completed Cathedral of St. John the Divine; 

walk west to Riverside Drive, then north to the 

1. Carrigan House. The original Nicholas de Peyster House 
stood at One Hundred and Fourteenth Street and Riverside Drive 
and was the terminus of the Bloomingdale Road as fixed by the 
Law of 1703. It burned down in 1835. The property was sold to 
Andrew Carrigan, President of the Emigrant Industrial Savings 
Bank, who built the present house.*9 

Go east on One hundred and Fourteenth Street and north on Broad- 
way, passing 
Buildings of the old Bloomingdale Asylum, one in the South Field 
of Columbia University and another, now the Columbia Faculty 
Building, northeast corner of One Hundred and Sixteenth Street 
and Broadway. 

2. Tablet, erected by the Sons of the Revolution, on the En- 
gineering Building (near One Hundred and Seventeenth Street), 
Columbia University, marking part of a site of the Battle of 
Harlem Heights, September 16, 1776. On the west side of Broad- 
way, just south of Barnard College, was the wheat field where 
the main action was fought. 

See also memorial window for the battle placed in St. Luke's 
Home for Aged Women at One Hundred and Fourteenth Street 
and Broadway by the New York State Society of the Daughters 
of the Revolution. 

Go east on One Hundred and Sixteenth Street. 

3. Columbia Library, the gift of Seth Low. See inscription on 
the pediment to commemorate the foundation of King's College, 
which stood at College Place and Murray Street. Within may 
be seen the iron crown formerly in King's College and a collec- 
tion of early diplomas with signatures of former presidents. 

On the opposite side of One Hundred and Sixteenth Street, in 
the quadrangle formed by Hamilton Hall and the Hartley Dor- 
mitory, see the statue of Hamilton by Ordway Partridge. *i4 

125 



Route 19 HISTORICAL GUIDE Morningside 

Go north on Amsterdam Avenue. 

4. Tablet on southeast corner of Fayerweather Hall of Col- 
umbia University, on Amsterdam Avenue, facing One Hundred and 
Seventeenth Street, erected by the Empire State Society Daughters 
of 1812 on February 22, 1900, to commemorate New York City 
defences during the War of 1812. " Fort Haight " mentioned thereon 
should read " Fort Laight," being so named in honor of Edward W. 
Laight, Commander of the Regiment of City Infantry, 1814. General 
Garrit Hopper Striker, whose name is inscribed on this memorial, 
served as Captain of the 4th Company, 5th Regiment, 82nd Brigade, 
which regiment was the last employed in erecting the defences on 
Bloomingdale Heights. The original plan was to place the tablet 
on Block House No. i in Central Park, near which defence Captain 
Striker's command was stationed, but owing to the isolated position 
of the tower, and the likelihood of the memorial being hidden from 
view by foliage, the offer of the Trustees of Columbia to have it 
affixed to Fayerweather Hall was accepted. 

Pass on the left Teachers' College. 

5. Block House No. 3, War of 1812, in Morningside Park, at 
One Hundred and Twenty-third Street, marked in 1904 by a tablet 
erected by the Women's Auxiliary to the American Scenic and His- 
toric Preservation Society. 

The little height just south formed part of Fort Horn, named 
for Major Joseph Horn, under whose immediate direction the works 
at McGoivn's Pass were erected (Excursion IV, Section I, 22, 25). 

6. Point of Rocks was the high ground at One Plundred and Twenty-sixth 
Street and Convent Avenue, and the site of the most advanced southerly Amer- 
ican military outworks on Washington Heights. Another redoubt stood on the 
hill nuw at One Hundred and Thirty-fourth Street, between Broadway and River- 
side Drive. I-Voni the Point of Rocks Washington directed and watched the 
Battle of Harlem Heights. The rocks have been blasted away. 

Day's Tmeni, where Washington stayed on his advance to the evacuation 
of New York in 1783, was on the site of I26tli- Street, 200 feet west of 
hi^hth .\venue. 

Go 2vest on One Hundred and Tzventy-second Street, passing, on the 
left, the neiu buildings of Union Theological Seminary. 

7. Grant's Tomb; designed by John H. Duncan; corner-stone 
laid by President Harrison, 1892, completed 1897, at a cost of $600,000, 
subscribed chiefly by the people of New York City; within are the 
sarcophagi of General U. S. Grant and his wife. The interior deco- 
ration is by J. Masscy Rhind. See the battle flags of the Civil War 

126 



Heights MANHATTAN 1^ Route 

and nlimefous memorials. It is controlled by the Grant Monument 
Association. 

North of the tomb are trees planted by Li Hung Chang and a 
tablet to commemorate his esteem for General Grant. Souvenir 
History to be obtained from the custodian.*io 

Go north along Riverside Drive. 

8. Tomb of "An Amiable Child" (St. Claire Pollock, baptized 
by Bishop Moore, November ii, 1792), buried here in 1797. It is 
said that the child lost its life by falling over a cliff near this spot. 
In 1796-8 George Pollock, probably the uncle of the child, bought this 
property, then known as " Strawberry Hill " or " Vandewater 
Heights," from Nicholas de Peyster, and when he sold part of it to 
Cornelia Verplanck, he reserved the burial plot which, on his return 
to Ireland in 1800, he deeded to her to preserve. 

9. The Claremont, owned by the city and a public restaurant 
since 1872, was built shortly after the Revolution by Michael Hogan, 
at one time British Consul at Havana, and named after the "royal 
residence at Surrey of Prince William, Duke of Clarence, afterward 
King William IV, with whom Hogan had. served as fellow midship- 
man in the Royal Navy and who visited him at his town house in 
Greenwich Street in 1782. Viscount Courtenay, afterward Earl 
of Devon, occupied the house and from it in 1807 viewed the trial 
trip of Fulton's steamship, the "Clermont." In 1815 it became tho 
abode of Joseph Bonaparte. The Post family purchased the property 
in 1821. 

10. View of the Palisades and Fort Washington Point from 
the Viaduct which was built to extend Riverside Drive to Wash- 
ington Heights. The valley between was known in Dutch days as 
"The Clove of the Kill," or " Matje David's Vly" (the Widow 
David's Meadow). During the Revolution it was called the " Hol- 
low Way." The settlement in the valley between One Hundred and 
Twenty-fifth and One Hundred and Thirty-fifth Streets was known 
as Manhattanville. A rude ferry to Fort Lee was established before 
the Revolution.*! I 

Descend to Manhattan Street and go east to Snbzvay. 



127 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




ij8 



MANHATTAN 

BATTLE OF HARLEM HEIGHTS. 

By Hopper Striker Mott. 

This, the only contest of the Revolution within the limits of New York City 
that resulted in a victory for the Americans, had a greater influence on the 
result than is generally acknowledged. Washington's army had been disastrously 
worsted on Long Island and was in flight when this success clinched the dogged 
determination which made possible the brilliant exploits at Trenton and 
Princeton. 

The Americans, on abandoning Long Island, had withdrawn up the Island of 
Manhattan, time for the retreat being gained through the instrumentality of 
Mary Lindley Murray (Section IV :i and introductory note). During the de- 
lay, Putnam and his command, in their straggling retreat along the Blooming- 
dale Road, had passed in safety to within a mile of the Morris House where 
Washington had his headquarters. When the British realized that the patriots 
had joined the main army, they encamped that night along the New Cross 
Road (Apthorp Lane), Sir Henry Clinlon taking possession of the Apthorp 
Mansion, and threw up fortifications just north, extending across the island 
from Hoorn's Hoek to Striker's Bay. Earl Cornwallis was in command of the 
Reserve, while other generals led the English, Scotch and Hessians. 

The first line of works thrown up by the Americans was located about One 
Hundred and Forty Seventh Street (Excursion IV, Section II :i) and the hill 
as far south as " The Hollow Way," the valley through which Manhattan Street 
now passes, was occupied by them. Generally, these were the positions of the 
two forces on September i6, 1776. On that morning, Colonel Thomas Knowlton. 
who had seen service at Lexington, Bunker Hill and Long Island, was directed 
by Washington to make a reconnoissance of the enemy's position. Moving 
southward with his Connecticut Rangers along the westerly side near the Hud- 
son, they were screened from view by the woods covering Hooglandt's farm. 
It was not until they reached Nicholas Jones' farmhouse about sunrise that 
the British pickets, light infantrymen, were encountered. Evidently stationed 
on the Bloomingdale Road at about One Hundred and Fourth Street, their 
regiments were encamped a short distance to the south. During the brisk skir- 
mish which now took place, the woods along the dividing line between the Jones 
and Hooglandt farms echoed the sharp firing from both sides. The forces were 
so disproportioned as to numbers, and the object of the movement had been so 
far attained that Knowlton ordered a retreat, which was effected without con- 
fusion. He had, however, ten killed in action. They fell back along the line 
of the Road, closely pursued. The enemy halted at the elevation known as 
" Claremont," from which point they could catch glimpses of General Greene's 
troops on the opposite slopes. 

This was the third time within a month that the British had scattered or driven 
Washington's men with ease, and it only remained on this occasion for their 
bugler to sound the contemptuous notes of the hunt across the Hollow into the 
American lines. To quote one of the latter's officers: "The enemy appeared 
in open view and in the most insulting manner sounded their bugle horns as 
is usual after a fox-chase; I never felt such a sensation before — it seemed to 
crown our disgrace." Washington had gone down to the advanced position and 
heard the firing. He was urged to reinforce^ the Rangers, but was not im- 
mediately persuaded of the advisability of forcing the fighting. Eventually, he 
determined on a strategical plan, viz: to make a feint in front of the hill and 
induce the enemy to advance into the Hollow, and second, should this prove 
effective, to send a strong detachment circuitously around their right flank to 
the rear and hein them in. This plan succeeded in so far that the enemy, see- 
ing the advance, promptly accepted battle, " ran down the hill and took posses- 
sion of some fences and bushes," from which vantage a smart fire was begun, 
but at too great a distance to do much execution. The flanking party, composed 
of Knowlton's Rangers, now back at the lines, was reinforced with three 
companies of riflemen from the Third Virginia Regiment under Major Andrew 
Leitch. In some unlucky manner the attack was j)remature " as it was rather 
in flank than in rear." Both the brave leaders fell in this engagement, Knowl- 
ton living but an hour. _ Leitch survived until October 2nd, when he died at a 
little blacksmith's shop in the neighborhood of the present One Hundred and 
Twenty-ninth Street. Nothing daunted by the loss of their commanders, the 
Rangers and Riflemen pressed on. The British, who had been inveigled into 

129 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

the Hollow Way, had in the meantime Deen put to flight by the Use of artillery, 
and were pursued back towards their camp along the line of the Road to a 
buckwheat field on top of a high hill. Heretofore the manoeuvring had taken 
place largely on the Hooglandt farm; the main action was then transferred to 
Van de Water's Heights. 

The general limits of this " hot contest " were the high ground extending 
from Columbia University around westward and northerly to Grant's Tomb 
and Ciaremont. The fighting grew into a pitched battle, lasting from noon 
until about two o'clock. Nearly 1800 Americans were engaged, composed of 
commands representing New England, Maryland and Virginia, with volunteers 
from New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. 

The enemy finally retreated, followed in close pursuit, and the day was won. 
The route crossed an orchard just north of One Hundred and Eleventh Street 
and terminated in the vicinity of Jones' House, where Knowlton first found 
them in the early morning. It was considered prudent to withdraw, and late in 
the afternoon the troops returned to camp, rejoicing in a success they had not 
anticipated. It is estimated that about 30 men were killed and not over 100 
wounded and missing. A total British loss of 171 was reported. This action 
put new courage into the patriots and exerted a wide influence over subsequent 
events. 

The above account of the battle follows that of Henry P. Johnston, Professor 
of History in the College of the City of New York. 

LANDMARKS OF THE BATTLE-FIELD. 

The Apthorp Mansion, where Wasliington waited until his little army of 
3500 men, none of whom had breakfasted or slept, had passed in retreat from 
the oncoming enemy, following them to the Roger Morris House (Jumel Man- 
sion) at One Hundred and Sixty-second Street, his headquarters until after the 
battle (Excursion IV, Section II). When Howe took possession of the Apthorp 
House it was whispered about that he was made welcome there, and when the 
war was over Apthorp was included in the list of persons suspected of being 
Tory sympathizers. Although indicted for treason, he was never tried for his 
alleged crime. Property which he owned in Massachusetts in connection with 
his brother was confiscated, but his New York realty was left untouched. 
(Section V:7). 

I'an de Water Heights, owned by Herman van de Water, stretched between 
One Hundred and Sixth and One Hundred and Twentv-fourth Streets, and in- 
cluded a part of present Morningside Park. These He'ights were a portion of 
the De Key tract and were bounded south by the land of Theunis Eideyse van 
Huyse, and east by Harlem Commons. Van de Water and Adriaen Hooglandt 
purchased one-half of the tract from de Key in 1738. 

The Houses of Humphrey Jones, his son Nicholas Jones and the Striker Man- 
sion are described in Section V;8, 11, 12. 



133 



MANHATTAN 

SIDE TRIP TO FORT LEE. 

By Edward Hagaman Hall. 

Take Fort Lee Ferry from West One Hundred and Thirtieth Street, 
and the trolley up the Palisades to Fort Lee Village. 

The site of the fort is on the bluff bounded by Cedar and English 
Streets and Parker Avenue. In the woods southwest of the pond 
(now dry) and of the church, may be seen some remains of the 
fireplaces or chimneys of the huts of the American troops, and west 
of these the zig-zag line of breastworks can be traced. 

Washington's Well is northeast of the church (east of Parker 
Avenue), and still further east is a huge flat stone which was 
utilized for the bottom of a military bread oven. Traces of re 
doubts are visible on the crest of the Palisades east of the fort, 
and another redoubt some distance north was used to protect the 
sunken obstructions between Jeffreys Hook or Fort Washington Point 
and the Jersey Shore at this part on the river. 

Fort Lee Park, consisting of 7^ acres, was given by Dr. James 
Douglas in 1910. This includes the chief Revolutionary sites in the 
neighborhood. 

The Fort Lee Monument was dedicated September 26, 1908, on 
Parker's Pond Lot, by the Fort Lee Monument Association. It rep- 
resents a Continental soldier and drummer boy climbing the Palisades. 



131 




I'LATE XXV. Route 20. 
132' 



C. K. 



MANHATTAN 



ROUTE 20. 

SECTION VII— KIP'S BAY TO HORN'S HOOK; THE EAST 
RIVER ISLANDS. 

Corrected with the aid of Frank Warren Crane. 

(Figures refer to Plate XXV). 

Thirty-fourth Street to One Hundredth Street, east of Fifth Avenue. 

Kip's Bay indented the eastern shore of Manhattan at Thirty-fourth Street 
■where now are the ferry slips. Near by, on the east side of Second Avenue 
between Thirty-fifth and Thirty-sixth Streets stood until 1851 the Farm- 
house of Jacob Kip where, in 1655, he brought his young wife, Marie de la 
Montague. Here also the British landed on September 15, 1776, when they 
captured the Island of Manhattan. 

Turtle Bay is a rocky cove at about Forty-fifth Street on the shore of 
which stood an old storehouse where the British kept military supplies. These 
were captured in 1773 by a band of Liberty Boys under John Lamb and Mari- 
nus Willett. Fortifications occupied this spot during the two wars with Eng- 
land. 

Artillery Park was at Forty-fifth Street and First Avenue where Nathan 
Hale was executed. 

Cannon Point was the name given to the projection into the East River of 
East 55th Street. From this point may be obtained a good view of the 
dangerous rocks and eddies of the East River and of the south end of Black- 
w^ell's Island. 

The river shore is as bold and rocky as it was in the early days, the swift 
current of the East River making it difficult to utilize this portion of Man- 
hattan for docks. 

The old Post Road after leaving Madison Square and crossing Third Avenue 
between Forty-second and Forty-third Streets, ran to Second Avenue, crossing 
it at Fifty-second Street (at Cato's Road House) and again at Sixty-third 
Street. It crossed Third Avenue at Sixty-fifth and Seventy-seventh Streets and 
Fourth Avenue at Eighty-fifth Street, and thence ran through Central Park to 
Harlem, its west branch joining the Bloomingdale Road. 

The 4TH Milestone is at Third Avenue and Fifty-seventh Street, and the 
5TH Milestone just one mile north, at Seventy-seventh Street (see Appendix: 
Milestones and Post Roads). 

Odellville was the name applied to a hamlet of sixty years ago lying in the 
region of Third Avenue and Forty-ninth Street. From it a long lane led to 
the country house of Horace Greeley on the East River shore. 

Yorkville was a village on the old Post Road between Eighty-third and Eighty- 
ninth Streets, Fourth and Second Avenues, by some so considered from Fifty- 
ninth to One Hundredth Street, the old Hell Gate ferry being then at the 
foot of Eighty-sixth Street. Seventy-fourth Street was the south boundary of 
the old " Town of Harlem." 

Take Second Avenue Elevated R. R. to Fiftieth Street and walk cast 
to First Avenue. 

1. Site of the Beekman House on Beekman Hill, between Fifty-first and Fifty- 
second Streets west of First Avenue, where P. S. 135 now stands. The house 
was built in 1763 by Wm. Beekman and became the headquarters of Howe, Clin- 
ton and Carleton. In a greenhouse on the grounds Hale was tried as a spy and 
here Andre received his final instructions before going north to meet Arnold. 
The house was torn down in 1874, but one of its mantels and some of the Dutch 
Scripture titles may be seen in the New York Historical Society Building. 
Note the steep incline leading up to Beekman Hill. 

2. Beekman Place, between Forty-ninth and Fifty-first Street, 
near the river, preserves the historic name. Note the view of the 
East River here. 



Route 20 HISTORICAL GUIDE Kip's b'ay to 

Go north to Fifty-third Street and east to the 

3. Shot Tower, built by Mr. Youle in 1821 (succeeding the old 
tower of Revolutionary days) and used during the Civil War. 
Nearby stood until recently the De Voor Farmhouse, built about 200 
years ago, at the foot of East Fifty-third Street. The Spring Valley 
Farm was granted in 1677 by Governor Andros to David Duffore 
or De Voor. It was later called the Odell, Arden or Brevoort es- 
tate. It was a good example of substantial Dutch architecture and 
one of the oldest buildings in the city when destroyed. De Voor's 
Mill Stream, the Saw Kill or Saw Mill Creek, ran from the high 
ground of upper Central Park, being crossed at Seventy-seventh and 
Fifty-second Streets by two "Kissing Bridges." 

4. The Brevoort House at 415 East Fifty-fourth Street is of 
Dutch architecture but much later than the De Voor House (af- 
ter 1800). It was a country residence of the Brevoort family, 
though not the original homestead. 

Go north on Avenue A under the new Queensboro Bridge. 

5. Smith's Folly, a quaint old house near the terminal of the 
new Queensboro Bridge, 421 East Sixty-first Street. It was built 
for a stable in 1799 (see date on rear wall) by Colonel Wm. 
S. Smith, son-in-law of President John Adams. After Smith's 
failure it was used as a tavern until 1830, wh*^n it was bought by 
Jeremiah Towle, City Surveyor, and until 1906 was occupied by his 
daughters. Across the street are two old residences, one occupied 
by the Female Guardian Society Industrial School. 

6. The Schermerhorn Farmhouse, built 1747, at the foot of 
East Sixty-fourth Street was a summer home of Governor George 
Clinton. It is now used in connection with the new buildings of 
the Rockefeller Institute of Medical Research, the erection of which 
obliterated the Jones Chapel and an old graveyard where were buried 
members of the Jones, Hardenbrook and Adams families. 

Jones' Wood north of Seventieth Street, was part of the 90-acre farm (from 
^5ixty-sixth to Seventy-fifth Streets) originally owned by the Provoost family. 
Samuel Provoost became the first Bishop of New York and was President of 
Columbia College. His cousin, David Provoost, was a Revolutionary soldier 
who became a smuggler (" Ready Money Provoost ") and hid his ill-gotten 
gains in the Smugglers' Cave " on the shore of this farm, or in a cave at 
ilallets loint, Astoria. The old Provoost family vault disappeared in 1858 
trum the foot of East Seventy-first Street. The Jones family acquired this 
property about 1803 and later Jones' Wood became a popular picnic resort. 
It was chosen as the site for a large city park for which was substituted the 
land covered by the present Central Park. 

Go west on Sixty-eighth Street. 
134 



Horn's Hook MANHATTAN* 20 Route 

7. Monument in the German Reformed Church, Sixty-eighth 
Street, between First and Second Avenues, erected by the church 
in memory of Baron Steuben, an active member of the church of 
which J. J. Astor was elder, clerk and treasurer about 1800. The 
church was organized in 1758 and erected its first edifice on Nassau 
Street between Maiden Lane and John Street. In 1822 it moved 
to Forsyth Street, in 1861 to the corner of Norfolk and Stanton 
Streets, and in 1897 to the present location. On the occasion of the 
150th anniversary of the church (1908) the bell now used was 
presented to the congregation by the German Emperor.*i2 

Take First Avenue car to Eighty-sixth Street and go east to East 

River Park. 

8. The Grade House in East River Park near Eighty-eighth 
Street stands on what was known in early days as Horns 
Hook (its first owner, Siebert Classen, coming from Hoorn, Hol- 
land), and later as Rhinelander's or Observation Point, where bat- 
teries were placed during the two wars with England. The house 
was built by Archibald Gracie about 1813 and Washington Irving 
was a frequent visitor here and at the John Jacob Astor residence 
which stood just south near the present Eighty-sixth Street and 
Avenue A. Some of the trees in the park were sent from China and 
Japan. 

Note view of the upper end of Blackwell's Island, Mill Rock, 
Hell Gate and Ward's Island (see article below on East River 
Islands). 

9. Site of the Yalless Hopper House, on the west side of Second Avenue be- 
tween Eighty-third and Eighty-fourth Streets, until 1855. It was a quaint stone 
structure built by Benjamin Waldron, whose daughter Elizabeth married Hopper 
in 1759 and passed into his possession on the death of his father-in-law in 
1782. Its sides were indented with shots from British ships during the attack 
at Hoorn's Neck. An advertisement offering for sale the farm of Adolph 
Waldron in 1786 states that a ferry had long been established to Hallet's Cove 
on Long Island. 

Go west on Ninetieth Street, passing 

10. The Prime House (best seen from Ninetieth Street be- 
tween Avenue A and First Avenue), now one of the buildings of 
St. Joseph's Orphan Asylum; some of its old fireplaces and mantels 
are preserved and from its upper balcony is obtained a fine view of 
Hell Gate. Nathaniel Prime, a merchant prince, had his town house 
at No. I Broadway. He built the uptown house in 1800. 

Go north on Park Avenue to 

11. The Winfield Scott Mansion, at Park Avenue and Ninety- 
third Street (northwest corner), erected in 1847 and now used as 
an academy by the Ursuline Sisters (about to be torn down, I9I2).*I3 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



THE EAST RIVER ISLANDS. 

Near the turbulent waters of Hell Gate is a group of three islands 
covered with vast buildings of stone or brick where the poor, the 
sick and the insane of the city, as well as the offenders against law 
and order, are cared for by the Departments of Charities and Cor- 
rection. 

Blackwell's Island, called in Indian days Minnahanonck or Long 
Island, and, later, Manning's Island, was granted to Captain John 
Manning, Sheriff of New York County, in 1664. Because of his dis- 
graceful surrender of the city to the Dutch in 1673, his sword was 
broken and he spent some years in retirement in his " castle " on the 
island. He left it to his step-daughter, who married Robert Black- 
well. In 1828 the city bought it for $50,000. Most of the buildings 
are of granite dressed on the island and built by convict labor. 
Around the island are heavy granite sea walls. 

Passes may be obtained from the Departments of Charities and 
Correction. 

Hell Gate is the channel between Astoria, Manhattan, Ward's 
and Blackwell's Islands, at the junction of the Harlem and East 
Rivers. Mr. Edward Hagaman Hall learned that " Hell Gate " is a 
name in use in Holland where it is spelled Helle-gat and is ap- 
plied to a difficult water passage between the Volkerak and Holland 
Diep, on the much-traveled waterway between Antwerp and Rotter- 
dam, the name being used in the same sense as the English translation 
" Hell Gate." The efforts to derive the name from an ancient root 
meaning " beautiful " or " clear " have no foundation in fact. 

Owing to hidden rocks and conflicting tides, the strait is yet dan- 
gerous for navigation, although many rocks have been removed 
by the government. The great work of exploding these reefs was 
begun in 1869-76 and completed in 1885. Among its features are Pot 
Rock, the Devil's Frying Pan, Flood Rock, Hog's Back, Nigger Head 
and Gridiron. A description of the strait is given in the Labadist 
Journal. Mill Rock, or Leland's Island, opposite Ninety-third 
Street, used to be known as " Sandy Gibson's," a favorite stopping 
place for fishermen. Here, in 1812, a blockhouse was built for the 
defence of the city. 

^Z6 



MANHATTAN Islands 

Ward's Island (also called Great Barent, Barn or Buchanan's 
Island) was bought from the Indians by Van Twiller and used 
by him as a pasture. In 1776 it was occupied by the British who 
established a camp here. After the Revolution two brothers, 
Jasper and Bartholomew Ward, bought it and divided it into 
farms. In 1812 a cotton mill was built and a bridge which con- 
nected the island with One Hundred and Fourteenth Street. 
In 1840 it became the Potter's Field, 100,000 bodies being brought 
here from Bryant Park (see Section IV). 

4. Little Hell Gate is the strait which divides Ward's Island 
on the north from 

Randall's Island (Belle Isle, Little Barent or Montresor's 
Island), which has had many owners since the English ceded it 
to Thos. Delavall, an early collector of customs. Among the 
owners was Captain James Montresor, who lived here during 
the Revolution. Here, in 1776, 250 Americans were defeated in 
an attempt to capture a British force. Jonathan Randall bought 
the island in 1784 and in 1835 sold it to the city for $50,000. 
A pass to visit the House of Refuge may be secured from the 
Department of Charities. 

North and South Brother's, Riker's, City, Hart's, Hunter's and 
Twin Islands are described in Excursion IX. 



U7 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ADDENDA— 1912 

*i (p. 107). The Cruger Mansion, a reproduction of Boscohel 
House, seat of the Douglas family in Scotland, was the home of 
William Douglas and his sister, Harriet Douglas Cruger. Kossuth was 
a guest, and his two nieces lived here many years. 

*2(p. 109). The Irving House was built by Mr. Martin, who in the 
50's sold it to Mr. Phelps. The family say Washington Irving never 
lived here. 

Tablets and medallion heads: {a) William Lloyd Garrison, south- 
east corner Seventeenth Street and Fourth Avenue, to commemorate 
his death here, May 24, 1879; {b) Henry George (Sc. Richard F. 
George), on Union Square Hotel, Fifteenth Street and Fourth Avenue, 
erected 1909 to commemorate his death here, October 29, 1897. 

*3 (p. no). Herman Melville, the writer, lived at 104 East Twenty- 
sixth Street. 

*4 (p. 112). The Methodist Historical Society has a collection of 
relics in the Methodist Book Concern, 150 Fifth Avenue, corner 
Twentieth Street; the Huguenot Society, 105 East Twenty-second 
Street, has a collection of books relating to the settlement of America 
by the French. 

*5 (p. 114). Near Greeley Square: Statues of (a) Horace Greeley, 
Broadway and Thirty-third Street, by Alexander Doyle, erected by the 
Typographical Union and a Grand Army Post; {b) William E. Dodge, 
by J. Q. A. Ward, erected by New York merchants. 

In the Hotel Imperial, Broadway and Thirtieth Street, is the paint- 
ing. "Bowling in Bowling Green." 

The Arsenal, Thirty-fifth Street and Seventh Avenue, contains tab- 
lets and war relics from the old Elm Street Armory. 

'*() (p. 117)- Union troops were encamped in Reservoir Square. On 
July 4, 1863, the Draught Riots began with an attack on the Colored 
Orphan Asylum near by, at Forty-third Street and Fifth Avenue. The 
"♦"roton Cottage" was burned by the mob. 

Statue of William Cullen Bryant, by Herbert Adams, on the east 
side of the Park, near the Library, erected by the Century Association 
in 191 1. 

138 



MANHATTAN 

West of the Bryant Memorial is a Memorial Fountain to Josephine 
Shaw Lowell, social worker and philanthropist, erected May 21, 1912. 
See tablet in front, sunk in the ground. 

In the Republican Club, on the site of St. Ignatius' Church, at 
54 West Fortieth Street, is a large collection of rare prints and maps 
of old New York. 

*7 (p. 121). The name "Times Square" was given shortly after the 
erection of the present Ti...es Building, by a citv ordinance, April 13, 1904. 

In the New Amsterdam Theater, 214 West Forty-second Street, 
!s the painting, "Reading the Declaration of Independence to the Army 
Dn the Common, July 9, 1776" (see p. 54). 

*8 (p. 123). Statue of General Franz Siegel, by Bitter, Riverside 
Drive and io6th Street, erected by public subscription. 

*9 (p. 125). Fulton Water Gate and Monument, to the memory of 
Robert Fulton, designed to stand on Riverside Drive, between 114th 
and ii6th streets, to be erected through public subscription cbtained 
bv the Robert Fulton Monument Association. When completed the 
re nains of Fulton are to be transferred from Trinity Churchyard to 
;his monument. 

*io (p. 127). Japanese Cherry Trees and tablet in honor of Grant 
ind the friendship of Japan for the American people, presented by the 
Japanese Government in 1912. The tablet is just northeast of the 
;omb on a granite block. 

*ii (p. 127). Tablet at the south end of the Viaduct, near 128th 
Street, to commemorate the Hollow Way, erected 1910 by the Knicker- 
ocker Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution. 

*i2(p. 135). The block bounded by Fifth and Madison avenues, 
Seventieth and Seventy-first streets, was part of the great Lenox Farm 
eft to James Lenox by his father, Robert Lenox. In 1870 Mr. Lenox 
?ave this block to a Board of Trustees for a public library, and here 
Lenox Library stood until after the opening of the New York Public 
library, the proceeds of the sale of this property being used to complete 
he new library. 

The American Jewish Historical Society, No. ^2^^ Lexington Aventie, 
•ontains books relating to the history of Jews on the American Ccn- 
inent. 

*I3 (p- 135)- Milestones are found along Third Avenue as follows: 
^o. 2, between Sixteenth and Seventeenth streets (see Exc. III. p. 91) ; 
'Jo. 4, at Fifty-seventh Street; No. 5, at Seventy-seventh Street; No. 7, 
t 117th Street (see Appendix A, p. 371). A Revolutionary cannon 
tands at the southeast corner of Third Avenue and Fifty-first Street. 

139 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

*I4 (p. 125). Carl Schurz Memorial, to be dedicated May 10, 1913, 
at Morningside Drive and One Hundred and Sixteenth Street, erected 
by public subscription. It is the work of Karl Bitter and Henry Bacon 
and consists of a bronze figure 9 feet high on a granite pedestal with 
the words — 
Carl Schurz, Defender of Liberty and Friend of Human Rights. 

Bas-reliefs represents his work in behalf of the Negro and the Indian, 
At One Hundred and Fourteenth Street and Manhattan Avenue is 

statutary by Bartholdi representing Washington and Lafayette, the gift 

of Charles Broadway Rouss. 

In Hancock Square, St. Nicholas Avenue and One Hundred and 

Twenty-third Street, is a statue of Winfield S. Hancock, erected by 

members of the Grand Army of the Republic. 



140 



EXCURSION IV— CENTRAL PARK TO KINGSBRIDGK 

From One Hundred and Fourth Street to Two Hundred and 
Thirtieth Street. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley. 

Corrected 1906 and 1909 with the aid of Reginald Pelham BoUon. 

Revised 1912 
Copyright 1897, by the City History Club of New York. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



za s I 




Plate XXVI. Map of McGown's Pass and Vicinity in 1776. With 
Location of Some More Modern Sites. 

Prawn by Edward Hagaman Hall, from whom prints of original 11 inches 
S(iuare can be obtained. Reproduced by permission. 

Division marks in margins represent projection of center lines of streets and 
avenues. Sites and topographical features are carefully located with refer- 
ence to these lines. 

J"or complete key to above map see " McGowan's Pass and Vicinity," by 
I'.dward Ilagaman Hall. 



142 



MANHATTAN 



Index 



1. American Battery, 1776, whence Washington watched Battle of 

Harlem Heights. 

2. American Battery, 1776. 

3. Matje David's Vly, 1776. 

Ground embraced between 4, 8, 14, and 15 wa§ battlefield of Har- 
lem Heights; eastern portion now called Morningside Heights. 

4. Claremont Restaurant. 

5. Grant's Tomb. 

6. Barrier Gate, 1814. 

7. Fort Laight, 1814. 

8. Blockhouse No. 4, 1814. 

9. Block House No. 3, 1814. 

10. Barnard College ; bloody buckwheat field, September 16, 1776. 

11. Columbia University. 

12. St. Luke's Hospital. 

13. Block House No. 2, 1814. 

14. Cathedral of St. John the Divine. 

15. 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, British fortifications erected 1776; 20 
is on the great Hill (the Circle) in Central Park; 22 is also 
site of Fort Clinton, 1814; 23 is also site of Nutter's Battery, 1814. 

24. Fort Fish, 1814. 

25. Block House No. i, 1814. 

26. British redoubt, 1776; Benson's Point redoubt, 1814, 

27. Mill Rock Block House, 18 14. 

28. American redoubt, evacuated September 15, 1776, 

29. Now Mt. Morris Park. 



143 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

CENTRAL PARK TO KINGSBRIDGE 

Bibliography. 

" Harlem, Its Origin and Early Annals," Jas. Riker. 

" New Harlem, Past and Present," Toler and Nutting. 

" History of the. War of 1812," R. S. Guernsey. 

"Field Book of the American Revolution," Vol. II, Lossing. 

" McGown's Pass" (American Scenic and Historic Preservation 
Society), E. H. Hall. 

Lives of Alexander Hamilton, John James Audubon, General Na- 
thaniel Greene and Washington. 

"Washington's Headquarters," published by the American and 
Scenic Preservation Society. 

"The Assault and Capture of Mt Washington," R, P. Bolton 
(Empire State Society, Sons of the American Revolution). 

" Transactions of the Long Island Historical Society," Vol. HI. 

Holyrood Parish Magazine, articles by R. P. Bolton. Astor arid 
Lenox Libraries. 

Magazine of American History, Vol. VI. 

"The Diary of Lieutenant Charles Philip von Krafft " (New York 
Historical Society). 

" The Campaign of 1776 around New York and Brooklyn," John- 
ston. 

" Force's American Archives," Vol. II, Series V. 

" Memoirs of Alexander Graydon," 1832 and 1846. 

" History of Attacks on New York," Stedman. 

" 1776, or the War of Independence," Lossing. 

"The History of the County of Westchester," Rev. Robert Bolton. 

"History of Kingsbridge," Thomas Edsall. 

"History of Westchester County," Shonnard. 

Annual Report of the American Scenic and Historic Preservation 
Society, 1905. 

"The Indians of Washington Heights," pub. by Reginald Pelham 
r>(jlton (Am. Museum of Natural History, 1909). 

1912 Report Am. Scenic and Hist. Pres. Soc, p. 147. 

* refers to Addenda, 1912, p. 173. 

144 



MANHATTAN 

SECTION I— UPPER CENTRAL PARK, MOUNT MORRIS 

PARK AND THE VILLAGE OF NIEUW HAERLEM. 

(Figures refer to Plate XXVI.) 

ROUTE 21. 

A. NORTHERN CENTRAL PARK. 

Enter the Park from Fifth Avenue and One Hundred and Second 
Street at the Girls' Gate and follozv the East Drive; or from One 
Hundred and Tenth Street and Lenox Avenue, and walk south. 

21. McGown's Pass Tavern, on the site of the original tavern, 
built b}' Jacob Dyckman, Jr., about 1750, sold in 1760 to the widow 
of Capt. Daniel McGown, who, with her son Andrew, kept it as a 
favorite resort for hunters with foxhounds. The old stone McGown 
house was in 1790 replaced by a frame structure, and the property 
was sold to Thos. B. Odell in 1845. He in turn sold it in 1847 to 
the Sisters of Charity of St, Vincent de Paul, who added several 
buildings, one of which was used by the Free School Society. 
The heights were then called Mt. St. Vincent. After the act of 
1853 was passed authorizing the laying out of Central Park, from 
Fifty-ninth to One Hundred and Sixth Street (extended to One 
Hundred and Tenth Street in 1863) the Sisters moved (1858) to Mt. 
St. Vincent-on-the-Hudson (Edwin Forrest's "Font Hill"), but they 
had charge of a military hospital in the old buildings during the 
Civil War. After the war two of these were occupied as a road- 
house and an art museum respectively, but both were burned in 
1881. In 1883 the present tavern was erected on the original site 
and in 1891 the old name " McGown's (wrongly spelled McGowan's) 
Pass " restored by law. 

The old Post Road ran through this pass, branching just north, one road 
:ontinuing to Harlem, the other, then known as Harlem Lane, running north- 
west to meet the Bloomingdale Road. Along this latter road a body of 
American troops was pursued by the British, September 15, 1776. On the fol- 
lowing day the British occupied the Pass and erected on the heights (which 
became the center of a defensive military signal system) a number of works 
which they held during the war. In 1864 traces of a Revolutionary camp 
were found at (20) the Great Hill or Circle (between West Drive and 
Eighth Avenue, opposite One Hundred and Fifth Street) where was located 
3.(6 of the British redoubts of 1776. On November 16, 1776, nearly 3000 
Americans captured at Fort Washington (Section III, 61), marched through llie 
Pass en route for military prisons. On November 21, 1783, the British evacuated 
:he works at the Pass, which were thereupon occupied by the American 
:roops. 

Take path on right to top of hill above Harlem Mere. 

145 



Route 21 IrliOl WlS.lV^/il-» \J[^J±±J1^ v^tiiiia* jraxiv 

22. Remains of Fort Clinton, named for Mayor DeWitt Clin- 
ton, an American redoubt, erected in 1814 to protect the city from 
anticipated British attacks. See memorial tablet on mount of old 
cannon and mortar, erected in 1906 by the children of the City 
History Club. The earthworks, traces of which are still visible, 
were thrown up by various volunteer bodies, including Colum- 
bia students, the Society of Tammany and the Master Butchers' 
Association. This fort is on the site of a British earthwork of 
1776. 

The flat plateau east of McGown's Pass Tavern was leveled for 
(24) Fort Fish, and (23) Nutter's Battery, was 550 feet north of Fort 
Clinton and 600 feet north of Fort Fish. 

Cross East Drive and ascend hill opposite Seventh Avenue Gate, 
on the line of One Hundred and Ninth Street. 

25. Block House No. i, on the rocky bluff opposite "Warrior's 
Gate " (Seventh Avenue). This was one of four stone towers 
erected in 1814 guarding the roads from Harlem and the north. 
On the south face see the tablet erected 1905 by the Women's 
Auxiliary to the American Scenic and Historic Preservation So- 
ciety. 

From this hill, looking north to northeast, may be seen the site 
of the original village of Nieiiw Haerlem (Plate XXVH), the 
boundary between which and the City of New Amsterdam ran in a 
straight line from Seventy-fourth Street on the East River (two 
chimney stacks of the Metropolitan Railroad Powerhouse), through 
McGown's Pass, to the northeast corner of (11) Columbia University 
buildings and beyond to a point on the Hudson (3), near One Hun- 
dred and Twenty-ninth Street. All the low ground to the east 
now covered by buildings was meadow or marsh, through which, 
on the line of One Hundred and Seventh and One Hundred and 
Eighth Streets, ran the Harlem Creek. 

To the north, between Central Park and Washington Heights, lay 
Vredendal, the land of Dr. Montague, the first settler of Harlem. 



146 



MANHATTAN 



ROUTE 22. 

B— THE SITE OF THE ORIGINAL VILLAGE OF NIEUW 

HAERLEM. 

Established by Stuyvesant in March, 1658, which existed 200 years 
and is now lost to sight beneath the modern Harlem. 

By Reginald Pelham Bolton, 1909. 
Note. — So few traces of Niew Haerlem remains, that this section 
is not laid out as an itinerary, although the antiquarian may find in- 
terest in identifying the sites. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXVI and XXVII). 

Indian Trail, now St. Nicholas Avenue, and once the Albany Post Road, 
also in part called Harlem Lane. This ran through the centre of Vredendal. 
The site of the homestead built by Montagne in 1636 was where it crosses 
Seventh Avenue close to the 8th milestone. 

At right angles from the Farmer's Gate, to the northeast, another Indian 
trail ran to the Harlem River, then called the Great Kill, which trail became 
one of the village streets. 

Vredendal, or Quiet Dale, the first Harlem settlement, was begun^ in 1656 
by Dr. Montagne. It was known by the Indians as Muscoota, or the Flats, and 
included the lowlands which extended north and northwest of Central Park, 
from the Farmer's Gate to, and including, Morningside Park (near 7). 

Montagne's Creek, known to the Indians as Rechewanes, in later times called 
the Mill Creek, and in modern times the Harlem Creek. The large gasometers 
at One Hundred and Seventh Street stand in the old bed of this creek, which 
extended back on lines of One Hundred and Seventh to One Hundred and 
Fourth Streets to Central park at Fifth Avenue and One Hundred and Ninth 
Street. A little stream ran into it from the neighborhood of Morningside 
Park. 

The Mill Camp, at One Hundred and Tenth Street and Fifth Avenue, was the 
site of the local grist mill, established in 1667 by Captain Delavall, with a dam 
across the creek at Third Avenue and One hundred and Tenth Street. 

29. Mount Morris Park. This hill was known as the Slang Berg, 
or Snake Hill, from the rattlers which infested it. The playground 
at the south end is a part of the Calf or Clover Pasture in which the 
settlers of Harlem had common rights. An American and, after- 
wards, a Hessian Battery was constructed on the summit in 1776 
commanding the mouth of the Harlem River. 

The Fire Tower is one of the last relics of the old Volunteer Fire 
Department; the bell was rung every evening at eight up to recent 
years, and this practice was resumed in 1909. 

30. Sylvan Place. This little secluded street occupies part of 
the old Church Lane. Note the old trees on either side. 

31. Dutch Reformed Church on One Hundred and Twenty- 
first Street, near Third Avenue. This is the fourth structure and 
stands on part of the original Town Lot from which the timber was 
cleared as long ago as 1666 by the then lessee, Nelis Matthyssen, a 

147 



Route 22 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Nieuw 




E 



TT.1LA5ANT AYE 



REYJ^rDFORTKE 

\TYHl£ro-pcf-CW3' 

IxcvK-.W- '^ECTlQXl' 



Plate XXVII. Route 22. 

Swedish l)nil(ler of fences. The building used to face on Third 
Avt-nnc, hut in I.S86 it was turned round to its present position. In 
thr helfry is the original bell, cast in Holland, which once hung in 
the first church. The inscription on it reads: 



"Amsterdam Anno 1734 Me Fecit." 

This church stands near the middle of the C/infr/i Lane, or Great Way, 
alongsulc which (he village was laid out.* i 
32. The Great Way. At the corner of One Hundred and Twentieth Street 

143 



Haerlem MANHATTAN 22 Route 

^nd Lexington Avenue is a triangular liouse, tlie angular side of which shows the 
line of the old Church Lane. On the northeast corner of One Hundred and 
Twenty-fifth Street and hirst Avenue, the line of Church Lane extends di- 
agonally through a lumber yard to the river. 

33. Midway of the block between Second and First Avenues on One Hundred 
and Twenty-sixth Street, the street cuts through the center of the original 
graveyard. Here, among the graves, the Hessian soldiers were picketed in 
1781. 

34. Vervcelen's First Ferry to the Bronx was established in 1663, on the 
northeast corner of One Hundred and Twenty-sixth Street and h'irst Avenue. 

35. On the northwest corner of One Hundred and Twenty-fifth Street and 
First Avenue was the house of the Voorlcser or Reader of the Dutch Church. 

36. One hundred feet west of First Avenue, in the line of the north half of 
One Hundred and Twenty-fifth Street, stood the original Dutch Church, built 
in 1668. 

37. On First Avenue, at the south side of One Hundred and Twenty-fifth 
Street, stood the second Dutch Church. 

Note that One. Hundred and Twenty-Fifth Street to Lenox ;\ venue passes 
through the Indian Schorakin, the Dutch Zegendal, or Vale of Blessing, known 
generally as Jochiem Pietersen's Flat, the second farm settled, before the village 
was formed, by Captain Jochiem Pietersen Kuyter, .a Danish gentleman, who 
was murdered by the natives in 1654. 

38. At First Avenue and One Hundred and Twenty-fourth Street, the avenue 
and street cut the old Indian Trail. 

39. Between One Hundred and Twentieth and One Hundred and Twenty-first 
Streets and Pleasant Avenue was a large Indian camp, probably a fishing place. 
A ruunber of uncompleted arrow heads were found here in 1855, indicating 
long occupation and a place of manufacture. 

Pleasant Avenue extends along what was the margin of the meadow lands, 
known to the Indians as the Conykeekst, and to the Dutch as the Otterspoor, 
from the numerous otters with which these banks abounded. _ This tract was 
granted to the Jonkheer Jacobus van Curler in 1636, afterwards purchased "by 
Van Keulen and known for many years as Van Keulen's Hook. 

Montagnc's Point, Pleasant Avenue and One Hundred and Fifth Street 
(Plate XXVI) known to the Indians as Rechcwanes or the Great Sands. Here, 
in 1636, Dr. Montague landed from his dug-out with his family and farm 
hands, the pioneer settlers. 

Hellgate Bay. The large powerhouse of the Metropolitan Railroad Com- 
pany, at Ninety-Sixth Street and First Avenue, occupies the center of the Bay, 
the meadow lands on which were reserved for the Dutch Church. 



149 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




150 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE 23. 

SECTION II.— HAMILTON GRANGE TO FORT GEORGR 
West One Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street to Dyckman Street. 
(Figures refer to Plates XXVIII, XXIX and XXXI; see also XXX.) 
Take Broadway Subzvay to One Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street; 
walk north on Hamilton Place to One Hundred and Thirty- 
ninth Street and north on Convent Avenue, passing 
The new buildings of the College of the City of New York 
(here Historical Museum may be visited). Hamilton Place oc- 
cupies the line of Old Broadway, the old Bloomingdale Road, 
vs^hich led from Morningside Heights over to the Post Road at 
One Hundred and Forty-seventh Street. *2 

41. Hamilton Grange, One Hundred and Forty-first Street and 
Convent Avenue, next to St. Luke's Church, formerly stood on 
the west side of the avenue, between One Hundred and Forty- 
second and One Hundred and Forty-third Streets. It was oc- 
cupied by Alexander Hamilton as a country seat (1802-4) and 
named " The Grange " for his ancestral home. See the tablet 
erected in 1908 by the Washington Heights Chapter Daughters of 
the American Revolution on the porch of the house and an early 
engraving of Hamilton in the vestry room of the church. 

The Thirteen (liquid amber) Trees, said to have been planted by 
Hamilton in honor of the thirteen States, were between One Hun- 
dred and Forty-second and One Hundred and Forty-third Streets, 
about 50 feet west of Convent Avenue; all are now destroyed. 
Go east to St. Nicholas Avenue and north to One Hundred and Fifty- 
second Street. 

St. Nicholas Avenue runs a little west of the original King's Way or Al- 
bany Post Road, " Breakneck Hill " was part of the old road at about One 
Hundred and Forty-seventh Street. 

American Intrenchment No. i, at One Hundred and Forty-seventh Street was 
constructed across the Heights in September, 1776. It was used in the fight 
with British frigates on Sunday, October 27, and again in the defense of the 
Heights on November 16, 1776. 

A tablet in the park space. One Hundred and Forty-seventh 
Street and Broadway, erected by the Washington Heights Chap- 
ter, Daughters of the American Revolution, marks the line of this 
intrenchment. 

At One Hundred and Fifty-second Street, on the west side, stood until i88t 
the farmhouse of Jan Dyckman, grandson of the original Harlem settler of 
the name, 

Gc west on One Hundred and Fifty-second Street to Broadway. 

42. The Ninth Milestone, with date 1769, stands in a private 
garden on the north side of One Hundred and Fifty-second 
Street, between St. Nicholas and Amsterdam Avenues. *3 

151 



Route 23 



HISTORICAL GUIDE Trinity Cemetery 







pDmDDDQDDQnaoDCKanar 



CwLoAriAi- Tji-V^y^ (f 



nnrirnr-. „^^^„^^-^^n 



mKCARCO Poll TMEI 

eixr HISTORY CLUJ 

RP BOLTON 



Plate XXVIII. Route 23. 

Go north on Broadway. 

43. Tablet, erected by the Sons of the Revolution in the wall 
of Trinity Cemetery, northwest corner of Broadway and One Hun- 
dred and Fifty-third Street, to commemorate the fighting at this 
place in the assault on Fort Washington and marking the second 
line of its southern defences. 

The high mounds at One Hundred and Fifty-third Street, within 
the Cemetery, were crowned with American redoubts. 

Trinity Cemetery, within which may be seen the tombs of Gen- 
eral Dix, Philip Livingston, J. J. Astor, Stephen Jumel and other 
distinguished men; also a cenotaph to President Monroe, whose body 
was removed to Virginia in 1858. The monument to Audubon is 
visible through the gateway on One Hundred and Fifty-fifth Street, 
between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue. 

One Hundred and Fifty-fifth Street was the extreme northerly 
limit of the plan of the city as laid down by the Commissioners of 
1807. 

152 



Washington's H'dqrs MANHATTAN 23 Route 

44. Minniesland, the home of John James Audubon, can be 
seen from Riverside Drive on the line of One Hundred and Fifty- 
sixth Street, near the river, in Audubon Park. The whole tract 
from Amsterdam Avenue to the river was the property of Audubon. 
The house was built in 1841 and the mansard roof added in 1864. 
Audubon lived here till his death, January 27, 185 1. It is said that 
in the laundry of this house the first telegraphic message was re- 
ceived from Philadelphia on an instrument set up by S. F. B. Morse. 

45. Museum of the Hispanic Society of America, at One Hun- 
dred and Fifty-sixth Street and Broadway, donated in 1904 by 
Archer M. Huntington. It contains a library of books and manu- 
scripts, and a collection of objects of art and historical interest, as- 
sociated with Spanish history and art. 

46. The Museum of the Numismatic Society (west of 45) con- 
tains a fine collection of coins and medals of general historical in- 
terest. 

Go east to Broadway and north to One Hundred and Fifty-ninth 

Street. 

A TABLET at One Hundred and Fifty-ninth Street and Broadway, erected by 
the Mary Washington Col. Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, marks 
the third line of intrenchments across the island. 

Go east to Edgecombe Avenue, or on One Hundred and Sixtieth 
Street to Jumel Place. 

47. Washington's Headquarters, the Roger Morris or Jumel 
Ma,nsion, One Hundred and Sixtieth to One Hundred and Sixty- 
second Streets, between Edgecombe Avenue and Jumel Terrace, opened 
to the public in 1907 as a Revolutionary and Colonial Museum, under 
the care of the Washington's Headquarters Association of New 
York and the Daughters of the American Revolution. 

For full account of the Mansion see p. 156. 

The cannon on the lawn is a Parrott Gun of the Civil War 
period. 

North of the mansion, on One Hundred and Sixty-second Street, 
near Edgecombe Avenue is a rock on which it is said that FitzGreene 
Halleck composed " Marco Bozzaris." 

Go north on St. Nicholas Avenue. 

48. Site of the Cross Keys Tavern, an old time road house, on the east side 
of the Albany Post Road (now St. Nicholas Avenue) at One Hundred and 
Sixty-filth Street. It is said that here Colonel Knowlton's body was brought 
September 15, 1776. The head of the leaden statue of George III (erected in 
Bowling Green) was brought here, and later was stolen by (Tox, the Tory inn- 
keeper, and buried at Kingsbridge until the arrival of the British troops, when 
it was sent to England. 

153 



Koute 23 

PValk- north on Broadway. 

40 Site of the Bradley Farmhouse (1800), between One Hundred and 
Sixty-eighth and One Hundred and Sixty-ninth Streets, west of Broadway. 
This was the site of a camp of Americans in 1776, and later of Hessians, to 
1782. Numerous remains of camp fireplaces, with military objects were found 
here when streets were opened through the farm. 

Note on the west side, between One Hundred and Seventy-first and One 
Hundred and Seventy-Second Streets, part of a fine avenue of sycamores which 
formerly led to an old mansion overlooking the Hudson and known as the 
French Academy. Where One Hundred and Seventy-first Street is cut through 
rocks west of Fort Washington Avenue were traces of several camp fires and 
a redoubt. Most of these remains will rapidly disappear with the building 
operations encouraged by the extension of the Subway. 

Go east on One Hundred and Seventh-second Street to Amsterdam 
Avenue; or walk direct up Audubon Avenue. 

Lands walked over are part of the last allotment of Common Lands of the 
Town of Nieuw Haerlem in 1712. Occasionally traces of old stone fences may 
yet be seen in vacant blocks. 

At One Hundred and Seventy-second Street, walk east around the 
Reservoir to the terrace on the east side. Note the fine view over the 
Bronx. 

50. High Bridge, built to carry the first Croton aqueduct across 
the Harlem in 1842. See tablet on bridge abutment. The high 
tower of the Water Department affords a fine panoramic view 
of the Heights and the Bronx, but it is not always accessible 
without a permit from the Department. The upper gallery is 404 
feet above the river. 

51. Crab Island. The marshy ground on the Bronx side of the Harlem at this 
point was the place of embarkation of the 42d Highla-nders in their attack in 
the Battle of Fort Washington, November 16, 1776. They landed in. a ravine 
about One Hundred and Sixty-fifth Street in what is now Highbridge Park. 
The American troops were concealed among the rocks of the Park. 

Take Amsterdam Avenue car going north. 

52. British Redoubt. East of Amsterdam Avenue, in a field, 
opposite One Hundred and Ninetieth Street, a British redoubt with 
embrasures may still be seen. This formed the extreme east end of 
the Fort George outworks, commanding the Harlem River, Palisades 
extended from it down to the river bank. At One Hundred and Nine- 
tieth Street, on Audubon Avenue, was an Officers' Camp of the Brit- 
ish Army. 



154 



Fort George MANHATTAN 23 Route 

53. Fort George, in 1776 " Laurel Hill," later called Fort Clin- 
ton. Three fortifications were constructed from 1776 to 1783. The 
first, Laurel Hill, was taken by the British November 16, 1776, the 
American Colonel Baxter being killed. This was located under the 
present site of the Schultheis Casino. The second was an enlarge- 
ment of the first, built by British troops in 1779, and extended around 
the present Fort George Avenue. Part of the fortification may still 
be seen east of Audubon Avenue, opposite One Hundred and Nine- 
ty-second to One Hundred and Ninety-third Streets. 

54. The great military Camp of Laurel Hill was occupied by many British and 
Hessian regiments between 1777 and 1783, and extended over the present truck 
gardens, west of Audubon Avenue, from One Hundred and Ninetieth to One 
Hundred and Ninety-fourth Streets. This hill was known in Dutch davs as 
the " Ronde-vlys-berg " or " Round Meadow Hill," reserved for a future 
" dorp " or village, but divided in 17 12. 

Note the fine views: west — Fort Washington; northwest — Fort 
Tryon; the flat valley below was the farm of the Kortright family 
to 1776; east — Fordham Manor, with New York University, just 
north of the site of Fort No. VHI, the ridge extending north towards 
Valentine's Hill, the site of Fort Independence (Excursion IX, Sec- 
tion 2) ; north — the view includes the " Round meadow " ; the Dyck- 
man farm and Nagel lands beyond Two Hundred and Tenth Street; 
"Sherman's Bay" or the "Half Kill"; Inwood, or the Cock Hill, 
site of Cock Hill Fort of 1776 and beyond, to the northeast, Marble 
Hill, site of Fort Prince Charles (see Section IV). 

Walk down St. Nicholas Avenue to Dyckman Street, or through the 
woods, passing 

55. British Earthworks in the woods half way down the hill in line 
with Amsterdam Avenue. 

(For points near Sherman's Creek see Section IV: 87, 88). 

56. Site of the house and farm of John Courtright, or Kortright {1703-80), 
south of Dyckman Street, at intersection of Arden Street and Sherman Avenue. 
Quantities of shells and household rubbish have been excavated here. 

Return via Subway from Dyckman Street. 



135 



Route 23 HISTORICAL GUIDE Washington's 

WASHINGTON'S HEADQUARTERS, ROGER MORRIS OR 
JUMEL MANSION 

JOSIAH C. PUMPELLY, A. M., LL. B. 

The Roger Morris House, more recently known as the Jnmel 
Mansion, and now as Washington's Headquarters, is a fine speci- 
men of Georgian architecture and ranks in historic interest with 
St. Paul's Chapel and Fraunces Tavern. 

Lieutenant-Colonel Roger Morris, of the British 47th Regiment 
and a member of the King's Council, who was Washington's 
comrade in arms and wounded in the ill-fated attack on Fort Du 
Quesne, bought the property and in 1765 erected the house which 
he presented to his bride, Mary Philipse, as a wedding gift. 

It was occupied as headquarters by Washington from Septem- 
ber 16 to October 21, 1776. Here he formed plans for de- 
fending the Heights and for blocking the passage of the Hudson 
River and here he issued the remarkable series of general 
orders and carried on the famous correspondence with William 
Duer of the Secret Committee of Safety.' In the neighborhood 
were camped 8000 inexperienced volunteer forces, mostly raw 
and undisciplined, in motley garb and held together only by 
the bond of a common principle and the power of a united love 
of liberty and independence. 

During the battle which resulted in the capture of Fort Wash- 
ington, November 16, 1776, the Morris House was the center 
of operations. The three lines of earthworks to the south were 
carried by English troops under General Lord Percy; the 42d 
Highlanders scaled the hill above the present Speedway, while 
the main attack by the Hessians was in front of Fort Tryon. 
The prisoners from Fort Washington were first assembled in 
the Morris barns before being taken to the hulks and prison 
houses in New York. 

The house was the headquarters of Lieutenant-General Sir 
Henry Clinton, and, therefore, the headquarters of the British 
Army, during the entire summer of 1777. 

During the summer of 1778 it was occupied, after his return 
from Philadelphia, by Lieutenant-General Baron von Knyphausen 
and his German staff. It continued throughout the war to be the 
Hessian headquarters, and in the last years was occupied by 
Lieutenant-General von Losberg. 



Headquarters MANHATTAN 23 Route 

After the Revolution the Morris farm was confiscated and 
sold. It was successively farmhouse and inn, the latter known 
as Calumet Hall, where the first change of horses was made 
after leaving New York for Albany. In 1790, President Wash- 
ington and his Cabinet, after a visit to Fort Washington on 
July ID, dined here " on a dinner provided by a Mr. Marriner." 
Among the guests of the President were John and Abigail Adams, 
Alexander Hamilton and Mrs. Hamilton, General Knox and 
Mrs. Knox, Thomas Jefiferson, Mrs. Tobias Lear, John Park 
Custis and Nellie Custis. 

In 1810 the house was bought by Stephen Jumel, a wealthy 
French wine merchant, who restored it to its condition in Wash- 
ington's time. In 1815 the Jumels went to France in their own 
ship for the purpose of bringing Napoleon Bonaparte to America. 
They remained abroad until 1826, the house being rented during 
that time. Stephen Jumel returned in 1828 and the family was 
united in the old house. The Jumels brought with them many 
presents from Napoleon and souvenirs of his reign. His cam- 
paigning trunk, a chariot clock from the Tuileries, a table painted 
by Josephine and numerous pieces of furniture remained in the 
house until 1888. Stephen Jumel died in 1832 and was buried in 
the grounds of the Cathedral of St. Patrick in Prince Street. 

In 1833 Mme. Jumel married Aaron Burr. The marriage was 
soon followed by a separation and divorce. 

From a period even before the Jumel purchase the house was 
the resort of French emigres. Louis Napoleon, Jerome and 
Joseph Bonaparte were at various times guests of Mme. Jumel. 
Mme. Jumel died in 1865 and her tomb may be seen in Trinity 
Cemetery, west of Broadway, near One Hundred and Fifty-fourth 
Street. 

Nelson Chase, who studied law in the office of Aaron Burr 
and married Mary Bownes, the niece of Mme. Jumel, occupied 
the house for fifty years. He was an able lawyer and litterateur 
and entertained here James Parton, the poet, N. P. Willis, his 
sister Fanny Fern, Mrs. Blennerhasset and many other literary 
friends. 

While a guest here, FitzGreene Halleck wrote his celebrated 
poem, " Marco Bozzaris." 



157 



Route 23 HISTORICAL GUIDE Washington's 

After the death of Chase the property changed hands several 
times and finally in May, 1903, it was purchased for $235,000 by 
the city, through the intercession of the Washington Heights 
Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution, assisted 
by the Society of the Sons of the American Revolution. 

On December 28, 1903, the house was formally opened under 
Whc auspices of the City of New York and on January 19, 1905, 
the Park Department decided to retain control, and in 1907 
the Washington's Headquarters Association of New York and 
the Society of the Daughters of the American Revolution acquired 
the use of the house for a museum of historic relics and furnish- 
ings of the period of the Revolution. 

The Council Chamber, the large octagonal room at the back 
of the hall, known in Washington's time as the Court-Martial 
Room, contains some rare pieces of Colonial furniture, notably 
one of the Washington plates decorated with the insignia of the 
Cincinnati. It is said that in this room Washington received 
visits of the sachems of the Five Iroquois Nations who offered 
their allegiance to the cause of liberty. 

The Guard Room, in charge of Reginald Pelham Bolton, con- 
tains a collection of objects dug up on the battlefield and camp 
grounds in the vicinity by Messrs. Bolton and Carver, such as 
cannon balls and bar-shot, buttons of British and Hessian regi- 
ments, shoe-buckles, coins. Revolutionary weapons and Indian 
remains. 

The Dining Room contains portraits of the hosts and hostesses 
and famous guests of the house, all carefully arranged and veri- 
fied by W. H. Shelton, the Curator; also, a collection of Napo- 
leon-Jumel china presented bv Edwin Francis Searles of Methuen, 
Mass. 

The Tea Room, which in Washington's time must have been 
the office of the Adjutant General, contains old furniture, por- 
traits, cabinets of china and souvenirs of the Colonial and Revo- 
luti(jnary periods. 

Washington's Bedroom and Office and the Rooms of Lafayette 

and Burr arc on the second floor. The Washington bedroom is 
furnished as a Colonial bedroom, and one of its notable exhibits 
is a small table on which Major Andre wrote a letter to Arnold 
in the presence of his captors. The Lafayette Room contains 

158 



Headquarters MANHATTAN 23 Route 

the collection of Mrs. Louis Bennett of West Virginia, and in- 
cludes the richly carved bed and sofa used by Lafayette at the 
Charleston (S. C) Hotel. 

Other important exhibits are the Washington table from 
Fraunces Tavern, a British army blanket of the period of the 
Revolution, reproduction of the West and Copley portraits of 
Roger Morris and Mary Philipse (presented by the Hon. H. M. 
Bower, Mayor of Ripon, England), Washington watches, mourn- 
ing pitchers and handkerchiefs, Aaron Burr's trunk, Governor 
Bradford's punch-bowl, Governor Trumbull's chair and Lafayette 
relics. 

On the front of the house note the tablet erected in 1900 by 
the Washington Heights Chapter, Daughters of the American 
Revolution. 

The building and grounds are open to the public every day 
from 9 to 5. 

The Eleventh Milestone, originally at 170th Street and Broadway, 
was removed to Roger Morris Park by the City History Club, 191 1, and 
stands at the rear of the Mansion. In 1912 the Club provided a marker 
and bronze tablet with the following inscription : 

II Miles 

from 

N. York 

In 1769 at 156th St. 

In 1819 at 170th St. 

The City History Club 

1912 



See Historical Sketch of Washington's Headquarters, prepared under 
the auspices of The Washington Headquarters Association, New York, 
by Emma A. F. Smith. 



159 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



HVD^OyM 



RlVEF. 




mDQDDDDDDODDDr 
ngaaDDDDDDDDDDDDiDDDDE 

dmm QDmaanilpn PDDiLaaJlE 

' DC? " 



_ -.:d 



amc 




Plate XXIX. Routes 23, 24, 



25. 



160 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE 24. 

SECTION III— FORT WASHINGTON. 

One Hundred and Eighty-first to One Hundred and Ninety-sixth 

Streets. 
Take Broadway Subway to One Hundred and Eighty-first Street and 
walk west to Broadway. *4 
(Figures refer to Plate XXIX; see XXX). 

57. Site of the original Farm of the Van Oblinus family, between 
179th and i8oth streets, west of Broadway; first Dutch settlers 
in this region (before 1706). In 1691 the ground was granted to Joost 
Oblinus, Magistrate of Harlem, and was known as the "Indian Field," 
or "Great Maize Land," having been one of the planting grounds of 
the Weckquaskeek tribe. 

58. In Holyrood Protestant Episcopal Church, at Fort Washington 
Avenue and One Hundred and Seventy-ninth Street, is a tablet erected 
in 1902 by the Mary Washington Colonial Chapter, Daughters of the 
American Revolution, in commemoration of the exploit of Margaret 
Corbin, who took her soldier husband's place on his death during the 
attack on Fort Washington (see 69, p. 167). In 1902 a Peace Bell was 
dedicated in memory of the successful end of the Revolution. The 
surrounding land was occupied by American barracks in 1776 (a camp 
market being held here in October of that year), and by Von Donop's 
Hessian hut-camp until 1781. 

59. Site of the Blue Bell Tavern, on the west side of Broadway, 60 feet north 
of One Hundred and Eighty-first Street. At this point Washington reviewed 
the army of occupation on Evacuation Day, November 25, 1783. The tavern 
was a well-known hostelry probably started about 1730; Cadwalader Colden 
mentions it in 1751. It was occupied by Howe on the capture of Fort Wash- 
ington. Afterwards it became the store and home of the family of Bernard 
Bauer, or Bowers, and existed as a dwelling to 1870. (See the view in 
Valentine's Manual, 1857, p. 208.) 

The westerly hill north of One Hundred and Eighty-first Street was known 
as " Long Hill," changed in 1776 to " Mount Washington "; Laurel Hill, now 
Fort George, lies northeast of the line of Broadway. 

Go west on One Hundred and Eighty-first Street and north through 
the old Bennett Lane, passing on the right 

60. Death Gap, the ravine to the north, the traditional scene of 
great execution, as here the British and Hessian troops tried to force 
their way up the heights, the defenders hurling great boulders down 
on them from above. Human bones have been found in the valle}' 
below, many near the Roman Catholic Church and One Hundred and 
Eighty-seventh Street. 

161 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




MANHATTAN 

INDEX TO PLATE XXX. 









C 



^ <u ^ ^ bo -O 



•s It i '«||^ |S«J 

•S .S - I J t^ c .^ S -2 ^ S t^ M o -S !• ::^ .^ ^ 
d\ 6 h4 oi CO "+ to vd K. 00 2^ d M ci 









ix 
























x 




t« 


bo 










o 
























p 
















fo 
























w 




c 


• t? 


























•— < 










(U 


X 






































c 


(/i 










O 












C/5 






s 






tie 


t« 


OS 


• 


<u' 

o 

u 


d 
H 


H 
<u 

e 




c 


<lj 
> 

XI 


X 


a 


1 


6 

o 






>-■ 

o 


c 
o 


c* 
o 


-5 
c 

E 

B 
o 
u 


% 


O 


.2 

CO 

C 


l-l 


1 




1 






1 






1 




(J 


o 


0-1 

O 




^ 


::: 
o 
-a 


bfl 




O 


o 


o 


o 


O 


c 


O 


o 


O 


o 


o 


o 


(V 


o 


o 


o 


<v 


E 


X 


o 


Ph 


Plh 


fe 


fe 


1— 1 


Ph 


fe 


fe 




fe 


u 


^ 


fe 


fe 


Ph 


0^ 




-H» 



lo vo i^ CO 



163 



Route 24 HISTORICAL GUIDE Ft. Washington 

• The " Hessian Spring " in the ravine below the rocks is now covered by 
Bennett Avenue at One Hundred and Eighty-fourth Street. The line of the 
avenue above was the site of the hut-camp, and some traces of the garrison of 
English and Scotch troops were found here in 1909. The line of an old zig- 
zag road, connecting Fort Washington and Fort George, may still be traced 
on both sides of Broadway. 

61. Remains of Fort Washington, the central citadel of the 
defenses of the Heights in the Revolution, built chiefly by Penn- 
sylvania troops, directed by Colonel Rufus Putnam, afterwards 
captured by the British, and called Fort Knyphausen. This is the 
highest point of land on Manhattan, 270 feet above tidewater. 
Here the American garrison of 3000 men and officers surrendered 
on Nov. 16, 1776. At One Hundred and Eighty-third Street and 
Fort Washington Avenue the site of the fort is marked by a 
marble wayside seat and tablet (the gift of James Gordon Ben- 
nett), erected in 1901, under the auspices of the Empire State 
Society, Sons of the American Revolution, and of the American 
Scenic and Historic Preservation Society. The tablet is at the 
base of the northeast bastion of the fort. The west bastions are 
plainly visible southwest of the Bennett House; the east glacis 
was the slope on the north side of One Hundred and Eighty-first 
Street and ravelins or breastworks extended across the old Ben- 
nett Lane and front yards of the two houses on One Hundred 
and Eighty-first Street, at the intersection of Fort Washington 
Avenue. Along Fort Washington Avenue have been unearthed 
numerous military relics, and 75 feet south of One Hundred and 
Eighty-first Street were found bones of 45 dead who appear to 
have been buried in a trench. This was the site pf the garrison 
burying ground, and those killed at the Battle of Fort Washing- 
ton were probably buried at this point. 

62. Bennett House, the one-time residence of the elder and 
younger James Gordon Bennett, founders of the " New York 
Herald." 



164 



MANHATTAN 

ROUTE 25. 

SIDE TRIP A— FORT WASHINGTON MONUMENT TO 

FORT WASHINGTON PARK. 
Walk south on Fort Washington Avenue to One Hundred and Eighty- 
first Street, west to Riverside Drive, once Boulevard La- 
fayette, and south to the entrance of Fort 
Washington Park. 
(Figures refer to Plate XXIX). 
Follow the path over the bridge, crossing the deep cutting of the 
Hudson River R. R., nicknamed the " Dolly Varden," the earliest 
railroad line (date of franchise August 19, 1847) to enter the city, 
over which a few passenger trains and many freight trains still pass. 

63. Sunset Lane meets this path from the south just before it 
crosses the bridge. Cedar Point is the projection into the Hudson 
•northwest of the bridge. A fine view may be obtained up the 
river as far as the Tappan Zee. After crossing the bridge, turn 
up the side path to the left and on the top of the hill see the 

64. Redoubt, built in October, 1776, by American troops, di- 
rected by Imbert, a French engineer, the best preserved of the 
entire district. *5 

Pass south through the redoubt and dozvn over the rocks a short 

distance to 

65. Site of telegraph mast, a circular hole in a flat rock, cut in 
1852 for the support of a tall mast from which were suspended 
telegraph wires to the New Jersey shore, before the submarine 
cable was perfected. See the iron staybolts in the surrounding 
rocks. 

Descend to the river shore. The extreme point is 

66. Jeffrey's Hook, now known as Fort Washington Point, the 
place from which ships were taken and sunk in the Hudson to 
check the passage of the British fleet in 1776. Here Washington 
crossed to and from Fort Lee, which is situated nearly due west 
on the Palisades. (Excursion to Ft. Lee: Excursion V, Section 6). 
The point is covered by remains of a one-gun " lunette," or mot>n- 
shaped battery, built in 1776. Note the beaches where men and 
stores were landed. Indian shell heaps line the bank of the east- 
erly beach. 

Take a rocky path south along shore to the Fort Washington Rail- 
road Station, or return by Sunset Lane to Depot Lane 
and ascend east to Broadzcay. passing 

• 67. Site of Post's Tavern, at the east side of Broadway, opposite Depot Lane. 
It was a well known hostelry from the Revolution to about 1854. Many small 
relics have been found at the northwest intersection of the above streets. 

Return to Subway Station at One Hundred and Eighty-first Street or 
takp. Side Trib B. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



HvD^o/>r B-nN^EK. 




iDDDQoan 



DDDD 






^pEEr)vr>^-r 



ITV HISTORY CLUB MA.K.LE>\ 

R P BOLTOAl. 



^JVl 






Plate XXXI. Routes 23, 26, 28a. 



16O 



MANHATTAN 



ROUTE 26. 

SIDE TRIP B— TO FORT TRYON. 
(Figures refer to Plate XXXI; see also XXX.) 

Walk north along Fort Washington Avenue, passing 

68. Libby Castle, built in 1864 by William Alexander Richards 
and occupied for a time by William Tweed. 

69. The site of Fort Tryon is at One Hundred and Ninety-seventh 
Street, on what was known as Forest Hill. A small two-gim 
"fleche" (marked by a tablet, the gift of C. K. G. Billings and 
erected in 1909 under the auspices of the American Scenic and 
Historic Preservation Society), forming the one-time northeast 
angle of the fort, is still visible. On the northwest side of the 
hill breastworks may be seen, probably the scene of Margaret 
Corbin's exploit. Around this hill took place the bloodiest re- 
sistance of the battle, 600 Maryland and Virginia troops with- 
standing 4,600 Hessians for nearly three hours. Half way down 
the hill towards the Hudson, and reached from the top by a nar- 
row path, was the spring which, at one time, supplied the gar- 
rison. In the little field on the east side are said to be buried 
the Hessian dead. 

70. The Abbey is a fanciful name applied to the old Hays 
House, now a restaurant. 

Descend by the hill, turning southeast to Broadway, thence north to 
Dyckman Street, passing 

71. The site of the old Black Horse Tavern of about 1812, on 
the corner of Riverside Drive and Dyckman Street. *6 

Return by Subway or Surface Cars. 



167 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 27. 

SECTION IV.— KINGSBRIDGE TO INWOOD. 
(Figures refer to Plates XXXI and XXXII; see also XXX). 
Take Broadway Subway to Two Hundred and Twenty-fifth Street 

Station. 
72. Marble Hill, once known as Humock Island or Papirinemen 
("a place parcelled out"). This Indian name included the creek 
around the Hill. 

72>- The King's Bridge, established by Royal Grant of William 
and IMary to Frederick Philipse of the Manor of Philipsburgh in 



HVD30.V 



RIVJIB. 




Plate XXXII. Routes 27, 28. 
168 



Ship Canal MANHATTAN 27 Route 

1693 and first constructed about twenty yards east of the present 
bridge, rebuilt in 1713, near its present position. It was broken 
down after the retreat of Washington's troops over it in October, 
1776; repaired by Knyphausen's forces; abandoned from 1779 to 
1782 as too exposed to American attacks, and replaced by a bridge of 
boats and pontoons further west. The bridge rebuilt after the 
Revolution was practically on the present lines, except that it was 
double, having a flume or dyke to supply water to Macomb's grist 
and marble mills. The latter were destroyed in 1856. 

The Wading Place. A shallow place about 150 teet west of the bridge, 
first used as a ford for passengers and beasts. 

In 1673 a ferry was established here by Verveelen. 

Under the present Broadway bridge was a little marshy island, locally known 
as Gardener's Island, on which was an Indian shell heap. 

74. Fort Prince Charles, or the Charles Redoubt, at the corner 
of Marble Hill Avenue and Two Hundred and Twenty-eighth Street, 
was marked in 1894 by a flagpole and a notice board. It was an 
earthwork commenced by the American forces in the summer of 
1776 to protect the bridge, and was completed by the Hessian troops 
after November, 1776. Another small fleche, or angular redoubt, 
was located to the east, on Kingsbridge Avenue. 

75. Site of Hyatt's Tavern, built and opened by Jacob Dyckman, Jr., in 1763, 
soon after selling McGown's Pass Tavern (Section I), west of the present 
Broadway, exactly opposite the Kingsbridge Hotel in now vacant lots. 

y6. Farmer's Bridge, also known as the Dyckman, Free, or 
Queen's Bridge, built in 1759 to evade the tolls at the King's Bridge, 
on Dyckman's and Vermilyea's lands. It was broken down by the 
American forces while retreating from Fort Independence in Novem- 
ber, 1776; restored and used by the Hessians in landing on this 
island; again broken in 1778, on account of the American attacks, 
and later restored. Filled in and covered over 1912. 

77. United States Ship Canal, established and constructed by 
the United States Government. Before it was cut through, two little 
brooks ran east and west on the line of the center of the swing 
span of the bridge. These, in 1817, were enlarged into a little canal 
by the owner, Curtis and John Bolton, the latter an Alderman of 
New York, and a marble mill and quarries were established here by 
them. The present double-deck swing span replaced (1906) the 
single swing span, which now forms part of the Fordham Manor 
Bridge at Two Hundred and Seventh Street. 

78. The Marble Arch was built in recent years as an entrance 
to the Seaman, now the Drake Estate. 

79. The Twelfth Milestone, set into the wall of the entrance 
to the Isham property, at Two Hundred and Eleventh Street. Its 
original position was about One Hundred and Ninetieth Street. 

169 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 28a 

SIDE TRIP A.— COLONIAL AND REVOLUTIONARY SITES 
EAST OF BROADWAY. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXI and XXXII). 

Take the old Nagel Lane to the east, or the recently opened Two 

Hundred and Fourteenth Street to 

80. Colonial Burying Ground, established by the early settlers, 
after 1677, on the Nagel property and placed in trust, 1807. It con- 
tains remains of the Nagel, Vermilyea, Post, Ryer and other local 
families. The Dyckman remains were removed in 1905, except those 
of Staats Morris Dyckman and family. At the east end of the 
graveyard, small stones mark the graves of the unknown dead, 
tradition says of the Hessian and British garrison, 1777-83. From 
the south side of the graveyard the remains were removed in 1909 
to widen Two Hundred and Twelfth Street. 

81. Site of the Negro Burying Ground, across Tenth Avenue, between Two 
Hundred and Eleventh and Two Hundred and Twelfth Streets, for the slav«s 
of the settlers, — it contained thirty-six graves, all destroyed by excavation in 
1902. 

82. Indian Ceremonial Pits were located on Two Hundred and Eleventh 
Street, west of Tenth Avenue. They were opened in 1904 and found to con- 
tain the remains of a dog, a snake and a turtle, oyster shells and pottery, 
probably used in a ceremony known as " The Wliite Dog Feast." 

JValk east to Ninth Avenue. 

83. Site of the "Century " House, burnt down 1901, entirely removed in 1907, 
stood near the bank of the Harlem, in the line of Two I^undred and Thirteenth 
Street. The house was built by Jan Nagel (the 2d) in 1735-6, used by General 
William Heath as headquarters in 1776, and later occupied by British and 
Hessian officers. Buttons of an officer of the 17th Light Dragoons were found 
here, as were buttons of the 15th, 38th, 47th, 57th, 8oth and of the Royal 
Provincial Regiments, also Hessian buttons, Hanoverian and British coins. In 
front of the house the remains of a small building were discovered in 1906, 
with military objects (bayonets, bar shots, bullets, etc.), showing Revolutionary 
occupation. It was possibly the original settler's house, 1677 to 1735. *7 

ll'alk south along the river bank or along Ninth Avenue to Two 
Hundred and Tenth Street. 

84. Site of the Dyckman House, at Two hundred and Tenth Street, on the 
bank of the river, used during the Revolution by officers of the British troops, 
but destroyed or abandoned about 1781. 

Two Hundred and Eleventh Street was the line of division of the farms of 
Nagel and Dyckman, partitioned in 1744; it also formed the north boundary of 
the hrst land grant of this district to Jansen and Aertsen in 1647. 

85. At Two Hundred and Ninth Street, on the river bank, note the traces of 
a great Indian shell heap. Two dog burials were found here. 

Continue south on Ninth Avenue. 

86. l-'oRDiiAM Manor or Ni:w York University Bridge. 

'I he low ground here on the Harlem was the meadow known as Myndert's 
lly. tiie nu-adow of Meynard Journee whose name the Dutch changed to 
Mcyndcrt Maljaart. It was bought from him in 1676 by Nagel and held by 
his heirs, although in the middle of the Dyckman lands, and known to modern 
times by the name of the original owner. 

87. A British Camp of considerable extent existed on the edge of the bank 

170 



Sherman's Creek MANHATTAN 28a, 28b Routes 

of the river, between Two Hundredth and Two Hundred and First Streets on 
a site now entirely covered by the power house of the New York Edison Com- 
pany. 

Here was a group of military buildings, storehouses or officers' huts. Near 
the remains of a great camp fire, numerous military objects, including many 
buttons of the loth, 23d, 37th, 64th and Royal Provincial Regiments, were 
found. 

Holland's Ferry across the Harlem was maintained at this point, to connect 
with Fort No. \lll, on the hill just south of the Hall of Fame (New York 
University). This ferry was attacked and the ropes cut by the American forces 
in the raid in 1781. 

Walk west along the north side of 

88. Sherman's Creek, known by the Dutch as the " Half Kill," 
and later as the "Round Meadow Creek" (1811). On the southeast 
bank the British troops landed November 16, 1776, to assault Laurel 
Hill (Fort George) (53, 54). 

Walk west on Academy Street, passing through the Round Meadow 
or Ronde Vly, to Broadway. 

89. The brook running from Broadway to the Creek was known as Pietcr 
Tuynier's (the gardener's) Run, or Fall, being on the lands allotted at a very 
early date to Pierre Cresson. 



ROUTE 28b. 

SIDE TRIP B.— WEST OF BROADWAY TO COLD SPRING. 

From Broadway, go zvest on Acadoiiy Street. 
Note. — If Side Trip A is omitted, continue dozen Broadway from 
(79) y passing at Hawthorne Avenue the Dyckman House (98). 

90. Indian Village and British Camp of the 17th Regiment. The center of 
this large camp was approximately in the garden between Coojjer Street and 
Seaman Avenue; it was excavated in 1907 and the numbered buttons of many 
British regiments were found. Indian pits were found, some being ceremonial, 
and several Indian human burials were also discovered here in 1907-08, with 
many aboriginal weapons and stone implements. 

Walk south around Seaman Avenue to Pvescoti Avenue. 

91. Site of British Officers' Quarters, at the intersection of Seaman and 
Prescott Avenues. Buttons of many regiments have been found here. 

Above Rieff's Cottage were found the remains of a flagpole, military bake- 
ovens and other indications of camp life. 

Walk north up Prescott Avenue. 

92. Site of 17^/1 Regiment Hut. A fireplace (about 150 feet north of Rieff's 
Cottage on the west side of Prescott Avenue) was found in 1904 and marks 
one of the huts of this regiment which are shown in Von Krafft's sketch map of 
1778. The regiment moved hence to Stony Point and was captured there July 
15-16, 1/79, by the American troops under General Anthony Wayne. 

Walk over the hill and down the into the wooded valley known as 

the Clove. Follow the path to the west side of Manhattan 

along the shore of Spuyten Duyvil Creek to 

171 



Route 28 b HISTORICAL GUIDE Cold Spring 

93. The Cold Spring, or Spouting Spring, which probably gave 
its name to the Spuyten Duyvil Creek. The spring is now piped 
to a spot near the river, but originally spouted from the rocks. The 
Indian name of this locality, including (as they generally did) 
the Creek at this place, was Shora-kapkok, which may be trans- 
lated "as far as the sitting-down or resting place," probably sig- 
nificant of the secluded character of the hollow, undoubtedly used 
for a long period of time by the aborigines whose large palisaded 
village (Nip-nich-sen) occupied the summit of Spuyten Duyvil Hill 
opposite. 

Note the great tree, the largest tulip on the Island of Manhattan, 

but probably not older than the past century, 6 1-2 feet in diameter, 

grown through an Indian shell heap which extends to the south. *8 

Return south along the path about 75 yards thence west through 

the woods to the 

94. Indian Rock Dwelling, discovered by Alexander C. Clieno- 
weth, within which were found aboriginal pottery, tools, bones, etc., 
now in Case I, Indian Room of the American Museum of Natural 
History, evidencing long occupation by tribes, antecedent to their 
scattering by the Mohawk Indians in 1673. In the rocks above was 
a cache, or store place, and below, to the east, under a large rock, 
are evidences of use of a fireplace. 

95. Cock Hill. The hill above was known in colonial da>;s as Cock Hill, 
possibly shortened from Shora-kapkok, corrupted, in Revolutionary times, to 

' Cox's Hill," confounded with the name of the Tory innkeeper of Kings- 
bridge. The remains of an American fort, enlarged by the British and used to 
1780, were once on the land of James IMcCreery, but are not now discoverable. 

From Cold Spring a trail leads over the hill to the Hudson where 
may be seen the point of anchorage of Henry Hudson in September, 
1609, and of the first encounter with the natives of Nip-nich-sen (see 
93). 
Returning to Broadway, take path leading to Emerson Street, passing 

96. Indian Planting Ground, now cultivated land, on the Isham property which 
has yielded many Indian objects and tools, discovered' by W. L. Calver. *9 

97. Scene of Fighting, November 8-9, 1776. This entire vale was the scene 
of a skirmish between Pennsylvania troops and the Hessian advance guard, 
November 8-9, 1776, and was also the line of march of the center division of 
the Hessian army advancing against Fort Tryon on November 16, 1776, under 
Baron Knyphausen. 

Traces of Indian camps and military encampments have been found at several 
places in this vale. 

98. Dyckman Dwelling: the second, or perhaps third, Dyck- 
man house, built in 1787, probably with materials from the older 
houses; it gives a good idea of the appearance of colonial farm 
dwellings, being much like the Century House. See old chimney 
on the south side, 

172 



MANHATTAN 



ADDENDA, 1912 

*i (p. 148). This is now used for a Sunday-school and parish build- 
ing, the bell having been removed to the new church structure at Lenox 
Avenue and One Hundred and Twenty-third Street. 

In Cowperthwait's store at One Hundred and Twenty-first Street and 
Third Avenue may be seen an interesting collection of prints of Old 
New York. 

A good view of the Harlem Kills and neighboring islands may be 
obtained from the Willis Avenue bridge. 

*2 (p. 151). The Historical Museum of the City College contains a 
collection of rare prints and maps of old New York. On the wall is 
a tablet, erected in 1908 by the Sons of the Revolution to record the 
occupation of the Heights by the American army after the battle of 
Harlem Heights. 

*3 (p- 151)- Fountain and Light Tower at Edgecombe Avenue and 
One Hundred and Fifty-fifth Street, erected in 1894 by bequest of 
George Hooper of Brooklyn. 

Tablet in the wall of the kiosk or pergola on Riverside Drive at 
One Hundred and Fifty-first Street, erected in 1912 in memory of the 
U. S. sailors of the Nezv Hampshire who were drowned in the Hudson 
in 1909. 

*4 (p. 151). Fountain and memorial tablet at the west end of Wash- 
ington Bridge, Amsterdam Avenue, between One Hundred and Eighty- 
first and One Hundred and Eighty-second Street, erected 1912 in mem- 
ory of Andrew Jackson by the National Society U. S. Daughters of 
1812, Andrew Jackson Chapter. 

*5 (p. 165). In 1910 a boulder monument was erected here by the 
Fort Washington Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, It 
bears the words, "American Redout 1776." 

*6 (p. 167). Mt. Washington Presbyterian Church, at Dyckman 
Street and Broadway, w^as built in 1844-46 at Tnhhy Hook; this name 
was derived either from Peter Ubrecht, one of the Dyckman family, or 
from the earlier Indian name Ubiquaes, as in the deed of 1649. 

Public School No. 52 on Broadway at Academy Street was opened 
April, 1858, on land given by Isaac Dyckman ; the nearest school then 
was No. 31, at One Hundred and Fifty-sixth Street, but there had been 
the Hamilton Free School (1820- 1853, burned) near One Hundred and 
Eighty-seventh Street on the Kingsbridge Road. 

173 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

See painting in the Union League Club, "Passing the 
Outpost," by A. Wordsworth Thompson, the scene being at the Century 
House. 

*8 (p. 172). The tulip tree has been surrounded by an iron railing 
and the great cavities filled with cement by the Park Department. An 
inscription was placed on it in 1912 stating the age of the tree, its size 
and the history of the region. 

*9(P- 172). 

THE HISTORICAL ASSOCIATIONS OF ISHAM PARK 
By Reginald Pelham Bolton 

The land occupies a hill on the west side of the Kingsbridge Road 
conmianding views of the Dyckman tract, Inwood Hill, the Cold Spring 
hollow and Spuyten Duyvil Creek. 

This was a favorite haunt of the Indian local tribe, the Weck-quas- 
keeks, as shown by many evidences of their existence in its vicinity: 
human remains disinterred on the south margin of the Park at Isham 
Street, ceremonial dog burials at Cooper Street and numerous stone 
objects, tools and weapons. 

These and other historical objects are on exhibition in one of the 
rooms of the Isham Mansion set apart for the purpose. 

The land now comprising Isham Park was part of that granted in the 
year 1640 to Tobias Teunissen, a native of Amsterdam and a wool- 
washer by occupation. With his wife and three children he occupied a 
little home in this immediate neighborhood among the Indians who 
then frequented it. Teunissen fell a victim to Indian vengeance on the 
white colonists in September, 1665, and his family was carried into 
captivity. 

In 1677 the land north of a boundary on the line of Tw^o Hundred 
and Eleventh Street was purchased by Jan Nagel. 

In November, 1776, the Hessian Army erected on the highest part of 
the Park two redoubts ; a sharp encounter took place on November 8th, 
when the Pennsylvania troops, advancing from the woods of Inwood 
Ilill, drove in the Hessian outposts and fired their quarters; the entire 
Hessian division moved over the Park area, when, on November 16, 
1776, the assault upon Fort Washington was made. 

The present Isham residence was built by the Ferris family before 
1862, and was purchased in 1864 by William B. Isham. He laid out 
the grounds, during which he disturbed many relics of the military 
occupation. 

174 



MANHATTAN 

In 191 1 the park, then comprising more than six acres, was presented 
by Mrs. Julia Isham Taylor to the city to be named in memory of her 
father, William B. Isham. In order to protect the park and preserve 
the view of Inwood Hill and of the Palisades of the Hudson, an ad- 
dition of several acres was acquired and given in 1912 by Miss Flora 
E. Isham. 

Some of the most picturesque portions of Inwood hill will become a 
park, thus preserving the natural features of its original forest and its 
historical remains. (Route 28b.) For a discussion of the name Spuytcn 
DuyvH see the 191 1 Report of the American" Scenic and Historic 
Preservation Society. 

The mansion is a brick and frame building of peculiar shape, having 
four wings extending from a central circular hall and stairway. 

It is in excellent preservation and has been arranged by the present 
Park Commissioner, Hon. Charles B. Stover, as a public building, 
with conveniences for the use of the public, and a nursery for the 
mothers and children. 

One of the upper parlors is devoted to the use of The City History 
Club as a country meeting and exhibition room. 

Alongside this room is the museum of local antiquities, discovered, 
prepared and loaned by Reginald Pelham Bolton and William L. 
Calver, which includes Indian objects. Colonial and Revolutionary re- 
mains from the Dyckman tract and Isham Park. There is also a very 
interesting exhibit of Indian w^eapons and articles collected by the late 
W. B. Isham, indicating his interest in the historical subjects for which 
his old home is now in part utilized. 

One of the objects of local interest, preserved by the care of the late 
William B. Isham, is the Twelfth Milestone on the old Kingsbridge 
Road, which he secured and placed in the wall of the present Park at 
the entrance to its beautiful driveway. This stone stood originally 
about a mile south of its present site, near One Hundred and Ninety- 
second Street, from which position it was removed northwards three- 
quarters of a mile about 1819, when the present City Hall was made 
the point from which the distances were measured. 

The City History Club is now the designated custodian of these 
milestones, and it has prepared a tablet marking this stone. (See 
Appendix A.) 



174a 



PART TWO 



BOROUGH OF THE BRONX 

EXCURSION IX.— ROUTES 29-34^. 

By Randall Comport. 

Copyright. 1906, by the City History Club of New York. 
Revised 1910 and 1912. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

HISTORICAL SKETCH OF THE BRONX 

The Borough of the Bronx derives its name from its first white 
settler, Jonas Bronck, who made his home near the Bronx^ Kills in 
1639 (50, p. 195). His house, which he styled Emmaus, was the scene 
of the signing of the Treaty of Peace with the Indian Sachems in 
1642, and stood close to that stream which was named in his honor 
"Bronck's River"— a name that we now spell Bronx. 

Many Indians of the Mohican nation, Suwanoy (Sewanoe) tribe 
and Weekquaskeek local tribe made this Borough their home and 
hunting ground, dwelling on the shores of the Hudson, the Sound 
and the Harlem River. They have left various Indian names behind 
them, such as Aqueanounck (Aquahung), Quinnahoung, Kekeshick, 
Muscoota, Laaphawachking, Mosholu. Many titles date back to early 
purchases from Indian sachems. 

The earliest Dutch community settled was probably in 1654, at old 
Westchester Village. The English soon followed, some of the first 
titles being granted by Gov. Nicolls. Among the best known are 
Thomas Cornell, at Clason's Point ; John Throckmorton, at Throgg's 
Neck; and Thomas Pell and Ann Hutchinson, amid the wilds around 
Pelham Bay. Other early settlers include Daniel Turneur, near High 
[fridge ; John Archer, at Fordham Heights : Van Der Donck, at Van 
Cortlandt, and Jessup and Richardson, at Hunt's Point. 

The Revolution brought into prominence another noted family — the 
Morrises. Lewis Morris was a member of the Continental Congress 
and a signer of the Declaration of Independence ; Richard was a Sena- 
tor; Gouverneur a Representative in the Provincial Congress and later 
an envoy to France. Lewis Morris affixed his name to that famous 
document, although he knew that a British fleet was anchored close to 
his home in the lower Bronx. An attempt was once made to have 
Congress choose Morrisania as the capital of the United States instead 
of placing it on the Potomac. Many Revolutionary scenes were enacted 
in this borough, and a full quota of its residents went forth to serve in 
defence of their country's rights. The dreaded Neutral Ground 
extended from King's Bridge up to and beyond the Yonkers line. Pel- 
ham Bay Park saw the Battle of Pell's Point (Sec. VI), and West- 
chester Village may well boast of the Battle of Westchester Creek 
(Sec. V). Other sections could also tell of individual engagements with 
the King's forces. 

The early and middle portions of the nineteenth century brought 
great changes. Fruitful farm lands produced their abundant crops. 

176 



THE BRONX 

Then came wealthy business men, who located here their country 
estates and whose mansions are yet to be found in many nooks, despite 
the northward advance of the city. The nineteenth century brought 
with it also two poets of world-wide fame — Joseph Rodman Drake, 
whose tomb still stands at Hunt's Point, and Edgar Allan Poe, whose 
Fordham cottage is still a familiar landmark. 

The year 1874 saw the western portion of the borough annexed 
to New York City, and in 1895 the remainder was added. Bronx 
Borough to-day (1912), a large part of which was purchased in early 
days for "2 gunns, 2 kettles, 2 coats, 2 adzes, 2 shirts, i barrel of cider 
and 6 bitts of money," is a community of over 500,000 souls, ranking 
with such cities as Detroit, Milwaukee or Washington, or equivalent in 
population with the whole State of New Hampshire. In 1912-13 it was 
erected into the County of the Bronx by a State law following a 
referendum vote. 

Countless six-story apartments have sprung from suburban fields 
and meadows as if by the hand of magic. The borough's parks, over 
4,000 acres in extent, are its special pride, — the Zoological Park and 
the Botanical Gardens in particular being unrivalled throughout the 
world. 

Thus we have briefly reviewed the 30,000 acres of hill and plain that 
are rapidly merging into that wonderful city which is so proud to style 
itself "the Metropolis of America." 



177 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XXXIII. Key Map to the Bronx 
(Numbers Indicate Routes) 



C. K. 



178 



THE BRONX 



THE BRONX 

Bibliography. 

" History of Westchester County," Bolton. 

" History of Westchester County," Scharf. 

" History of Westchester County," Shonard. 

" History of Bronx Borough, New York City," Comfort. 

" History of Kingsbridge," Edsall. 

" History of Yonkers," Allison. 

"The Old Post Road," Hine. 

"Historic New York" (Paper on "The Neutral Ground"). 

"Battle of Pell's Point," Abbott. 

" The Spy," Cooper. 

*' Reminiscences of an Old Westchester Homestead," Pryer. 

" The Borough of the Bronx," Cook. 

" Story of the Borough of the Bronx of the City of New York," and 
"A Princess and Another" (Scene at Screven's Point, see 87, p. 203), 
both by Lieut. Stephen Jenkins. 

The * refers to Addenda, 1912, pp. 183, 198, 202, 204 and 215. 



179 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XXXIV. Routes 29, 29a, 29b 

l-roni KinRsbridge north the section including Yonkers was in Revolutionary 
• lays t. rnicd tlie Neutral Ground, the scene of numerous ravages by irregular 
liaiids known as Cozi'boys and Skintiers, who committed such lawless depreda- 
tionb thai many of the residents were forced into temporary exile, 



iba 




^ V Vi 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 29 

SECTION I.— KINGSBRIDGE TO VAN CORTLANDT PARK 

(Figures refer to Plates XXXIV and XXXVI) 

Take Broadzvay Subway to Two Hundred and Forty-second Street, 
passing on the right, at 225th Street, site of old Free Bridge (1759) 
(76, p. 169), and on the left, at 230th Street, old King's Bridge 
(.73, P- 168), and further west, the Tippett Mansion (i on Plate 
XXXIV; see bottom p. 185); at 230th Street, the 

2. Macomb Mansion, on the Bronx mainland, faces the Broad- 
way Bridge. In 1693 this was known as the public house " at the 
north end of the bridge," and in 1776 as Cox's Tavern. It was bought 
by Alexander Macomb in 1797, who built nearby in 1800 the first 
Macomb's Dam (see 25), and in 1848 was sold to the late J. H. God- 
win. Parts still show its great age. 

At Kingsbridge the old Post Roa^ from New York divided, the Albany Post 
Road (1669), now Albany Road, leading northward to Van Cortlandt, Vonkers 
and Albany, while the Boston Post Road (1672) led northeast over Williams- 
bridge through Eastchester and New Rochelle to Boston. The Kingsbridge 
Road extended southeast up Breakneck Hill to West Farms and Westchester, 
passing at the foot of the hill the old house still called Emmerich's Head- 
quarters, after the colonel of the Hessians who had their extensive camp on 
the premises. See 2 a, Plate XXXV^I. 

Enter Van Cortlandt Park and walk through 

3. The Dutch Garden, south of the mansion, surrounded by 
a moat. One of the stones of the old mill forms the base for 
the pedestal of a sun-dial. 

4. Van Cortlandt Mansion, now a museum in the care of the 
Colonial Dames, built in 1748 (see inscription on walls) by Fred- 
erick Van Cortlandt. See tablet on the southeast corner. Note 
the quaint key-stones over the windows, probably brought from 
Holland. Here were entertained Washington, Rochambeau, the 
Duke of Clarence (later King William the Fourth) and others. 
During the Revolution this structure was the headquarters for 
the Hessian Jaegers. In one of the rooms Captain Rowe, of the 
Pruicsbank Jaegers, expired in the arms of his bride-elect, hav- 
ing been mortally wounded in an engagement with the patriots 
in the Tippett Valley. Here Washington stayed over night in 
1781 previous to leaving for Yorktown, and again on November 
12, 1783, before crossing King's Bridge to enter New York. 

See guide-book, to be obtained from the custodian. 

181 



Route 29 HISTORICAL GUIDE Van Cortlandt 

5. The Rhinelander Sugar House Window is just northeast 
of the mansion (see inscription). It was presented by J. T. O. 
Rhinelander in 1903, and was formerly part of the old sugar 
house in Rose and Duane Street. (Excursion 1:46). This is flanked 
by two cannon from Fort Independence (see 34). 

6. The Statue of Major-General Josiah Porter is behind the 
Mansion; it was presented by the National Guard, State of New 
York, in 1902. 

10. The Parade Ground, military camping place, lies to the north. It is 
the site of Van der Donck's Planting Field (1653) where he located his boww- 
erie secured by purchase from the Indians and grant from Governor Kiett, and 
about 1650 built a house near the site of the first Van Cortlandt house (8). 
Later his lands were called Colendonck, or Donck's Colony. 

Go east, then south, on Path to 

7. The site of Van Cortlandt Saw and Grist Mills (1700) at the west end 
of the bridge over the dam. These mills were in use for over two hundred 
years; they were struck by lightning and burned in 1901, and the picturesque 
ruins were later removed; one of the millstones is still to be seen near the west 
side of the Mansion. 

8. The site of the original Van Cortlandt House (1700) and the Van Der 
Donck House (1650). Adrian Der Donck, the first white settler, came here 
about 1650, built his house and established his bouwerie (see 10). His vast 
estates were known as the Yonk-Herr's (Young Gentleman's) land, whence the 
name of Yonkers. 

9. The Berrian Burying-Ground, between the mansion and the 
lake. Further east was the negro burying ground, where the 
slaves of the early owners were interred. Across the lake may 
be seen the extensive golf links of Van Cortlandt Park. 

Van Cortlandt Lake was made in 1700 by throwing an em- 
bankment across Tippett's Brook, the Mosholu of the Indians. 

Follow the railway embankment to the north, cross the road and take 
rough path beyond over the track and to the top of 

11. Vault Hill and the Van Cortlandt Burial Vault. In 1776 
Augustus Van Cortlandt, then City Clerk, carried the records of 
New York City up here and hid them in this vault where they 
were preserved during the Revolution. In 1781 Washington 
built camp fires on this hill to deceive the British, while he was 
withdrawing his troops to Yorktown. About a mile northeast is 

12. Indian Field, on the Mile Square Road, Woodlawn Heights, 
which was the scene, August, 1778, of a battle between the British 
cavalry and a small party of Stockbridge Indians fighting on behalf 
of the patriots. At Two Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street and 
Mt. Vernon Avenue an im.pressive cairn of stones and a tablet have 
been erected, inscribed as follows: 

182 



Park THE BRONX 29 Route 

Upon this Field, August 31, 1778, Chief Nimham and Seventeen 

Stockbridge Indians, Allies of the Patriots, 

Gave their Lives for Liberty. 

Erected by Bronx Chapter, D. A. R., of Mount Vernon, N. Y. 

June 14th, 1906. 

. ^^^ S-— This may be reached with less walking by taking the Jerome Avenue 
trolley from One Hundred and Fifty-fifth Street and Central Bridge to Two 
Hundred and Thirty-third Street; go east to Mount Vernon Avenue and north 
to Two Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street. 

Follow the Colonial Lane north for a short distance to reach the old bridge 
where the fight between the Indians and the British began. 

N. B. — This tablet was removed by vandals, July 14, 1912. 

ADDENDA, 1912 
ROUTES 29a, 29b, 30 

*i (p. 184). Just south are the early church and school buildings 
of Mosholu. 

*2 (p. 185). This oak is in the Seton Hospital grounds. In private 
grounds north, facing the Hudson, is a quaint old cottage, once stand- 
ing on Canal Street. It was tioated through the early canal and brought 
in sections up the Hudson to its present site. 

*3 (p. 185). 24, a stone building, is now known as the Johnson 
residence ; it is on Nipinichsen Terrace, near the Parkway. 

In the wall of the Muschenheim house see the tablet, erected by 
Wm. C. Muschenheim in 1910 to commemorate Fort No. i. For full 
account of these forts see 191 1 Report of the x\merican Scenic and 
Historic Preservation Society. Near it stands the Hudson Monu- 
ment, erected 1909-1912, by the Henry Hudson Monument Committee of 
the Bronx Citizens' Hudson-Fulton Celebration Commission. The 
liuted column was designed by Walter Cook; the figure of Hudson by 
Karl Bitter, and the two bronze tablets by Henry M. Shrady. 

*4 (p. 187). This may be reached by the 138th St. trolley; walk 
up Gerard Ave. from 138th St. 

*5 (p. 189). See on the left, south of Trcmont Ave., the Lewis G. 
Morris Mansion, built about 1830; note the stone tower and arched 
portico. North of it stands the Messiah Home for Children, the gift 
of the late H. H. Rogers. 

*6 (p. 189). In 1909 a bronze bust of Robert Fulton on a pedestal 
of Conemara marble was placed above his tablet. In 1910 eleven more 
names were chosen by the Senate for places in the Hail of Fame. (For 
full account of the origin of and procedure for securing places in the 
Hall of Fame, and for a full list of the tablets, see 1908, 1911, I'Ji^ 
Reports of the American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society.) 

183 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 29a. 

SIDE TRIP A— TWO HUNDRED AND FORTY-SECOND 

STREET TO YONKERS. 

From the Subway station go north and take road on left running 

north {Newton Avenue, part of the old Post Road), 

passing on the left 

13. The 15th Milestone, recently reset by the City History 
Club. Note that this stone has the stonemason's name graven on 
its face. About 400 paces north is the *i (p. 183). 

14. Van Cortlandt's Miller's House, a white house built for 
the miller of the old estate. Further along, on the left, is 

15. The Hadley House, partly of wood unpainted and partly 
of stone covered with vines. It probably antedates the Van Cort- 
landt Mansion. It is said to have given shelter more than once 
to Washington, and to-day stands on a 60 acre farm. In the ad- 
joining woods many relics have been found, including old Eng- 
lish muskets, and an Indian skeleton in a sitting posture, holding 
a small child's skeleton in its arms. Tradition says that slaves 
were kept in the old stone room in the south wing of the house. 
Just above, north of Riverdale Lane, is the Samler House, the 
older portion dating back to the Revolution. 

Go east to Broadway and take car to Valentine Lane. Walk west to 
Hawthorne Avenue, passing remains of 

17. Washington's Chestnut, a gigantic tree over two centuries 
old. A tradition relates that Washington used this tree as a place 
of observation. 

18. The Lawrence House, at the corner of Hawthorne Avenue. 
Washington stopped here and this is probably the house which 
was given to Lawrence as a reward for his services as guide. 

Go east on Valentine Lane and south on Riverdale Avenue. 

16. The home of Clara Morris, gate over the Yonkers line. 
Go west on Two Hundred and Sixty-first Street and take H. R. R. R. 

train from Mt. St. Vincent. 

19. Font Hill, the actor Forrest's old home (named for a 
former owner, La Font), is a stone castle with six towers within 
the spacious grounds of Mt. St. Vincent Academy. 

Below Riverdale Station is 

20. The former home of Mark Twain, Sycamore Avenue and 
Two Hundred and Fifty-third Street, one block north of which 
is the Morosini Mansion, home of the late banker. It contains a fine 
collection of ancient armor. 

184 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 29b. 

SIDE TRIP B— WESTERN BRONX. 

From Two Hundred and Forty-second Street, go west on Sl^iiyten 
Duyvil Parkzvay to Dash's Lane on which see 

21. The Gardener's Cottage, near Two Hundred and Thirty- 
eighth Street and Greystone Avenue, built in 1766 by Frederick 
Van Cortlandt. A Jaeger camp was here during the Rcvohition. 



22. Upper Cortlandt's, or Van Cortlandt's on the Hill, to dis- 
tinguish it from the house on the meadow below; the Stone 
House was built in 1822 by Augustus Van Cortlandt and later 
owned by Waldo Hutchins. Further west, near Spuyten Duyvil 
Parkway, in private property at the end of Two Hundred and 
Thirty-seventh Street, is the 

23. Cowboy Oak where tradition says Cowboys were hanged 
during the Revolution. *2 (p. 183). 

24. The Berrian Farmhouse, at the point of Berrian's Neck, 
commanding a magnificent view of the Hudson. See Cold Spring 
across Spuyten Duyvil Creek (Excursion IV 193) . See also sites 
of Forts Nos. One, Two and Three. *3 (p. 183). 

No. One forms the foundation of W. C. Muschenheim's house, Spuyten Duyvil 
Hill, west of the junction of Sydney Street and Independence Avenue. 

In his residence are cannonballs taken from the bank around the house, 
and Indian shells from aboriginal pits discovered in 1909 under the lawn lu 
front of the house. 

No. Two, or Fort Swartwout; crown of hill, northeast of intersection of 
Sydney and Troy Streets. 

No. Three, brow of Spuyten Duyvil Hill, north of Sydney and east of Troy 
Street. 

Under Spuyten Duyvil Hill is the site of the Indian Village of Nipinkhscn, 
from which Indians came who attacked Hudson in 1609. 

Under the hill, west of Riverdale Avenue, is the Tippett Man- 
sion, the home of the family for which Tippett's Brook was 
named (at 230th Street; see i, Plate XXXIV). 

18S 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




©DAGRAM 
Section 2 Excursion IX 

BRONX 
Compiled for The City History Club 
OF New York by ChorlcsKondcl.CE 



Plate XXXV. Routes 30, 31, 32, 34a 



m 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 30. 

SECTION 11— CENTRAL BRIDGE TO UNIVERSITY 

HEIGHTS. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXXV and XXXVI). 

Take Sixth or Ninth Elevated Road to One Hundred and Fifty-Hfth 

Street and Jerome Avenue car across Central Bridge and 

north on Jerome Avenue, at first following 

the line of the old Macomb's Dam Road. 

25. Central Bridge is practically on the site of the old Macomb's Dam 
Bridge, near which was the old Macomb Dam, making a pond out of the 
Harlem to supply the Macomb Mill at Kingsbridge. The dam was broken 
down by a delegation of citizens about 1840 and, being declared a public nui- 
sance, was finally abandoned. 

A mile to the southeast, reached by walking east on One Hundred 
and Sixty-tirst Street and soiitJi on Gerard Avenue is 

26. The Francis Mansion, at One Hundred and Forty-sixth 
Street and Gerard Avenue, built about 1830 by Captain Francis, in- 
ventor of the metallic life-saving boats. He was offered knight- 
hood by Queen Victoria and other honors by Germany, and finally 
received in his own country the "thanks of Congress." The old Dutcli 
oven is still in the basement. *4 (p. 183). 

Near One Hundred and Sixty-sixth Street the car passes on the 
right the site of the 

27. Cromwell Farmhouse, built 150 years ago, lying at the head 
of Cromwell's Creek, where the wild geese gathered in such flocks at 
night that sleep was almost impossible. 

On the high ground to the west is the 27a, Anderson Mansion, 
almost on the site of the early hom.e of Daniel Turncur, tlie 
original patentee of Devoe's Point (about 1675.) This was the 
ancient Nuasin of the Indians. Jerome Avenue skirts the old Woolf 
Farm,- the first owner of which came over with the Hessian troops 
during the Revolution and settled on Cromwell's Creek. 

Leave car at 

Featherbed Lane, so called because it was extremely rough 
and stony or from the story that the Americans, surprised by the 
British, were rescued by the ingenuity of the farmers' wives, who 
spread feather beds on the lane, thus enabling them to escape 
without being heard. 

Walk west tn Macomb's road, one of the oldest roads in this section, 

to the 
187 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




N. Y. University THE BRONX 30 Route 

28. Townsend Poole Cottage. Note the date of erection, 1782, 
in iron figures on the stone wall, reading backwards. In this 
cottage were lodged the Esquimaux brought by Lieutenant Peary 
from the far north. 

IValk along Featherbed Lane west to Marcher (Shakespeare) Avenut^, 
then down to Jcssup Place to the 

29. DeVoe Cottage, built in 1804, one of the landmarks of the 
region. The family is descended from the Huguenot family of 
Devaux. 

Walk down Jessup Place to Boscohel Avenue, then north to Wash- 
ington Bridge, from the middle of which may be obtained fine 
panoramic views north and south. Take Aqueduct Avenue car 
to University Avenue. ^s (p. 183). 

30. New York University, removed here from Washington 
Square in 1894 (Excursion II, Section III). 

The Hall of Fame, to honor great Americans, was dedicated 
on Memorial Day, 1901, when the first 29 tablets were unveiled. 
II more were unveiled in 1907. Note the view of the Dyckman 
and Nagel farms in Inwood Valley and of the heights of Fort 
Washington. There is a small historical collection in the Li- 
brary. *6 (p. 183). 

Tablet to mark site of Fort No. Eight, erected in 1906 on the 
Chemistry Building by the Sons of the Revolution. The Schwab 
mansion is within the site of the fort. (Refer to monograph on 
"Fort No. Eight" by Prof. Schwab of Yale.) At the old stone 
Archer House, just below, Colonel De Lancey of the Loyalist 
" De Lancey Horse," had his headquarters, while the nearby Fort 
No. Eight was occupied by the Americans.! 

The site of Fort No. Seven (no trace) is at Sedgwick Ave. and Fordham 
Road. 

On the campus is a monument to the Founders of N. Y. Uni- 
versity (built of material from the old building). 

tA stone inscribed "Fort Number Eight, 1776-1783," stands on the 
prolongation of "Battery Hill," 80 yards S.W. of the Hall of Chem- 
istry. This marks the exact location. 



180 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 30a 

SIDE TRIP A.— TO JEROME PARK RESERVOIR 

(Figures refer to Plate XXXVI) 

From N. Y. University take Aqueduct Avenue trolley north to Kings- 
bridge Road, passing 

31. The Webb Shipbuilder's Home and Academy, fronting on 
Sedgwick Avenue. In front of it is a figurehead from an old bark. To 
the north rises the Roman Catholic Orphan Asylum, occupying the 
site of Fort No, Five. Fort No. Six was on the east side of Aqueduct 
Avenue, between 190th and I92d Streets. 

32. Fordham Manor Dutch Reformed Church, Kingsbridge 
Road and Aqueduct Avenue, the successor to the structure of 
1706. Virginia Poe, wife of the poet, was first buried here. The 
Poe Cottage, where Edgar Allan Poe and his wife lived, stands 
on the old Kingsbridge Road, one-half mile east (see 69). The 
large buildings to the southwest are those of the Roman Catho- 
lic Orphan Asylum, 

Go north on Claflin Terrace along the west side of Jerome Park 
Reservoir, 300 acres in extent, occupying the site of the 
Jerome Park Race Track. The reservoir has obliterated 
the sites of the Betts and Bathgate Houses. 

Z?>. Fort No. Four (lately restored and marked by a flag-pole), 
one of the chain of forts built by the Americans in 1776 to command 
the valley below, 

.,-,'^'"F's Redoubt bet. 33 and Kingsbridge Road. 34. Fort Independence (1776) 
I lit- site of this fort is now occupied by the residence of Wm. O Giles on Giles 
IMace. near Fort Independence Street. In 1772 General Richard Montgomery 
• Iwelt in this section, calling it his King's Bridge Farm. On his land stood until 
recently the ruins of a Revolutionary powder magazine known as Washington's 
I'owder House. On the edge of the hill is the 

35- M0\T(;0MI-:RY COTTAGK. partly destroyed 1909, of Dutch architecture, 
at Heath Aveniie and hort Independence Street. Across the old Boston Post 
Road was the Farm of Dominie Tctard. Chaplain to General Montgomery and 
Irench Interpreter to General Schuyler, his house dating from 1776. 

Take Sedgwick Avenue trolley north to Sulnvay or south to Third 
Avenue Elevated, or continue on Route 30b. 



190 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 30b. 

SIDE TRIP B— WILLIAMSBRIDGE AND WAKEFIELD. 

(Figures refer to Plate XXXVI and XXXVII). 

Take Jerome Avenue trolley to Van Cortlandt Avenue and zvalk east 
to Woodlawn Road, passing 

36. The Isaac Varian Homestead, erected in 1776, the old 
wing (now destroyed) dating from 1770. An encounter between 
the British and Americans occurred here in 1776, the Continentals 
driving their foes out of this house and along the Boston Post 
Road to Fort Independence, (see old graveyard in rear). 
Go south on Woodlawn Road to Bainhridge Avenue. 
2>7. The Church of 'the Holy Nativity, built into the walls of 
which are three old tombstones, two of the Bussing family dated 
1751 and one of the Valentine family. 

At Webster Avenue take White Plains Avenue trolley, 
and see in passing 

38. The Hermitage, a noted French restaurant. This locality 
is the scene of Hopkinson's Smith's "A Day at Laguerre's " 
and ''Other Days." 

Continue on trolley north on White Plains Road. Near Williams- 
bridge Square, see on the west 

39. A Revolutionary House, painted red, its sides full of holes 
made by British bullets. 

Opposite the Catholic church is the site of the old Williams House, 
the home of the family after which Williamsbridge is named. 

40. The Hustace House, one of the oldest landmarks of the 
region, Two Hundred and Twenty-first Street, facing an old white 
house on a disused lane. 

41. The Havens House, northeast corner of Two Hundred and 
Twenty-second Street, very old and containing many relics, including 
the mahogany bedstead on which Commodore Perry died. It is said 
that the piano now in Washington's headquarters at Newburgh was 
the property of Mrs. Havens while she was in the family of 
Governor Clinton, by whom she was adopted. On the corner 
of Two Hundred and Twenty-eighth Street stood the shingled house, 
torn down in 1885, used for a time by Washington as headquarters.* 

igi 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




DDAOIRAM 
Sectiom 2-B ExcuRsion IX 

BRO 
Compiled for The City History Club 
ofNdwYork byChoriesKandel.CE 



Plate XXXVII. Routes 30b. 34a 



192 



Woodlawn THE BRONX 30b Route 

42. Site of Pcnfield Homestead, once standing at Two Hun- 
dred and Forty-second Street, east of White Plains Road, over 
a century old. See quaint inscriptions on the old-fashioned win- 
dows, hand wrought nails and timbers and Dutch bricks testify 
to the age of the house. Go west through 241st St. to Webster Ave. 

At Demilt Avenue once stood the Thirteen Trees planted in early days by a 
relative of the Paulding who helped to capture Andre. They have all yielded 
to the onward march of progress, the last one, a black walnut, measuring 3 
feet 8 inches at the butt, having been cut down a few years ago. 

Return to Baychester Avenue and go west to Webster Avenue, pass- 
ing, at Baychester and Matilda Avenues, 

43. The former home of Adelina Patti, where she spent part 
of her girlhood. 

44. Washington's Gun House, on the old Hyatt Farm, west of 
Webster Avenue and just below the car barns. Here Washington 
is said to have stored his guns — hence the name of the adjoin- 
ing settlement, Washingtonville.f 

Take Webster Avenue trolley south, passing 

Woodlawn Cemetery. Among the 66,000 interments are those of 

Admiral Farragut and Lieutenant De Long. The Receiving Vault 

occupies the site of the Valentine Homestead. In the southeast corner 

of the cemetery is an American redoubt thrown up by American troops 

under General Heath (45 L 

*This was while Washington was retreating toward White Plains. He left 
the cannon here in order to make more rapid progress and thus be able to 
make a better stand against Howe (see 100). The house may best be reached 
via Harlem Station car to terminus, thence on McLean Avenue car. 

•|-4ia. The Chateauneuf Residence on the south side of Two Hun- 
dred and Thirty-first Street, west of White Plains Road, built about 
1853, was the refuge of the widow and children of the Marquis de 
Chateauneuf, formerly Governor of Touraine, who fled from France 
to escape espionage. 



193 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 





<</ 



enAGRAM 
Section 3 Excursion IX 

BRONX 
Compiled for TheCityHistoryClub 
OF New York by Charles Kandd.CE 



Plate XXXVIII. Ruutes 31, 33, 34a 



194 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 31. 

SECTION III— HARLEM RIVER TO HUNT'S POINT. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXXV and XXXVIII). 

'At One Hundred and Twenty-ninth Street, foot of the Third Avenue 
Elevated Road, take Third Avenue trolley, passing at 
Third Avenue and One Hundred and Thirty- 
sixth Street 

46. The old Mott Mansion, formerly the home of the founders 
of Mott Haven. It is now used as two tenements. 

47. The Mott Memorial Dutch Reformed Church, at Third 
Avenue and One Hundred and Forty-sixth Street, erected by Jordan L. 
Mott about i849-*7 (p- 198). 

Go east to St. Ann's Avenue and south to 

48. St. Ann's Episcopal Church, at St. Ann's Avenue and One 
Hundred and Fortieth Street, contains a memorial window and 
several tablets in memory of the Morris family. The church was 
a gift from Gouverneur Morris. The vaults in the grounds and 
below the church contain the remains of many distinguished 
members of the family, including Mrs. Morris, a lineal descend- 
ant of Pocahontas. *8 (p. 198). 

Go south to One Hundred and Thirty-third Street and take Southern 
Boulevard trolley east. 

49. Site of Gouverneur Morris Mansion (line of One Hundred and Thirtieth 
Street and Cypress Avepue), lately destroyed, the home of the Morris faniilv 
of Morrisania, where Lafayette and other notable persons were entertained. 
It was filled with relics, including Morris' wooden leg. Gouverneur Morris, 
the statesman, soldier and diplomat, owned 1920 acres of Bronx real estate. 
Indian pits have been discovered under the lawn north of the house. Close 
by is the site of the home of Lewis Morris, a signer of the Declaration of In- 
dependence, 

Just west, near the beginning of Bronx Kills, is 

50. The site of the home of Jonas Bronck, the first settler in the Bronx, 
1639 (see Historical Sketch). The house had a tiled roof and Bronck "used 
real silver on his table, had a table cloth and napkins, and possessed as many 
as six linen shirts." At this house, which was like a miniature fort, the 
treaty was signed by the Dutch with the Weckquaeskeek sachems, Ranaqua 
and Tackamuck, 1642. 

In the Morris High School, at One Hundred and Sixty-sixth 
Street and Boston Avenue, are two mural paintings by Edward 
Willard (presented by the Municipal Art Society in 1907) rep- 
resenting (i) the making of the Treaty of Peace between the 
Dutch and Indians in 1642 at the house of Jonas Bronck and (2) 
Gouverneur Morris before the Convention framing the National 
Constitution. 



Route 31 HISTORICAL GUIDE Hunt's 

Passing Port Morris, the car goes near Leggett Avenue, formerly Leggett's 
Lane, along which the British marched, passing a deep cave near the Long- 
wood Club House where the Americans had, while in flight, hidden the bodies 
of some of their companions. On the right is the site of the Whitlock or 
Casanova Mansion (1859), in its day one of the most magnificent houses in 
America. The door knobs were of solid gold and the house had secret rooms 
and underground passages. Just beyond, the Boulevard crosses Lafayette 
Lane. Under the trees to the right was an old structure called the " Kissing 
Bridge." 
Leave the car at Hunt's Point Avenue and take Hunt's Point Avenue 

trolley (or take Hunt's Point car from near Intervale Avenue 
Station of the Subivay), passing on the right 

51. The site of the Locusts, of Revolutionary days, the home of the tutor 
of tiie Faile family, who formerly taught in the family of Sir Walter Scott. 
Beyond is , . , r , , ,- - 

52. The site of Woodside, built in 1832, the residence of the late L. L.. 
Faile (now occupied by the American Bank Note Co.) 

Beyond is the east end of Lafayette Avenue, formerly the narrow Lafayette 
Lane. In 1824 the French general traveled from Boston to New York via 
Fox Corners, presumably to stay at one of the Leggett houses on Hunt's Point. 
George Fox was one of the marshals of a delegation of New York citizens to 
meet and escort him. The lane was thus named in his honor. Lafayette is 
said to have " paused in silent meditation at the grave of Joseph Rodman 
Drake.'* On the south side of Lafayette Avenue stands 

53. The Corpus Christi Monastery. Adjoining is the extensive 
55. Sevilla Home for Children. Across Hunt's Point Avenue is 

54. Sunnyside, one of the finest residences in the Bronx, the 
former home of Peter Hoe. Note the view of Manhattan, show- 
ing St. Panick's Cathedral, the Cathedral of St. John the Divine, 
St. Luke's Hospital, Columbia Library and Grant's Tomb. A 
short distance below Cherry Lane branches off, leading to the 
Leggett P jck near the foundations of an old Leggett house. 
Further along, nearer the Sound, is the site of Blythe, formerly 
the residence of Francis J. Baretto, after whom Baretto's Point 
was named. It was of Revolutionary date and when its inside 
shutters were closed, it was a miniature fortress. 



Down in the field to the right are the sites of the Jessup and Ricliardson 
Houses, near the ancient spring. In 1660, Governor Nicolls granted 1,000 acres 
in this region to Edward Jessup and John Richardson, who had bought it 
from the Indians. Among their descendants were the Hunts, after whom the 
point is named, and they were related to the early Leggetts. 

In the field opposite, on the long slope below the Dickey Mansion, see the site 
of the 

Leggett burying-ground, whence ten bodies of early settlers were removed, 
one being that of Mayor Leggett of Westchester. 

On the left, beyond the curve in the road, is the 

56. Joseph Rodman Drake Park, containing the grave of Joseph 
Rodman Drake, author of " The Culprit Fay," " Bronx " and 
"Ode to the American Flag." The stone is "a modest shaft, 
half hidden by the tangle of bushes and wild flowers that border the 
road, marking the grave of a poet who knew and loved our own 

196 



Point THE BRONX 31 Route 

neighborhood in the early days when all was country-like and 
the city far away." The inscription reads : 

Sacred to the Memory of 

Joseph Rodman Drake, M. D., 

who died Sept. 21st, 1820. 

"None knew him but to love him; 

None named him but to praise." 

The burying-ground has been included in the new Joseph Rod- 
man Drake Park. See the ancient gravestones of the earliest 
members of the Hunt family. Among the relics of the old Hunt 
Inn is a pane of glass from one of the windows on which is 
written with a diamond the names of Drake and Nancy Leggett, 
joined at the end with a bracket and the single word " Love." 
The poet was a lineal descendant of the colonial Drakes, settlers 
of Eastchester. 

Across the road is the 

Graveyard of the slaves of early residents, among them being 
"Bill," the colored pilot of the Hussar (see 83). Further down on 
the left across the bridge are 

57. Lord Howe's Intrenchments among a group of trees. In 
the gravel pit on the east side have been found prehistoric stone im- 
plements. Close by is an old cave, declared to have been a Revolu- 
tionary powder house. At the extreme end of the Point ! ^ the 

58. Hunt Mansion, dating back to 1688, and built in four sec- 
tions as the residents gradually added to their wealth, the most 
ancient house on the estate which for two centuries has been 
known as Hunt's Point. Among the welcome guests here were 
Drake and Halleck. 

Return by new Hunt's Point Avenue to Southern Boulevard, along 
which, near Fox Square, see 

59. Foxhurst Mansion, Westchester Ave. and 167th St., built in 1848 
by the late W. W. Fox, one of original Croton Aqueduct Com- 
missioners. Back of this stood the old Hunt Inn, erected in 1660, a 
noted tavern, the starting place of countless fox hunts and the ren- 
dezvous of the Red Coat officers. 

When burned in 1892, many interesting relics were found in 
its walls. 



197 



Route 31 HISTORICAL GUIDE Ambleside 

60. Ambleside, opposite 59, formerly the residence of the Simpson 
family, and the site of Brightside, the country seat of the late Colonel 
R. M. Hoe, inventor of the rotary printing press. Ambleside is on 
Simpson Street, below Westchester Avenue; Brightside was on the 
Southern Boulevard east of V/estchester Avenue. 

Return by Subway from Simpson Street Station. 



ADDENDA, 1912 
ROUTE 31 

*7 (p- 195)- See within tablet to Jordan L. Mott, "Founder of the 
village of Mott Haven; born at Hempstead, L. I., A.D. 1798; died in 
New York City, A.D. 1868," etc., erected by the congregation. 

*8 (p. 195). St. Ann's was erected in 1840 by Gouverneur Morris 
in memory of his mother, Ann Carey Randolph of Roanoke, Va. 
Gouverneur Morris lies buried here in one of the family vaults. 

*9 (p. 197). The stone portion bears marks of the shells of Lord 
Howe's fleet. 



19B 




St. Paul's Church, Eastchester 

PoE Cottage, Fordham 
Photographed by Randall Comfort 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 32. 

SECTION IV.— WESTERN MORRISANIA, FORDHAM AND 

BRONX PARK. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXXV, XXXVI and XXXIX). 

Take Third Avenue Elevated Road to One Hundred and Sixty-sixth 

Street, or Subway to One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street 

and Third Avenue Elevated Road to One Hundred 

Sixty-sixth Street. Go west on One Hundred 

and Sixty-seventh Street. 

61. Old Stone Gate House, below One Hundred and Sixty- 
seventh Street, west of Third Avenue. This is the oldest build- 
ing in Morrisania and the only one standing that was there be- 
fore the village was formed in 1848. *io (p 202). 

62. Wm. H. Morris Mansion, near Findlay Avenue, built in 
1816, near the site of an older house erected in 1795 by James 
Morris. 

It is said that Frances Hodgson Burnett was married here. Jefferson 
Davis was a visitor and used to wander in the woods nearby. Just 
west is the site of the Morris Panuhousc, dating from 1792, a (|uaint 
stone structure.*! r (]>. 202). 

64. The Zborowski Mansion, the present headquarters of the 

Bronx Park Department, a solid stone building in Claremont 

Park. It was built in 1859, and is evidently on the site of an 

older building dating about 1676. 

Beyond is the famous Black Swamp, where cattle have been lost since the 
time of the Indians, and which for years defied the efforts of all contractors 
to fill lip. (63, Plate XXWr.) 

Continue north on Webster Avenue, transfer east on Tremont Av- 
enue, passing near the site of the Bathgate Homestead, 

and north on Third Avenue Trolley. 

At One Hundred and Seventy-sixth street is the site of the Bathgate Avenue 
House, a very old structure, recently destroyed. 

65. The Jacob Lorillard House, in the grounds of the Home 
for Incurables at One Hundred and Eighty-second Street, now 
the home of the Medical Superintendent. Here-Poe once re- 
cited '' The Raven." Just below, at Oak Tree Place, was the 
celebrated oak tree where met the boundaries of the ancient 
manors of Morrisania, Fordham and the Jessup-Richardson Patent. 
Leave trolley at Fordham Road and walk east to Washington Avenue. 

66. Powell Farm House, Fordham's oldest house, said to be 
haunted. 

199 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XXXIX. Routes 32, 34a 



200 



Fordham THE BRONX 32 Route 

67. Stenton Residence, scene of the recent murder (1906), 
having secret rooms. In the rear stood an old barn, recently 
burned, said to have sheltered Washington's horses during the 
Revolution. 

66 is above, 67 below 189th St., east side of Washington Ave. 
Walk west to Fordham Square. 

68. Nolan's Hotel, where Washington is said to have stopped 
when he stabled his horses in the Stenton barn. 

Walk west up the hill along the Kingsbridge Road to the 

69. Poe Cottage, where Edgar Allan Poe lived (1846-49) and 
wrote many of his poems, including "Annabel Lee," " Ulalume " 
and " Eureka." Here Virginia, his invalid wife, died and was 
buried from the Fordham Manor Dutch Reformed Church (32). 
In Poe Park, directly opposite the cottage, is a bust of Poe 
with an inscription, erected by the Bronx Society of Arts and 
Sciences on the centenary of his birth, January 19, 1909. 

In the Briggs House (near 69), lived an old lady who sup- 
plied Poe with the necessities of life during his deepest poverty. 

70. Valentine Farmhouse, further west on Fordham road, near 
Concourse, remodeled into a modern residence. 

Take trolley to Fordham Square, then northbound car, passing on the 

right 

71. The grounds of Fordham University, or St. John's College 
(founded 1841), where was once Rose Hill Manor on which 
stands the Rose Hill Manor House; formerly here stood the Rose 
Hill Manor Farmhouse, 1693. Here was born Andrew Corsa, the 
last of the famous Westchester guides to Washington and Rocham- 
beau. 

Leave the trolley at Bronx Park Station, One Hundred and Ninety- 
eighth Street, and visit the 

72. Botanical Museum; open 9-5, see Appendix D. 

73. Horticultural Hall. 

74. Hemlock Grove (Forest Congress). 

75. The Indian Well (Bath or Basin). 

76. Lorillard Fall. 

77. Lorillard Mansion Museum; open 11 a.m. -3 p.m. (free), under 
the auspices of the Bronx Society of Arts and Sciences; histori- 
cal relics, photographs and objects of natural History, see Appen^ 
dix D. 

2QX 



Route 32 HISTORICAL GUIDE Bronx Park 

7S. Old Fashioned Flower Garden (Pierre Lorillard's famous 
"Acre of Roses," used to impart aroma to his snuff). 

79. The Lorillard Snuff Mill. 

80. Zoological Gardens; open 9-5, see Appendix D. 

81. The Rocking Stone, near the restaurant. 

Return via Subway from One Hundred and Eightieth Street Station. 

Bronx Park may be reached direct as follows : The Botanical Garden 
and Lorillard Mansion Museum via Third Avenue Elevated to 198th 
Street; Zoological Park via West Farms (Lenox Avenue) Subway 
Express to terminal ; or by Third Ave. Elevated or trolley to Fordham 
Road; thence by Bronx Park trolley. 

From upper Manhattan take trolley from 207th Street (Broadway) 
Subway Station. 

ADDENDA, 1912 
ROUTE 32 

*io (p. 199). From here wal|c west through 167th Street to Webster 
Avenue ; on the hill to the west is Wm. H. Morris Mansion. 

*ii (p. 199). The marble Heinrich Heine Lorelei Monument and 
Fountain stands six blocks south, at i6ist Street and Mott Avenue 
(entrance to the Grand Boulevard and Concourse). It was presented 
by the German-American Societies of New York in 1900 (62a on 
Plate XXXV). 

LORILLARD MANSION MUSEUM 
(See also p. 400) 

Among the historic relics are the following: hand-made laths, 
shingles, nails and odd-shaped bricks from old Bronx dwellings; old 
maps and rare prints; an army saddle, swords and Confederate money 
of Civil War days ; a piano in six stages of evolution ; tiles, mosaics, 
plates, bas-reliefs, busts and sculptures ; and a Chinese puzzle of carved 
ivory presented to Poe while in his Fordham cottage. 



202 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 33. 

SECTION V— THROGG'S NECK. 
(Figures refer to Plates XXXVIII and XL). 

Party of 15 adults may secure pass in advance from Commandant, 
Ft. Schuyler, to go on Government boat Tuesdays, Thursdays or 
Saturdays, 

Take Government boat for Fort Schuyler, passing en route 

82. Port Morris, where the Great Eastern anchored after her 
first trip to New York. Close by the 

83. British Frigate-of-war Hussar sank (Nov. 23, 1780), reported laden 
with a mass of British gold and American prisoners. Numerous attempts 
have been made to recover the treasure, but in vain. 

Copper rivets of the American prisoners' manacles, projectiles and parts of 
the ship's woodwork have been found (56). 

84. North and South Brothers Islands, the former containing 
the City Isolation Hospital. A few feet off this shore, on June 15, 
1904, sank the ill-fated General Slocum. 

58. Hunt's Point, where can be seen the old Hunt Mansion 
(1688). On this neck lies buried Joseph Rodman Drake (56). 

85. Bronx River. During the Revolution the British fleet re- 
ceived orders " to proceed up the Bronx and attack the Yankees 
in hiding above!" An English officer reported^ *' We have 
crossed the Bronx without the loss of a single man!" 

86. Clason's Point, where Thos. Cornell settled in 1643. 

An ancient stone farmhouse, formerly standing close to the shore was shelled 
by Lord Howe's fleet as the ships passed enroute to Throgg's Neck, October, 
1776. 

Some of the stones have found their way into the structure 
of the Clason's Point Inn, part of which is the house con- 
structed by Cornell in 1643 and burned by the Indians the same 
year. 

87. Screven's Point (mouth of Westchester Creek), where 
may be seen the Wilkins Farmhouse. Here the Sewanoe Indians had 
a fortified castle, whence the name "Castle Hill." At this point Adrian 
Block saw Indians and their wigwams on his voyage of discovery 
(1614). Within the Wilkins Farmhouse several Loyalist clergymen, 
including Rev. Isaac Wilkins, rector of St. Peter's, and Right Rev. 
Samuel Seabury, the Bishop, were hidden in a secret chamber, their 
food being lowered to them through a trap door. 



203 



Route 33 HISTORICAL GUIDE Ft. Schuyler 

88. Zerega's or Ferris Point, called "Grove Siah's " by its 
colonial owner, Josiah Hunt, whose father, Thomas Hunt, 
received a patent for it from Governor Nicolls. On this point 
stands the Ferris Mansion built 1687, said to be the oldest house 
in the Bronx. 

.89. Throgg's Point, styled in old records " Frog's Point," at 
the extremity of which stands Fort Schuyler, where the boat 
lands. The fort was established in 1833- Throgg is an abbrevia- 
tion of Throckmorton, the name of a colonist who settled here 
in 1642, obtaining his "land brief" from the Dutch. One of his 
companions was Roger Williams. 

ADDENDA, 1912 

ROUTE 33 

By Trolley 

Take Westchester Avenue and Clason's Point trolleys, passing en route 
on the right the colonial Ludlow Mansion on the "Black Rock" 
estate (so designated in the Patent of 1667 and still so called). On 
the right, nearer the Point, is the Clason's Point Military Academy; 
the square stone chateau was erected by Dominick Lynch in the early 
part of the nineteenth century; here was celebrated the first Mass in 
Westchester County. On the right, at the end of the Pomt, is the old 
Monnot Mansion. Nearer the trolley is 86, Clason's Point Inn, with 
the inscription, "In the year 1643 Thomas Cornell bought this point 
from the Indians. Part of this building is the original house con- 
structed by him." 1 

87. Screven's Point may be reached direct by walking down Castle 
Hill Avenue from Westchester Avenue 

88. At the end of Zerega's Point stands Island Hall, built 1823, 
the home of the Zerega family for five generations. Remains of the 
old ferry to Whitestone, L. I., are visible at the tip of the Point. 



204 



THE BRONX 
ROUTE 33a. 
SIDE TRIP TO WESTCHESTER VILLAGE. 
(Figures refer to Plate XL). 
This involves a walk or drive of five miles unless points 92-95 are 
omitted, in which case two miles may be saved by taking the 
trolley from the junction of Fort Schuyler Road and Eastern Boule- 
vard direct to 96, 

Follow the Throgg's Neck or Fort Schuyler Road to the Eastern 
Boulevard, passing 
On the left the extensive Havemeyer estate, where the British, un- 
der Howe, landed for their attack on Westchester, October 12, 1776. 

90. "Hammond Castle," under the great trees near Penny field 
Road, erected in 1800 by Abijah Hammond and recently re- 
modeled. Beyond the fence is 

91. The Robert Homestead, former home of the founder 
of Robert College, Constantinople. Across the lane is the Van 
Schaick Mansion, in the grounds of which is a cedar of Le- 
banon, declared to be the finest specimen of its kind in the United 
States. It was brought to America by Philip Livingston. 

To the west is the country home of the late Collis P. Huntington. 
Take trolley to Westchester (omitting g2-gs) or follow the Eastern 
Boulevard to the Middletown Road, passing 

92. Ferris Mansion, in the Westchester Country Club grounds, 
used as Lord Howe's headquarters after the landing at Throgg's 
Neck, October, 1776. Marks on the staircase are said to have been 
made by the hoof of one of the officer's horses. The house was saved 
from destruction by the British fleet through the heroism of the mis- 
tress who calmly walked up and down the veranda. 

To the west is the original 

93. Ferris House, owned for a time by the early settlers of 
that name. 

Go west to Westchester Avenue, turn north a short distance and see 

94. The Spy Oak, said to be the largest of its kind east of the 
Rockies. A British spy is supposed to have been hanged from it 
during the Revolution and there is much legendary lore connected 
with the old forest monarch. 

95. The Paul House, just north, is one of the oldest land- 
marks of the region. 



'05 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XL. Routes ss, 33a 



206 



Westchester THE BRONX 33a Route 

Return to Pelham Road and cross the 

96. Westchester Creek Causeway, where, on October 12th, 
1776, was fought an important battle between the Americans under 
Heath and the British under Howe. The patriots ripped up the plank- 
ing of the old causeway just before the enemy reached the spot, and 
greeted their approach with a volley, repulsing them. Two days later 
the English brought up their cannon and began a fortification where 
the Westchester Presbyterian Church now stands, but withdrew their 
troops and guns a few days later. Howe then sought to join with 
the Hessians near New Rochelle, a feat accomplished only after a 
desperate struggle with Glover at Pelham's Neck. (See Section VI 
and "The Battle of Pelham Neck:" Abbott.) 

Westchester Village was called by the Dutch Oost-Dorp and 
the whole region was known as Vredeland, or Land of Peace. The 
village is the oldest in the county, having been first settled by the 
Puritans in 1650. The site was purchased from the Indians in 1654 
by Thomas Pell, and was described as " all that tract of land called 
Westchester." 

97. Bowne Store, west of the causeway — the old village store. 

98. St. Peter's Church, on Westchester Avenue, fourth build- 
ing on this site, the first having been erected in 1700. The chime 
of bells is said to have been presented to the church in the time 
of Queen Anne. The churchyard contains stones dating back to 
1713. Beyond the Sunday School building is the site of a Quaker 
Meeting House, while another stood just west. Both were 
destroyed by fire, it is said, on the same night. Near by flows 
the Indian Brook, on the banks of which the celebrated George 
Fox is said to have addressed' the first Quaker meeting held in 
America (1672). To the west is 

99. St. Peter's Rectory (opposite Glebe Avenue) standing on 
land forming part of the "Ancient Glebe," given by the town in 
1703. 

Return by trolley to the Third Avenue Elevated or Subway. 
N. B. If the water trip to Fort Schuyler is omitted, take West- 
chester Avenue trolley from One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street Sta- 
tion of the Third Avenue Elevated Railroad, or the Subway 
Station at One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street and Third Avenue, 
and reverse the order of points. 

The new Throgg's Neck trolley from West Farms will make it possible 
to cover this route comfortably. 

207 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XLI. Route 34. 
208 



a K, 



THE BRONX 

ROUTE 34. 

SECTION VI.— CITY ISLAND AND PELHAM BAY PARK. 
(Figures refer to Plate XLI). 

(Latter part of trip recommended as a carriage or bicycle trip, as it 
involves between 4 and 5 miles walking. Pelham Bay Park may be 
reached by new extension of Westchester Ave. trolley. 
At One Hundred and Twenty-ninth Street station of the Third Av- 
enue Elevated take Harlem River Branch of the New Haven 
R. R. to Bartow (trains leave 15 minutes before every hour). 
At Bartozv take horse car for City Island, passing 
100. Glover's Rock. Read the tablet — (erected by the Mt. Ver- 
non Chapter of the D. A. R. in 1901), describing the Battle of Pell's 
Point (Oct. 18, 1776), which began near this rock, when 550 men 
under Colonel Glover detained Howe long enough for Washington 
to reach White Plains in safety. Cannon-balls were found here when 
the railroad track was being constructed, and a distinctly marked 
Indian pot-hole was discovered near Bartow Station. 

loi. Site of Indian burying- ground, where Indian remains have 
been found. There were two Indian villages on this neck, one near 
the Eastern Boulevard and one on the very extremity of Pelham 
(Rodman's) Neck. Before crossing the bridge see the 

102. Marshall Mansion, or 'Colonial Inn. While crossing the 
new bridge, see just north of the present structure the approaches 
of the*i2 (p. 215). 

103. Old City Island Bridge, originally spanning the Harlem 
at Harlem Village, some of the timbers having been taken from the 
old frigate man-of-war " North Carolina." Previous to its erection 
.here, City Island was reached by ferry. 

City Island, " the Pearl of the Sound," or " Gem of the Ocean," 
received its present name because a city was planned here to outstrip 
New York. It is said that the oyster culture started here. Note the 
rural appearance of streets and houses. 

From the end of the car line, walk on to the end of the island, pass- 
ing on the left the 

104. Horton Homestead, the oldest house on the island. Most 
of City Island was once comprised in the Horton Farm. Close 
by is the Belden Mansion, with extensive grounds, at Belden's 
Point. To the shipyard here some of America's Cup Defenders 
are sent to be broken up into scrap-iron. 

209 



Route 34 HISTORICAL GUIDE City Island 

From the dock see about one mile south 

105. Stepping Stones Light, so called from its location on one 
of the "Devil's Stepping Stones," an irregular line of rocks jutting 
out into the Sound. According to an old legend the Evil One made 
his retreat over these stones from Westchester County to Long Island 
to escape the vengeance of his Indian foes. Heaping up all the stones 
he could find in Long Island at Cold Spring, he hurled them at his 
enemies in Westchester, thus accounting for the number of boulders 
in Westchester and the freedom from them in Long Island. In a 
boulder southeast of Eastchester may be seen the likeness of a foot 
said to be the Devil's imprint. 

Returning go to the right at Ditiiiars Street to see the 

106. Macedonia Hotel, on the eastern shore. Read the in- 
scription which states that the wing is part of an English frigate 
"Macedonia " captured by Decatur during the War of 1812. Visit 
the old cabin and see the mast-hole, hammock-hooks and iron 
ring to fasten the guns, also the officers' staterooms. 

See from here Hart's Island, the " Potter's Field " of New York 
City. *i3 (p. 215). 

Take the car back to Bartow, and follozv the Eastern Boulevard about 
half a mile north to the 

107. Bartow Mansion, the summer home of the Crippled Chil- 
dren's Association. 

Not far away is the site of the original Pell Manor House, though some 
sav that it was on the extreme end of Pelhani Neck. Many tales are told of 
this house, under the title of " Mysteries of a Pelham Farm House." 

In the center of a large field in front are the traditional remains of the 

^ 108. Pell Treaty Oak, the famous tree where Thomas Pell in 1654 
signed the treaty with tlie Sewanoe Indians, purchasing about 10,000 
acres from them. (But sec 1912 Report, Am. Seen, and His. Pres. Soc.) 
Between the Bartow Mansion and the Sound is the 
109. Pell Family Burial-ground. Note the four (modern) 
stone corner-posts, with the emblem of the Pell family, A Pelican 
Gorged, and each bearing a different inscription. Read the inscrip- 
tion on the large centre-stone. 

Return to the Boulevard and continue to the white stone gate-posts 

leading to 
no. Hunter's Island, where see the Hunter-Iselin Mansion, 
summer home of "The Little Mothers." On the southeast side of 
the island are said to be the great Indian rock Mishow and the graves 

210 



Split Rock THE BRONX 34 Route 

vi two Indian sachems. The Indian name for this region was 
Laaphawachking (the place of stringing beads). 

Take the right-hand road over to Hunter's Island leading to the 

111. Twin Island, on the second of which stands the Ogden 
Mansion. From this point a fine marine view may be enjoyed. 
Return on the Boulevard to Prospect Hill Avenue (Split Rock Road). 
along which Glover's gallant men so stubbornly resisted the advanc- 
ing British. 

Follow Split Rock Road to the 

112. Collins House, or the Joshua Pell Mansion, one of the 
Pell homes. 

113. Split Rock is a gigantic boulder, cleft squarely in twain, 
a good sized tree growing in the crevice. Tradition states that the 
early home of Ann Hutchinson (for whom the Hutchinson River is 
named) was near this spot. She came here in 1642 with her younger 
children and her son-in-law, and in the same year her cabin was 
burned by the Indians, and all but one of her family were killed, her 
eight-year-old daughter escaping, only to be captured. Some say 
she perished on the crest of Split Rock. (Tablet, 1909.) 

Cross the City Line and continue to Boston Road; then follow Wolf's 
Lane, line of the American retreat. 
At the foot of the hill, on Wolf's Lane, near Cohmibus Avenue, is 
(also known as the Rodman or Coudert Mansion) 

115. The stately stone Pell Mansion, perhaps the finest of 
all, with its splendid columns and iron lattice-work, and the family 
coat of-arms. In the woods near by is the 

116. Lord Howe Chestnut, where Howe and his generals 
lunched on Oct. 18, 1776, while resting during their pursuit of the 
Americans. Some say that they lunched at the Pell House, tak- 
ing the old lady's last turkey, 

117. Hutchinson River Bridge, where the battle of Pell's 
Point ended and the day was saved for Washington. This bridge, is 
on the line of the original Boston Road, opened in 1672. 

Return by trolley to Mt. Vernon, or fake the N. V., Westchester and 

Boston R. R. 



211 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ROUTE 34a. 

SECTION VII.— EASTERN MORRISANIA AND WEST 
FARMS TO EASTCHESTER. 

(Figures refer to Plates XXXV, XXXVII, XXXVIII and XXXIX). 

From West Farms to Eastchester involves a walk of about five miles. 
Take Third Avenue Elevated Road or Lenox Avenue Subway 
Express to One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street and Third Av- 
enue and change to north-bound West Farms trolley, running 
along Third Avenue (formerly the old Post Road) and Boston 
Road to West Farms, passing on the right at One Hundred and 
Fifty-sixth Street the site of the 

Old school house where many of the children of the early residents received 
their first training. Near the Sixty-third I'recinct Station the Avenue turns 
to the right, crossing where once flowed old Mill Brook, the division line in 
thousands of titles for real estate. On its banks once stood the old Morrisania 
mill, thus giving it the title of Saw Mill Brook. At One Hundred and Sixty- 
first Street is the new Court House on the site of the old Hammer Hotel. 
West on Third Avenue, near One Hundred and Sixty-third Street, stood the 
shingled Georgi House, one of the three buildings standing on Gouverneur Morris' 
farm in 1848 when he sold it to be cut up into building lots to form the village of 
Morrisania. Here the car climbs the steep hill of Boston Road. What is now 
Third Avenue north of this point was once the narrow and shaded Fordham 
Lane, extending through the fields and woods of the Morris farm. 

At Boston Road and Cauldwell Avenue, below One Hundred and Sixty-sixth 
Street, was Pudding Rock, a gigantic glacial boulder where the Indians held 
their corn feasts, and under the cool shade of which the tired Huguenots 
paused to rest on their long Sabbath journey from New Rochelle to New 
York. 

118. The Tenth Milestone, at One Hundred and Sixty-eighth 
Street, marks the distance from the English City Hall on Wall 
Street. 

Opposite Union Avenue is the site of the Jennings Homestead, known also 
as the Drovers' Inn and the Old Stone Jug, built in the middle of the 18th 
Century. 

119. At McKinley Square, One Hundred and Sixty-ninth Street 
and Boston Road, see the flag-pole and tablets on trees in mem- 
ory of Lincoln, Garfield and McKinley; note also Civil War 
mortar and cannon balls. 

On the east side of the junction with Minford Place is the site of The Spy 
House. In this little building, it is said, lived an American spy who played 
in the neighborhood the part of Cooper's spy at Mamaroneck. Where the 
Southern Boulevard crosses may be seen the 

120. Old Hunt House where Washington stayed over night 
while holding an important conference with a spy. 

Leave the car at One Hundred and Seventy-seventh Street and go 

north to One Hundred and Eightieth Street. 

212 



West Farms THE BRONX 34a Route 

West Farms preserves the appearance of a country village. 
Just below rises the stone Crowther Homestead, dated about 
1816, containing interesting carved white marble mantels. Poe 
was a frequent visitor here.*i4 (p. 215; on map 120a). 

At the right pass the site of the DeLancey Block House, a noted place for 
the Royalists until destroyed in a midnight attack by Aaron Burr during the 
winter of 1779. It stood on the land of the Peabody Home (One Hundred and 
Seventy-ninth Street), the building preceding which was known as the Uncle 
Daniel Mapes Temperance House. 

Near One Hundred and Eightieth Street stands the venerable 

Purdy Mansion, dating from 1820. Two blocks west on One 

Hundred and Eightieth Street is the old 

121. West Farms Presbyterian Church, built 1815, opposite the new 
Beck Memorial. Many veterans of the Civil War are interred in the old 
church cemetery. While excavating near by, the skeleton of a Revolu- 
tionary officer was found, clad in Continental regimentals. Church 
burned 1912. See Soldiers' Monument, erected 1909. 

At the lower end of Bronx Park, see ruins (W. bank of river npp. 182nd St.). 

122. Lydig's Mills, built in early times. Just north stood the quaint John- 
son's Tavern, an ancient inn where the stage-coach from Boston to New York 
stopped to change horses. 

- Go north along the west side of the Bronx through the Park. 

123. DeLancey Pine, 150 feet high, in the thick branches of 
which the American sharpshooters used to hide while picking off 
the British in the De Lancey Block House (trunk E. bank, opp. boat- 
house. 

" Memorial of the fallen great, 
The rich and honored line, 
Stands high in solitary state 
DeLancey 's ancient pine." 

124. Fording Place where all travelers had to wade their steeds 
through the river. Beyond is the old hamlet of Bronxdale, near 
which is 

Bear Swamp (so-called because long the haunt of bears), on the site 
of a Sewanoe Indian village which remained until 1689. 
Cross the broad Pelham Parkzvay; continue north on the Boston 
Road through Spencer's Square. 

In the woods to the left on the W. side of Boston Road is 

125. Underbill Burying Ground, said to have been bought by 
that family from the Indians. A mile beyond is an old house on 
the height of ground from which may be obtained a fine view of 
the surrounding country, 

126. 15th Mile Stone, near Two Hundred and Twenty-second 
Street (removed for safe keeping to Borough Hall). Half a mile 
further 

213 



Route 34a HISTORICAL GUIDE Eastchester 

Cross Rattlesnake Brook into Eastchester. 

127 Rattlesnake Brook was named from the reptiles which flourished here, 
one six feet in length being slain as , late as i775- Bears, deer and wolves 
abounded in Eastchester and the remains of a large wolf pit are still visible 
on the Purdy Estate. 

Follow Eden Terrace west to 
128. Seton Falls, the great Seton Cave, the Indian Hiding Place 

and some Indian Fortifications, all concealed in the dense woods, now 
close to the new line of Two Hundred and Thirty-third Street. 

Village of Eastchester, one of the oldest in this section. On 
all sides arc evidences of Indian occupation, quantities of arrow 
and spear heads being found all about. Wigwams occupied the 
site of the old Morgan Residence, while a fortified castle of the 
Sewanoes stood on the hill behind the Fowler Mansion ; here the early 
settlers erected in 1675 a "General Fort." Washington, passing through 
the section in 1790, says he found it "very rough and immensely stoney." 
At Boston Road and Dyre Avenue stands Old Point Comfort Inn, 
pre-Revolutionary, but remodeled, where Lafayette was once entertained. 
Walk dozvn Mill Lane to (2 miles) 

129. Reid's Miller's House. On the marshes stood the famous 
Reid's Mill, a tide-mill which once ground grain for the farmers 
for miles around. It was built in 1739. 

Return to the Post Road and go north on Provost Avenue or White 

Plains Road. 

130. Vincent-Halsey House, the smaller portion being of Revo- 
lutionary date. Nearby was the old Guion Inn, a Revolutionary 
tavern where Washington once stopped and mentioned in his diary 
that these roads were " immensely rough and stony." 

131. Groshon House, a quaint old landmark, the former resi- 
dence of a Huguenot family, " Gros-Jean." 

132. St. Paul's Church, built in 1765, opposite the site of the 
first building erected in 1699. During the Revolution St. Paul's 
was used as a British hospital. See the historical collection, 
which includes an old Prayer Book and Bible. These, together 
with the great bell, were buried during the war in the Vincent- 
Halsey grounds. After the war, while the old church was used 
as a court of justice, Aaron Burr pleaded here many causes. 

The lawn opposite St. Paul's Church was the colonial village 
green. Here stood the first church structure, erected 1699, and 
used as fuel by the British while occupying the present build- 
ing. Here were also the village stocks, dating from 1720. In 

214 



St. Paul's THE BRONX 34a Route 

the locust trees which still stand was fastened the iron staple 
to which criminals were tied to receive punishment. 

St. Paul's Churchyard, containing 6,000 bodies. Note the quaint 
inscriptions on the tombstones, the oldest being dated I704.*i5 

Return by trolley to Mount Vernon and train to New York; or N. Y , 
Westchester and Boston R. R. at Dyre Ave. and zx^d St. 
N. B. Section VII could begin here, the route being reversed. 



ADDENDA, 1912 
ROUTES 34, 34a 

*I2 (p. 209). Near the end of Pell's Point see the old Bowne 
residence, with shingled sides. 

*I3 (p. 210). Stephen Jenkins in his "Story of the Bronx," pp. 
431-432, states that this Macedonian is not the British, but a later 
American warship used for a time as a practice ship at the U. S. Naval 
Academy. Walk one-half mile south from Bartow Station to see the 
new Pelham Bridge and the Tallapoosa Club House, a former 
Lorillard mansion. 

*i4 (p. 213). Across the Bronx may be seen the old Wilson or 
McKesson homestead. 

*I5 (p. 215). See tablet, erected 1911, by the Empire State Society, 
Sons of the American Revolution, giving an account of the history of 
the original meeting-house, the village green and the present structure. 

Two tombstones in St. Paul's Churchyard, erected by the Bronx 
Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution, read as follows : 
"Here lie interred the skeletons of American Revolutionary soldiers 
found at Tuckahoe, 1909." "This marks the ^itc of the sand \V\\. in 
which are buried those Hessian soldiers who died in the church when 
used as a hospital, 1776." 

Opposite St. Paul's, across Columbus Avenue (a part of the coIduimI 
Boston Post Road, laid out in 1672), is the white Crawford Tavern, 
built before the Revolution. It was a famous rendezvous for English 
officers, and from its old sign post a British deserter wns summarily 
hanged. Near by stood the Giiion Tavern, where Washington was 
once detained several days by illness. On leaving he kissed the cheek 
of the hostess, which her husband insisted should never be washe(' 
again. 

215 



NOTES 



216 



NOTES 



217! 



NOTES 



2j8 



PART THREE 

BOROUGH OF BROOKLYN 
EXCURSIONS XII AND VUL-ROUTES 35-43. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



KEY MAP 

OF 

BROOKLYN 

AND 

QUEENS 

Numbers indicate RouU 




144) 



^sto^a A^' 



FLUSHING 



CororTa 



NEWTOWN 



MJrcfifipoint. 






Bushwic 
^Williamaburd 



136) 



NEW UTRECh/ 



(39) c,'^' 



Middle 
Vlllade. 



East NY 
NEW LOT* 



Can<irs(<| 



S 



JAMAICA 



O 




^ o 



«^. 



SRAVESEND 



Plate XLII. Brooklyn and Queens. C. K, 



220 



^ 



EXCURSION NO. XII.— HISTORIC BROOKLYN. PART 2, 
By George W. Nash, M. D. 

Copyright, 1909, by the City History Club of New York. 
Revised 1912 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




222 



HISTORIC BROOKLYN 



1 



BIBLIOGRAPHY 

"History of New York," by Brodhead. 

"Historic New York" (Half Moon Papers), by M. W. Goodwin. 

" Historic Homes on Long Island," by Henry Whittemore. 

" History of Long Island," by B. F. Thompson, 2 vols., 1843. 

" Early Long Island," by M. B. Flint, 1896. 

" History of Long Island," by Peter Ross, 3 vols. 1903. 

" Historic Long Island," by R. R. Wilson, 1902. 

" The County of Kings and City of Brooklyn," by H. R. Stiles, 1884. 

" History of the City of Brooklyn," by H. R. Stiles, 3 vols., 1867-70. 

" History of the City of Brooklyn," by S. M. Ostrander, 2 vols., 1894. 

"Llistoric and Antique Scenes in Brooklyn and its Vicinity," by 
T. W. Field, 1893. 
■ "The Eagle and Brooklyn," by H. W. B. Howard, 1893. 
; " The Prison Ship Martyrs," Captain Fitch's Diary, 1776. 

" History of the Town of Flatbush," by F. M. Strong, 1908. 

" Social History of Flatbush," by G. L. Vanderbilt, 1899. 

"Brooklyn's Gardens" (Flatbush), by C. A. Ditmas, 1908. 

" Chronicles of Erasmus Hall." 

" The Stone House at Gowanus," by Georgina Frazer. 

" History of Long Island," by N. S. Prime. 

" Revolutionary Incidents of Suffolk and Kings Counties," by Henry 
Gnderdonck, Jr. 

" Historic Homesteads of Kings County," by Charles A. Ditmas. 

" Reminiscences of Old New Utrecht and Gowanus," by Mrs. Bleecker 
Bangs. 

" The Eastern District of Brooklyn," by Eugene L. Armbrnster. 

Publications of the Long Island Historical Society 

Vol. I. 'The Journal of a Voyage to New York and a Tour in 
Several of the American Colonies, in 1679-80." By Jasper Daukcrs 
and Peter Sluyter {Labadist Journal). Translated aud Edited by 
Henry C. Murphy. 

Vol. II. "The Battle of Long Island," by Thomas W. Field, 1869. 

Vol. HI. "The Campaign of 1776 Around New York and Brook- 
lyn," by Henry P. Johnston, 1878. 

22i 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate XLIII. Battle of Long Island. C K. 

By permission from Stiles' "The County of Kings and City of Brooklyn," 

published by W. W. Munsell. (Redrawn). 

Key to the Map 

A. At Gowanus, where Grant opened the battle with the Americans under 

Stirling. , j u *!, 

B. American position under Sullivan in Greenwood Cemetery, attacked by the 

Hessians under DeHeister. 

C. Howe's position at the rear of Sullivan. 

D. Howard's Half Way House. • x. e *■ 

E. Howe's final position on the American flank, Grant attacking in the front. 

F. Fort Putnam (now Fort Greene). 

G. Brooklyn Ferry, line of American retreat. 

224 



BROOKLYN 



HISTORICAL SKETCH OF BROOKLYN 

The Brooklyn of to-day was made up by the consolidation of several small 
towns, all of which retain in some measure their early characteristics. 

The earliest settlements were in what may be called the Greater Brooklyn: 
those of Bennett and Bentyn at Gowanus in 1636, and that of Rapelje at Wall- 
about in 1637. Other acquisitions were made by purchase from the Indians, 
until the Indian title to all the west end of Long Island was extinguished. Even 
in early days, the population of Manhattan overflowed its own boundaries and 
some of its inhabitants sought the fertile plains of Long Island for their farms 
and homes. This necessitated some means of ready communication, and a ferry 
was established as early as 1651; then, as now, this ferry started from the foot 
of Fulton Street, although the shore lines are not the same as they were at 
that time. 

Difficulties with the Indians on the mainland, brought about by the bad ad- 
ministration of Kieft, extended to Long Island, and the settlements were al- 
most wiped out by Indian forays. Other settlers came later, and a village sprang 
up along the highway to Flatbush, about a mile from the ferry. It was this 
village that was named Breuckelen, for an old town in Holland not far from 
Amsterdam; this was in 1643, when a charter with associated privileges was 
granted. A hamlet grew up also at the ferry and was known as Ferry Village. 

Under the Dutch the settlements progressed slowly. At the time when 
Stuyvesant succeeded Kieft, there was " considerable discontent among his own 
people; jealous neighbors looked with longing eyes on the thrifty farms," and 
the Indians, feeling keenly their past wrongs, were brooding, plotting and 
waiting. Stuyvesant's rule was arbitrary and brooked little opposition; still the 
inhabitants obtained some measure of local self-government and the town made 
some advance. Church services were held in 1654, although the town did not 
have a minister of its own until 1660; a market and school were also estab- 
lished. As elsewhere in the colony, slavery existed in a mild form until finally 
abolished in 1825. The Indian outbreak of 1663, which seems to have been a 
general rising, brought from the Dutch farmers the statement that " the town 
could not afford a standing army of 8, 10 or 12 men," the number requested. 

The transition from Dutch to English rule affected the town very little. 
The short period of the Dutch re-occupation (1672-3) was noted chiefly for the 
alacrity with which the farmers took the oath of allegiance and "ttle change 
was experienced when the English again came into possession. In 1675 Brooklyn 
had 60 assessed persons with a valuation of 5204 pounds sterling. In 1679 a 
little flare-up of Dutch temper was shown when the sturdy inhabitants vented 
their feelings on the Kings Arms in the Court House. Fulton Street, at first 
merely a narrow lane leading from Ferry Village to Breuckelen, was ordered 
regularly laid out (1704) to East Hampton and was to be four rods wide. It 
belame part of the first post road through Long Island in 1764 and in 1867 it 



[n 1784, at the first town meeting after the Revolution, 
- - 'had disappeared, and it is — "'^' 

members of the Rapelje fa 
had been confiscated. 

The Battle of Long Island 



that all the town records nao oisappcaicu, niiu ... .^ ^^t^^^^^-^ "i a i*u tu^ 
removed to England by members of the Rapelje family who sided with the 
British and whose estates had been confiscated. 



strategic importance of •'''^ Pf„=f ".f^f^ Grant by the shore road to Gowanus, 
rnT'a rj^ll\Tut£ilTT:Lr^&e^>e?\y i^e ntidd.e pass, himsCf took 

"■\SrbiSe "begin on August .7, when G-nt'^ -en -„=^ J^^^ A-J'%^- (^ree" 
Stirling and pushed t!"7 back toward *= f°/*";,„i"„7 ^^"^^ef „n 'reaching 
S~<'ar J'rr^a°;"Kf ?n «maif Joad turn^ _shan,„^ ,0 tj^^wes. 
^t S" S'r.o'-r'e'SSnlJ'in-a^.i^.' Zn plbfd hard on the front and the 



Sketch HISTORICAL GUIDE of Brooklyn 

Americans were forced to retreat, Sullivan being captured. Immediately Howe 
sent forward troops against Stirling, while Grant, made aware of this move- 
ment, pressed heavily against them, and here again the Americans, caught in a 
trap, were compelled to retreat, losing Stirling, The day of disaster to the 
Americans closed with an exhibition of devoted bravery on the part of the Mary- 
land regiment who held back the British until their struggling companions could 
reach safety. The British did not push the advantage gained and thus gave 
Washington opportunity, under cover of a fog, to transport all his men safely 
to New York. 



The British kept possession of Brooklyn and occupied it until the end of the 
war. With a number of regiments quartered here, the people felt martial rule 
keenly, as the gay life of .the soldiers contrasted strongly with the condition 
of the patriots and a scene of waste and desolation was revealed after the 
evacuation. During this period the first Brooklyn newspaper was issued. 

In spite of the presence of the British and of the general apathy of the 
people, there were men patriotic enough to loan the government large sums of 
money, through the medium of American prisoners of war. After the evacuation 
the town slowly pulled itself together; new ferries were established, churches 
and schools organized, mills started, a fire department introduced and a bridge 
to New York suggested. At a town meeting of the trustees held just prior to 
the act of incorporation in 1816, it was decided that the usual supper at the 
end of the deliberations should be at individual expense and not a public 
charge. Incorporation put a stimulus on the people and the shiftless village 
grew steadily in importance and character until in 1834 a city charter was 
granted. As a city, Brooklyn made a quiet and substantial growth, expanding 
slowly to meet new conditions until in 1840 it covered 12 square miles, with a 
population of 30,000. 

In 1854 Williamsburg and Bushwick were absorbed and in course of time the 
neighboring towns of Flatbush, Gravesend, New Utrecht, New Lots and Flat- 
lands were annexed, so that at the time of its own incorporation wifli New 
York in 1898, Brooklyn had an area of 50,000 acres and a population of nearly 
1,000,000. 

In 1909 the city had 396 Protestant and g? Roman Catholic Churches, besides 
31 synagogues, thus entitling her to be called the " City of Churches." The 
immense docking facilities show the energy of her business men, while their 
philanthropic impulses may be seen in many directions. 

N. B. For d eta- led accounts of the former villages named above see Sections 
I, II and III, and Excursion VIII. 

ADDENDA BY CHARLES A. DITMAS. 

The first authentic i)urchases of land on Long Island were made June 16, 1636, 
when the following purchases were made from the Indians: (i) Part of Flatbush 
(divided by Canarsie Lane) by Jacobus van Corlear; (2) Flatlands south of 
I'acrdegat (excepting Barren Island) by Andries Iludde and Wolfcrt Gerritsen 
(Van Kouwenhoven) ; the plantation was called Achtenveldt, and the town New 
Amersfoort in honor of Wolpl.ert's birthplace in Netherlands; (3) Flatlands Neck 
by Director \V outer Van Twiller. 

Van Corlaer transferred his grant to Van Twiller in 1638, but this transfer was 
later forbidden and in 1652 all grants to Van Twiller were annulled; Van 
Kf)uvyenhovcn s grant was annulled in i6s2, but later confirmed again. His widow 
married Robert Kibertse Stoothoff, who acquired the patent and most of the land; 
a descendant, Wilhelmus Stoothoff sold the patent rights to Col. Tohannes Lott 
ot Matlands, whose three sons passed them down to hteir descendants. 

Ihc other flats passed to the Dutch Government and were known as "the 
(.overnors I'arni, and during Stuyvesant's time were managed by Pieter 
Clausen VVyckoff. ^ 



22t 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 35a. 
SECTION I.— WILLIAMSBURG 

Take Grand Street car from Manhattan side of the Williamsburg 

Bridge. 

Note, while crossing, the Queensboro Bridge and Blackvvell's 
Island to the left. The city has utilized the space under the ap- 
proaches to the bridge from the Williamsburg Plaza as a play- 
ground for children. See on the left in the Plaza the equestrian 
statue of Washington, presented to the city by ex-Register James 
R. Howe; it was designed by Henry W. Shrady and cost $50,000. 
The Plaza is the starting point for cars running in every direction. 

Williamsburg. The village, named for Colonel Williams, U. 
S. A., who surveyed the land, was begun soon after the Revolu- 
tion. In 1792 a New York merchant named Woodhull established 
a horse ferry from Grand Street to this section and the village 
clustered around the ferry. It grew rapidly, due to natural advan- 
tages, nearness to New York, and convenience to the farmers 
of the interior. A second ferry was started soon after and the 
rivalry thus induced stimulated growth. A church was organ- 
ized, a school and a distillery were added and many improvements 
followed. The village secured a charter in 1827, and in 1829 it 
had a population of 1007. Then came speculation and the crash 
of 1837, after which the town settled down to steady growth and 
prosperity. In 1849 it became a city, and in 1852 it had a popu- 
lation of 40,000; in 1854 it was annexed to Brooklyn. The neces- 
sary expansion of New York City to accommodate its increasing 
population, together with the erection of the bridge, has com- 
pletely changed the farms of old Williamsburg to a compactly 
built city. 



227 



Route 35a 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Williamsburg 







Plate XLIV. 



C, K. 



Nearly all the old landmarks have disappeared and it is difficult to 
locate the landmarks of but a few years ago. The Tozvn Hall 
was situated at the corner of Bedford Avenue and South Second 
Street, now occupied by the Brooklyn Union Gas Co. The old 
building was torn down previous to 1874. 

At the corner of Metropolitan and Bedford Avenues is an 
old hip-roofed house and another may be seen at the corner of 
Bedford Avenue and South Third Street. On the opposite side of 
the avenue is a dilapidated brick building, the remains of the 
Pentecostal Tabernacle (demolished 1909). 

228 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 35b. 

SECTION II.— GREENPOINT. 
Take a "Cross Town" car from the Plaza at Williamsburg. 

The earliest settlement at Greenpoint was that of Dirck Volck- 
ertsen in 1645, whose house was on the shore at the foot of the 
present Calyer Street. He was also called Dirck the Norman, 
from which is derived the name of Norman's Kill. Greenpoint 
was known as the " Keike " or " Keikout," meaning " Lookout 
Bluff." 

There was no attempt at any village organization until 1660, 
when the inhabitants were required to concentrate, so as to be 
better prepared against Indian attack. 

The place had several owners; in 1663 the Meserole family 
owned 107 acres; besides this there were patent lands granted by 
the Dutch governors. The town had a quiet history till the Revo- 
lution, when the Hessian allies of the British troops were quar- 
tered among the people. After the declaration of peace there 
were but four or five families in Greenpoint and the place was 
almost apart from the world, except for the row boat ferry con- 
nection with New York. The town has grown steadily since 1832 
and in 1854 it was consolidated with Brooklyn. 

The overflowing population from Manhattan has transformed 
this section from the old time farms to solid blocks of buildings. 
In early days the farmers looked to Bushwick Square for their 
central activities and it was not until 1846-50 that this section 
developed its own public conveniences. Men living to-day have 
trudged to Bushwick to school, driven to Bushwick to church, 
and carried their farm produce to the Bushwick town dock for 
shipment. 

During the middle of the last century ship building was a suc- 
cessful business all along the water front. The people had com- 
munication with New York by means of small row boats from 
various points along the shore, the most important being the 
ferry at the foot of Java Street. 



229 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Fro/n t^e/fesera/e(Pe/Ka/of/ca/(k/t. 
3j per/niss/on. 

Plate XLV. Greenpoint. 



230 



Greenpoint BROOKLYN 35b Route 

(Figures refer to Plate XLV). 
The most prominent landmarks now to be seen are: 

5. The Meserole Homestead, 1000 Lorimer Street, between 
Meserole and Norman Avenues; originally a typical Dutch farm- 
house, as shown by an old photograph, it has been enlarged until 
nothing now remains of the first structure but the wing which 
was built in 17S9. 

10. Original building of St. Anthony's Roman Catholic Church, 
150 India Street, erected about 1857. It is made of brick and is 
now a wire works factory. 

The first Dutch Reformed Church, built about 1850, was on Java 
Street; the second building, still in use, is on Kent Street, between 
Manhattan and Franklin Avenues. 

HISTORIC SITES. 

1. The Bennett Homestead, later occupied by John Meserole. 

2. Stone house built by Captain Pieter Praa about 1700. 

3. House built by John A. Meserole about 1790. 

4. Location of the house of Dirck Volckertsen, the Norman. The 
first settler on Greenpoint and one of the earliest settlers in Kings 
County, 

7. The Calyer Homestead. 

8. House built by John I. Meserole about 1800. 

9. House occupied by Volckert Dirksen, the eldest son of Dirck 
Volckertsen, and afterwards occ 'nied by Jacob Meserole. 

ADDENDA, 1912 

Duryee House, Frost Street, between Humboldt and Graham Streets, 
an old shingled building on the former Blackwell (now Bliss) estate, 
said to be one hundred years old and once occupied by Washington. 
A house of old Dutch architecture stands at 418 Meeker Avenue, near 
Penny Bridge. 



231 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 35c. 
SECTION III.— BUSHWICK. 
Take Grand Street car from the Manhattan side of Williamsburg 
Bridge, transfer to the Metropolitan Avenue car and ride to 
Bushwick Avenue; go north three blocks to old Bushwick Square, 
the centre of the original Dutch village of Bushwick. 

Jan der Swede is the first name connected with the settlement of Bush- 
wick; he came here 1645-50. In 1661 Governor Stuyvesant had the village laid 
out and later gave it the name of " Boswijck," or " Town of the Woods;" at 
the same time he inaugurated some measures of local government. 

The English occupancy disturbed the Dutch but little, though the new rule 
was more arbitrary than that to which they had been accustomed, especially as 
to church affairs. In 1665 the first sermon was preached here and, in order to 
minister to the spiritual needs of the people, clergymen came from the Flat- 
bush church for over forty years. Previous to 1700, there is mention of a 
" Commons " for the care and watering of cattle. In 1687 Governor Dongan 
granted increased privileges in a new patent. Under the English rule the popu- 
lation grew to about 165, while it had been about 100 during the Dutch control. 
Previous to the Revolutior^ the town was represented in the Provincial Congress 
and had a militia company. After the Battle of Long Island the Hessians, 
quartered on the inhabitants with all that pertains to such an occupancy, kept the 
people in a continued state of irritability. After peace was declared many 
of the Hessians took up residence here. It was joined to Brooklyn in 1854. 
Owing to the impulse of a crowding population, but few landmarks remain, but 
these are of an interesting character. 

(Figures refer to Plate XLVI). 

1. Reformed Church of Bushwick, organized 1654. The first 
church was built in 1709 and the present structure in 1825. 

2. Bushwick Churchyard, containing a few headstones; entrance 
to the left on Humboldt Avenue. Nearby is the site of the 
Bcadcll Homestead, at the corner of Metropolitan and Bushwich 
Avenues. 

The old Wood Point Road, starting at the church, is worthy 
of mention; it was a typical country road, crossing the fields to 
the cemetery near the Devoe House (8), thence across the mea- 
dows and hills to the Town Dock. The first part of the road is 
still in use and is plotted on the map. 

3. Old Town House site, opposite the present church on Wood 
Point Road. Near it men were exposed for punishment; courts 
and elections were held in its rooms; later it became a tavern, 
the town fathers having leased it for such a purpose; finally, it 
was sold and then disappeared. 

Go east on Orient Avenue to 
Cooper Park, given to the city of Brooklyn in 1895 by the 
Cooper family. Behind the comfort house is a brick shed where 
the Coopers experimented in the manufacture of varnish. On 
Morgan Avenue at the rear of the Park are 

4 and 5. Two Cooper Houses, the larger built by William 
Cooper for his own occupancy about i860 and the other built 

232 



Bushwick 



BROOKLYN 



^ 



35c Route 



®|U 



DI/A&RAM ".BUSHWICK 

C'OLO roWN cEMCTear 







PR05 r 



5 



Withers . ,^ A \:^ ^^^ 



JACK SON 



P4 RK E 



T B£NTO|< 















■® 




Plate XLVI. Route 35c. 



C. K. 



by him for his niece. On Maspeth Avenue, opposite the north 
side of the Park, see 

6. Peter Cooper Tenements; a row of wooden houses with tall 
pillars in the middle of the row, erected by Peter Cooper for his 
workmen. In the rear of the row was the old Cooper Glue Fac- 
tory. 

Peter Cooper was born in 1791 of Revolutionary stock and 
died in 1883. In his youth he mastered a number of trades and 
later entered business, engaging in the manufacture of iron and 
machinery. He constructed the first locomotive engme built in 
this country and was largely instrumental in the laying of the 
Atlantic Cable. His public spirit and philanthropy are best evi- 
denced in Cooper Union, a lasting monument to his memory. 
The two brothers married the Beadell sisters. 

2^3 



Route 35c HISTORICAL GUIDE Busbwick 

Go north through Banzett Street (officially mapped as Debevoise 
Avenue), passing on the right 

7. An old house (painted red) in the middle of the field to the 
east (northeast corner of Maspeth and Morgan Avenues). It was 
built from the timbers taken from the old "Manor House" (9). 

8. Devoe House, a small stone building inside the enclosure 
between Parker and Bennett Streets on Banzett Avenue; en- 
trance on Bennett Street through Trotter's ice-cream factory. 
It is evidently the lower floor of an old Dutch stone house. 
Notice in the living-room the wooden beams in the ceiling and a 
fine example of an old carved mantel. 

C. Nearby is the site of the old Town Cemetery of which no trace 
remains. In 1879 all the bodies were removed to the churchyard and 
the cemetery obliterated. 

At the corner of Meeker and Kingsland Avenues were 

9. The Manor House, sometimes called the Wyckofif House 
(7) and 

10. The Debevoise House and ham. Both houses belonged to 
families prominent in public afifairs. The barn was used by the 
Hessians during the Revolution. The WyckofT House was built 
by Theodorus Polhemus of Flatbush, who represented the town in 
the Provincial Congress from 1775-77. His children sold out to 
the Wyckoff family. The Bushwick branch of the Debevoise 
family is descended from the Huguenot DeBevoise, the first 
school teacher of Brooklyn. 

11. Van Raust House site at 245 Withers Street, near Kings- 
land Avenue. This house was occupied by Captain McPherson, 
leader of the company of men from whom the British obtained 
guides for their expeditions. After peace was declared these 
guides came to Bushwick and encamped there. 

12. Skillman House site, 37 Frost Street, between Lorimer and 
Union Avenues, the house being torn down about 1880. It is said 
that Washington was entertained here. During the stay of the 
guides mentioned (in 11) a party of Americans planned to secure 
some boats belonging to the British. These boats drifted to 
the shore near the Skillman farm and the Skillman house was 
the gathering place of the party making the capture. 

13- Conselyea House site, corner of Humboldt Avenue and 
Jackson Street. The Conselyea family was a noted one during 
the Revolution. William Conselyea was hung in his well by the 
British to make him name the hiding-place of his money. 

234 



Bushwick BROOKLYN 35c Route 

Return to Bushwick Square and take east bound Metropolitan Av- 
enue car to the bridge, crossing Newtown Creek; transfer to east 
bound Maspeth car to Flushing Avenue and take car marked Park 
Rozv, soon passing on the right and left several houses of old Dutch 
architecture belonging to the Wyckoff family originally (Excursion 
XI, Section III, 43). 

After passing under the Manhattan Bridge, see on the right 
the United States Marine Hospital, Wallabout Market and the 
Navy Yard (Excursion VIII, Section II). 



235 



NOTES 



236 



NOTES 



237 



:motes 



238 



EXCURSION VIII. I 

HISTORIC BROOKLYN— PART I. ! 

J 
By Frank Bergen Kelley. 1 

Revised, 1909, with the aid of George W. Nash, M.D., and 1912, with 
THE AID OF Charles A. Ditmas. 

Copyright, 1905, by the City History Club of New York. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 











BR.OOn.LyN HEIGHTS 



BOflOUO^M HALL 
iStction J. £KCijr»ion V///. 



Plate XLVII. Route z6. 



C. K.\ 



240 



BROOKLYN 

The * refers to Addenda, 1912, pp. 264-265. 

ROUTE 36 

SECTION I.— BROOKLYN HEIGHTS TO BOROUGH HALL. 

(Figures refer to Plate XLVII). 

Take South Ferry to Atlantic Avenue; walk up to Hicks Street, 
north to Montague Street and west to Montague Terrace, from which 
is obtained a fine view of Manhattan and the Harbor; or Wall 
Street Ferry to Montague Street. 

1. Grace Episcopal Church, organized in 1847. When the 
church floor was renewed in 1899 the old Remsen Well was dis- 
covered; it is nearly under the font. 

The old Grace Court Spring, destroyed in 1908, was on the Prince 
Estate, between Grace Court and Remsen Street, on the bluff. The 
Remsen House stood one block in the rear of the church on Joralemon 
Street. The family owned a large farm on the Heights, Joris 
Remsen having bought it of his father-in-law in 1706. 

Walk north on Columbia Heights, noting the small parks along the 
edge of the bluff. 

Brooklyn Heights was the center of the residence section of the Old Ferry 
Village. As this Excursion chiefly describes historic houses still in existence, and 
as few important landmarks remain here, the student is referred to Stiles| 
"History of Kings County," pp. 105-139, and Stiles' "History of Brooklyn," 
Vol. II, Chap. 2, for interesting itineraries through the old streets of Ferry 
Village in 181 6, 

At the corner of Henry and Clark Streets is the Grace M. E. 

Church, successor to the "Old Sands Street Church," organized 

in 1794. See tablet. 

Turn east at Orange Street. 

2. Plymouth Church, between Hicks and Henry Streets, a 
plain brick building erected in 1847-50, seating 2800 persons. See 
the stained glass windows representing the " History of Puritan- 
ism." A building is planned nearby as a Beecher Memorial. 
Henry Ward Beecher, born in Litchfield, Conn., in 1813, came to 
Brooklyn in 1847 when he was .installed here as pastor. In the 
pulpit of Plymouth Church he acted as auctioneer one Sunday 
morning (Feb. 5, i860) and sold a slave girl into freedom. He 
died March 8, 1887.*! 

241 



Route 36 HISTORICAL GUIDE L. I. Historical So. 

On Cranberry and Hicks Streets are two hip-roofed houses. 
Continue on Orange through Nassau Street across Fulton to Adams 
Street and walk east to 

3 Public School No. i, at Concord and Adams Streets, site 
of the first district school of Brooklyn (1816, rebuilt 1842), where 
also was held the first (Union) Brooklyn Sunday School in 1816. 
See tablet in the gable on the front of the building. 

Go north on Concord to Jay Street and east to 

4 St. James Pro-Cathedral, Jay and Chapel Streets, the first 
Roman Catholic Church on Long Island (organized 1822). See 
bust of Peter Turner (1787-1853) and two tablets dedicated to him 
as founder of the first Roman Catholic Church and school on 
Long Island. 

There are about 6,000 graves in the adjoining churchyard. 

Continue on Jay Street to Myrtle Avenue and walk to 

5. Brooklyn Borough Hall (begun 1836, completed 1840), the 
original City Hall of Brooklyn. See in front the statue of Beecher 
by J. Q. A. Ward. In the space behind the hall, once occupied by 
a military garden, is the County Court House. 

In the Borough Hall Subway Station see the tablet commemor- 
ating the opening of the first Subway uniting Manhattan and 
Brooklyn, January 9, 1908. *2 
Walk west on Fulton to Pierrepont Street and south to Clinton Street. 

6. Long Island Historical Society at Clinton and Pierrepont 
Streets (open to the public), founded 1863; contains an excellent 
reference library, rich in books on local, history. The museum, 
in addition to a general collection of interesting articles and 
prints, has a large number of specimens illustrating the Natural 
History of Brooklyn and many relics and memorials illustrative of 
Colonial life. The curator will explain the collection. 



242 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 37. 

SECTION IL— FULTON STREET, FORT GREENE PARK 
AND NAVY YARD 

(Figures refer to Plate XLVIII). 

Take Fulton Street surface or elevated lines to Flatbush Avenue, 

passing 

7. Site of the First Dutch Church of Brooklyn, on Fulton Street, near 
Lawrence. It was erected in 1666, rebuilt in 1766, and removed to Joralemon 
Street in 1807. Until 1654 the people had to go to New Amsterdam for church 
services; from that time until 1660 they were obliged to attend the church at 
Flatbush, when a petition was made for a church of their own. This was 
granted and they worshipped in a barn while measures were taken for the 
erection of a building. 

8. Tablet, erected by the Sons of the Revolution on the Smith- 
Gray Building, Fulton Street, corner of Flatbush Avenue, to mark 
the line of defence in the battle of Long Island " from the Wall- 
about to the Gowanus." Near by is the site of Labon's Inn, a 
road-house which was occupied by the Hessians. 

Go north on Hudson to Willoughhy Avenue and east to Fort Greene 

Park. 

9. Martyrs' Tomb, Fort Greene Park. The tablet over thf 
entrance to the tomb commemmorates the " American Seamen, 
Soldiers and Citizens who perished on the prison ships " of the 
British at the Wallabout during the Revolution. This is the cor- 
ner stone of the vault erected by the Tammany Society, April, 
1808. The tomb contains the remains of 11,000 patriots. 

Fort Putnam stood here during the Revolution, the name being 
changed to Fort Greene during the War of 1812. 

The monument recently erected by the city is 145 feet high, 
including a bronze urn 20 feet high. The architects were McKiln, 
Mead and White. The entire cost was defrayed by contributions 
from the U. S. Government, N. Y. State Government, New York 
City and the Prison Ship Martyrs Association. 
Walk north on St. Edward's Street through City Park to Navy Street. 

10. Brooklyn Navy Yard (entrance opposite Sands Street), es- 
tablished 1801. 

N. B. Secure pass at the gate. 

When inside the reservation, follow Park Avenue and First 
Street to Trophy Park and see ancient and modern Spanish 

243 



Route 37 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Wallabout 



cannon, Spanish contact mines, Civil War ^relics and a monu- 
ment to the sailors who fell in China m 1856. *3 

In Wallabout Bay were located the infamous Jersey and other 
prison ships during the Revolution, and in a vault just outside 
the Navy Yard rested the bones of the prisoners until removed in 
1873 to Fort Greene Park. 

The surrounding region was known as The Wallabout (" Waal- 
boght") and was settled in 1637 by Joris Jansen de Rapelje and 
other "Walloons" or Huguenots who had fled to Holland for 
refuge. 

Adjoining the Navy Yard is Wallabout Market, which is well 
worth a visit, especially in the morning. 



;p4^^5~ 



/YJivy YARD. 



(2) 



aN^' 






^f3AR.K. /1V£ 



ilJ' 



J 



lT 



SDDDQCu 



ruLTON str.ee T 

rOR-T &R.£BNE /=>/t/tK 
A/AVY YARD BR.OOKLYN 
Section 2. Excvraior. 




Plate XLVHI. Route zT. 
244 



C K, 



BROOKLYN 
ROUTE 38 

SECTION III.— PROSPECT PARK, FLATBUSH AND 
FLATLANDS 

(The figures refer to Plate XLIX). 

(The points in Section III can be covered in an automobile 
or carriage in three hours. See Automobile Routes, Part VI). 

ROUTE 38. 
A. PROSPECT PARK 

Take Flatbush Avenue car from Atlantic Avenue terminal of the 
Subway to the entrance of Prospect Park. 

At the entrance to Prospect Park see 

11. Soldiers' and Sailors' Memorial Arch, erected in 1897 to 
the memory of the heroes of the Civil War. The arch was de- 
signed by John H. Duncan and the bronze quadriga and the tab- 
lets by Powers and MacMonnies. To the left is 

12. The Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences, which has a 
number of departments in each of which lectures and courses 
of instruction are regularly given. It has an excellent museum. 
The building is open on week days from g to 6 and is free except 
on Mondays and Tuesdays. 

A branch of the Institute, the Children's Museum, is located in 
Bedford Park in a Colonial residence. It may be reached from the 
entrance to Prospect Park via Eastern Parkway to Brooklyn 
Avenue and four blocks north of Park Place, or by Bergen Av- 
enue cars to Brooklyn Avenue, or by Fulton Street "L" (City 
Line) to Brooklyn Avenue Station and walk south to Bedford 
Park. The collections are selected with special reference to the 
needs of children and illustrate the various departments of science. 
The historical room is of particular interest for its models of 
colonial houses, furniture, costumes and other articles pertaining 
to the life of the colonists. 

At Prospect Park take electric omnibus (25 cents) or walk to 

13. Battle Pass Tablet (on the East Drive near the public play- 
grounds). The tablet marks Valley Grove, the outer line of de- 
fence in the Battle of Long Island. The chief part of the battle 
was fought in the region now included in Prospect Park. 

245 



Route 38 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Prospect Park 

"tv^tit :: honor "Maryland, ^o.r H.,„^.ed J^ who on 
this battlefield, August 27, 1776, saved the American Army. 
(For sletch of battfe see Excursion XII; for full accounts see 
Stile«' and Johnston's works), (p 3^7) 

Within the Park are statues and monuments of Payne, Irving, 
Moore, Lincoln, Stranahan and others. 

From the Monument, walk to the Willinck (Malbone Street) exit of 
the Park to Flatbush Avenue. 



- DIAGRAM - 

/TLATBUSH AVENUE. 
S»ct,on 3. . Excursion VM 




^flPTiloi. 




If© 



Plate XLIX. Routes 38, 39- 



C. K. 



246 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 39. 
B. FLATBUSH 
(If Flatbush is made a separate excursion, take Brighton Beach 
" L" train to Prospect Park Station.) 

Flatbush, in the early days called Midwout, was first settled in 1674- the 
origin of the present name is lost in obscurity. The land was purchased several 
times from the Indians. For many years the town was under the absolute rule 
of the Governor; m 1653, the people, chafing at his arbitrary methods, forced 
from him a little show of self-government which was granted. pcrhai)s as a re- 
ward for help rendered in putting down pirates. The H:nKlish occupation 
brought a change in laws and customs, but the inhabitants kept on placidly in 
their own ideas of liberty and the pursuit of happiness. The stocks and whip- 
ping posts were provided, as was usual. In early part of the eighteenth 
century the road to Flatbush was made a turnpike with a toll gate at what is 
now the corner of Fulton Street and Flatbush Avenue; in 1842 it was moved 
to near Hanson Place, and, later, as Brooklyn grew, still further away until, 
after a number of years, it stood at about where Fenimore Street meets the 
Avenue. The town lay in the track of the Battle of Long Island (see Excur- 
sion XII) where the Hessians overcame the American forces under Sullivan. 
The subsequent quartering of British soldiers on the town was a source of 
keen hardship. Since the Revolution, Flatbush has progressed quietly; in 1894 
it was annexed to Brooklyn. It has always been a residence section and is 
now an important suburb in Greater New York. 

Take Flatbush Avenue car south to Flatbush Reformed Church, 

passing 

15. LefFerts Homestead (pre-Revolutionary), 56.3 Flatbush 
Avenue. 

16. Vanderbilt Homestead (pre-Revolutionary), 610 Flatbush 
Avenue. See Dutch ^Dven and fire-place in the cellar. Demolished. 

17. Birdsall House, 612 Flatbush Avenue, once famous for its 
ivy and garden. It was formerly Judge Leffert Lcfiferts' house. 

18. Melrose Hall site (built 1750), corner of Winthrop Street; 
noted for its legends. 

19. Flatbush Dutch Reformed Church, corner of Church Ave- 
nue; built 1793-6 on foundations of the second church (1698), 
which was on the site of the original building erected in 1654, 
this being the oldest church on Long Island. See tablet erected 
by the Colonial Daughters of the Seventeenth Century. In early 
days the dead were buried beneath the church, and for many 
years no tombstones were used for fear of attracting the atten- 
tion of the Indians. In a part of the yard unmarked by stones 
are the remains of many who died in the Battle of Long Island. 
The church was used by the British as a military prison. ^Liny 
of the epitaphs are in Dutch. 

20. Erasmus Hall High School (formerly Academy), near 
Snyder Avenue, built in 1786 by private subscription (llam.lton 
and Burr contributing), and chartered by the Regents in 1787. 
Wm. Alex Duer, son of Lady Kitty Duer, was an early graduate; 

247 



Route 39 HISTORICAL GUIDE Flatbush 

in 1797 John Henry Livingston, first Theological Professor of the 
Reformed Church, was the head of the school. It became a pub- 
lic school in 1896 and is hidden by the modern building. 



22. Site of /. C. Bergen House, corner of Albermarle Road, built 1735. 
When occupied by David Clarkson in 1776, it was sacked by the British, 
and later it was used as a military prison. The original parsonage for 
Dominie Freeman, who served the Dutch church, 1705-41. 

23. Lott House, 1084 Flatbush Avenue. 

24. Site of Vanderveer Homestead, 1159 Flatbush Avenue, built 
in 1787 (or 1788) on the site of an earlier house. The land on which 
the house stood was granted to the ancestor of the present owner in 
1660, by Governor Stuyvesant. Demolished 191 1. 

26. Henry S. Ditmas House, corner Ditmas and Flatbush Avenues, 
built about 1800; notice Dutch door. 

27. Old House at 1240 Flatbush Avenue. 

28. Cortelyou-Vanderveer House site, 1249 Flatbush Avenue. The 
house has been moved to Ditmas Avenue and East Twenty-sixth Street, 
behind the Cortelyou Club House. Just east was the well-known 
Vanderveer Mill, between Paerdegat Pond and Canarsie Lane. This was 
the first Long Island windmill and was built in 1804. It was used as a 
refuge for negroes during the Draft Riots. It was burned in 1879. See 
illustration in L. I. Historical Society. 

Go zvest to Avenue G to Amersfoort Place 

29. Another Ditmas House, erected 1827, by George Van Nuyse. 

Return and continue south, passing 

30. Old House and pump on the lower corner of Avenue J. 



248 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 40. 

C FLATLANDS 

(Figures refer to Plate L). 

"Nieuw Amersfoort," the Dutch name for Flatlands, was established i6^6 
the first Dutch plantation on Long Island. The Canarsie Indians occupied this 
region, and in the great shell heaps at Canarsie and at Bergen Beach may be 
found traces of their wampum industry. Here the Indians and their Dutch 
successors raised crops of maize on the " Great Flats on Flatlands Plains " 
The " Indian Path " ran from Brooklyn Ferry to Bergen Island, following in 
part the " King's Highway " of to-day. The first patent recorded was in 1636 
to Andreas Hudden and Wolphert Gerritsen Van Kouwenhoven, and a local 
court was established in 1654. The town managed to get along until 1667 
without a charter. For over a century it had' only ten men at the head 
of affairs. Political changes made but little impression on the people. Dur- 
ing the Revolution, when the English troops were quartered on the town, the 
Dominie was allowed to continue preaching, a rare occurrence at that time. 
Flatlands was annexed to Brooklyn in 1896. 

This region resembles Holland in its general flatness, marshiness, dikes and 
creeks, and its outlook over salt meadows and Jamaica Bay, which is often 
dotted with slow-moving sailing vessels. 

I. Flatlands Church, Flatbush Avenue north of King's High- 
way, built 1847-8, on the site of former buildings of 1662 and 1794. 
Some of the original colonial furniture is in the manse. Near the 
church is the old graveyard and the old school on the original 
school lot. Notice the new public school just north. Several 
Dutch houses and old barns may be seen in the neighborhood. 
(See 14). The church was organized in i654.*4 
Continue on Flatbush Avenue car east on Avenue N to Mill Lane. 
Go south to 

2. Schenck-Crooke House, built about 1656. See the great rafters, 
which are built ship fashion, and the old fireplaces.*5 

3. Bergen Homestead on East Seventy-second Street (Bergen 
Beach), built about 1655. See the old fireplaces, Dutch door and 
knocker.*6 

Return on car to Flatlands Avenue and ivallc zvest 

4. Old Van Wyck Homestead (demolished). 

Go south on Kimball Street, passing 

5. Jeromus Lott-Vanderveer House, corner of Avenue P. 

6. Lett House (between Fillmore Avenue and Avenue S), 
built in 1800 of material from the original homestead. 

This entire section was first granted to Andrics Hudden and 
Wolphert Gerritsen in 1636 by Wouter Van Twiller, the grant 
being confirmed by Stuyvesant in 1658 and reconfirmed by Gov- 
ernor Nicoll in 1667. A portion came to the Lott family in 1719 

249 



Route 40 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Flatlands 




Plate L. Route 40. 



C. K. 



(see copy of the grant and various transfers in the possession 
of the family whose descendants now occupy the house). 
Go west on the Neck Road, crossing the bridge over Gerritsen's Creek. 
7. Gerritsen Tide Mill and Mill Race on the edge of the 
Whitney place. The original mill was built shortly after 1636 by 
one of the Gerritsens. 

Continue zvest on Neck Road, passing 

8. Stillwell House, corner of Ryder's Lane, about a century 
old, the barn being still older. Note the milestone in front bear- 
ing the inscription "Eight and (Three Qu)arters Miles to Brock- 
land Ferry." 

See north on Ryder's Lane 

9-10. Two old Ryder Houses on either side of the lane. 

Six houses of Dutch architecture stand near the end of the Coney 
Island Jockey Club grounds. 

250 



Flatlands Neck BROOKLYN 40 Route 

Go north on Ocean Avenue, passing 

ir. Bennett House on King's Highway, built by the elder Ben- 
nett for his son. 

12. Bennett Homestead, corner Avenue P and East Twenty- 
second Street, formerly fronting on King's Highway. 

13. Van Nuyse-Magaw Homestead, 1447 Ocean Avenue, a 
well-preserved Dutch farmhouse over a century old. 

Go east on Avenue J to Flathush Avenue. 
D. SIDE TRIP THROUGH FLATLANDS NECK 

Take Flatlands Neck Road from Flathush Avenue and go east, and 
north to Church Avenue, passing 

14. Van Wyck House on the corner of Avenue L or King's 
Highway. Note the bull's eyes in what was originally the front 
door, now the rear. Pass on the left the Flatlands Reformed 
Church and old school house. (Van JVyck House has been dcnuilisJicd.) 

15. House of W. H. Kouwenhoven, King's Highway near Ave- 
nue H. 

16. Historic Tree, Avenue G and Neck Road. (Appendix E.) 
Betweep the church and Church Avenue about ten houses of typical 

Dutch style may be seen ; also an early school house. 

Canarsie Lane, just beyond the school house, leads to old Canarsie 
Village ejection IV). 

! i; Take Church Avenue car back to Flatbush. 

See additional notes on Flatlands, p. 263. 



i25i 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




BROOKLYN 



ROUTE 41. 

SECTION IV.— NEW LOTS, EAST NEW YORK AND 
CANARSIE 

(Figures refer to Plate LI). 

New Lots had its beginning when the farmers of Old Lots in Flathush feel- 
ing crowded, came here and settled in 1670. The town was organized in' 1852 

East New York, so named from its location, was founded by John R. Pitkin" 
a merchant from Connecticut, in 1835. ' ' 

Take Fulton Street {City Line) train to Cleveland Street Station. 
Go north one block to Jamaica Avenue, then to the ri^Jit one block to 

(A) Snedeker House, opposite the head of Elton Street. 
The house belongs to the city. See the beautiful mantel in the 
front room.*7 

Go two blocks west on Jamaica Avenue 

(B) Schenck House, built in 1705. *8 

Take Street car or "L" road to Crescent Avenue and go south to 
Old Mill Village (stage 10 cents), passing on the left the 

1. Peck House, near P. S. 159, at Pitkin and Lincoln Avenues. 

2. Old Mill, now called Van Wicklen IVIill, on the left, ap- 
proaching the quaint little village which is situated on both sides 
of Old Mill Creek, formerly called Bull Creek. The mill was 
built in 1770 by Van Brunt. The village usually has in September 
a Mardi Gras festival which is worth seeing. 

The old mill wheel is silent, with moss now long grown o'er. 
The creaking gate 'neath the rustic bridge shall stem the tide no more. 
The miller, too, has passed away, no more the wheat and corn 
Shall grind to the chug of the old mill wheel by the waters that have gone. 

— From a Festival Program. 

Go back from Old Mill PTRnge to New Lots road and ivalk zvcst to 

3. Van Brunt House, corner Shepherd Avenue, of Dutch archi- 
tecture, with hip roof; one of the oldest houses in this section. 

4. New Lots Dutch Reformed Church, built in 1824, but organ- 
ized many years earlier as an ofifshoot of the Flatbush Church, 
the congregation meeting in the old schoolhouse (6). The 
farmers, feeling that the distance to the Flatbush Church was too 
great, obtained permission to erect a building of their own; not 
having much ready money, the men went into the woods, cut 

253 



Route 41 HISTORICAL GUIDE New Lots 

and hauled the timber to the mill, made and fitted the frame and 
then had the "raising"; in fact, they did everything but the 
plaster work. 

5. Churchyard on the side of P. S. ^2, which stands on the 
site of the original school. Among the families buried here are 
the Van Dykes, Elberts, Snede(i)kers, Ryders, and Emanses. 
Several stones bear the date 1796- 

6. Old New Lots School, just north on Barbey Street, between 
Livonia and Dumont Avenues, over a century old and now used as 
a dwelling. It was moved to this site when the new school was 
built. The lower part was used by the teacher for his home and 
the upper part as a school and church. Near by is the 

7. Duryea House, at 562 Jerome Street, well preserved. 

Continue west on New Lots Road. 

8. Van Sicklen House, corner Van Sicklen Avenue, built about 
1730. 

9. Rapalye House, 349 New Lots Road, built about 1730 and in 
very good condition. See the twin doors in the back, a character- 
istic of the period. 

Ethan Allen, who had been captured in Canada, was billetted 
here under parole as a prisoner of war. Elated at the victory 
of the Americans at the Battle of Bennington, he gave expression 
to his feelings at Howard's Half Way House; this was too much 
for his captors and. he was immediately arrested and confined in 
the Provost Prison in New York, where he was afterwards 
exchanged. 

10. Lott House, at 321 New Lots Road, about a century old.*9 

11. Snedeker House, corner of Snedeker Avenue, built about 
1750. 

The Van Sinderen House, near Junius Street, has lately been de- 
molished. 

Take Canarsie train from New Lots station to Canarsie Beach. 

12. Vanderveer Mill site at Flatlands Avenue and East One-hundred and 
Seventh Street. (Leave tra.in at Flatlands Avenue and East One-hundred and 
Fifth Street and walk to East One-hundred and Seventh Street). 

This mill was in use up to the Civil War. Only ruins remain (built 1672). 
The Vanderveer House was built about 1820. 

Continue on the train to Canarsie Park, passing 

13. Schenck House in Canarsie Park, built about i770.*io 
Walk north on the old Canarsie Lane to Remsen Place, 

254 



E. New York BROOKLYN 41 Route 

14. Wyckoff House, built 1664 of material brought from Hol- 
land. The land was purchased from the Canarsie Indians in 1630 
and has been in the family since that date. *n 

Take the train hack to East New York Station; walk cast three or four 
blocks on Atlantic Avenue. At the corner of Alabama Avenue is 

15. The Howard House, occupying the site of Howard's Half 
Way House. It was from this house that Howe impressed inn- 
keeper Howard and his son as guides to Flatbush at the Battle 
of Long Island. Here Ethan Allen was arrested (9); this was 
also the scene of draft riots during the Civil War when a num- 
ber of men were killed; see the painting (within the hotel) illus- 
trating this event. The building has been much altered. 

Take Broadway " L" road to Palmetto Street Station. Two blocks 
north, at the corner of Evergreen and Woodbine Avenues, is 

16. Suydam House site, now occupied by the Second Germart 
Baptist Church. The house was built in 1724 and was occupied 
by the Hessians during the Revolution. 



255 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




an 



rnf® 



a«*-i^ sr. 



BMtti^" 



D/ A GRAM 

OF 

NEW UTRECHT 

Section 6 £xCi/fMiOf* Kw 



Plate LIT. Routes 42, 43. 



C. K, 



^56 



BROOKLYN 

SECTION v.— FORT HAMILTON, NEW UTRECHT AND 
GRAVESEND 

(Figures refer to Plates LII and LIII). 

ROUTE 42. 

A. BROOKLYN BRIDGE TO FORT HAMILTON 

Take Fifth Avenue Elevated Railroad. 
After leaving St. Mark's Avenue Station, see on the right the 
old Gowanus Canal. 

Leave the train at Third Street. 

See on a building near the foot of the station stairs 

I. Tablet erected by the Sons of the Revolution to commemo- 
rate and giving a representation of the Vechte-Cortelyou House, built 
1699 by Claes Adrientie van Vechten and later occupied by 
Jacques Cortelyou.*i2 

Here Lord Stirling made his famous defence during the Battle 
of Long Island. This house and others nearly as famous, including 
the Bennett-Schermerhorn House at Third Avenue, near Twenty-sixth 
Street (erected in the Seventeenth Century on the site of the original 
house built by Bennett, the pioneer of "The Gowanus"), and the De- 
Hart-Bergen House at Third Avenue, near Thirty-seventh Street, 
(erected before 1679 by Simon Aertsen and described in the Labadist 
Journal) have only recently disappeared. This was the site of the 
original Gowanus Creek, where was the old Freeks Mill (sometimes 
called Brower's Mill), burned in 1776 on the retreat of the Ameri- 
cans. It was built in 1661 and was the oldest tide mill in Brooklyn. 
Near by was Denton's Mill. After passing the Twentieth Street 
Station, see on the left 

2. Greenwood Cemetery, opened in 1842, covers portions of 
the Bennett, Wyckoff and Bergen farms. It contains 474 acres 
and the number of interments up to 1907 was about 340,000. At 
the north entrance (where carriages may be hired, 25 cents), see 
the sculptures of sacred character. The most conspicuous monu- 
ments are the Soldiers' Monument on Battle Hill, the iMremon's 
Monument, the Canda Memorial, the Mackay Mausoleum and 
statues or monuments for Roger Williams, DeWitt Clinton, 
Henry Ward Beecher, Horace Greeley, Samuel F. B. Morse, the 
Brown Brothers and Henry Bergh. *i3 

257 



Route 42 HISTORICAL GUIDE Ft. Hamilton 

After turning into Third Avenue at Thirty-eighth Street, see 
on the right 

3. Old hip-roofed house near Gowanus Bay.*i4 

At Sixty-fifth Street change cars for Fort Hamilton. 

4. The military works at Fort Hamilton were begun in 1808 
by Mayor DeWitt Clinton and the present fort was constructed 
1825-31. It is a stone case-mated structure commanding the 
" Narrows." The military reservation contains 96 acres. General 
Robert E. Lee and " Stonewall " Jackson were stationed here 
previous to the Civil War. The fort covers the site of the old 
Simon Cortelyou House, built in 1699, and purchased by the 
U. S. Government in 1892. General Howe used the house as his 
headquarters in 1776. Cortelyou was a Tory and, on account of 
his ill-treatment of American prisoners, suffered imprisonment. 
After his death the house became a tavern. Nearby was Denyse's 
Ferry, where the British landed August 22, 1776. 

N. B. — Write in advance to the Commandant for a permit. 

5. Fort Lafayette originated as " Fort Diamond " on Diamond 
Reef during the War of 1812, and its name was changed about 
1825 to honor the French hero who was then visiting New York. 
During the Civil War it was used as a military prison. The inte- 
rior was burned in 1868 and it has since been used for the storage 
of ordnance, etc. 

Here, at The Narrows, Verrazano first saw New York Harbor 
and Hudson's men landed just below on Coney Island to bury 
the body of John Coleman, who had been killed by the Indians. 
(But see Excursion X:io). 



258 



BROOKLYN 

ROUTE 43. 

B. NEW UTRECHT 

The land on which the village of New Utrecht now stands was purchased 
from the Indians in 1652 for 6 shirts, 2 pairs of shoes, 6 pairs of stockinRs 6 
adzes, 6 knives, 2 pairs of scissors and 6 combs, and settled shortly after 'in 
1 66 1 the town received a charter; in 1663 it was raided by some Knglish "from 
the east end of Long Island, who claimed this section also; in 1753 a ferry 
was established across the "Narrows" to Staten Island; in 1755 there were (^^ 
slaves in the town. " The town has been purchased three times from the In- 
dians; has received six different government patents and has undergone four 
different changes of government administration." 

From Fort Hamilton take Fifth Avenue trolley and transfer at Eighty- 
sixth Street to ear going east. Get off at Sixteenth Avenue 
and walk north to Eighty-fourth Street. 

6. Dutch Churchyard, in which stands St. John's Lutheran 
Church (entrance on Eighty-fifth Street). Sec many quaint old 
tombstones. The original Dutch Reformed Church of New 
Utrecht formerly stood in this yard. It was an octagonal-shaped 
building with a tall spire. During the Revolution the British 
used it as a hospital and as a riding school. Adjoining the old 
church stood the DeSille (later Van Brunt) House in which 
General Woodhull died. It was built in 1657 and torn down in 
1850. DeSille was a court officer under Stuyvesant. 

7. Nostrand House, with stone wing, corner of Eighty-fourth 
Street and Sixteenth Avenue. The house was bought from John 
Lott, who obtained it from Barrie, who kept a tavern here dur- 
ing the Revolution. When Washington was President, he was 
entertained in this tavern while on a tour of inspection. 

8. Voorhees House, 1531 Eighty-fourth Street, west of (7). an 
old Dutch stone house covered with stucco. (7) and (8) will 
soon be destroyed to make way for street improvements. 

9. Van Brunt House, 1752 Eighty-fourth Street, built about 
1660 and used as quarters for British officers during the Revolu- 
tion. The stone kitchen is the oldest portion of the building. 
It is said that the hickory trees in the rear are over a cctitury 
old, the seeds having been brought from Maryland. 

ID. New Utrecht Dutch Reformed Church, opposite tlic east 
end of Eighty-fourth Street, erected in 1828 at this point t.^ settle 
a controversy. It was organized in 1677 and occupied the site 
of the St. John's Lutheran Church (6) from 1700 to 1828. 



Route 43 HISTORICAL GUIDE New Utrecht 

The old New Utrecht school house occupied this site and was torn 
down to make way for the present church structure. When the news 
of Washington's visit (see 7) was made known, the teacher hned up 
the pupils in front of the school and Washington, dismounting, shook 
hands with every child. Among them was Peter Van Pelt, who be- 
came the well-known Dutch Reformed clergyman of Staten Island. 

11. Liberty Pole in front of the church, the third pole on this 
site, the first having been erected in 1783, the second in 1834 and 
the present one in 1867. See two tablets on the pole. In Octo- 
ber, 1908, a society composed of the descendants of the patriots 
who erected the first pole was incorporated under the laws of 
the State of New York.*i5 

Go north on Eighteenth Avenue to Eighty-first Street. 

12. Van Pelt Manor House. The ancestors of the Van Pelt 
family came to America in 1663, one brother settling in New 
Utrecht, and it is claimed that he erected this house in 1664. 
The land was purchased in 1694 by Aert Tunise (Van Pelt) from 
Hendrick Mathyse Smack. British officers were quartered here dur- 
ing the Revolution. 

The milestone in front of the house dates from 1741 and is the 
private property of the Van Pelt family. *i6 
Go south on Nineteenth Avenue to Eighty-sixth Street, walk east to 

13. Van Pelt House, between Bay Twenty-third and Bay 
Twenty-fourth Streets, built 1812. 

Go south on Bay Twenty-fourth Street to Benson Avenue. 

14. Benson House, originally a Couwenhoven House. 



260 



BROOKLYN 



ROUTE 43a. 

C. GRAVESEND AND CONEY ISLAND 

In 1643 Lady Moody, an Englishwoman, fixed upon this spot as a place where 
she and others could exercise that liberty of conscience denied to her by her 
own people. She was a woman of force, education and refinement and it was 
not long before she became a power in the community. The town of Cravesend 
was originally laid out in a square, and two cross roads divided this into four 
equal squares which were cut up into 40 lots for as many settlers; curiously, 
only 39 parts are ever mentioned. The town soon grew beyond these limits 
but never attained to the growth and prosperity of its neighbors. 

Coney Island was part of the above grant. It belonged to the Canarsie 
Indians and was called by them " Narrioch " and by the Dutch " Conynge 
Hook." It was granted by Governor Kieft to Guyspert Op Dyck and later 
was held by DeWolf until Governor Nicolls gave it in 1668 to the town of 
Gravesend. In 1685 it was divided into 40 lots which were held by various 
families until 1734. when Thomas Stilwell obtained the whole island. In 1829 
was erected the Coney Island House, the first hotel on the Island. Modern 
Coney Island began in 1844 when a " Pavilion " was erected. Since that 
time the place has grown steadily as an amusement center. Coney Island Creek 
has been partly filled in, so the place is no longer an island. 



M 







<^/ZAV£S£A/D. 



t5* 



en 



mm. 
ortr 



® i 



5*ct/'on^^^ 



^xci/rsjo/t y//f 



Plate LIII. Route 43a. 



C. K. 



261 



Route 43a HISTORICAL GUIDE Gravesend 

From Coney Island take Reid Avenue car to Gravesend, getting off at 
Neck Road, walk west on Neck Road, passing 

15. Hicks-Platt House, a well-preserved Dutch stone house 
covered with stucco. It is claimed that this house was on the 
Bouwerie of Lady Moody and built in 1643; that Stuyvesant and 
Kieft were entertained here and that it was used as a hospital 
during the Revolution. *i7 

16. Bergen House, near the corner of Van Sicklen Street. 

Turn south on Van Sicklen Street to 

17. Lake House, in a good state of preservation, built about 1800. 
It is on the site of the houses of the first Lakes in Gravesend. 
Return to Neck Road, walk cast and on the south side near the M. E. 

Church see 

18. Old Gravesend Town Cemetery. 

Continue east, crossing the railroad track to Village Road; turn south 

to 

19. Williamson House, well-preserved. 

Return to Neck Road. 

20. Stilwell House, 95 Neck Road, corner Village Road. 

21. Emans House, further to the east, on the south side of 
the road. 

22. Lake House, between East Fourth Street and the Boule- 
vard. 

Continue on Neck Road, crossing the Boulevard or Ocean Parkway. 

23. Old Dutch House. 

24. Voorhees-Sheppard House, opposite Homecrest Avenue, 
built in 1730. 

25. Van Cleef House, corner East Sixteenth Street and Neck 
Road. 

Return by Brighton Beach Elevated Road. 



262 



BROOKLYN 

ADDITIONAL NOTES ON FLATLANDS 
By Frederick Van Wyck. 

The first deed of land on Long Island was made to Andrics Mudde 
(Hudden) and Wolphert Gerretsen Van Kouwenhoven on June i6, 
1636, and comprised the land from Flatbush to the ocean and 
Gravesend to Paardegat Outlet, excepting Bergen's Island (Ber- 
gen Beach). The latter was granted to Captain John Underhiil 
in 1646 for aid in fighting Indians. 

Hudde never resided at Nieuw Amersfoort, but Van Kouwenhoven 
made there in 1636 the earliest settlement by Europeans on Long 
Island, his plantation, Achterveldt (after or across the Plain) con- 
sisting of 3600 acres within the triangle bounded by the old road from 
Flatbush to Flatlands on the west, th6 road from Flatlands to 
Flatlands Neck and New Lots on the southeast, and the old con- 
lecting road (Hubbard's Lane) on the northeast. This became 
later the Village of Flatlands, the Dutch church being located at 
the head of a small stream leading to Jamaica Bay. The site of 
the church was the seat of Indian religious rites and an Indian 
burial place. Indian remains are still found here. 

Adjoining the Indian burial plot is the public school plot, a deed 
from the Van Kouwenhovens' successors showing it to have been 
used for school purposes in 1695, making it probably the oldest public 
school property in New York. 

The houses of Wm. H. Kouwenhoven on the east side of Flat- 
lands Neck Road near Avenue H, and of the late George Kouwen- 
hoven, near the bridge over the Paardegat Outlet and Avenue G, 
are on land which has never been out of the possession of the family aud 
are on land included in the original grant. (Second house burned 1910 ) 

The white oak tree on Avenue G, west of Neck Road (called 
Amusketahole by the Indians), stands on the southeast co'rner of 
the former town of Flatbush and was marked on October 17, 1666, by 
arbitrators appointed by Governor Nicolls to settle a boundary line 
dispute between Flatbush and Flatlands. It is mentioned in the 
patent dated March 11, 1685, by Governor Dongan to the inhabi- 
tants of Flatlands. 



26Z 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ADDENDA, 1912 

*i (p. 241). The "Guide to the Windows," to be obtained within, 
describes the 28 windows which set forth the influence of Puritanism 
upon the liberties of the Republic. In one of the church parlors may be 
seen the four flags presented by Beecher, May 21, 1861, to the Beecher 
Regiment (the 67th N. Y. Volunteers) and returned to the church. 
May 21, 1910, by the survivors; also the original bill of sale of the slave 
and a painting of Beecher Selling the Slave. Read "Life of Beecher" 
by his son, and "Reminiscences of Plymouth Church," by S. M, 
Griswold. 

The "Beecher Memorial," an institutional building, is to be erected 
in 1912-13 west of Plymouth Church by members of the Arbuckle family. 
The arcade will bear bas-reliefs commemorating the anti-slavery 
struggle; a bronze statue by Borglum will be placed in the little park in 
front, representing Beecher selling the slave. 

*2 (p. 242). See within the rotunda of Borough Hall portraits of 
former Mayors of Brooklyn ; in the Court House are portraits of 
Supreme Court justices, etc. 

The First Reformed Chiireh stood originally (1666-1807) on the site 
of the department store of Abraham & Straus, but was removed in 
1807 to Joralemon Street, near Borough Hall, and in 1835 it occupied 
the site of Murphy Park, in the rear of the Hall. 

The Old Mansion House, a well-known hostelry, stands on Hicks 
Street, between Clark and Pierrepont Streets. 

*3 (p. 244). The U. S, Naval Museum, founded by naval officers 
in 1833, has a library and collection of historic relics. The old 
War of '12 frigate Vermont at the Cob Dock is used as a receiving 
ship, recruiting station and house for recruits and sailors awaiting 
assignment to service. 

*4 (p. 249). Inside the church is a tablet erected 1910 by the 
Colonial Daughters of the Seventeenth Century to commemorate the 
original building erected in 1663. 

*5 (p. 249). The Schenck House was built in 1656 by Captain John 
Schenck on Mill Island. It is probably the oldest house in New York 
City still standing as originally erected. 

*6 (p. 240). The Bergen House was built shortly after (2), but has 
been much altered. 

*7 (p- 253). The Snedeker House is gone, but another old house, 
recently remodeled, stands near its site. 

264 



BROOKLYN 

The National Cemetery, a short distance east, contains many graves 
of Union soldiers and some Civil War cannon. 

An extensive view may be had from the top of the hill, near the 
reservoir. Remains of an old mill lie in the pond just east.' 

*8 (p. 253). The Schenck House is used as a tool house for the 
new Highland Park. 

*9 (p. 254). This is also called the Henry Rapelye House, and is 
said to have been built about 1672. 

*io (p. 254). Parts of an older house are incorporated in the Schenck 
House. 

*ii (p. 255). To reach the Wyckoff House take a Reid Avenue car 
to Utica and Church Avenues; walk south on Utica six blocks to 
Canarsie Lane, then east four blocks, past Kouwenhoven Place. The 
house is one block west of the Manhattan Beach R. R. Opposite it are 
the remains of another Dutch house, once used as a barn by the 
Suydams. 

*I2 (p. 257). The Vechte-Cortelyou House remains on the old site, 
but it is completely buried on account of filling in the hollow here. It 
has been proposed to unearth it and set it up in a near-by park (read 
"The Stone House at Gowanus"). 

At Third Avenue and Seventh Street see the slab in the sidewalk 
with the following inscription: "Burial place of ye 250 Maryland 
soldiers who fell in ye combat at ye Cortelyou House in ye Battle of 
Long Island on ye 27th day of August, 1776." Graves were visible 
here in 1900, before the land was filled to level the ground. 

*I3 (p. 257). See also the Pilots' Monument, given by N. Y. Harbor 
pilots; Sea Captains' Monument to Capt. John Correja ; Fire Monu- 
ment to victims of the Brooklyn Theatre fire of December, 1876. 

*I4 (p. 258). At Thirty-ninth Street and Church Avenue, near the 
east end of the cemetery, are two old houses of Dutch architecture. 

*i5 (p. 260). The fourth liberty pole was erected in August. 1910, 
through the generosity of Mr. and Mrs. Towns and Cortelyou Van Pelt. 

*i6 (p. 260). The milestone and a small plot of land around it have 
been presented to the city, and the City History Club plan to mark 
the stone with a tablet. 

*I7 (p. 262). C. A. Ditmas says Lady Moody never owned this 
house, her property being at the other side of the town square. The 
land was owned by Ralph Cardell (?), who later purchased Lady 
Moody's home, hence the error. The house has been completely altered, 
but contains portions of the original structure. 

a65 



NOTES 



266 



NOTES 



267 



NOTES 



268 



PART FOUR 



BOROUGH OF QUEENS. 



EXCURSION NO. XI.-^HISTORIC QUEENS. 

By Frank Bergen Kelley 

Compiled from an Unpublished Manuscript Entitled 

"ANCIENT LANDMARKS OF QUEENS BOROUGH" 

By J. H. Innes 

Author of "New Amsterdam and Its People," "The Old Bark Mill, 
or First Place of Religious Worship in New York," etc. 

I 

Copyright, 1908, by the City History Club of New York. 

Revised 1912, with the Aid of Robert E. Parsons and other Members 
OF the Flushing Historical Society. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




C. K. 



Plate LIV. Old Tracts and Routes in Newtown. 



272 



QUEENS 



Bibliography 

"History of Long Island," (2 vols.) by B. F. Thompson, gives 
general information in regard to the various towns. 

"History of Long Island," by Nathaniel S. Prime, includes many 
interesting particulars as to church matters. 

" Antiquities of Long Island," by Gabriel Furman. 

"Queens County in Olden Times," by Henry Onderdonck. 

" History of Queens County," by Munsell. 
•"Annals of Newtown," by James Riker, Jr. (scarce). 

Newspaper articles on Queens, written, 1880-90, by \Vm. O'Gor- 
man, Town Clerk of Newtown, and articles on " Ancient Newtown — 
formerly Middelburgh," 1898, by J. H. Innes (may be found in the 
N. Y. Historical Society Library). 

" New Amsterdam and Its People," by J. H. Innes. 

"History of the Town of Flushing," by H. D. Waller. 

"Travels in America," by John Davis. 

"Journal of a Tour in New York," (pp. 25-36) by John Fowler. 

"Historical Long Island," by R. R. Wilson. 

"Early Life in Long Island," by M. B. Flint. 

N. B.— The City History club is greatly indebted to Mr. J. II. Innes, 
through whose scholarship, unwearied energy and courtesy this EX- 
CURSION has been made possible. 

Thanks are also due for research and the preparation of copy 
and charts for the press to teachers and students of the Bryant. 
Jamaica and DeWitt Clinton High Schools, and to many residents of 
Flushing, Newtown and Jamaica. 

Additional Bibliography 

"Long Island Historic Houses," by Henry L Whittemore. 
" The Quaker Cross : A Story of the Old Bowne House," by Cornelia 
Mitchell Parsons. 



273 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

HISTORICAL SKETCH OF QUEENS 

The Borough of Queens of the City of New York was formed on 
January i, 1898, from the former townships of Newtown, Flushing 
and Jamaica, together with Long Island City and a small portion of 
the town of Hempstead, embracing the Far Rockaway and Rockaway 
Beach district of that town. This territory, forming the western 
portion of the old County of Queens, was reorganized at the time 
mentioned and became the County of Queens, while the eastern por- 
tion of the former county received a new organization and became 
known as the County of Nassau. 

The first settlements in this territory were made by individual 
Dutch farmers from 1637 to 1656, under grants from the Director- 
General and Council at New Amsterdam, in what may be described 
in a general way as the districts forming the present Long Island 
City. They were under the direct supervision of New Amsterdam 
authorities and were known as the Out Plantations. The remain- 
der of the present borough was settled entirely by colonists from 
various parts of New England under grants from the Dutch authori- 
ties at New Amsterdam. They received township governments, but 
modelled after the Dutch form, and their villages received Dutch 
appellations. There were, however, originally no Dutch settlers 
among them except in one or two isolated cases. In course of time 
many Dutch bought lands among them. These settlements were made 
as follows : In the spring of 1642 a patent was issued to Rev. 
Francis Doughty (for himself and a party of associates) of the 
remainder of the land included in the former town of Newtown. Un- 
der this patent a settlement was begun, principally along the Mespat 
Kill, afterwards known as Newtown Creek, but it was destroyed in 
the Indian war of 1643. In 1644 Heemstede (Hempstead) was settled 
by a company from Watertown, Wethersfield and Stamford in New 
England. In 1645-6 Vlissingen (Flushing) was settled, and in 1652 
Middclhurg (Newtown), in the old Doughty patent, — in both cases 
by colonists from Massachusetts and Connecticut, while in 1656 Rust- 
dorp (Jamaica) was settled by a party from Hempstead and Flush- 
ing. The above were the only settlements in the territory of the bor- 
ough for a long period, except that in 1656, after the second Indian 
war, the inhabitants along the Mespat Kill were for a short time gath- 
ered for security into a village called Arnhem, on what was known 
as Smith's Island in the Mespat Kill; this village was abandoned 
in 1662. 

274 



QUEENS 

The history of Hempstead and Jamaica was uneventful during the 
Dutch rule, but in Flushing and in Middclburg there was consider- 
able dissatisfaction, the people of the latter place going so far as to 
attempt to put themselves under the jurisdiction of Connecticut and 
to alter the name of their town to Hastings in 1663. After the 
surrender to the English in 1664, these towns were organized for the 
purposes of civil administration into what was known as the IV est 
Riding of Yorkshire (in analogy to the civil divisions bearing the 
same name in Yorkshire, England), with a Sessions House for judi- 
cial and administrative business at Jamaica. The names of the 
towns were now changed, but Heemstcdc being so simihir in form 
to the English town of Hempstead, and Flissingcn being so well 
known to the English under the name of Flushing, these forms were 
retained, while Rustdorp reverted to its Indian name of Jamaica, and 
Middelburg received the name of Newtown, together with a patent 
in 1667 by which the former Out Plantations were added to it. In 
1683 these towns, together with the eastern town of Oyster Bay, 
were united to form the County of Queens with its court house and 
other county buildings at Jamaica. This organization remained un- 
disturbed unti4 after the Revolution. In 1814 Jamaica, then vv)th a 
population of 1500, became an incorporated village, as did Flushing 
in 1837, with a population of about 20'.x>. Soon after the introduction 
of steam navigation, and as early as 181 1, Astoria began to attract 
attention as a place of suburban residence and in 1839 it was incorpo- 
rated as a village. About 1853-4 Whitestone (formerly a mere ham- 
let) began to grow from the establishment there of a factory of 
tinned and japanned ware, while College Point owed its growth as 
a village at about the same time to the setting up of a factory of hard 
rubber ware, though it was not incorporated until 1880. 

In 1836 the Brooklyn and Jamaica Railroad was opened, its first 
time-table taking effect on April 26 of that year. On March i, 1837, 
under the auspices of the Long Island Railroad, it was opened through 
Queens County to Hicksville, and to its terminus in Greenport in 
1844. The New York and Flushing Railroad was opened June 26, 
1854, its East River terminus being a dock at Hunter's Point near the 
mouth of Newtown Creek, from which it connected a few times daily 
with one of the Harlem boats for the lower part of New York. In 
1861 the terminus of the Long Island Railroad was changed horn 
Brooklyn to Hunter's Point, soon after which the latter place began 
to grow rapidly until, in 1871, with Astoria, Dutch Kills and the 
surrounding districts, it was incorporated as Long Island City. 

275 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




QUEENS 

The * refers to Addenda, 1912, p. 314. 

ROUTE 44. 

SECTION I.-HUNTER'S POINT AND STEINWAY TO 
NORTH BEACH. 

(Figures refer to Plate LV, letters to LIV). 

Thirty-fourth Street Ferry to Huntc/s Point, Stcinway trolley to 

the Plaza end of Queenshoro Bridge; or car 

from Fifty-ninth Street, Manhattan, across 

Queenshoro Bridge. 

K. Dominie's Hook. — Originally an island surrounded by salt water marshes, 
possessed by Dominie Everardus Bogardus and his wife Anneke Jans BoKardus. 
about 1642; later confirmed by patent, and still later owned by the Bennett 
family, who sold much of it to Dr. Nott of Union College, from whom it came 
to the trustees of that institution. In 1842 it was connected with VVilliamsl)urR, 
Greenpoint, Ravenswood and Astoria by a turnpike, now known as \'crnon 
Avenue. In 1854 the New York and Flushing Railroad was opened, starting 
from a pier at the foot of Newtown Creek, with boat connection to New 
York. It was now for a short time called Nottston, and became a subject for 
land speculation. In 1861 it became the terminal for the L. I. R. R., and began 
to grow under the name of Hunter's Point. 

The original farmhouse was on the shore of Newtown Creek, near the 
present bridge to Greenpoint. The later farmhouse, standing until recently, was 
a little farther back from the Creek. 

a-a. Line of ancient road from " Maspcth Kill " (Newtown Creek) along 
Dutch Kills to Burger Jorissen's Mill, thence to East River, laid out 1640-54. 

1. Site of Van Alst House (east side of Barn Street, north of L. I. R. R.), 
Dutch Kills, recently removed. The original house, just south, was on the old 
farm of Jan Jansen of Ditmars ("Jan Platneus," or Flatnose), 1643, and on his 
death, in 1651, was sold to Joris Stevensen, ancestor of the \^^n Alst family. 
The creek near by (Indian name " Canapaukah ") was called Caper's (nrivatecrs- 
man's) Kill, as Stevensen had been a seafaring man. The Van Alst burial 
ground, now almost blotted out, was at the intersection of Barn Street on the 
north side of the L. I. R. R. For an account of Indian events near by, see 
** New Amsterdam and its People," pp. 167-8 

2. Paynter House (Skillman Avenue, corner Jackson), prob- 
ably on the site of the house of Burger Jorissen, blacksmith, of 
New Amsterdam (Excursion VII), who had a grant here in 
1643. Here he built the Paynter House, burned, Jan. i, 1913. 

3a. First mill in this part of Long Island (called Ryerson's Mill during the 
Revolution); i*. . ^. , , r-, •,, 

3. The mill pond, now overgrown with reeds. The dam (just north of Skill- 
man Avenue) was removed in 1861, when the L. I. R. R. was built. 

b-b. Burger's Sluice, constructed through the swamp to supply the pond, 
Still exists in a few places as a dry ditch paralleling the railroad tracks 

Continue on Steinway Avenue car to Grand Avenue, 



277 



Route 44 HISTORICAL GUIDE Steinway 

4. Site of John Hallett's Farmhouse, southeast corner Grand and Steinway 
Avenues, The large farm, patented in 1654 to Wm. Hallett, lay northeast of 
this point. In the Revolution it belonged to Wm. Lawrence, a strong patriot. 
Here Maj.-Gen, Robertson took up quarters on August 30, 1776, and encamped 
10,000 British soldiers north of the house. Two weeks later he withdrew, 
crossing to Westchester, and Gen, DeHeister's Hessians succeeded them. Many 
balls from the American battery at Hoorn's Hook fell on the heights back of 
the house. 

5. Samuel Hallett Farmhouse, on a height north of the inter- 
section of Newtown and Grand Avenues, is supposed to have 
been built by Samuel Hallett (a great-great-grandson of the 
patantee; see 17) about 1752, *2 

6. Site of the House of Wm. Hallett (grandson of the patentee), near the 
corner of Newtown and Jamaica Avenues, where (Jan. 24, 1708), with his wife 
and five children, he was murdered by two of his negro slaves (" Riker's 
Annals," p, 142). , , . , 

c. Site of the Ridge Road to Dutch Kills, now nearly closed or obliterated. 

7. Middletown, a hamlet, begun about 1800, near the old school- 
house of 1721. Only one or two houses remain. 

Continue north on Steinway Avenue to old Boivery Road, passing on 

the left 

B. Lubhert's, or the Great Swamp, dry now, as the trees have 
been cut, 

d-d. Old Bowery Road, now partly obliterated, laid out i638-'50 
by settlers of the Poor Bowery and the Out Plantations. 

Walk east on IVinthrop Avenue; continue on Shore Road 

8. Moore House, well preserved, one of the oldest build- 
ings in New York, standing on what was once a parcel of 50 
acres of woodland reserved by the West India Company, possibly 
for ship timber. After 1664 it was patented to Wm, Hallett, who 
had already bought up the Indian title. In 1684 he sold it to 
Captain Samuel Moore, son of the Rev, John Moore (see p. 291), 
who built this house for himself and his son Joseph in 1690-95. 
In 1769 it was sold to Jeromus Remsen. Here in 1757 several 
French prisoners of war were lodged on parole, and it is said 
that they spent much time hunting near by. About 1776 it was 
occupied by the militia officer, Colonel Jeromus Remsen, who had 
to take refuge in New Jersey during the British occupation. 



278 



Bowery Bay QUEENS 44 Route 

9, 10. 17th Century Houses, near the bend of the Rowcry liay 
Road. The Bowery Bay schoolhouse, built in 1829, stuud near 
the bend. The Totten Homestead stands opposite. 

11. Rapalye House (dating before 1750), probably on the site 
of the original homestead, and standing in front of the old 
family burying-ground. Here Harck Siboutsen of New Amstcr 
dam settled about 1650, receiving his ground brief in 1654. In 
1729 his son Jacobus willed it to Abraham Lent, his nephew. 
Dr. Riker, a family connection, took reluge here from the Brit- 
ish after the battle of Long Island. About 1800 the house came 
into the possession of Isaac Rapalye, who held it nearly half 
a century. 

12. Riker Homestead, a rare example of property remaining 
in the same direct family line and name since the first settle- 
ment. Abraham Ryker married the daughter of Hendrick Har- 
rrtensen, the first settler of this part of Long Island, and secured 
the patent for this land in 1654. The present house is r8th cen- 
tury in style and possibly contains part of the original house. 

C. The Poor Bowery (North Beach), historically one of the most interesting 
portions of Long Island, was settled by Hendrick Harmensen in 1638. when he 
brought cattle here from New Amsterdam. He was for several years the only 
farmer of the north side of Long Island, and was called Hcnrxcus AgricoLj. 
Hendrick, the Boor (farmer) in the Doughty patent of 1642. He was killed 
by Indians in 1643 and his widow succeeded to the Bowery and married 
Jeuriaen Fradell of New Amsterdam in 1645, who the same year obtained 
a ground brief for the farm from Kieft. It contained 154 acres, besides the 
Houwclicken (Dowry Island, later Luysters) of Bowery Bay, separated by a salt 
water creek. 

The deacons of the Dutch Church bought the farm before 1654, to establish 
maintenance for their poor, hence it was called *' Armen " or " Poor Bowery." 
About 1688, they sold it to Pieter Cornelissen Timmermann (also called 
Luyster), the first of that family here. It remained until lately in the possession 
of the (Touwenhovens (descendants of the last named owner). 

e-e. The rivulet surrounding the lands of " Hendrick the farmer " (as it 
is described in the Doughty patent of 1642), still flows south of the Bowery, 
draining 

D. Trains Meadow, used as a common fresh meadow by English settlers 
of Middelburg (Newtown) as early as 1662, some of the earlier drains bcinvr 
still visible. It was first recorded as Long Trayncs Meadow (Long Drains 
Meadow?). It was divided among the settlers in 1678, and part is still a wild 
and secluded jungle. The " rivulet " was later piled U'cssclls or Lodowwk s 
Brook, the Indian name being " Sackhichneyah." 

13. Kouwenhoven Farmhouse, now forming the rear of a 
hotel, probably occupies the site of the original house of C 
The whole tract is now the property of the North Beach Im- 
provement Co. *3 

Continue through North Beach along the trolley line, crossing thr 

bridge. 

279 



Route 44 HISTORICAL GUIDE Bowery Bay 

14. Jackson's Mill Pond, now nearly dry, the mill (near the 
bridge) being operated first by Warner Wessells, and destroyed 
by the Indians in 1655. It was re-established by Pieter Cornelis- 
sen Luyster, before 1670. It was later known as Kip's and Fish's 
Mill. 

f.f. Old Road from the vicinity of the present Corona to this mill, laid out 
about 1662. 

15. Farmhouse of Abraham and John I. Rapalye (i8th cen- 
tury), just across the bridge on the right, on that part of the 
13,000-acre tract patented by Rev. Francis Doughty (1642), re- 
served for his own use. It came to the Stevenson family and 
(about 1700) to Jesse Kip, their connection by marriage. The 
present house was probably built by Captain Thos. Hazard, to 
whom the farm belonged, shortly after 1724. 

16. Site of Rev. Francis Doughty's House, or the house built by 
his son-in-law, Adriaen Van der Donck, the jurist and determined 
opponent of Peter Stuyvesant. It was on or near the site of the late 
Strong residence. It was for years the home of the Rapalye, Remsen 
and Strong families (in lineal descent), and is described by John 
Davis in his " Travels in America," i8oo-'oi, as the seat of his fre- 
quent entertainment. A shore road probably existed at the time of 
the original settlement. 

Return by trolley from North Beach or walk to the Jackson Avenue 

line. 



280 



QUEENS 

ROUTE 45. 

SECTION II.-ASTORIA TO STEINWAY. 

(Figures refer to Plate LVI; letters to LIV). 

Astoria Ferry from East Ninety-second Street, Manhattan. 

See on the left, Hell Gate, Great and Little Mill Rock, Ward's 
and Blackwell's Islands on the south (Excursion V, Section 7). 
Astoria was originally known as Hallett's Point; the bay just below 
the point is still called Hallett's Cove and that above Pot Cove. The 
latter is the scene of the wreck described in Irving's " Knickerbocker 
History of New York." 

In i860, Astoria and Ravenswood were a favorite suburban resi- 
dence district, but are now greatly deteriorated in portions. Until 
1800 this was the almost exclusive possession of the Hallctt family 
(see Historical Sketch of Queens). 

Walk up Fulton Avenue to Main Street. 

17. Hallett House (i8th century), near northeast corner Main 
Street and Shore Boulevard, on or near the site of the ancient 
stone homestead of Wm. Hallett, original patentee of 1500 acres 
here. The shore portion had been granted before 1638 to Jacques 
Bentyn of Van Twiller's Council, who is supposed to have built 
a house here destroyed by the Indians in 1643. In 1654 it was 
granted by Stuyvesant to Hallett, whose house was also de- 
stroyed by Indians in 1655, and rebuilt on the same spot about 
1670, where it remained until supplanted by the present house, 
about a century later. 

18. Hallett House (opposite 17) on the site of the original 
house built by the patentee for his son William, prior to 1678, 
and burned in 1770, 

19. Stevens House (Boulevard, between Temple and Elm 
Streets), built for a country residence by General Ebenezer Stevens, 
who purchased the land from the Halletts not long after the Revolu- 
tion, and named it Mt. Napoleon. Here on July 14, 1813, he gave a 
dinner to Mayor DeWitt Clinton and several prominent military men 
on the occasion of the inauguration of military works on Hallett's 
Point (known as Castle Stevens and Castle Bogardus) for protec- 
tion against the British. 

281 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate LVI. Route 45. 
282 



C. K. 



Astoria QUEENS 45 Route 

S-S. Sunswick Creek, now small, but once sufficient to help feed a 
latlr-k'nown'a" s'uydam's^ Mm?"*'' °"^^ '""^ ^'""'^''^ °^ ^^P^-" J-"^^ ^^'-^'we... 

stolid neT'^he fr^f'Tebste'' StT^^t/" *'^ ''''''' ^^'^ ^^ *^<= '^*^ C-^-^. 
h. Ha//^f^ Lan^ from the old Hallett dock followed the line of Main and 
Greenoak Streets (past the farm buildings of Wm. Hallett, Jr.), throuRh St 
Georges Place, Welling Street (between the Hallett orchards), Main Street. 
Newtown Avenue and Grand Avenue to "The Narrow Passage" (see 44) and 
Newtown, ^^ 

22. Site of the Hallett burying ground, adjoining the old Astoria 
Methodist Church, built in 1843, and now used as stores and a tene- 
ment (near junction of Main Street and Fulton Avenue). 

23. Site of House of Jas. Hallett (great-grandson of the patentee) near corner 
Flushing Avenue and Hallett Street. Van Alst Avenue was laid out in 1774 as 
a narrow road between Jas. Hallett's garden and orchard to give the farms 
along the river access to the cove and was provided with two swinging gates. 
It was in constant use by the British during the Revolution, (For other Hallett 
farms see 4, 5, 6 in Section I.) 

Walk Up the hill past the Public Library to Franklin Street and go 

west. 

24. St. George's Episcopal Church, on the site of the first 
church erected at Hallett's Cove in 1828, the old graveyard lying 
just below^. 

25. Blackwell Mansion, between Remsen and Woolsey Streets, 
one of the first houses erected here after the breaking up of 
the Hallett farms. 

Other Blackwell houses are at the northeast corner Franklin 
and Remsen Streets, and on Franklin Avenue opposite Wardcll 
Street. 

26. Reformed Dutch Church of Hallett's Cove, near Remsen 
Street, cornerstone laid in 1836. 

27. Presbyterian Church, near Stevens Street, erected 1846-7. 

Return on Franklin Avenue and go north on IVoolscy Street to the 

Boulevard. 

i-i. Lawrence Lane (later Linden Street and now Hoyt Avenue), till lately 
lined with lindens. Fly, Vh or Vleigh Brook, 100 feet south, separatrng the 
Lawrence and Hallett estate's. It was named from Luhbert's Vly or swamp 
(see B, Sec. I) and its deep bed may yet be seen from behind houses on lloyt 
Avenue. 

Walk along the Boulevard to Winthrop Avenue. 

The Shore Road Boulevard about 1880 formed one of the finest 

roads about New York, being well macadamized, protected by a sea 

wall and lined with well-kept suburban residences. Although this 

section has deteriorated, it will probably remain a residence «li^triot. 

283 



Route 45 HISTORICAL GUIDE Astoria 

as the channel of the river is too narrow and the current too swift 
for docking purposes. 

28. Site of the Edward_ Woolsey House, corner Woolsey Avenue, burnt in 
1898. This tract was originally patented to Anneke Jans and later bought by 
Thos. Lawrence, who purchased all the farms in this neighborhood to lay the 
foundation of a great estate. A house was built just before 1726 when this 

Eart was sold to Joris Rapalye. who held it until 1768, when the house was 
urned and the farm came back to the Lawrences, and the late mansion was 
built. In Revolutionary days it was the home of Jonathan Lawrence, a wealthy 
New York merchant patriot, who was forced to abandon it during the British 
occupation. Philip J. Livingston lived here and the soldiers destroyed most of 
the timber. Later it came into the possession of the Woolseys, connected by 
marriage with the Lawrences. The park-like grounds lie neglected, but there 
is reason to believe that they may be purchased by the city for a public park. 

29. A. D. Ditmars House, corner Ditmars Avenue, on a tract 
originally patented to Philip Geraerdy, proprietor of the White 
Horse Tavern (see " New Amsterdam and its People," p. 12). 
His widow sold it to the Lawrences, and Daniel Lawrence had a 
house and farm here prior to 1719, when he sold it to Wm. Pen- 
fold, an English sea captain and marriage connection. 

The dock, just north, is said to have been the point of embarka- 
tion for the Hessians in their pursuit of the Americans through 
Westchester. 

After the war the place was brought by Dr. Dow Ditmars, whose 
son, Abraham D. Ditmars, was the first Mayor of Long Island 
City. The building is over 100 years old and possibly contains 
portions of the original house. 

30. Ancient stone house, corner Wolcott Street, on a walled 
bank. Here, in 1653, Teunis Craie, town crier of New Amster- 
dam, obtained 74 acres from the Dutch Government (" New 
Amsterdam and its People," p. 89). In 1654 he leased it to his 
son Geurt, on condition that he and Gerrittsen Vries clear 8 
acres and deliver to him annually " 100 pieces of merchantable 
firewood." Improvements were stopped by the Indian war of 
1655. It was bought in 1681 by Hendrick Martensen Wiltsee, of 
Copenhagen, who built a house on the site. He resisted the 
Lawrences' endeavors to obtain the property, and in 1706 he 
turned it over to his son Teunis, who sold most of it to Daniel 
and John Lawrence. The Wiltsees remained in the old house 
until 1737, when they sold it to Richard Berrien, and either he 
or Jacob Rapalye, the next owner, built the present house, which 
is one of the best preserved specimens of an i8th century farm- 
house. 

Turn east on Winthrop Avenue. 

284 



Steinway QUEENS 45 Route 

d-d. Bowery Bay Road is now largely closed (Section I) 

■y]. Berrien's Lane, running towards Berrien's Island. Near the shore stoo.l 
once Cornelius Berrien s farmhouse, erected about 1727. At the south end of 
the lane stood the little school of 1735, on a lot one rod square, and used for 
100 years. 

31. Wyckoflf House (i8th century), on the hill above Rapalye 
Street, on the site of the house of Simon Joosten, to whom 54 
acres were granted in 1654. It was bought by the Lawrences, 
held until 1732, and then sold to Cornelius WyckofT. (It is now 
called the Peter Rapalye House.) 

Z2. Kouwenhoven House (late 17th century), on the site of the 
first residence of the Lawrences, who bought up in all 700-800 
acres. In 1732 it was sold to Wm. Leverich, who held it iov some 
years. 

2)2>. Burial ground of the Lawrence and Leverich families, 
nearly opposite Z^^ well kept and crowded with monuments. 

Return by Steinway car to Thirty-fourth Street Ferry or transfer to 

Astoria. 



285 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




MA5P£TJ/\lAl//!f£L ///IL 



Plate LVII. Route 46. 



C. K. 



286 



QUEENS 



ROUTE 46 

SECTION III.-MASPETH AND LAUREL HILL. 

(Figures refer to Plate LVII; letters to LIV.) 

Take Grand Street car from Manhattan terminus of Williamsburg 
Bridge, or Flushing Avenue (Newtown) car from Brooklyn Bridge to 
Old Flushing Road. From here may be made a side trip south (see 
below). 

k-k. Road from the Ferry (Flushing and Covert Avenues, alonp; east shore of 
Maspeth Kill, to the bowery of Joris Rapalye and Hans Hansen (Hcr^'cn), 
scene of Doughty's first settlement. The road was laid out by (he Dutch 
settlers in 1642. In 1643 they were attacked by Indians, when most of the 
houses were destroyed, few ever being reoccupied. 

Walk zvest, crossing L. I. R. R. Tracks to 

34. Queens Head Tavern, southeast corner Maspeth and Flush- 
ing Avenues, built supposedly by the town and leased by various 
landlords. It became a resort for soldiers during the Revolution, 
later was a well-known stage house and is still in good repair as 
a private house. 

35. DeWitt Clinton House, (diagonally opposite) built about 
1725 by Joseph Sackett, Judge of Common Pleas. Riker claims 
that it was afterward the residence of Walter Franklin, an opu- 
lent New York merchant, till his death in 1780, and after him of 
Colonel Corsa, of French and Indian War fame. DeWitt Clin- 
ton married a daughter of Franklin, a niece of Corsa. *4 

36. The Town Dock stood just west, under the L. I. R. R. tracks, on a 
salt-water inlet nearly silted up at present. Here farmers brought their produce 
to be loaded on shallow market boats for New York. It was laid out by tlie 
commissioners in September, 1722, and used until the Revohition, when it be- 
came a landing place for British supplies, General Warren having headquarters 
in the Clinton House. In 1792 the Town voted to rebuild tlie dock at public 
expense and to erect a store house here, dockmasters being elected annually. 
After the establishment of steam ferries it gradually fell into disuse and wa« 
finally abandoned in 1865, rapidly going to decay. 

37. Site of Wav Farmhouse on the knoll west of the dock, the original home- 
stead of that family in Newtown. In 1815 the Furmans bought the place and 
erected a pretentious mansion, now demolished, on the site. Two rooms wore 
papered with scenes from Telemachus and Parisian views. Sec the Mott I'ri- 
VATE Burying Ground near by. A later Furman House remains across the 
street. Ancestors of Dr. N'alentine Mott rest here. 

E. Smith's Island (now called Furman Island), named from either Richard 
Smith (a partner of Francis Doughty in the first town natent) or Hcn.lrick 
Barent Smith, an early settler whose land ran from Flushing Av.-mi<- Here 
the Dutch laid out the village of Arnhem. 

287 



Route 46 HISTORICAL GUIDE Maspeth 

Go back to 35 and walk north on Belts Avenue, passing on the left 

38. Underbill Covert Farmhouse, with several old barns, dat- 
ing back to the early i8th Century. John Denman first located 
here about 1662. One barn is said to be the original homestead. 

39. Site of the Belts Homestead, recently torn down to "lake way for the 
Mt Zion Cemetery, northeast corner Nevytown ^"d Betts Avenues Here Cap^ 
tain Betts located in 1652, and here he lived until his death at the age ot 100 
in 1713. A \ ^ 

1. Old Brook School Road (including part of Newtown Avenue) used as a 
short cut to Calamus Creek and existing in 1682 Later it was extended soutn. 

40. Site of the Old Brook School House, built about i739, and only lately 

'^ZZ Fresh Pond Road, so-called from a large pond "°w, ^"^^,^f i^^'^'j^e^o 
east angle of this road and Mt. Olivet Avenue. It was .^ajd out about 1680 
to give access to disputed lands near the present cemeteries of Cypress Hills 
and the Evergreens. ■,- -a a a 

S Tract at iunction of Fresh Pond Road and Cooper Avenue, divided and 
settled ?n 1684^ tS prevent encroachment by Dutch settlers of adjacent towns 

n n Calamut Road, the original road from the landing on Mespa KUl 
(Newtown Creek) to Middelburg, opened about 1651. being the fi^^t line ot 
Communication with New Amsterdam. It was ^^^er ^"T^n as the Lowe^ R^^^^^ 
to Brooklyn Ferry, the Upper Road (modern Grand Street ana maspeui 
Avenue) being laiS out neaJlJ half a century later.. The cf amus in the ad 
iacent swamps gave rise to its name. On it remain several old larmhouses. 
^ F Thk Maurice Woods, property of the P^testant Episcopal Church of the 
n,-nrpep nf T onff Island the gift of Congressman Maurice. 1 he trees nave 
?robaWy stood since tKe Revolution, when much of the Newtown forests were 
cut by the British. . 

0-0 This portion of Betts Avenue was originally a wood lane of the extensive 
Betts estate, later an open road known as Featherbed Lane. 

Walk west on Newtown Avenue, passing 

41. Alburtis House, on Laurel Hill Road, possibly including 
the frame of the house of Thos. Case, an eccentric Quaker, organizer 
of a strange religious sect, known as Case's Crew. His wife inter- 
rupted the service in Rev. Wm. Leverich's church at Newtown in 
1675, addressing him as a " whited sepulchre," and demanding his 
resignation (Riker, p. 92). John Alburtis bought the land in 1682, 
and his family held it for over a century. 

42. Peter Debevoise House, corner Newtown and Celtic Av- 
enues (now the property of Hugh McCullough), dating back to 
about 1780. 

The Newtown and Bushwick Turnpike (Shell Road) was opened 
about 1840 (see p. 298). 

Return by trolley to Hunter's Point 



288 



QUEENS 



ROUTE 46a. 

SIDE TRIP SOUTH ON FLUSHING AVENUE. 

(See also Excursion XII, Section 3). 

Walk south on Old Fushing Road to Ondcrdonck Avenue. 

43. Cluster of old houses, marking some of the earliest settle- 
ments of Newtown, two on the west side of the road being well 
preserved: 

a. The Woodward or Woodard House, opposite the end of 
Woodward Avenue, supposed to have been built by Joseph Wood- 
ward about 1750, on a large farm containing a great orchard and 
cidermill. It previously belonged to the Schencks, whose mill- 
pond can yet be distinguished by a circle of decaying willow 
trunks. 

b. The Wyckoff Farmhouse, just south, on the site of the 
house of Hendrick Barentsen Smit (see E), one of the first set- 
tlers. After a boundary struggle of over 100 years between the 
towns of Bushwick and Newtown, his farm was finally adjudged 
to be in Newtown, and on January 10, 1769, the line was fixed at 
Arbitration Rock, on the edge of the nearby swamp. *5 

Take car on Flushing Avenue to Park Rozi', Manhattan. 



289 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




BIAC5RAM 

COFtOTMA T® 

MIDDLE VILLAGE 

SECTION545- ExcursionXI 



Plate LVlll. Routes 47, 48, 50. 
290 



C. K. 



QUEENS 
ROUTE 47. 

SECTION IV.— HUNTER'S POINT AND WOODSIDE TO 

CORONA. 

(Figures refer to Plates LV and LVIII, letters to LI.) 
Take Jackson Avenue Trolley to IVoodsidc car barns. 

Jackson Avenue was laid out about i860 as a toll road to 
Flushing. 

See along it three milestones marked respectively: "2 miles," 
"3 miles" and "5 miles from 34th Street Ferry" (4, 3 and r 
mile from Flushing Bridge). See Appendix A. 

P-P. .Site of the British Camp, along the Dutch Kills Road, traces of huts 
being visible until recently. 

44- The Narrow Passage, a tongue of dry land crossing formerly almost im- 
passable swamps (now mostly drained), and occupied by the early road. It 
v.-as an important strategical point in the Revolution and was guarded by the 
British. 

J[\ The Wolf Swamp, a wet woodland until 1866-7, in early days infested by 
wolves. It is now drained in part and divided into lots forming part of 
Woodside. 

q-q. Ancient road forming Middelburg and part of Woodside and Bowcrv 
Bay Avenues, connecting plantations of Bowery Bay and Dutch Kills, opened 
about 1655-60. 

r-r. Woodside Avenue, from the town (Middelburg) to the Dutch settle- 
ments. *6 

45. Jackson Mansion (corner Jackson Avenue and Bowery 
Bay Road), in large grounds, surrounded by the remains of an 
old forest. The house was built about 1802 by Wm. Payntcr, 
owner of the estate. 

Go north on the Bozvery Bay Road (behind 45). 

46. Site of the Moore Farmhouse (several blocks east on Jamaica 
Avenue), adjoining the small burying ground now marked by some 
decaying evergreens. During the Revolution this property was owned 
by Nathaniel Moore, great-grandson of Rev. John Moore, first minis- 
ter of the town. It was taken by the British after the Battle of Long 
Island and became the headquarters of Lieutenant-Gencral Sir Henry 
Clinton. A straggling suburban settlement now occupies the farm. 

47. Purdy Farmhouse (opposite Grand Avenue), built shortl.\ 
before the Revolution and scene of the shooting of one of tin 
soldiers of the Royal Highlanders Regiment (the "Black Watch") 
while on a marauding expedition, by one of the slaves of Cornelius 
Rapalye, then owner (Riker, p. 207). 

48. Riker Farmhouse (opposite Wilson Avenue), on property 
purchased in i(388 by Abraham Rycker (or Riker), who owned 
the farm north. In 1717 his son Abraham built the small house 

291 



Route 47 HISTORICAL GUIDE Woodside 

which forms the middle of the present building. In the Revolu- 
tion it was owned by his son, Jacobus Riker. In 1776 the house 
was plundered by the British, and later the Hessian troops en- 
camped near by used the great oven to bake their bread. 

Return to Jackson Avenue and take trolley on Neivtotvn Avenue to 

R. R. crossing, Woodside. Cross tracks to see 50; the spring is 

reached by a path behind 50, which is at 56 Betts Avenue 

49. The old Town Spring or Watering Place (Woodside and 
Betts Avenues), on high ground 125 feet to the west of the road. 
Originally it was known as Rattlesnake Spring, then Newton's 
Spring, from Captain Bryan Newton, in the Dutch service at 
New Amsterdam, who had in 1652 a patent for the land running 
up to it. It still has a large flow. There was once a large tank 
or pool by the roadside for public use, but this plot, 100 feet 
square, has been enclosed as private property, whether without 
extinguishing public rights is not known, 

50. The Cumberson House, just south, post-Revolutionary, re- 
placing one of earlier date, was plundered by the British and later, 
near the close of the war, was attacked at night by British de- 
serters, one of whom was shot fatally by Thos. Cumberson, then 
owner (Riker, p. 213). R. C. Cliurch is on site of Sackett House. 

Return to Jackson Avenue and take trolley Easf^y 

s-s. Trains Meadow Road and Old Bowery Road, laid out before 1678. 

51. Hazard (later Duryea) Homestead, at the corner. The 
farm was owned as early as 1740 by Jas. Hazard, prominent in 
the Episcopal Church of Newtown. 

52. Rapalye House, of the middle i8th century. Daniel Rap- 
alye had a large farm here about i737, but this house seems of a 
somewhat later date. 



t-t was a road from the town to Peter Cornelissen's mill, opened about 1700. 
The two large mansions of Colonial style on the west side date about 1840 
and occui)y parts of the large farm of Colonel Edward Leverich a projector of 
the L. I. R. R. They are: 

53. Late residence of Chas. P. Leverich, once president of the 
Bank of New York, now deceased. 

54. Late residence of Henry S. Leverich, now deceased. 

55. Fish's Store (now closed), just across the Flushing Road, 
a curious shingled building occupied as a storehouse by Thos. 
Fish about i8oo-'20. 

292 



Corona QUEENS 47 Route 

H. Site of the Fashion Race Course, the principal race course near New York 

1850-65, later supplanted by Jerotne Park. The surrounding brick wall has 

mostly disappeared and the track has been cut up into lots 

I. I. Original home lots of first settlers of Middclburg ' 

L. L. On the west broad market gardens occupy what was onrp thr^ rn.»^^m 

Fields of the first settlers of Middelburg. ^ ^"*' ^^'»'"'"» 



56. Lent Farmhouse, at the angle of Flushing and Jackson 
Avenues (Montgomery Street), overlooking Flushing Bay, re- 
cently rebuilt and remodeled, probably on the site of the earlier 
house of John Ramsden, one of the first settlers, who died here 
soon after 1688. The second house was erected about 1712, a 
giant sycamore which overshadowed it having been preserved. 
During the Revolution it was occupied by Captain Thos. Law- 
rence. The 37th British Regiment was encamped here, i78o-'8i, 
to guard it against the attacks of " whaleboat men" from the 
mainland. 

J. Jonckers Island (south shore of Flushing Bay), named for 
"Joncker" (lord) Adriaen Vanderdonck (first settler of Yonkers), 
son-in-law of Rev. Francis Doughty (see 15, Sect. I). It was once 
well wooded land and a picnic resort of some fifty years ago known 
as St. Ronan's Well. The trees have disappeared and much build- 
ing sand has been carried away from the " island." 

57. Site of Rapalye House, on the south side of Flushing and Newtown 
Turnpike, on the farm occupied by Cornelius Berrien and his brother-in-law. 
Abraham Brinckerhoof, soon after 1684; later by Joris Rapalye, a brewer, and 
his descendants; though long untenanted, it was kept in good condition by the 
Elliot family on whose grounds it stood until burned in 1906. 



293 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ROUTE 48. 

SIDE TRIP.— CORONA TO COE'S MILL. 

P^tom Corona Station folloiv trolley east along Corona Avenue 
Line of the road (u-it Plate LIV) laid out in early days from the 
town to Coe's Mill. 

58. Burroughs Farmhouse (i8th century), well preserved, on 
Corona Avenue, between Mulberry and Sycamore Avenues. The fields 
of this farm included much of the village. 

Titus House, of Dutch architecture, built about 1760, now used as a 
club house. 

Turn off at Colonial Avenue to see 

59. The Coe or Rapelye Farmhouse. The house dates brick to 
about 1750 and the mill was established by Captain John Coe about 
1652, being shown on the Hubbard Map of 1666. It remained in the 
family until nearly the Revolutionary period, since which time it has 
been called Titus', Rapalye's or Carll's Mill and operated until lately. 
The later mill was burned about 1875. See the great rafters and fire- 
place in the cellar of the old house. 

60. The Lott House, built 1843, on the site of an older house, lies 
on the other side of the creek. 

61. Town Watering Place, dating from latter half of the seven- 
teenth century, the springs being collected from over two acres in an 
old stoned tank now filled with soil. 

v-v and w-w. Supposed route of original roads from Middleburg 
to Coe's I\Iill and to Jamaica, changed about 1750. 



294 



QUEENS 

ROUTE 50. 

SECTION V.-MIDDLE VILLAGE. 

(Figures refer to Plate LVIII, and letters to LIV). 

Take Calvary Cemetery car from Thirty-fourth Street Ferry to Luth- 
eran Cemetery, termmus of route on Metropolitan Avenue. 
Go to left to Cemetery Gate 

And from the top of the hill note view of this district. See old 
house. 

Take' trolley east on Metropolitan Avenue, passing 

A new Methodist Church (note tablet) to St. John's Cemetery. 
Here go to the left on Dry Harbor Road, passing the Methodist 
Cemetery and site of the old Methodist Church and crossing Furmans- 
ville Road to the 

62. House of the late Judge Furman. The road was so called 
because it terminated in a cluster of farms. The house (of about 
1750) faced a large pond, lately hlled, surrounded by great i)lack 
walnut trees, now mostly destroyed. 

Go east on Furmansville (now called Middle Village) Road to Trot- 
ting Course Lane. 

63. Tompkins Farmhouse, one-quarter mile north on a hill, on 
the east side of the road, built about 1760 by Sanniel VVaKlron 
During the winter of i78o-'8i the Royal Highland Regiment wa- 
quartered here, forcing Waldron to give up to them the use of 
his blacksmith's shop and committing great depredations in tlu- 
locality. Go north on Trotting Course Lane to see two old houses. 

Go south on Trotting Course Lane 

(leading to the South Meadows, laid out in 1668, and rcccivinK its present 
name in 1821, after the laying out of the Union Race Course.) 

A short distance east on the IVhitepot Road see 

64. Whitepot School, first established here in T739. this being 
the fourth or fifth building. 

65. Springsteen Homestead, beyond the L. I. R. R. bridge, 
where Casper Joost Springsteen settled in 1700. Much of the 
land around still belongs to the family. Two old houses near by. 

y-y. Whitepot Road, laid out early in the i8th Centurv. See several old 
SH'iSr ••pi.T'"or-?.1o,;?,°y' U ^.T^K I^'^^TU '.^rJ^-lon, '.Inc. 
dried up. 

295 



Route 50 HISTORICAL GUIDE Middle Village 

Return and go south on Trotting Course Lane. 

66. Van Duyn Homestead, in neglected grounds now owned 
by St. John's Cemetery. The Van Duyns were original settlers 
here, Captain Dow Van Duyn being active in the Royal service 
during the Revolution. In consequence the farm was confiscated 
by the state government after the war and sold to Thos. McFar- 
ran, a New York merchant. The house passed through several 
hands and for a time was untenanted and considered haunted. 
In 1778-79 it was the guardhouse of the Royal Highlanders. Later, 
it was for some time used in connection with a large dairy. 

M. Hempstead Swamp, lands allotted and clearing begun about 1670, when 
draining began. 

67. Remsen Farmhouse, one-quarter mile south on the op- 
posite side of the road. This is possibly part of the original 
dwelling of Abraham Remsen, who in 1712 aided in clearing 
Hempstead Swamp. His grandson, Jeromus Remsen, Jr., was 
Colonel of a regiment of Kings and Queens County Militia at 
the Battle of Long Island. The family were under constant 
British surveillance and the farm suffered many depredations 
(Riker, p. 188). t 

68. Site of the Dow Suydam Farmhouse, "built just below about 1736, and 
destroyed by fire a few years ago. 

69. Van Duyn Homestead. William Van Duyn cleared the land and settled 
here about 17 19, the family prospered and built the present dwelling before 
the Revolution. Shortly before that the estate was divided and while the north 
half was confiscated (see 66), the south remained in the family. It was the 
last cleared land in this direction, running into forests reserved as hunting 
grounds by the Indians in their deed to Middelburg (1656), now forming Cypress 
Hills Cemetery and Forest Park, the latter being laid out about 1898. 

Go south to Myrtle Avenue and return by trolley. 

tNoTE. — The Remsen House has been taken down by Mr. Jeromus Vanderveer, 
who lives opposite the old site, Trotting Course Lane and Metropolitan avenue. 

Diagonallv opposite in the old burying ground see the stones for Col. Jeromus 
Remsen and other members of family. 



296 



QUEENS 

ROUTE 49. 

SECTION VI. 

THE VILLAGE OF NEWTOWN (KLMHURST) CALLED MID 
DELBURGH BY THE DUTCH 

(Figures refer to Plate LIX). 

Take L. I. R. R. {Thirty-fourth Street Ferry) to Elmhursl; or N. )'. 

and Queens County Electric R. R. from fool Borden 

Avenue, Long Island City {Thirty-fourth Street), to 

Elmhurst; leave car at Shell Road. 

This village was settled early in 1652 (Rikcr's statement. Annals of New- 
town, p. 27). That It " was begun upon the street where the Presbyterian 
Church now stands, on both sides of which lots were laid out " is so in- 
accurate as to be entirely misleading. The house lots were laid out on the 
south side of the street (now Hoffman Avenue), and on the north siile of 
Court Street, the intervening space being occupied by a wet tract traversed by 
the small Horse Brook. The lots laid out in this space (about an acre or two 
each) were intended only for pasturage, and were so used for nearly a century. 
Then some small houses were built, a few of which have survived, giving an 
antiquated air to the neighborhood, while most of the other old houses have 
disappeared. 

Unfortunately the historic name was changed to Elmhurst a few years ago 
to satisfy the fancy of a real estate speculator. 

The itinerary begins at the north end of the old village, beyond 

the railroad station. Here at the northwest angle of Broadway ami 

Shell Road see 

1. Moore House, the middle portion being probably the orig- 
inal home of Samuel Moore, son of Rev. John Moore, first min- 
ister at Nev^town. The latter died in 1657, in occupation of the 
"town house" (10), his family being asked by Stuyvcsant to va- 
cate in February, 1661 (as it was public property), in favor of 
the newly-appointed schoolmaster. This date thus approximately 
fixes the date of this house, making it contemporaneous with the 
Bowne house of Flushing (14, Sec. VII), these being two of the 
oldest known houses in the vicinity of New York. In one of 
the records the " barn lot " of this farm is spoken of in 1663. im- 
plying the existence of the house before that time. The property 
has always remained in the family of the original owner. 

2. Woodward (later Victor) House (the north wing. iSth cen- 
tury). 

The original homestead (torn down about 1880) stood some .list.ince north 
the farm having been in the family from 1666. The barn was ^'^-^.'M"'-''. ''^ '»^,^, 
British as a hospital and was the scene of the shooting by T hos. \Nood«nrd of 
a British soldier for stealing poultry (Riker p. 214). . 

3. Flushing Road, opened about 1815 and long mamlaincd as a 
plank road. 

297 



Route 49 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



Newtown 




PLAN OF 
VILLACEOrNEWT«WN 

(tLMHURSTJ 

COPYRIGHT 1906 
BjJ.H.Inntv 



Plate LIX. Route 49. 



4. Shell Road, constructed about 1840 of crushed oyster shells. 

5. Site of the house of Daniel Dloomfield, a resident before 1666. In 1840, 
after passing through many hands, it came to Samuel Lord, head of the old 
New York dry goods house of Lord & Taylor. Though carefully preserved by 
the Lords, after building a large residence east of it, it was burned in 1872. 

6. Formerly a small hrook occupied the line of the electric road. 

7. Old Town Watering Place, a small pond for watering cat- 
tle, referred to in 1820 as having been in use " from time im- 
memorial." It was enclosed by Samuel Lord in 1842 by permis- 
sion. Pond now filled in. 

8. Clermont Terrace, built, 1850, by Samuel Lord as model 
suburban residences. 



9. Site of the "new house" (so-called in 1689) of Content Titus, who had 
bought the old "town house" (to) in 1672, where he resided for a time. 
At a town meeting in 1689 it was resolved that the records be kept in this 
" new house." 'I'he house passed to his daughter Abigail, her husband, 
George Furniss, and through many other hands until destroyed, 1905-6. 



298 



Newtown QUEENS 49 Route 

10. Site of the ancient Town House of Middelburg or Newtown built about 
1654 to be used as a parsonage, for public meetings, and the holding of re- 
ligious services and first occupied by Rev. lohn Moore. After his death 
in 1657, the widow remained in possession of the premises, including 2n acres. 
She married later Francis Doughty, son of Rev. Francis Doughty, the first 
patentee of Newtown. In 1661, on the appeal that this was i.ublic property. 
Stuyvesant ordered Doughty to give up the premises. In 166-; the building was 
repaired and newly thatched, two rooms being then lathed and plaslcrivf In 
1665, at a meeting of deputies from Long Island towns at Hempstead to settle 
various disputes. Governor Nicoll and the Assembly awarded the proi)erty again 
to Mrs, Doughty. In 1672 Content Titus, son of a New ICngland niunecr and 
a new resident, married Mrs. Doughty's daughter by Rev. John Sloorc, and 
bought the jtremises. He spent a long and active life here, dviiig in 1710. 
For some time he allowed the town the use of the house for public meetings. 
The property was sold to Wm. Sackett, and in 1761 he left a large part of it, 
including the house, to St. James Episcopal Church, apparently as a rectory. 
There being no separate rector until 1797 (when Rev. Henry \'an Dyke came'), 
it was probably leased out. The English traveler. John Davis, wrote an in- 
teresting description in 1798 of the house. The date of its destruction is un- 
known. The present building is quite modern (about 1840). 

11, 12. The present parsonage (separated by a narrow lane 
from 10) and the modern St. James Church, dedicated in i84<). 
when the old church (23) was abandoned. *8 

13, 14. Meadow of the Church of St. James, and lane leading 
thereto devised to the church by Wm. Sackett in 1761. Part of the 
meadow, fronting Main Street, has been built on for 50 years or 
more. 

15. Site of the second Town House of Newtown, built about 1677, and first 
used as a parsonage until 1695, when a house was purchased for the new 
minister. As the church was frequently v/ithout a pastor, it was probably 
occupied as a school and for town business. In 1747 it was superseded by a 
third Town House immediately adjacent, which was used until 1805. when a 
fotirth was erected on the site of 15, remaining in use until 1851 (24a). 

The Newtown Hotel occupies the site of these buildings. 

15. The Little Commons (marked on plan x x x x) remained common 
until sold at auction in 1849, most of it being previously occupied by the 
Town House, etc., and a plot given the congregation of St. James t..r ns lirst 
church; the bulk was leased for pasturage, etc. 

16. The Dutch Reformed Church, built in I733. octagonal in 
shape, with a high pitched roof, and used in the Revolution as a 
British powder magazine. It was. taken down in 1S3T and the 
present building erected in 1832. 

Go east on Union Avenue formerly 

17. Dutch Church Lane, or Dutch Lane, leading from J''^/';"^';''„*"j;j%°'J 
Common Field of the first settlers. Widened and extended m 1824-27 and now 
called Union Avenue. . „ „ • 1 » , 

18. Negro Burial Ground, set apart by the ^own in 18.8 now occupjcd ^ 
an African church. The old lane (17.) .here took ^" jj"^" 'J ♦"{" Vhls lm\^^v, 
closed portion with a small grove adjoining was probably given for tins punwsi. 
on the straightening of the lane at the period named. 

The land was divided about 1700. 

209 



Route 49 HISTORICAL GUIDE Newtown 

20a. Ludlow House, probably the only old house built (about 
the end of the Revolution) in the Commons Tract, on land owned 
in 1738 by Samuel Fish, who resided in the center of the village. 

21. Maj-Gen. Robertson's camp, the British army entering Newtown Aug, 30, 
1776, three days after the Battle of Long Island. At night they are said to 
have committed great depredations (Riker, p. 190). 

Return to Broadway. 

22. Site of old Newtown Hotel (about 100 feet from corner of Cook Avenue 
and Broadway), a tavern of the early 19th century on land now belonging to 
the Reformed Church. 

23. The original St. James Episcopal Church, built 1733 on , 
land granted by the town. It is well preserved and was used 
until the present church (12) was erected; still in use on special 
occasions. The steeple at the west end was taken down a few 
years ago. *9 

24. Small neglected Burying Ground in rear of the church. 
24a. Sixth Town Hall (now a police station since consolidation), 

built 1893 on the site of the fifth Town Hall, erected 1851. The latter 
was an unpretentious structure, on the south side of which was later 
erected a small one-story brick Town Clerk's Office. The lot was 
originally an open space in the roads. 

25. The Town Spring at the rear of 24 (now filled) and used till 24a was 
built. 

26. Site of the Howard Farmhouse (removed about 1886), on the home " lot " 
of John Reeder, an original settler. It was probably the site of Reeder's 
house, built toward the end of the 17th century. 

Go east on Court Street. 

27. The Horse Brook, where the townspeople watered their 
horses. 

28. Early 19th Century house on the site of the house of 
Joseph Reeder, an old inhabitant whose family kept the property 
till 1736, when they removed to Orange County. 

28a. View of old village from Prospect and Chicago Avenues. 

29. Col. Bernardus Bloom's Farmhouse, on the farm composed 
in part of 3 home lots bought by Col. Bloom in 1742. The farm 
originally consisted of 40 acres purchased by John Brinckerhoof 
soon after 1700. It was long in the possession of the Suydams 
and has undergone several changes. 

30. Old Town Burial Ground, in which most of the first set- 
tlers were buried. In 1901 the remains of the first three pastors 
and two prominent laymen, including Content Titus (see 10), 

300 



Newtown QUEENS 49 Route 

were reinterred in the Presbyterian burial ground. Spasmodic, 
but unsuccessful, attempts have been made to clear the ground 
and put it in order. 

30a. The so-called Burroughs House (about 1700), on the site 
of the home of Wm. Stevenson, sold by him to Richard Belts in 
1742, and in the Betts family for nearly a century. It stands 
just west of the site of the house of John Burroughs, an original 
settler, long the Town Clerk. In 1674, for sending a comi^uni- 
cation to Gov. Andros reflecting on the Government, he was or- 
dered to be fastened for an hour to the whipping post in front 
of the City Hall in New York with a paper on his breast setting 
forth his offence (Riker, p. 91). 

30b. Colonial House (about 1750), on the site of the house of 
Edward Jessup, an original settler, whose extensive farm was 
considered to mark the end of the town, as in 1660 a thief was 
sentenced to walk from the Town House through the village 
" with two rods under each arm, and the drum beating before 
him until he comes to Mr. Jessup's House." 

Return to Broadway. 
31. The Corner House (Broadway and Hoffman Avenue), 
erected about 1716 by Jonathan Fish, who had here a tavern 
famous for a century, his son, Samuel, keeping it (1723-67). In 
1756 some Acadian exiles were boarded here by the authorities. 
During the Revolution it was kept by Abraham Rapalye, a head- 
quarters of loyalists, refugees and British officers and men, when 
its ballroom on the upper floor was the scene of much gaiety. 
In 1776 Wm. Sackett, a prominent " rebel " here under arrest, 
escaped after getting his guards drunk. After the war it was 
called the Union Hotel, but was purchased with 11 acres of 
ground in 1817 by the Presbyterian Church, and used until 1821 
as a parsonage, when it was sold and used first as a store and 
then for a long period as a private residence. (There is a mod- 
ern house on the present corner.) 

It stands on the site of the house of Ralph Hunt, an original settler. In 
1668 this house and outbuildings were burned, and in 167 1 lluiit gave land lot 
the construction of the first church building in Newtown, services having pre 
viously been held in the Town House, which was just tlien decided to be 
private property (see 10). 

In this church (enlarged in 1694) Lord Cornbury inducted, against the will 
of the people, Rev. Wm. Urquhart, an Episcopal clergyman. 1-or proaUiinp n 
it in 1707, a visiting Presbyterian minister. Rev. J*V'" ''^V!r^71\ c'''*,L -churc " 
bury's warrant arrested and imprisoned in New \ ork. In \7i5 the ihurch 
again in the hands of the people, was formally reorganized as 1 resbyterian. In 
1716 the new church was built (see 32). 

301 



Route 49 HISTORICAL GUIDE Newtown 

Go west on Hoffman Boulevard to Maurice Avenue; follow the latter 
across the L. I. R. R. track and walk across lots to the left. 

31C. Farmhouse of Jonathan Hunt (?) dating perhaps from 
1700. 

Return via Calamus Road (passing several old houses) to Broad- 
way and turn to the left at Hoffman Boulevard. 

31 a-b. Old Road to the Ferry or Calamus Road. 

x-x. Hoffman Boulevard to Rusdorp (Jamaica) laid out before the i8th 
Century. 

3 id. Upper Road to the Ferry, laid out about 1696, along which Aug. 30, 
1776, Maj-Gen. Robertson's detachment entered Newtown, " driving before 
them large quantities of cattle " (Riker, p. 190). 

Return to Hoffman Boulevard 

32. The old Presbyterian Church and burial ground, erected 
1716 (see 31). After the British entry much damage was done 
this church by the loyalists, because the Presbyterians as a rule 
favored the American cause. Part of the steeple was sawn off 
and lowered to the ground at night by a band of young men; the 
building was then used as a guard house and military prison, and 
afterward demolished. The present structure was built 1787-91 
and is still used on special occasions. The stone church opposite 
was made possible by a special bequest in 1893. 

33. Presbyterian Parsonage, built 1821 on the site of an or- 
chard belonging to the "Corner House" (31), where Whitefield 
preached in 1764 to a large congregation. 

34. Large house end of i8th Century, builder unknown. 

35. Horse Brook Road (see 27). 

36. Site of the Bark Mill and Pond of Wm. Vallence, 1721. The house here 
may be of the same date, but reconstructed. The pond is now drained. 

Return to Hoffman Boulevard. 

2,7- House of Samuel Renne, or the Brettoniere House (from 
a later owner), now completely modernized, formerly of Colonial 
style and pre-Revolutionary. It is the second house from the 
corner of Brettoniere Street. It was for a time the headquarters 
of Sir William Howe, Commander-in-Chief of the British forces, 
and from this house he sent an account of the Battle of Long 
Island to Lord Germain in England. 

38. Site of the encampment of 23d Regiment or the Royal Welsh Fusiliers, 
vestiges of whose huts have been found on the hill behind 37. 

38a. Site of the Baptist Church, erected about 1809, long closed. In 1857 
it was removed to another site and known as " Association Hall," now on 
Thompson Avenue. 

302 



Newtown QUEENS 49 Route 

39. Site of the Quaker Meeting-House, erected 1722 and burned 1844. 

40. Site of the so-called House of Jacob Field, a small onc-storv stone building 
with loopholes m the garret; probably the home of an original settler: removed 
a few years ago. * 

41. Road to South Meadows, opened 1668. 

42. Modern house on the site of James Smith's house (an original settler) 
built about 1700, and recently torn down. Several other small cottages stood 
between this and 43 but were early demolished, these lands being consolidated 
to make up the Presbyterian parsonage farm. 

43. The Parsonage Farmhouse (sold 181 1 and then called the 
Thompson or Odekirk House) was built about 1750 on the site of 
the original parsonage (purchased by the congregation in 1695 with 
12 additional acres). The Town had previously (1678) set apart 50 
acres here for the minister's use. 

N. (On Plate LIV), is said to have been an artificial lake formed by beavers 
and covering the low grounds between Middelhurg and modern Wiulield. It 
was drained and divided among tiie inhabitants in 1678, at which lime and 
long after it was known as Smith's Meadows. 



303 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 51 

SECTION VII.— FLUSHING. 

(Figures refer to Plate LX ; letters to LIV). 

Long Island or North Side Railroad to Flushing. 

Settlement begun, spring of 1645, by a small band of English colonists, given 
permission by the authorities at New Amsterdam. Although later a few Dutch 
arrived, the English always predominated. These settlers came to possess com- 
paratively large tracts of land, but settled together upon their '* home lots " in 
the small village of Flushing. Unfortunately, the Town Records were destroyed 
by fire in 1789, together with the house of the Town Clerk, Jeremiah Vander- 
bilt, through the act of a negress slave, who was hanged therefor in the 
following year. The nearest village in early days in this part of Long Island 
being Hempstead, 15 miles distant through the forests, the only access of the 
settlers to the outside world (chiefly, of course, to New Amsterdam) for a few 
years was by water through the East River and Flushing Creek. 

OLD ROADS AND FAMOUS SITES IN FLUSHING VILLAGE 

a-a. Early Road, probably before 1650 (Main Street extended south), to in- 
tersect the road (once an Indian path from the Great Plains to the East River) 
made by Hempstead settlers to New Amsterdam. Part of it may have run 
much to the west of the present road. 

b-b. The Rocky Hill Road (following portions of Sanford, Parsons and Queens 
Avenues), leading to the southeast part of Flushing patent, intersecting the 
path to Hempstead and shortening the distance thereto. 

c-c. Fresh Meadow Road, branching south from bb, both being shown on 
the Hubbard Map of 1666. 

d-d. Road to Whitestone (now Whitestone Avenue), one branch continuing 
east to several farms along shore at "The '^hite Stone;" the other branch 
is the 

e.-e. Road to Lawrence Neck, now College Point. 

1. First Landing Place, later site of the Town Dock. A crooked lane (now 
Old Lawrence Street) led to the same and to 

2. Lawrence Homestead, supposed to have been on or near the site of the 
present Lawrence residence west of (New) Lawrence Street. 

3. The first dwellings, south side Bridge Street (originally the upper part of 
Lane to the Town Dock) and on both sides of Main Street near its head. 

4. The Town Pond originally on the site of the Public Square and vicinity; 
used for watering the cattle, etc. It received several springs east of Main 
Street, and ran off through swampy woodland to the north. It was filled up 
about 1843. 

5. The Block House (in 1704 called the Guard House) about on the present 
site of the New Armory, built for defense against the Indians in 1645. It 
was employed for town meetings and here, in 1646, the Rev. Francis Doughty 
preached until 1648, when, for derogatory remarks against the Dutch authorities 
at New Amsterdam, it was closed against him by the Schout. Here in 1704 
the Rev. Wm. Urcjuhart held the first Episcopal services in the town. In 1776 
the British pulled it down for firewood. On its site in 1827, the Orthodox 
Quakers (as oi)i)osed to the Ilicksites, whose meeting-house stands still a little 
to the west) built their first place of worship. 

6. Site of Prince's Nursery (1737, see Waller's History of Flushing), in 1750 
famous and known as the Linnaean Botanic Garden (consisting of eight acres) 
forming part of Farrington's Neck on which (site unknown) stood the earliest 
tide mill of the town. 

During the Revolution the Garden was preserved by special efforts of the 
British officers. It was visited by Washington in the fall of 1789. In 1841 
Linnaeus (now Prince Street) was opened and the land given up to building. 

7. Site of the British Beacon or signal pole, line of Washington Street, west 
of Bowne Avenue. It was in line with one ten miles east on Sutton's Hill, 
Cow Neck (Manhasset) and another on Norwich Hill, south of Oyster Bay, 
eighteen miles distant. 

8. Site of British Battery, commanding the village on high ground opposite 
Bowne Avenue. 

304 



Flushing 



QUEENS 



51 Route 



A. FLUSHING VILLAGE. 
Itinerary begins at bridge of the Whitestone Branch of the L. I. R. R. 

9. Prince Mansion (later i8th Century), well preserved, cor- 
ner Bridge Street and Lawrence Avenue. 

10. Hamilton Hall, southwest corner Washington and Garden 
Streets, built originally at Main and Locust Streets, in 1803, as 
a parish academy by St. George's Episcopal parish, but, not meet- 
ing success, it was removed in 1810 to its present site. 

Go East on Broadway.* 10 

11. Old Quaker Meeting-House, Broadway above Main Street, 
•built 1694-5, on 3 acres bought 1692 by the Quakers for this pur- 
pose and a burial ground. In 1696 they held their Yearly Meet- 
ing here for the first time, and in 1702 the Rev. George Keith i>f 
the Church of England attempted to preach here, but was pre- 
vented. The building was shingled, plastered and repaired in 1704, 
and the Quaker records say a new building was erected in 171Q.— 
meaning probably some addition. The British army used it as 




Plate LX. Route 51. 
305 



Route 51 HISTORICAL GUIDE Flushing 

a barracks, hospital and store-house, but in 1783 it was repaired 
and restored to its original use (Onderdonck " Friends in New 
York and Long Island," pp. 94-95)- 

Go West on Whitestone Avenue. 

12. Mitchell House, pre-Revolutionary, headquarters of Col. 
Hamilton of the British army, at the southeast corner Whitestone 
and Bayside Avenues. 

Return to Broadway. 

13. Aspinwall House, south side of Broadway, east of Union 
Street, probably built by John Aspinwall (about 1760), a New 
York merchant, and a British headquarters in the Revolution. 

Go east on Bowne Avenue (formerly Bowne's Lane) 

14. Bowne Homestead, on an old lane now widened and called 
Bowne Avenue, corner Washington Street, one of the oldest, if 
not the oldest, of buildings extant in the vicinity of New York. 
It was built by John Bowne, an English Quaker, who settled here 
about 1655. For opening it for the Quaker conventicles he was 
arrested by the Dutch authorities in 1662 and sent, in 1663, for 
trial to Holland. But he was soon released, and he returned in 
1665 (after the surrender to the English), and his house 
continued to be used for Quaker meetings, the celebrated 
George Fox being entertained here in 1672 on his visit from Eng- 
land (see 15, Sect. VIII). It is now a historical museum under 
the care of Miss Parsons,* and contains much colonial furniture, 
copper, silver and brassware, wearing apparel, etc. The sides of 
the house are covered with hand-made shingles. *ii 

15. Fox Oaks, once nearly opposite the Bowne House, now 
marked by a tablet on a boulder at the edge of the street (erected 
by the Flushing Historical Society, October 12, 1907), stating the 
fact that George Fox (founder of the Society of Friends) preached 
here in 1672. (Fox Journal, 8th cd., Vol. H, pp. 1C7-174.) 

Go dozvn Washington to Main Street and icalk south. 

16. Old house (end of i8th century), 27 Main Street, raised 
and a modern story placed beneath it. Other old houses similarly 
disguised may exist in the neighborhood. 

* I'ee for admission 25 cents; address for information Miss Parsons, 371 
Broadway, Flushing. 

306 



Flushing QUEENS 51 Route 

17. St. George's Episcopal Church (about 1850), and in front 
of the church built in 1812, still used for church purposes. The 
first Episcopal services were held in the Block House (see 5). 
then a church was built here in 1746. the land being given in 
1749 by Captain Hugh Wentworth, and the original building 
completed in 1761 through the liberality of John Aspinwall (13). 

Tablet (erected in 1803) within the church, in memory of 
Francis Lewis, a signer of the Declaration of Independence, who was 
church warden here in 1765-90. 

18. Garretson House, east side, between Lincoln and Locust 
Streets (latter 17th Century), a well-preserved farm house.* i J 

19. Flushing Institute (Amity Street), built in 1827, later 
known as St. Ann's Hall, and in, 1845 turned by Ezra Fairchild 
into a famous boarding school for boys. 

20. St. Thomas Hall built 1838-9; became known later as St. 
Joseph's Academy for young ladies. 

21. Sanford Hall (Jamaica Avenue south of Franklin Place), 
originally the stately mansion of Nathan Sanford, Chancellor of 
the State of New York, who in 1822 bought up several farms 
fronting on the present Jamaica Avenue and built this house in 
1836. Dying soon after, the house, with its park-like groimds, 
running back to Parsons Avenue, came into the possession of Dr. 
John Macdonald, who here established a celebrated private in- 
sane asylum. 



307 



Route 51 HISTORICAL GUIDE Outlying Points 

OUTLYING POINTS. 

B. SOUTH OF FLUSHING VILLAGE. 

22. Tract of the WUlett family (southwest of the village and extending to 
the Jamaica line), separated from its outlying farms by Kissena Brook. The 
site of the homestead is not known, but Thos. Willett, an English soldier in 
the Dutch service at New Amsterdam, left two children, William and Thomas, 
by his wife Sarah, who later married Charles Bridges, an English officer under 
the Dutch, and called by them Carel van Brugge (New Amsterdam, p, 192 
et seq.). Bridges and his family became early residents of Flushing and he 
was one of the patentees named in the Flushing town patent in 1664. He 
claimed some interest in the above tract of land whether in his own right or 
that of his wife. After his death in 1682, a patent was issued to his brother 
Thomas and to Thos. Willett, stepson of Charles Bridges. 

23. Willett Burial Ground is at north end of Cedar Grove Cemetery 
(reached by B. R T. trolley to entrance of Cemetery). 

24. Spring Hill Estate (Remsen Avenue and Mill Road), of Lieutenant-Gov- 
ernor (Tadwallader Colden, part of the Willett property bought by Colden in 
1762. He held the office of acting Governor of New York more than six years, 
between 1760-1775, and spent his last days here. His son David aiding the 
British, the farm was sold under forfeiture after the war and has passed 
through several hands, not being well kept up of late years. 

Fresh Meadow Tract (south of Flushing Cemetery), was settled in early 

days and many British troops were quartered here in the Revolution. 

24. Site of Duryea Farm House, near the south end of Flushing Cemetery, 
serving as British headquarters. 

From (21) above go south to Forest Avenue, go three blocks to left 
and take Jamaica trolley to Fresh Meadow Road. 

25. Lawrence House (Lawrence Road, east of Fresh Meadow 
Road). 

26. West House (west of Fresh Meadow Road, south of North 
Hempstead Road). 

27. Old house (corner Black Stump Road and Fresh Meadow 
Road). 

28. Wright Homestead (?), half a mile west on the Jamaica 
Road (south of North Hempstead Road), small, and perhaps dat- 
ing back to the early i8th Century. 

C SOUTHEAST CORNER OF FLUSHING TOWNSHIP. 
Best reached from Floral Park Station, L. I. R. R. 

29. Dongan or Earl of Limerick's Plantation, granted to Gov. Dongan in 
1683 and including 400 acres of woodland, Hempstead adding 400 acres of wood- 
land and prairie north of J'^loral Park and Hyde Park. He spent some time 
here and planned to entail it to his nephews, but it was sold after his death 
to pay his debts. Peter Smith, in 1720, bought the part containing the house, 
which lay on the east side of the road leading from Floral Park. 

30. Farm house of about 1750, well preserved, half a mile 
north of Jericho Turnpike, the only ancient house site on Don- 
gan tract. Probably Dongan's house was of a similar type, 
stories of his living in state in his " Manor of Queens Village " 
to the contrary notwithstanding. 

31. Strickland's Tavern; site (Jericho Turnpike and Rocky Hill Road) ante- 
dating the Revolution and plainly depicted on Stewart's Map of 1797, even the 
wagon sheds and sign boards being shown. 

308 



Murray Hill QUEENS 51 Route 

D. MURRAY HILL. 
Reached from Murray Hill Station, L. I. R. R. 

32. The W. Bowne residence (Mitchell Avenue and Fourth 
Street), formerly a stately mansion in a large grove, approached 
from Broadway by a w^ide drive shaded with tall elms. Hut 
streets have been ciiit through and small houses erected near by, 
destroying the original picturesqueness. 

S3. Murray Homestead, of Dutch Colonial style, built about 
I77S> south side of Broadway, east of Murray Lane, Murray Mill, 
and the home of the family connected with the Murrays of Mur- 
ray Hill, Manhattan (Exc. V, Section IV); the present Mr. Williani 
K. Murray is a great-grandson of the famous Mrs. Murray, who 
aided in the saving of Washington. 

E. COLLEGE POINT AND WHITESTONE. 

(Reached from College Point Station, L. I. R. R., or College Point 

trolley, from Thirty-fourth Street Ferry to Thirteenth 

Street and Third Avenue, College Point; turn 

to the right up Third Avenue.) 

34. Lawrence Farmhouse, on the Lawrence Neck Road, 
now Third Avenue and Twenty-first Street, College Point, east 
of the railroad crossing. It is of the Eighteenth Century; in 
fairly good condition. 

35. Wolf Pit Hill Farm, of the Powell family, in Whitestone. 
on the same road, east of Whitestone Road (probably about 1750). 




ing a ferry 
a crossing-place for some time. 

i^fuplSn^'o/'lo^ng ^Isgnd^-af/tmii Tr Coio£ ArchibaM Ham^ 
Flushing, a prominent British commander Remains consisting ot brick. 

masonry, etc., were unearthed here m December, 1907. 



309 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ROUTE 52. 

SECTION VIII.— JAMAICA. 
(See Plates LXI and LXII). 

As no complete history of this town has been written, the chief facts must 
be gleaned from memorials of the several churches, scattered records and old 
maps. The first settlers, all English, purchased the land from the Yemacah 
Indians (hence the name) and made the first settlement at the intersection of the 
Hempstead Road (to New Amsterdam ferry) with the Flushing Road. The 
Dutch authorities called the settlement " Rustdorp " (frequently spelled " Rus- 
dorp "), but this name was soon abandoned. The Yemacahs probably were lo- 
cated along the banks of the stream connecting Beaver Pond with Jamaica 
Bay. (For other historical notes see Historical Sketch.) 



♦ ' • 1 I < ; ; 












\imv,. 




OLD JAMAICA VILLAGE 

COP r nisH T, 190a. 



Plate LXI. Route 52. 

1. Site of Beaver Pond (now filled), once occupying the space between 
Beaver, South and Church Streets and Rockaway Road! 

2. The Parsonage Lot (east angle' Fulton and Beaver Streets, extending to- 
ward 1), reserved from the beginning, and on which was erected a parsonage in 
or about 1662. It was used for other town purposes, including the 

3. Town Burial Ground, occasioning a long contention between 
the Presbyterians and the less numerous Episcopalians, Lord 
Cornbury confiscating it for the use of the latter. The Rev. Mr. 
Hubbard was accordingly ejected July 4, 1704, and the Rev. Wm. 

310 



Jamaica QUEENS 52 Route 

Urquhart, the newly-appointed Episcopalian incum])cnt, although 
violently opposed by the townspeople, held it until 17 10. Then, 
through the marriage of a Presbyterian theological student to 
the daughter of Urquhart's widow, it came back to the Presby- 
terians and was held by them until 1813, when sold. Sec the 
Memorial Chapel of the Laidlow family in the east end of the 
yard. 




SD 




03 



DDonnsgss 



]DDDDDI 







OP 



m 



«"j,t"..»-"" 



lOaDDD_ 




n 



D 



po' 



I tPl»COP*L CmO«CM 

n Court houic 
I COlONi/ki. Mali. 

a P(«t»BlfT£«l*M Cl.U«C. 
SD NORMAL SCKOOL 



Plate LXII. Modern Jamaica. 
Walk north to Fulton Avenue. 



C. K 



4. Site of the first Meeting and Sessions House, on what seems to have heen 
originally part of the Parsonage Lot (west corner Fulton and Reaver Streets), 
built about 1663, and used for religious as well as town meetings (N. V. 
Ecclesiastical Records, p, 1892); it was only 26 feet scjuarc. (lovernor Nic<»ll 
having determined to organize Jamaica with adjoining territory for judicial and 
legislative purposes into " the West Riding of Yorkshire," proposed that the 
Long Island towns lay special taxes to erect a larger building at Jamaica as a 
Sessions and Meeting House. This was done in 1667, the new Sessions Mouse 
and prison standing next to the old town house, which later was made an 
annex to the prison. Still later, the Jamaica Hotel occupied this si>ot for 
many years. 

Walk zvest on Fulton Street. 
5. The Dutch Church (corner Church Street), on the site cf 
the first church (built 1716), an octagonal structure, and of the 
second (1832), burned in 1857. Previous to 1716 the congrega- 
tion worshipped with the Presbyterians in their temporary meet- 
ing house (see 12). See notice in front of the church with coat of 
arms and date of organization, 1702. 

311 



Route 52 HISTORICAL GUIDE Jamaica 

6. The King Mansion (incorrectly called " Manor," as there 
never was a * manor " in Queens County — it being inconsistent 
with the township system, under which this part was settled), 
erected about 1750, and in 1805 becoming the country seat of Ru- 
fus King, one of the first two New York senators; also of John 
A. King (son of Rufus), governor from 1856 to 1858. Though 
severely simple, this house formerly presented a very imposing 
appearance, owing to its extensive grounds, surrounded by a 
thick hedge of large forest trees. 

The grounds are now public property, known as King Park, 
and the mansion (bought by the town in 1896) is fitted up in part 
as a colonial museum under the care of the " King Manor Asso- 
ciation." It is free and open to the public on Mondays (for in- 
formation address Mrs. E. C. Chickering, Sec. King Manor As- 
sociation, Jamaica, N. Y.). 

IValk east on Fulton Street. 

7. Grace Episcopal Church (east of Church Street), on the site 
of the first church of 1734 and the second (1822), burned in 1861. 

8. Original site of Utuion Hall Academy (southwest corner Fulton and Wash- 
ington Streets), a famous educational institution (the third academic building 
on Long Island, after East Hampton and Flatbush), erected by voluntary con- 
tributions about 1792, and succeeded in 1820 by a larger edifice, the later 

9. Union Hall Academy (west side Union Hall Street, near L. 
I. R. R.), still standing and now used for dwellings. The old hall 
continued in use for some time as a female seminary, but was 
burned in 1841. The principal was Miss Eliza McHanna, a native 
of Ireland, who, in 1832, married the Rev. Wm. Thompson, an 
American missionary, whom she accompanied to the Holy Land, 
dying soon after in Jerusalem. 

10. Site of the Court House of 1709 (apparently occupying part of the site 
of the present County Clerk's Office), where in 1710 the Episcopalians held serv- 
ices until 1734. A new Court House was built in 1786 near Mineola. 

11. Van Wyck House, southwest corner New York Avenue. 

12. Site of the first Presbyterian Church building (middle of Fulton Street," 
southwest of the present structure), " a stone church with a high spire and a 
bell," erected in 1699, but seized (July, 1703) by the Episcopal rector, the Rev. 
Mr. Bartow, who was backed by Lord Cornbury. The latter forbade the 
Presbyterians to use it, but in 1708, after Gov. Lovelace's appointment, the two 
sects used it alternately, bv advice of the colonial authorities. In 17 10 the 
Episcopalians were excluded, and in 1727 the Presbyterian claims were con- 
firmed by the Court, and they used this building until the present church was 
built. 

13. The Presbyterian Church, erected 1814 (see 12). See tab- 
lets within containing names of former pastors. 

14. Colonial Hall (opposite 13) opened in 1843 as a female 
seminary, under Miss Mary Adrain, remodeled about 1897 by 
Ex-Sheriff Wm. C. Baker, to be used as a public hall and for club 
rooms, and now used as a boarding house, 

•^12 



Jamaica QUEENS 



52 Route 



15. Site of Henry Townsends House (northwest corner Clinton \vcn„.- 
where in 1657 he sheltered some Quakers who had come to NrlT \™c. [ 
presumably bound for Rhode Island. They had lanXl ^t Kln.l.h / "I'"".' 
they were compelled to leave Wm. Hallett's^anishiS" „r'\.. iS r'^' n^;, V^^ 
having proved the hostile attitude of the authorities. Finally John Swic 
placed his house at their disposal. ' j^im jxtwnc 

16. Site of the oW windmill (see early plan of Jamaica) south of Fulton 
and east of Canal Street, a venerable round building, in later years used a 
a carpenter shop. Its wooden "wings" were blown down in 1841. '"3 

OUTLYING POINTS NORTH OF FULTON STREFT. 

17. Old House (i8th Century) southwest corner Flushing Av- 
enue and Willett Street. 

18. Site of Duke's Woods on the hill portion of the King Farm, where cnui-l 
once be seen the grave of " Duke," a negro slave, the inscribed headstone bat- 
tered with the bullets of thoughtless sportsmen. 

POINTS SOUTH OF FULTON STREET. 
IQ. Baisley's Mill Pond, near Locust Manor, where the bones 
of a mastodon brought here in the glacial drift were discovered 
in 1858. 

20. Duryea's Mill site, "Three Mile Mill" southwest of 19 near its outlet, 
famous in early days. 

21. Seat of Citi::en Genet, on the Rockaway Road, south of 19 (as shown <>n 
the Stewart Map of 1797) on a farm of 370 acres conveyed to him by his 
father-in-law, DeWitt Clinton, October 17, 1795. Although recalled by tlie 
French government at Washington's request, because of liis insolence and 
arrogance, and insults to the administration, he continued to live here, as 
a private citizen for several years, ending his days in the northern part of the 
State. 

22. Ditmars Farm House, corner Rockaway Road and Lincoln 
Avenue, claimed to be about 180 years old. ' 

23. Greenwood House, Lincoln Avenue near Ilawtrcc Crock 
Road. 

Turn down Hawtrce Creek Road. 

24. Old House on Hawtree Creek Road about half a mile be- 
low 2^. 

See on left across Lincoln Avenue 

25. Van Sicklen House and ancient barns, on Road to P.n l-imi's 
Landing, just southwest of 23, 

Continue across Rockaway Road passing stud farm of John C. 
Stevens, owner of the yacht "America." 

26. Thomas Bergen House (built 1805) with large gambrcl 
window. 

Turn to left on Old South Road. 

27. Site of Rcrgcn Homestead of 1700 (near first house on left). 

28. Jacob Bergen House one-third of a mile further, h.j 
Return via Lincoln Avenue to trolley for Woodhaven. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



ADDENDA, 1912 



EXCURSION NO. XL— QUEENS. 

*i (p. 2'j'j^. A millstone from this or another old mill may be seen 
imbedded in the concrete sidewalk at 437 Jackson Avenue, said to have 
been imported from Holland by the Brouchard family, which settled 
here in 1657. It was placed here by Mr. W. Elmer Paynter, whose 
grandfather bought the mill property. Mr. Paynter had a collection 
of Revolutionary relics and a picture of the old Van Alst house 
(see i) in his real estate office at 171 Hunter Avenue. Barn Street 
(now nameless), on which was -the Van Alst house and burial ground, 
runs off at 374 Jackson Avenue. The body of Richard Hunter still lies 
here unmarked. 

The Paynter House (No. 2) is nearly opposite 449 Jackson Avenue. 
It is said to have been built about 1720, and will probably soon disappear. 

*2 (p. 278). This house has disappeared. 

The Brielle homestead, about one hundred years old, remains at 
325 Grand Avenue, near Brielle (now 15th) Avenue, and is occupied 
by descendants of the original owners, who bought the land from the 
Lawrences. 

*3 (p. 279). The hotel, known as "German Castle," stands some 
distance up on the hill. 

The Bowery Bay Cemetery lies near the western end of the Beach. 
It contains stones of the eighteenth century for members of the Rapelye, 
Cornell, Luyster, and other families of the neighborhood. 

*4 (p. 287). During the Revolution the house was occupied by 
Gen. Warren of the British army, and from the Town Dock near by 
he superintended the embarkation of his army from Newtown Creek to 
Kip's Bay, when New York was taken, September 15, 1776. 

*4 (p. 287). While residing here, De Witt Clinton developed his 
plans for the Erie Canal, and here he received the news of his unsuc- 
cessful candidacy for the Presidency. From this home he went to 
Albany to act as Governor of the State. 

Later this house was occupied by Judge David S. Jones, whose father 
has been called "the father of the New York Bar." 

The homestead was converted into a place of amusement known as 
"Clinton Park," and became a favorite Sunday dance hall ; later it 

3M 



QUEENS 

became a tenement, which it continues to he, aUhough it has been 
proposed to preserve it as an historical museum. Within may be seen 
the original Dutch doors, wide hall, winding stairs and some of the 
great fireplaces. The old buttonwood tree, i8 feet in diameter, under 
which Clinton is said to have frequently sat, remains in the grounds. 
(See "Historic Long Island Homes.") 

*5 (p. 289). The Cochran House stands midway between Metro- 
politan and Woodward Avenues; the Mott House between this and 
the Woodward House; the Schoonmaker House, with gambrel win- 
dows, stands opposite the Woodward House. 

The Wyckoff House, at 1375 Flushing Avenue, was the last home of 
Peter Wyckoff, of the fourth generation living here. He died here in 
the early part of 1910 at the advanced age of 82 years. He was inter- 
ested in banks and railroads and was President of the Grand Street 
and Newtown car line. 

*6 (p. 291). Recently removed to Seabright, N. J., at the request of 
the late owner, Mrs. John L. Riker, one of the Jackson family. 

*7 (p. 292). A better route for this portion of the Excursion is as 
follows : 

Continue on Jackson car to Flushing Avenue, where see 5^^ ^^d S7- 
On the left in passing may be seen 51 and 52. Return by the same 
trolley to Junction Avenue. 51 and 52 may be visited by following 
Junction Avenue and Old Bowery Road; then return to Junction Avenue 
and take trolley south, passing 53, 54, 55 to Main Street. Walk east to 
Sycamore Street and north to Linden Park. Here is a shell from 
the Maine, mounted in 1912 on a granite base by the Hugo Kruse Camp. 
Spanish War Veterans, in 'memory of Hugo E. Kruse, who lost his 
life when the Maine was destroyed. Return via L. I. R. R. frcm Corona 
Station. 

*8 (p. 299). Within the church see tablet erected liy the Rev. 
Edward M. McGuffey, the present rector, in IQOO. in memory of the 
Rev William Urquhart, the first rector, who organized this church m 
1704 The rector has the custody of a valuable collection of document 
and relics associated with the history of the church and of Newtow,;. 
listed and described in his "Souvenir Book of Samt James Church, 
which also contains some interesting illustrations and a ehr<.nnl..^> 

of the town and the church. „r.«<..rve.l 

*9 (p 300). The original wainscot and gallery have been pre cr 1 

Prince Wmiam (later William IV of England) worshiped heu 

-nrSs). soldiers' Monument. ^ ^^^ ^^:^:::-t 
of July Committee, and headed by Tbm. L. Bradtord rrmc , 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Liberty Pole at the western end of Flushing Park, intersection of 
Broadway (Jackson Avenue) and Main Street. 

In 1865 a movement was inaugurated for the building of a Soldiers' 
Monument by popular subscription. The monument was designed by 
Orange Judd of Flushing and erected at the apex of Flushing Park 
under the auspices of the George Huntsman Post, G. A. R. 

*ii (p. 306). The house was erected in 1661. During the Revolution 
officers of dragoons were quartered here, 

*I2 (p. 307). This is really the "Bloodgood Homestead," built in 
1642 (?) by Daniel Bloodgood, who died here in 1897, leaving it to 
his sister, Eliza Ann (Bloodgood) Garretson, who willed it to her heirs. 
It has recently been demolished. 

*i3 (p. 313). The Goffe House is an old house situated on Grand 
Street. It was known as the Wessel Smith residence many years ago. 
John O'Donnell, an old resident of Jamaica, reports that when he came 
to town in 1844 the house was then standing. 

Pettit's Hotel, Grand Street, near Flushing Avenue, was burned to 
the ground about six years ago. 

The Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument, on Hillside Avenue, at the 
intersection of Bergen Avenue, was erected by voluntary subscription 
collected under the auspices of the Alfred M. Wood Post, No. 368, 
Dept. N. Y., G. A. R. F. W. Buckstuhl was the sculptor. It was 
unveiled on Memorial Day, 1896. 



HOLLIS HEIGHTS 

*I4 (p. 313). In P. S. 35, Palatina Avenue, is a tablet, erected 1912 
by the Sons of the Revolution, N. Y. State Society, in memory of 
Gen. Nathaniel Woodhull, an officer of the Continental Army, who 
was wounded, captured and kept prisoner near this spot by the British 
during the Battle of Long Island. He is represented standing by his 
horse, sword in hand. 



316 



NOTES 



^17 



NOTES 



3i8 



PART FIVE 

BOROUGH OF RICHMOND 
EXCURSION X.— ROUTES 53-6oa. 



EXCURSION NO. X-HISTORIC RICHMOND. 

By George W. Nash, M. D. 

Compiled from the " Memorial History of Staten Island." by 

K. Morris, and from information given by many friends on 

the Island. Thanks are due to William T. Davis, 

J. H. Innes and Edward Hagaman 

Hall for valuable suggestions 

and criticisms. 

Copyright, 1908, by the City History Club of New York. 
Revised 1909 and 1912 

Additions, 1912, by C. G. Hine 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




LOWER 
NEW YORK BAY. 



MAP OF 
STATEN ISLAND 

BOROUGH OF RICHMOND. 

Number* indicata Houtta. 
mill Rail Roods. Roads. 



Plate LXIII. 



C. K. 



322 



HISTORIC RICHMOND. 



Bibliography. 

"Annals of Staten Island," by J. J. Cliitc (1877). 

"History of Richmond County, New York," edited by U M 
Bayles (1887). 

" Historical Sketches of Staten Island," by Ramond Tysen. 

"History of Staten Island," by I. P. Van Pelt. 

"Staten Island Magazine," Vol. I, Nos. 2 and 3, August and Goto 
ber, 1888. 

" Proceedings of the Natural Science Association of Staten Island,' 
Vols. I-IX, 1883- 1903 and (under the Society's new name), " Pro 
ceedings of the Staten Island Association of Arts and Sciences," Vol 
I, 1906- 1907. 

" Staten Island Names," by William T. Davis, containing a valu 
able map by Charles W. Leng and " Supplement to Staten IslaiK 
Names," by William T. Davis, both published by the Natural Scionci 
Association, New Brighton, Staten Island, N. Y. 

" Memorial History of Staten Island," by Ira K. Morris, 2 Vols 
1898 and 1900. 

" The History and Legends of Howard Avenue and the Scrpcntiii 
Road, Grymes Hill, Staten Island," by C. G. Hine. 

The * refers to Addenda, 1912, pp. 351-352. 



3^J 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



HISTORICAL SKETCH OF STATEN ISLAND. 

The island contains about 49,280 acres; the greatest length is a little over 
i3i miles and the greatest breadth is 200 feet over 7I miles. 

The Indian name was " Aquehonga Man-ack-nong," meaning the place of the 
high, sandy banks; in some old documents it is called " Eghqua-hons," which 
has the same meaning. 

Morris quotes Schoolcraft as giving the meaning *' the place of the bad 
woods." 

Previous to the coming of the white man, the island was occupied by the 
Raritans, a branch of the Delawares, under tribute to the Mohawks. Traces 
of the shell heaps made by the Indians are found in various parts of the 
Island. 

With the coming of the European, the history of Staten Island is wrapped 
up with that of the neighboring territory. 

Verrazano discovered the island in 1524. On September 2, 1609, Henry 
Hudson anchored in the Lower Bay and first saw the island, which was 
named "Staaten Eylandt " as a memorial to the States General of the Nether- 
lands under whose direction he was sailing. 

The first settlement was at " Oude Dorp " (old town) early in the period of 
the Dutch colonization. Among the first settlers were the Rapaelje family, 
who were connected with the first white inhabitants of Long Island. 

The Indians sold the island repeatedly; first to Michael Pauw in 1630, the 
first patroon, who called his grant " Pavonia." The Indian claim was finally 
extinguished in 1670 by Gov. Lovelace. In 1639, David Peterson de Vries, 
having obtained a grant from Governor Van Twiller in 1636, introduced some 
settlers. In 1641, Cornelis Melyn was made a patroon and the third attempt 
to settle the island was made at Oude Dorp. The Indians destroyed this village 
in 1641 and again in 1655, after which it was never rebuilt. (But see 
Note). 

In 1652 the Waldenses founded a village at Stony Brook which lasted until 
the middle of the eighteenth century, when it crumbled away. The latter part 
of the seventeenth century saw the Huguenots settling at Marshland, now 
Greenridge. During Kieft's misrule, the island suffered with the adjoining 
territory the ravages of the Indians. 

The English settled on the island in Stuyvesant's time and finally, in 1664, 
it came with other Dutch possessions under the British rule of Governor Nicolls, 
his first act being the capture of a block house on Staten Island. The setting 
off of the island from New Jersey was due partly to the difficulty of collecting 
the taxes; the Duke of York, to whom his brother, the King, had previously 
given New York, on this account decided in 1668 that all islands in the harbor 
that could be circumnavigated in twenty-four hours should belong to New 
York, otherwise to New Jersev. Captain Billopp successfully accomplished the 
feat in the prescribed time and. the island was adjudged to New York. A tract 
of land was awarded to him and he established the Manor of Bentley, at what 
is now Tottenvillc. New Jersey disputed this decision and the question was 
satisfactorily settled only in 1833. In 1673 the island was retaken by the 
Dutch, but was finally restored to the English on February 9, 1674. In 1679, 
the Labadists visited the island, and it is from them that so much of the 
everyday life of the colonists is known. The island was made into Richmond 
County in 1683; in 1688 it was divided into the towns of Northfield, Southfield, 
Westfield and Castleton; Middletown was established in i860. Cucklestowne, 
covy Richmond, was made the county seat in 1729. 

324 



Historical RICHMOND Sketch 

As headquarters of the British during the Revolution, the island was under 
martial law; many of the inhabitants were lukewarm to the patriot cause. 

General Sir William Howe brought his forces here July 3, 1776; making bin 
headquarters at New Dorp. His brother, Admiral Lord llowc, commanded the 
fleet here. The British erected forts at various places: at times the .Xmericans 
attempted to oust the British, and on their part the British made excursions 
from the island to the neighboring country. The British troops vacated the 
island on November 25, 1783, when many of the American Loyalists moved 
to various parts of the British Empire. 

By act of Legislature, slavery was abolished on July 4, 1825, when the 
fact was much celebrated. (See No. 12.) The island was governed by about 
seventy different boards until 1898, when it became the Borough of Rich- 
mond of Greater New York. It now feels the same impulses that exist in 
the other boroughs. 

Note: Mr. John H. Innes thinks that Oude Dorn was not built until 
1662-63 by Stuyvesant, on the order of the West India Company to fortify 
points on either side of the Narrows. In 1661 he informed the Company 
that all the houses in Staten Island had been destroyed during the Indian wars. 
Later he wrote that the village had been built about one-half hour's walk from 
the Narrows, there being no convenient place nearer the water. It was visited by 
the Labadists in 1679 (see their Journal in the L. I. Soc. Memoirs), when 
there were seven houses, three only inhabited, the people having removed on 
account of the poor soil to " Niewe Dorp." 

He doubts that the Rapaelje family ever settled in Staten Island, or that 
Waldenses founded Stony Brook, there being no documentary proof of these 
statements extant (see Nos. 62, 66, ^^). 



% 



325 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




RICHMOND 

ROUTE 53. 

From Manhattan take the Stalcn Island Municit^al Perry, at South 
Ferry, to St. George. 

(Figures refer to Plate LXIV). 

SECTION I— ST. GEORGE TO HOLLAND'S HOOK. 

Walk up Jay Street to South, then up to 

1. Public Museum (154 Stiiyvesant Place; sec p. 402) of the Statcn 
Island Association of Arts and Sciences, containing, among other 
relics, the last milestone known to exist on the island; it stood 
at the corner of Signs Road and Richmond Turnpike on the 
post route between New York and Philadelphia; all that is now 
to be made out is 

Miles 

to 

N. YorkE. 

2. Fort Hill, at the head of Fort Place, just above Sherman 
Avenue; here can be seen a masonry cavern used formerly m< 
a reservoir, and also the outlines of a British f(^rt. 

Walk hack to Tompkins Avenue; go north. 

3. Castleton Hotel; burned November, 1907, occupying the site 
of the old St. Marks Hotel, at the -corner of Nicholas Street and St. 
Marks Place; St. Marks Hotel was constructed out of the old 
" Marble House," built by Gilbert Thompson as a private house and 
at one time occupied by August Belmont; the large building opposite 
is the Curtis High School. 

Walk down Nicholas Avenue to and along the Terrace. 

4. Pavilion Hotel; between Church Street and Westerveli 
Avenue, now a tenement house; it was built in i8j8. as a resi- 
dence for Thomas E. Davis, and later became a hotel for wealthy 
Southerners. 

5. Hessians Springs; north on Jersey Street and parallel to 
it, ofif the Terrace; now utilized by the Hessian Springs Ice 
Company. It was once the most noted resort near New York, 
and was so called from the Hessian camp located here during 
the Revolution; there were two redoubts here on the heights 
at the entrance to the Kills. 

327 



Route 53. Sailors' HISTORICAL GUIDE Snug Harbor 

Nearby, on the shore, Gilbert Thompson, son-in-law of Governor Tompkins, 
built a schooner, in which he conveyed his family to Mexico; later it was 
used to bring Santa Anna, after the Mexican War, to Staten Island, where he 
lived in the DuBois House; see 19. 

Not far away was the site of Belmont Hall, where Isaacs' department store 
now is, between Westervelt Avenue and Jersey Street. It was built in 1832 
as a private residence and was used for many years by Major Duff, a West 
Pointer, as a military academy. The major became colonel of a New York 
regiment in the Mexican War and died in Mexico. 

6. John Drake Sloat lived where the Muralo office now stands, between York 
and Franklin Avenues: the house was destroyed by fare and was one of the 
oldest residences in New Brighton. 

7. The Cement House or Ward House, at the corner of 
Franklin Avenue, is nearly a century old; it is so called from 
being the first house built of cement blocks. It was the prop- 
erty of George A. Ward, who is said to have closely resembled 
George Washington. 

Continue on the Terrace. 

8. The Neville House or Stone Jug, at the corner of Tysen 
Street, now a hotel. It was built about 1770 and later became 
the residence of Captain John Neville, U. S. N. 

g. Sailors' Snug Harbor, an institution for old and disabled 
seamen. It was planned by Captain Thos. Randall and founded 
by his son, Robert Richard Randall, who bequeathed his prop- 
erty, the Minto farm, just south of Union Square, Manhattan, 
for this purpose. Alexander Hamilton and Daniel D. Tompkins 
prepared the will, and Gov. DeWitt Clinton aided in securing 
the charter. Though founded in 1801, on account of litigation, 
the corner-stone of the institution was not laid until 1831 and the 
first buildings were opened in 1833. The annual income from 
the rents of the Manhattan property yields about $400,000. 
There are accommodations for about 1200 inmates, all of whoni 
must have served five years under the American flag.*i 

Continue on the Terrace to Davis Avenue. 

10. The Kreuzer-Pelton House at the Cow(t. It was built by 
Rolph in 1722 and later came into the hands of the Kreuzers. 
It was the headquarters during the Revolution of Gen. Cort- 
land Skinner, commandant of Skinner's "American Loyalists," 
and, for a time, Prince William, who later became King Wil- 
liam IV, was entertained here by General Skinner. Here Cruzer, 
Barnum's lightning calculator, was born. It was bought by 
Daniel Pelton in 1839, and his daughter, Mrs. Gen. Duffie, still 
lives here.*2 

328 



Richmond Terrace RICHMOND 53 Route 

»>,? wP/Z^'m'!!^^'' ?v. '^°^* *P^"i[/ ^I"dson sent out a small boat from his shii.. 
the Half Moon, then in the Narrows, to explore the Kills; when opposite the 
Cove, at West New Brighton, they were attacked by the Indians from the 
shore, and an English sailor named Coleman, who was in command of the 
boat, was killed by an arrow; his remains were taken to Sandy Hook (some- 
say Coney Island) and buried, the place being still called " Coleman's Point." 

Go up Bard Avenue to Henderson Avenue, at the northwest comer 

of which see 

11. The house where George William Curtis lived. 

Return to Richmond Terrace. 

12. Swan Hotel, a shingle-sided building opposite the Post 
Office. It stood originally on the adjoining groinid and was the 
political center of Staten Island; here, in 1825, the recently freed 
slaves of New Jersey, Staten Island and Long Island celebrated 
their emancipation. 

13. Fountain House site, between Van and Water Streets, now occui)icd by a 
store near the Church of the Ascension. The house, built in 1750. was the 
headquarters of the British officers attached to the fort, wliich stood wiicrc 
the church is located; it was burned, as a war measure, by order of deneral 
Sullivan. It was the scene of the first public ball on Staten Ishind; the 
phrase " fiddler's change " originated here, as it was customary to take up a 
collection for the musicians after each dance. It was also the local political 
headquarters. When the house was torn down in 1895 a painting by Milburn 
the artist, who stopped here in 1840, was discovered. 

Walk to the Square bounded by the Terrace, Dongan, Dodinc and 
Cedar Streets. 

14. Dongan House site, owned by the English Governor, Thomas Donvjan 
(1682-1688), who in 1687 "purchased a manor house and some 25.000 acres 
of ground " on Staten Island, which he formed into tlic " Lordship and Manor 
of Casseltowne." The house was his hunting lodge. U.cre he lived until 1601. 
when he fled to England during the Leisler troubles. The estate went to his 
nephews, one of whom, Walter, succeeded to the title; finally it went out of the 
family into other hands, among them Judge Ogden Edwards. At the time of 
its destruction by fire, Christmas, 1878, it was owned by T. H. Williamson. 

Indian remains have been found nearby in the sand bank, and at the foot 
of the embankment was a famous spring, a meeting place for Indian harvest 
festivals- and treaty making. 

15. The DeGroot House, of Dutch architecture, at the corner 
of Columbia Street. DeGroot is the Dutch for LcGrand, the 
name of the original French family. 

Side trip along Columbia Street. 

16. The Scott-Edwards House, at the northwest corner of Co- 
lumbia and Prospects Streets, was the residence of Judge Ed- 
wards, the first Supreme Court Justice to reside on Staten Island 
under the Republic; he was the grandson of Jonathan Edwards 
and a cousin of Aaron Burr. 

17. The Tyler House, Clove Road, here a continuatioH of 
Columbia Street and Broadway; it was owned by Mrs. Juliana 
Gardiner, mother of President Tyler's wife, later by Mrs. Tyler. 
It was bought in 1878 by Hon. W. M. Evarts and later occupied 
by the Russian Consul-General. The park has been cut up by 
speculators. 

329 



Route 53 HISTORICAL GUIDE Port Richmond 

Continue on the Clove Road. 

i8. Oldest Corsen House on the island, a few rods north of 
Richmond Turnpike. It was built about 1690. 

Britton Mill, near Clove Lake, was the scene of local romances. 
Return on Clove Road to Cherry Lane, then south on Manor Road. 

19. The Dubois House, on the northwest corner; General 
Santa Anna lived here (see 5). 

Go west on Cherry Lane to 

20. The Decker House, on Barrett Street, just off Cherry 
Lane; the Decker family descended from Johannes de Decker, 
who arrived in 1655. 

Walk north on Decker Avenue and continuing streets to the Terrace 
at Port Richmond. 

21. Danner's Hotel, the old Port Richmond Hotel, also called 
the St. James Hotel, near the corner of Richmond Avenue. It 
stands on the site of the Revolutionary Fort Decker and was 
built soon after the war, as a private residence; it became a 
hotel in 1820 and was then the largest hotel in the county. Aaron 
Burr was a guest of the Winant " family and died here in Sep- 
tember, 1836. 1854-1856 it was the headquarters of the Know- 
Nothing or American Party. Its name has been changed many 
times, and the building itself is materially altered from the 
original form. 

There was another fort west of this locality. 

22. Van Pelt Academy, behind the Post Office at Port Rich- 
mond on the Terrace just west of Richmond Avenue, was once 
a famous school under the management of Dr. P. I. Van Pelt, 
minister of the Reformed Church; it is now a furniture shop. 

23. Dutch Reformed Church, a short distance up Richmond 
Avenue from the Terrace, opposite Church Street; it is on the 
site of the church burned during the Revolution; the Sunday 
School is said to be the oldest in the United States. See tablet 
over the front door. 

Go up Richmond Avenue, nearly opposite Harrison Street; see 

24. The Jacques House, now Progress Hall; also called Har- 
rison House. It was built by Isaac Jacques, a New York mer- 
chant and a descendant of the French Count Jacques, who came 
to this country toward the end of the 17th century. The willows 
came from St. Helena, the boxwood from Mt. Vernon and the 
fence from the residence of Mr. Jacques in Whitehall Street in 
Manhattan. 



Holland's Hook RICHMOND 53 Route 

Walk along the Terrace to the Linseed Oil Mills. 

25. The Housman House site, southwest corner John Street. The oricinal 
Housman came to America in 1675 or 1676. 

26. The Lake-Croak House, between Bay and Simnnson Streets. 
The land on which it stands was part of a lot K^rantt'd 1)%- Sir 
Edmund Andros to John Lee, December 16, 1680. 

27. The Post House, on the Terrace, in the grDunds cf thr 
MiUiken Iron Works, was erected in 1691. 

28. The DeHart House, next the car barn, a short distance 
east of Holland Avenue. This hou^e is over 150 years old and 
was once a school. 

There is an Indian graveyard on Holland's Hook, and on the hcinhts at 
the approach to the ferry were two British forts. 

Go south on Western Avenue, under the R. R. bridge, to Old Place. 

Old Place was at one time called Tunissen's Neck. Morris says the name 
originated in the following manner: Religious services were held in such a 
dilapidated building that a new place of worship was selected. This was ro 
inconvenient that the early building was repaired and worsiii|> resumed at the 
" Old Place." One section of Old Place was called " Skunkville." 

See two or three old houses on the right, on the old Daniel Jones nhice. 

29. Old Place Mill, a little east, on Washington Avenue; some of the 
foundations are still to be seen on the edge of the creek on the right side of the 
road. 

Go east on Washington Avenue past the school-house, and on the 
opposite side of the avenue, near South Avenue, see the 

30. Van Pelt-Decker House; the house stands a little back 
from Washington Avenue. Tradition says that the American 
forces, on one of their raids from New Jersey, found Van Pelt 
in bed; he was summarily pulled out of bed and forced to accom- 
pany the troops into New Jersey, where he fought with the 
patriot army: the next day his wife succeeded in Retting clothes 
to him. Later his wife kept a tavern for soldiers of both armies. 

Some distance farther east, opposite Harbor Street, stood until 1904 the 
Van Pelt Cottage, over 200 years old. 



ZZ^f^ 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




DIAGRAM 

5ECTI0N2- EXCURSIONX- 

RICHMOm 



Plate LXV. Route 54. 



C. K. 



332 



RICHMOND 

ROUTE 54. 

SECTION II.— ST. GEORGE TO NEW SPRINGVILLE. 

(Figures refer to Plate LXV). 

Take the trolley at St. George for Elizabeth Ferry and change to 
Bull's Head car at Port Richmond, passing 

31. Butler's Hotel Site, near the head of Washington Avenue; this was a 
favorite resort of the sporting fraternity; during the Revolution it was oc- 
cupied by British officers as headquarters; burned in 1892. 

Get off the car at Vedder Avenue, walk east to Willow Brook Road 
and then South to Watchogue Road. 

2,2. Pero-Christopher House, at northwest corner; across the 
road see 

33. Mersereau House, where Col. Joshua Mersereau lived and 
from which he had a hairbreadth escape during the Ri'vnluti.m; 
the British commander had put a price on his head. 

Southeast from Watchogue Road and Willow Brook Arcniic, 

34. Site of the Vreeland House, recently destroyed. 

Walk east on Watchogue Road to Prohibition Park.*3 

35. The Corsen-Ives House, at the corner of St. John Street. 
Ives was at one time the bicycle champion of the United States. 

36. Bodine's Inn site, at Castleton Corners; it was built by David Jacques 
before the Revolution; was made a hotel later and became the home ot the 
actor Keene during his last days. 

Walk south on the Willozv Brook Road to Willozv Brook; among the 
willows back of the ice-house, sec 
2,7. The Christopher Homestead, where the Committee of 
Safety met during the Revolution; it was reached by secret path«^ 
through the swamps; many Americans were captured while try- 
ing to reach it. 

Walk back to Richmond Turnpike, then zvest to Richnwnd or Old 

Stone Road. 

38. Bull's Head Tavern site at the corner; 5t was built in 174. 0^"^ ^" * 
Tory headquarters and the scene of many outrages; burned 1890. 4 

Continue south to New Springville. 
Long Neck, now known as New Springville. was the fot:rth 
oldest settlement on Staten Island. 

39. School House site, where the P-«-^ bmUUng ^tands; the c.i.m^ 
was built in the 17th century; the old stone was usrd in trit jr 

333 



Route 54 HISTORICAL GUIDE New Springville 

Walk south to Rockland Avenue, then east to 

40. Corsen House site; the Corsen family is one of the oldest on the island; 
the earliest mention of the name is in 1680. There are some fine family relics 
in the house, which stands on the old site. *5 

Get information here as to route to the wolf pit. 

41. Wolf Pit, reached by a pleasant trip through the woods 
to the north, or may be visited from 2>7- The pit was built many 
years ago by Captain Jones, who owned the surrounding woods. 
It was covered with brush and leaves and was baited with a 
piece of meat hung from a sapling just above it; the wolf would 
leap to this and fall through the brush into the hole. 

Go hack to the village and, at the corner of Union Street, see 

42. The Old Crocheron House; a little farther west is 

43. The later Crocheron House, which contains some fine old 
furniture. John Crocheron, the founder of the family here, was 
a prominent Huguenot; to escape execution in France he hid in 
a hogshead on board a vessel by which his neighbors were 
coming to America. His will was dated December 13, 1695. 

Walk along Union Street to Richmond Turnpike, then toward Travis- 

ville. 

44. The Ridgeway House; a long, low building, south of the 
road in the field. At Linoleumville, then called New Blazing 
Star, was a Revolutionary fort. House destroyed by fire, 191 1. 

Return to New Springville, walk south on Richmond Road, now 

Broadway. 

45. Simonson House site; built about 1690 by William, the son of Simon La 
Blant, who escaped from France during the Huguenot persecution, and on 
his arrival here was known as Simonson; he was the ancestor of the Simonson 
family in this country. The old house was of stone of the Dutch style of 
architecture, and, when it was destroyed, a brick building took its place. 

Continue on Broadivay. 

46. The Blake-Miller House, built about 1668; it is situated 
on the left, a short distance from Union Street. 

A short zvalk brings one to Karles Neck. 

47. The Barne-Tysen House, stands off the road to the west; 
the family came from Holland in 1660 and received a grant of 
land from Sir Edmund Andros in 1677; house built 1680. 

Walk back to Bull's Head and take the trolley home or follow the 

Richmond Hill Road to Richmond, where the car may 

be taken for St. George. 

334 



RICHMOND 

ROUTE 55. 

SECTION III-ST. GEORGE TO ARROCHAR. 
(Figures refer to Plate LXVI.) 

Take the trolley or walk along the streets near the shore through 
Tompkinsville and Stapleton. 

There was formerly a large spring near the south end of the R. R. tunnel, 
where ships obtained water; the vicinity was called from tiiis, the '* Watering 
Place." 

48. Old Health Officer's Residence, the only remains of the 
former Quarantine property, now owned by the American Cotton 
Docks Co., next to the United States Light-House Reservation. 
The property made an extensive plant; it was destroyed in 1858 
by the summary action of some of the inhabitants. For some 
time, the people of Staten Island had petitioned for a change 
of Quarantine to a less exposed place. Incensed by inaction, 
they took their own measures and burned the plant. The land- 
ing was the site of an old fort. 

Walk along Central Avenue to Arietta Street. 

49. Quarantine Ferry Landing, at the foot of Arietta Street, passing the 
R. R. Station, where was the site of Nautilus Hall (built 1808): this hall was 
a popular political resort, because "out of the way"; it was the scene of re- 
ceptions to Lafayette, Garibaldi, Van Buren, Tompkins, Scott, Seward and 
others. 

At the corner of GriMn and Arietta Streets, see 

50. The Dutch Reformed Church site. The church was built 1818, and after 
many years used as a shop; it was demolished in 1907, to make way tor a 
block of shops; Governor Tompkins aided in its erection. 

Just above, on the south side of Sarah Ann Street, near the Ruh- 
mond Turnpike, see 

51. General Van Buren's Home. 

Walk along GriMn and Bay Streets. 

52. The Planters' Hotel, at the northwest corner of Grant 
Street, was a popular resort for wealthy Southern planters. 

Go up Clinton and Church Streets: see 
53 The Pavilion Hill, known as Mt. Tompkins in the early 
days, where are the remains of two Revolutionary forts; one 
may get a fine view from this hill. The forts were rebmlt durmg 
the War of 1812. 

335 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



SECTION 3- EXCURSIONX 

RICHMOND. 




Plate LXVI. Route 55. 



C. K. 



Garibaldi House RICHMOND 55 Route 

Continue on Bay Street nearly to Congress. 

54. Commodore Vanderbilt's later house. 

Farther along, at the N. W. corner of Union Street, see 

55. Commodore Vanderbilt's earlier home. Mrs. Vamlerbilt. 
wife of the Commodore, died here. 

Continue on Bay Street. 

56. United States Marine Hospital. Originally a State hos- 
pital, erected 1834-1835, it was maintained by a State tax, which 
was later declared unconstitutional, on seamen entering the 
Port of New York. Later the Marine Society of New York 
purchased the property and rented it to the United States Gov- 
ernment, in 1883, as a Marine Hospital. Finally, in 1903, it was 
purchased by the United States Government. It contains 150 
beds. 

In the rear is a building called the Seaman's Retreat, over 100 
years old. This was the original hospital building established by the 
Marine Society. A short distance to the west, corner of Bay Street 
and Simonson Avenue, is the site of the first National headquarters 
of the Republican party, where General Fremont received the news of 
his defeat in 1856. 

Walk along Bay Street to Townsend Avenue. 

57. Townsend Castle site, at the west end of the avenue; three brothers 
came about 1661 and founded the family; the house was burned in 1885 to- 
gether with a number of fine historical paintings. 

Follow New York Avenue to Chestnut Street. 

58. The Garibaldi House, near Bachman's brewery, at the 
corner of Tompkins Avenue; it is marked by a tablet placed oh 
it by the lovers of the Italian General, who lived here for some 
time. He lived with Antonio Meucci, the inventor of a tele- 
phone system, who died here in 1889. The house was presented 
to the Italian Government by Frederick Bachman. It is now 
protected by a cement superstructure. 

Walk east on Chestnut Avenue to Bay Street, then south. 

59. The Austin House at foot of Clifton Avenue, said to have 
been erected in 1710 by a Dutch merchant; it is well preserved 
in the original style and contains many relics of the Revolution. 

60. Quarantine at the foot of Cliff Street; a British fnrt wan 
located here. 

337 



Route 55 HISTORICAL GUIDE Ft. Wadsworth 

Continue on up Bay Street and New York Avenue to 

6i. Forts Wadsworth and Tompkins, established by New York 
State during the War of 1812. In 1847 the United States Gov- 
ernment bought the reservation, demolished the old forts and 
built the present works, which have been constantly improved 
and brought up to date. It is said the first Dutch immigrants 
stopped here and a block house was erected here by DeVries; 
this was several times destroyed by the Indians. 

The fort was rebuilt by the English in 1776. The last shot 
of the Revolution was fired at this fort by a British gunboat 
on Evacuation Day, 1783, because of the open derision expressed 
by the onlooking Staten Islanders. It is hoped to mark this 
fort by a tablet. Inside the reservation was the old Fountain 
House. 

62. Arrochar is reached from the fort by the railroad or one can walk there 
by way of Richmond Avenue. Arrochar Park was once known as Oude Dorp 
(Old Town) and is the site of the first Dutch settlement on Staten Island, 
1 64 1. The village consisted of several log huts and was destroyed three times 
by the Indians. (But see Note, p. 325.) 

63. The Vreeland Homestead at South Beach was recently destroyed. 

Take the trolley hack to St. George. 



338 



RICHMOND 
ROUTE 56. 

SECTION IV.-ST. GEORGE TO NEW DORP AND 

RICHMOND. 

(Figures refer to Plate LXVII). 

Take the trolley for New Dorp, passing 

64. Emerson Hill and site of the house called "The Snug- 
ger3\" It is in Concord, earlier called Dutch Farms, on the 
west side of the road, just beyond the Clove Road, where the 
trolley from the North Shore connects with, this line. The 
present house was built by William Emerson, Judge of Rich- 
mond County, 1841-1843, not far from his original house, "The 
Snuggery." Ralph Waldo Emerson spent some time here; Henry 
D. Thoreau was a teacher in the family. *6 

65. The Clinch Homestead, near Spring Street, Concord, op- 
posite the hotel, was built about 1700, and was the early home 
of Mrs. A. T. Stewart; much modernized, upper story shingled. 
Further on, at Garretson, lately called Dongan Hills, on the east side 

of the road, see 

66. The Perrine Homestead, built about 1668. The village 
was named for John C. Garretson, whose two-century-uld man- 
sion here has lately disappeared. It was occupied at one time 
during the Revolution by Capt. Coghlan of the British Army, 
Opposite is Todt or Toad Hill, one of the high points on Staten 
Island. 

Todt Hill was also called Iron Hill, this metal having been extracted, .it 
times, from the hill. The ravine penetrating the hill was called Valley of the 
Iron Hill and Mersereau's Valley. It was the scene of the rescue of a young 
woman from a British officer, by her lover Mersereau. „ , , 

New Dorp, including Elm Tree Light, now embraces also Stony Hrook: here 
General Moncton rested with his army several weeks after the 'Tcnch and 
Indian war, during which time Sir Jeffrey Amherst was mvestcd with the 
Order of the Bath, October 25, 1761. , . 

It contained an important military post during the Civil \\ar. 

The trolley car passes on the right 

67. The Moravian Cemetery, within which is the Old Mo- 
ravian Church and Parsonage (now used as a Sunday School- 
room and the cemetery office); the original plot for this ceme- 
tery was bought on June 9, 1763. for $124.08*. being part of 
the estate of Governor Dongan (see No. 14); the Vandcrbilt 
family have added largely to the church property; the corner- 
stone of the old church was laid July 7. i/^.V. i" the cemetery 
are many graves antedating the church. See the Vanderbilt 
mausoleum. 

339 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



OUDE DORP 
ARROCHAR 




DIAGRAM 

SEC 4 EXC.X 

RICHMOND. 

Compild by G.W.Nash. M.D. 



Plate LXVII. Routes 56, 57, 58 



340 



Fountain House RICHMOND 56 Route 

68. The Aaron Cortelyou Homestead, opposite the ccnutery 
gate; also called the Lake or Gififord House. Because of a burg- 
lary in this house, a negro suffered the first legal execution in 
the county. 

yy. Stony Brook; the original Waldensian settlement in 1658 (Note. p. 
325), the second oldest settlement on Staten Island, and the County Scat from 
1683 to 1827. Here were Staten Island's first Court House and Jail, 168^; 
first Church, 1670; first Whipping Post (witches were punished here); first 
market or trading place; first marriage. 

The Huguenots settled here in 1658. 

The old Britton House was here; the site is just about opposite Tysen Avenue, 
on the west side of the road; it was built between 1650 and 1660 and de- 
molished in 1896, being one of the oldest structures on Staten Island. It was 
used as a court house; the family were driven out during the Revolution, anci 
the colonel of one of the British mounted regiments had his head<iuartiTs 
here; it was also used as a small-pox hospital. In early days it was the 
scene of an Indian massacre, where a whole family was killed. 

Continue to Nezv Dorp, sec 

78. The Black Horse Tavern, at the corner of Amboy Road 
and Richmond Road, a resort of British officers during the Revo- 
lution. 

Opposite, at the head of New Dorp Lane, is the site of the Patten House, 
built in 1837 to accommodate the crowds who came to see the New Dorp 
races along the Lane. It was a favorite resort of the Vandcrbilts; in its later 
days it was used as a Roman Catholic institution and finally as a tenement. 

79. The Rose and Crown House stood a little to the north of New Dorp 
Lane on the west side of Richmond Road; it was built by early Huguenot 
settlers, and was the birthplace of Bishop Bedell; while the headciuartcrs of Sir 
Wm. Howe, here he and his brother. Lord Howe, first heard the reading of the 
Declaration of Independence; later it was occupied by British officers, among 
them General Knyphausen, Sir Henry Clinton, Lord Cornwalhs and Sir (.uy 
Carleton. It was torn down in 1854. 

80. The Fountain House, on the opposite side of Richmond 
Road and just above the Black Horse Tavern, recently remodeled; 
it is one of the oldest houses remaining on Staten Island. Here 
Margaret Moncrieffe met Captain Coghlan; here, also. Lieut. 
Sidney A. Simons, U. S. N., was born. He was drowned off 
Cape Hatteras. 

Near by is Camp Hill, a British gambling resort and duelling 
ground. During the occupation of the island by the British, 
many officers were court-martialled for gambling and duelling. 



341 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 
ROUTE 57 

SIDE TRIP A.— TO ELM TREE LIGHT 

(Figures refer to Plate LXVII) 

Leave trolley at New Dorp Lane, then walk east; cross the R. R. 

track, passing on the left 

69. The Parker Clausen House, about no years old; has some inter- 
esting hardware. Nearly opposite, see 

70. Jacobsen-Vanderbilt House, built by Christian Jacobsen ; dur- 
ing the Revolution, British soldiers entered the house and fatally shot 
him; his will is dated January 10, 1782. Later the house was owned 
by Cornelius Vanderbilt and his son, William H. Vanderbilt. 

Further down on the left, see 
70a. Vanderbilt House, now owned by George W. Vanderbilt. It 
was given to W. H. Vanderbilt by his father, who sent him here to 
recover his health. His income from the farm at one time was over 
$12,000 a year. The house has been much modernized and has a square 
tower. It has been moved back from its former position nearer the 
lane. Near the foot of the lane, see 

71. The Cubberly House; the original name of the family is 
Coverle; the first of the name came in 1769; see the quaint kitchen. 

At the extreme end of the lane, see 
y2. Elm Tree Beacon, the landing place of the Huguenots, 1658. 
There was a chain of British breastworks near the shore; the old 
Track House, until lately, stood on the Vanderbilt farm at the foot 
of the lane. From New Dorp Lane turn off on Mill Road to the cast; 
at the corner of Tysen Lane, see 

73. The Lake Tysen House, situated in the field ; the Lake family 
settled on the island in 1670, coming from England. The house has 
been kept in its original condition by the descendants of the builders. 

Near by, see 
73a. Lake Farm House; during the Revolution it was occupied by 
British officers. Continue on Mill Lane to Giiyon Avenue 

74. Guyon-Clarke House, at 360 Guyon Avenue. It is an early 
Huguenot house, where was organized a British Masonic Lodge; see 
the old clock in the hall, and the land patent signed by Sir Edmund 
Andros. 

The Club House, near by, was frequented by the most prominent 
people of the island. Not far away to the south, on the Boulevard, see 

75. The Cole House; the family came to America in 1639, by way 
of Holland, where the name was changed to "Kool"; in America this 
became Cool, then Cole. Nearly opposite,- on the edge of the marsh, see 

76. The Lockman House Ruins; the lintel piece lately disappeared; it 
bore the inscription, "May 22, 1782." 

342 



RICHMOND 



ROUTE 58. 

RICHMOND. 

(Figures refer to Plates LXVH and LXVIII). 

Take trolley to Richmond, passing at the bend of the road, just be- 
yond New Dorp village, the duelling ground of the British officers. 

81. The Grote House, later occupied by Dr. Rottmi, just be- 
yond the corner of Egbertville and Rockland Avenues; it is over 
100 years old and was originally the home of Colonel Richard 
Connor, w^here Aai*on Burr made his last call. Above the ravine 
is the old Egbertville Academy. 

Richmond, formerly Cuckoldstowne or Cucklestownc, became 
the County Seat in 1729. 

At the end of the trolley line turn to the north. 

82. St. Andrews Church, one of the four churches established 
(1708) by Queen Anne; the church has still part of the silver 
service given by her to the church; it was occupied by the British 
as a hospital and was the center of two Revolutionary tights. 
The original building was built in 1713. See memorial tablet to 
commemorate Anne's gift in 1708 (unveiled October 21. kkxS).*; 



-^ 



® 



^ection4'. 




hO 



^KCUR^SfON X. 



Plate LXVIII. 
343 



Route 58. 



K. 



Route 58 HISTORICAL GUIDE Richmond 

On the hill zvhere the school house stands were 

SZ' The Whipping Post, removed 1825, and the Callows, the scene of the 
first execution in the county. 

84. Later Latourette House, made of brick; see 

85. The older Latourette House ruins — a council of war took place here lead- 
ing to the battle of Springfield, N. J. It was the headquarters of Lt.-Col. 
Simcoe, commanding the " Queen's Rangers." The Holmes family, ancestors 
of Nancy Hanks and Abraham Lincoln, once lived in this house. The earliest 
mention of the Latourette family is in 1726. *8 

S6. Old Mill. 

Return to the Village on the Mill Road. 

87. The Barton House and old Cuckoldstowne Inn site, corner of Rich- 
mond Road and Court Street, behind the County Clerk's office; this was the 
headquarters of General Cleveland, chief engineer of the British Army; here it 
was that Andre wrote his will. 

87 A. County Clerk's Office. 

88. Second County Court House site; building destroyed by the British in 
the Revolution (the first was at Stony Brook) ; the site was occupied for many 
years by the Richmond County Hall and since 1890 by St. Andrews Parish 
House. 

88A. Third County Court House, occupied by the Board of 
Supervisors, October, 1794, for the first time. In 1837 it was a 
dwelling and now a liotel. 

88B. Fourth County Court House, on Tysen Street, now in 
use. It was erected in 1837. See old graveyard near by. 

88C. Second County Jail, 1727, where now the street leads to 
Richmond Road. The first jail in Stony Brook. 

Nearly opposite was 

89. Old Dutch Reformed Church, original site; built 1808. 

89A. Site Old Dutch Reformed Church (second location, foundation may still 
be seen). 

There were three Revolutionary forts in Richmond, all on the hill above 
St. Andrews Church: one about 300 yards from the church, one still standing 
about a third of a mile west, and another on the hill overlooking the meadows, 
where the Bedell graveyard is located. 

Richmond was the site of the camp of the Seventeenth British Dragoons, 
the only regular British cavalry regiment in the Revolution; they acted as 
General Clinton's bodyguard. 



344 



RICHMOND 

ROUTE 59. 

SECTION V— ST. GEORGE TO GREENRIDGE AND 
GREAT KILLS. 

(Figures refer to Plate LXIX). 

Take the trolley at St George to Richmond; then the Fresh Kills 

Road to Greenridge, called in the early days Marshland and 

Fresh Kills, passing on the right, just across the bridge, 

90. Benham Mansion ruins; the house was built by Commander T. G. Ben- 
ham when he was a Lieutenant in the Mexican War; it was burned down 1897. 
It was also the home of Admiral A. E. K. Benham. *9 

Pass on the right the Cortelyou House, of late Dutch architecture, 
to the road leading to the right of the mill, now a cement block 
factory; see the; picturesque ruins of the millwheel behind the build- 
ing. 

Pass on the left 

91. Bedell House site, built in 1670, and a little farther on the site of the 
"House by the Mill," built in 1685; the latter house was a military storehouse 
during the Revolution; near it was a British fort and a Dragoon camp. Two 
battles were fought here. The Bedells came to America 1673, settling on Long 
Island, and on Staten Island a century later, 1767; see mention of the family 
in the county records, where Silas Bedell rendered a bill for doctoring. 

92. The Seaman House site, at the S. E. corner of Fresh Kills Road and 
Eltingville Road; this was the home of Benjamin Seaman, the last of the 
Colonial judges in Richmond County; he went to New Brunswick after the 
Revolution. The house was burned in 1890. 

93. The Huguenot Church site, near where the present barn stands on the 
Seaman estate; it was built between 1680 and 1695; the spot is to be marked 
with a stone; in the old churchyard were buried the last of Staten Island 
Indians "in 1826. 

Return on Fresh Kills Road to Giffords Lane, then south. 

94. Small Stone Building on the west side of the lane, a few 
feet from Fresh Kills Road; it is said that this is one of the 
houses where courts were held years ago. 

95. Holy Spring House, on the east side of the lane, at 
the corner of Dewey Avenue, in the hollow by a big tree. The 
earliest Roman Catholic services on this part of the island were 
held here. The house gets its name from a miraculous spring 
in the basement. 

Continue to Giffords, called Great Kills. 

96. Old School House site, near the Post Office f"'l. ^to^c of J >\\ Hcihcrinj:- 
ton. where may be seen relics of the Pp.llon family ,^"^,. ^'^V^,; J'^VVriowinL 
down Hillside Avenue to the Boulevard, where arc situated the three followiHK 
Poillon houses built about 1694: 

97. The Seguine House, a few feet east of Hillside Avenue. 

98. The Erastus Wiman House, a short distance west of 
Hillside Avenue. Wiman did a great deal to awaken .si.iten 
Island. 

24S 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




Plate LXIX. Route 59. 
346 



C, K, 



Rossville RICHMOND 59a Route 

99. The Woods of Arden House, quite a distance farther 
along, near Townsend Avenue. The name was given by WiniaH. 
The Journcay House ruins are passed on the way. 

There was an Indian burying-ground in Great Kills. 

Seguine's Point was the scene of an uprising of the people 
in 1859, on account of the establishment of quarantining h(is- 
pitals here. The buildings were burned, as were those at Tomp- 
kinsville, and the county was forced to pay the State $110,000, 
which sum included the loss of the buildings at Tumpkin^ville, 
destroyed in 1858. 

A floating hospital for yellow fever cases was located here in 
1859. In i860 Swinburne Island was made by filling in. and in 
1873 Hoffman Island was made in a similar manner, and so Sc- 
guine's Point was freed from the terror of .contagious diseases. 
Return by Townsend Avenue to R. R. Stations at either Eltingville 

or Annadale. 

ROUTE 59a. 
SIDE TRIP TO ROSSVILLE AND WOODROW. 

Follow Fresh Kills Road to Rossville; previous to the Revolution 

this was called "Smoking Point" and during the 

Revolution, " Blazing Star." 

100. Old Mill, where Richmond Creek empties into Fresh 
Kills. 

loi. Oakley House site, near the foot of Rossville Avenue, sometimes called 
Shea's Lane; it was the birthplace of James A. Hradlev. the foun.liT of Asburv 
Park; Bishop Asbury was entertained here soon after his arrival from Kiigland, 
in 1 771. It was a tavern before the Revolution. , 

It is claimed that the old stone house that stood until 1850 on the farm 
of Samuel W. Benedict, near Rossville, was built by David Teterscn dc \ rics, 
who came here from Holland in 1636 and established a bouwerie on ^«aten 
Island. There was a military redoubt at Rossville on the site of the Decker 
House. *io 

Walk down Rossville Avenue to Woodrozv Road, then turn east. 

102. The Winant House, used by Tory marauders; a quantity 
of silver was found in the cellar several years ago. 

Opposite is the Methodist Church, on the site of tlie first M. 
E. Church on Staten Island, about 1787- 

Walk across Huguenot Lane and follow Journeay Avenue. 

rot Peter Van Pelt House site, known as the Nolan House, destroyed «n 
1904!* it is loca/ed just bick of ^he present Nolan House. ii.sho, A.hury 
preached here shortly after his arrival in America. 
Return to Huguenot Lane, then south to Huguenot R. R. Station. 

347 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 




DIAGRAM. 

SECTIONS- EXCURSIONX' 

B.ICHMOMD. 



Plate LXX. Route 6o. 



C. K. 



348 




^..-^ ' 



RICHMOND 

ROUTE 60. 

SECTION VI.-ST. GEORGE TO TOTTENVILLE. 

(Figures refer to Plate LXX). 

Take the train to Tottenville, passing through Richmond ]' alley. 

104. The Old Tabernacle Rtuns, built 1822 as a place for Methodist worship, 
at Richmond Valley, near Railroad Station. 

Tottenville was formerly known as the Manor of r?entlev. 

IDS. Union House site, between the two shipyards on Rai'lroad Avenue, at 
the foot of Tyrrell Street. It was built in 1784 and was originally the John- 
son farmhouse; it was in the parlor of this house, later used as a barroom, 
that Commodore Vanderbilt married his cousin, Sophia Johnson. 

Walk along Broadway to Church Street, then over the mill dam. 

106. The Disosu'ay-Mill site, over ipo years old at the time of its de- 
struction; some of the foundation stones can yet be seen at the end of the dam 
to the left. *ii 

Return to the village, then follow Broadway, Main Street and Anthoy 

Road to the Lane and Bentley Avenue. 

107. The Billopp House, built about 1668 by Christopher Bil- 
lopp, who, in 1688, aided New York's claim to Staten Island by 
circumnavigating the island in his own vessel in less than 24 
hours; his reward was the grant of 1163 acres on the south shore, 
which he named for his vessel " Bentley Manor." His grandson, 
Christopher, was a loyalist and was carried off for ransom by 
some American Rangers and kept until exchanged for an Ameri- 
can prisoner. He was again taken but was freed by Washington 
at Howe's request. After the war he went to live in Nova 
Scotia. 

In this house took place an interview between Howe and an 
American committee, composed of Adams, Franklin and Rut- 
ledge, after the battle of Long Island, but no satisfactory agree- 
ment was reached. There have been several attempts to get 
the State to buy and preserve the house. The old family bury- 
ing-ground has disappeared, but two old gravestones lean against 
the veranda. Sir Henry Clinton, Generals Robertson and Kny- 
phausen and Major Andre visited here. Near the house is an old 
Indian burying-ground. At the present writing, a small fee 
is cliarged for admission. (See 1911 Report Am. Scon, and Hi^t. Frcs. 
Soc.) 

Continue to the extreme point of the island. 

108 Fort ruins; the fort was started by the War Department durioR ti.. 

^'f^^'c^^r^i s:^^lS? =;^:jsri;e^:e;^:Nhe beach wi.. s,.ow the 

way'ac?os7'the"meadot to 'Belmont Street; then walk -l,'' ,f/,-j-^' ;.',", ^.^c? 

i^^s;"ir^n?^a.^H^i.- ^^. :;-v s^ ^Cr'r" r^^ 

good deportment from the burgomaster of their n.itn- ..tv. M-... 
Revolutionary fort at Kreisherville. 

349 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ROUTE 6oa. 

SIDE TRIP TO PRINCESS BAY. 

Get off the R. R. train at Princess Bay Station and walk south on 
Princess Bay Road. 

no. Purdy's Hotel, on the shore; it is nearly 200 years old, 
but well preserved. 

A short walk along the shore brings one to 

111. The Androvette House. The family took up land in 1699. 

112, 113. The sites of British forts. 

Return by train to St. George. 



350 



RICHMOND 



ADDENDA, 1912 

*i (p 328). Near the main entrance to the grounds is a hronze 
statue, by St. Gaudens, over the grave of R. R. Randall, the founder. 

*2 (p. 328). The original Kreuzer House stood a little further back 
from this house, on the hillside; the Kreuzer burying ground was just 
a little west of the present house. The present house, properly called 
the De Groot-Pelton-Marriott House, was probably built by a De Groot ; 
Johannis De Groot occupied the house at the time of the Revolution and 
probably built the middle section connecting the two ends of the house ; 
the De Groots disposed of the house in 18 14. Since then it has been 
occupied by the Pelton family and lately by the Marriott family. The 
stone or western end dates about 1730; the middle part was built just 
before the Revolution, while the brick addition is less than 100 years 
old. Major Andre was at one time billetted here; he proved himself 
a good entertainer. There is a pretty romance connected with the vault 
behind the house. 

*3 (p- 333)- Housman House, built about 1735, on the nortli side 
of Watchogue Road, about half a mile from Richmond Turnpike. It 
stands on the east bank of Stinking Brook and is but little altered. 
The Housman family is an old one on the Island, having come from 
Holland in 1675. Garrett Housman was a noted Loyalist during the 
Revolution. 

Corsen House, at the junction of Richmond Turnpike and 
Watchogue Road, built in 1776. At one time Lord Howe and his escort 
(rested here for lunch; at his request a son was named for him. 
William Howe Corsen. 

Dongan Distillery. Tradition identifies this as the building now 
standing on the northeast corner of Richmond Road and Manor 
Avenue, to the east of 36; it has been modernized, due to necessary 
repairs. Dongan was Governor of the Province, 1683-88. 

*4 (p. 333)- The road between 38-39 is called S{(/ns /?<^tfrf.^ The 
name carries one back to the days of superstition when "signs" were 
frequently seen here; one sign especially common was a black dog as 
large as a horse, that came out at night from near by in the woods, 
frightening the easily scared travelers. 

*5 (p. 334)- This was a Jones house originally, coming mt.. tl 
Corsen family by marriage. 

Directly opposite 40 is another Jones house, on south sule .-f th 

351 



U' 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

road. Captain Jones, who occupied it during the Revolution, was a 
very prominent Tory; in spite of this, however, his family suffered 
much from the Hessians who were quartered on his farm. The western 
end is the oldest part. The house is still occupied by a descendant of 
the original owners. 

*6 (p. 339). Site of the Jiouse of Caf^t. Jacob Vanderbilt, on 
Serpentine Road, near Clove Road. It was burned down about 1901, a 
lone chimney marking the site. Capt. Jacob Vanderbilt, brother of 
Commodore Vanderbilt, was born in 1817 on Staten Island; in 1834 
he married a daughter of Gen, Israel Putnam. He operated a ferry 
from Whitehall Street, New York, to the Island. 

Grymes Hill gets its name from the Grymes family, a member of 
which built the house still standing on Serpentine Road, near Eddy 
Street. The house was built in 1836. 

*7 (p- 343)- Three tablets were erected in 1908: (i) for Queen 
Anne, who granted the charter and gave 153 acres in what is now 
Stapleton for the support of the church; this was sold for $70,000; 
(2) for the first rector, the Rev. E. S. MacKenzie; (3) for the fourteen 
rectors who served the church during its first 200 years of history. 

*8 (p. 344)- About 600 feet southwest of 85 are the remains of a 
British fort on the brow of a steep hill ; these are the only visible 
remains of a Revolutionary fort on the Island. From this spot may 
be had a beautiful and extensive view. 

*9 (p- 345)- On the west side of Fresh Kills Road, opposite Giffords 
Lane, not far from 90, is an old frame house belonging to a descendant 
of Henry Boehm, a noted schoolmaster of many years ago. During 
some repairs lately made a secret chamber was discovered, built in as 
part of the chimney, and reached by a loose board in the floor. 

*io (p. 347). Between Rossville and Kreischerville, on the shore 
by the glue factory, is the old stone Winant-Johnson House, of Dutch 
architecture. 

*ii (p. 349). The Disosway House is a little north of 106; it is a 
stone house on the shore road. The Disosway family was among the 
few patriot families on the Island. There is a tradition that durinir 
the Revolution the head of the family was captured by the British ; 
his wife was offered her husband's freedom if she would persuade 
her brother, also active in the American ranks, to cease his activity or 
join the British. She is said to have spurned the offer indignantly. 
The family came from France, the first settler in 1655. The mill, 106, 
belonged to this family. 



352 



NOTES 



353 



NOTES 



354 



PART SIX 



SPECIAL ROUTES 

I. ROUTES FOR CHILDREN, 
n. WATER ROUTES, 
in. AUTOMOBILE ROUTES. 



SPECIAL ROUTES 



I. ROUTES FOR CHILDREN. 
For Museums, etc., sec Appendix D. 

MANHATTAN. 

A. Bowling Green, Fraunces Tavern, Willett tablet, Hanover Sq.. 

Wall Street, Sub Treasury, Trinity Churcbyard. K. i. j, 3. 

B. Custom House, Battery Park, views of Bay, Aquarium. K. i. 4. 

C. Governor's Island. R. 4. 

D. City Hall, City Hall Park, Post Office. St. Paul's Cbapel and 

Churchyard. R. 5, 6. 

E. Washington Square, Exempt Firemen's Rooms in Jefferson Mar- 

ket. R. 10. 

F. St. Mark's-in-the-Bovvery, pear tree tablet, Cooper Union Mu>cum. 

Also by arrangement, Middle Church. R. 11. 

G. Bryant Park, N. Y. Public Library (Children's Room); Fifth 

Avenue bus to Central Park. R. 17. 
H. American Museum of Natural History (Indian remains found 

in Manhattan). 
I. Metropolitan Museum of Art (historical prints and oi)jccts). 
J. The Nev^ York Historical Society. 
K. McGown's Pass, remains of Fort Clinton, Block House No. i. 

R. 21. 
L. Block House No. 3, Grant's Tomb, Columbia University. K. i'). 
M. Washington's Headquarters. R. 23. 
N. High Bridge, Death Gap, etc., Fort Washington, Fort Washington 

Point. R. 23, 24, 25. 
O. Inwood and Cold Spring: particularly suitable ior an all-day 

outing, pure water at the spring. Take Broadway Subway to 

Two Hundred and Seventh Street Station, walk west to the 

public school, north to the old Dyckman House, and west along 

the trail through the woods. R. 28b. 



357 



Routes for HISTORICAL GUIDE Children 



THE BRONX. 

V 

A. Van Cortlandt Park and Mansion. R. 29. 

B. New York University, Hall of Fame, Historical Museum. R. 30. 

C. Tomb of Drake and houses on Hunt's Point. Lenox Ave. Subw^ay 
Express to Intervale Ave. Sta. ; thence via Hunt's Pt. trolley. R. 31. 

D. Botanical Garden, Horticultural Hall, in Bronx Park. R. 32. 

E. Indian Well, Hemlock Grove, Lorillard Mansion Museum in 

Bronx Park. R. 32. 

F. Zoological Gardens, Rocking Stone, Bronx River in Bronx Park. 

R. 32. 

For Routes D, E, take Lenox Avenue Subway to One Hundred 

and Forty-ninth Street, transfer to the Third Ave. Elevated R. R. 

to Bronx Park. 

For Route F, take West Farms Subway to One Hundred and 

Eightieth Street. 

G. Glover's Rock, Macedonia Hotel, City Island. R. 34. 



BROOKLYN. 

A. Bushvi'Ick Dutch Reformed Church and Churchyard; Cooper 

Park. R. 35c. 

B. Williamsburg Plaza and Bridge. R. 35a. 

C. Borough Hall, Beecher Statue, Long Island Historical Society. 

R. 36. 

D. Martyrs' Tomb, Fort Green Park; Navy Yard. R. Z7- 

E. Prospect Park (best seen from the electric omnibus, 25 cents). 

R. 38. 

F. Children's Museum (Brooklyn Institute), Bedford Park. Par- 

ticularly valuable. R. 38. 

G. Fort Hamilton. R. 42. 



358 



Routes for SPECIAL ROUTES 



Children 



QUEENS. 

Cross Queensboro Bridge, car to Stcinway, walk along the Old 
Bowery Road to North Beach. Return by trolley or College 
Point Ferry to Ninety-ninth Street, Manhattan. R. 44. 

Astoria Ferry from East Ninety-second Street, old houses in 
Astoria, walk along the Shore Road to Stein way, return by 
trolley to Astoria or by Queensboro Bridge. R. 45. 

Elmhurst, the old village of Newtown. R. 49. 

Quaker Meeting House, Bowne House (admission 25 cents) and 
other old houses of Flushing. R. 51. 

King Mansion, Jamaica. R. 52. 



RICHMOND. 

Municipal Ferry to St. George to see the Upper Bay. islands, 

light houses, old forts and Statue of Liberty. 
Borough Hall and Museum of the Staten Island Association of 

Arts and Sciences. R. 53. 
Sailors' Snug Harbor and old houses near by. R. 53. 
Forts Wadsworth and Tompkins. R. 55. 
Billopp House, Tottenville. R. 60. 
Old houses in New Dorp. R. 56. 
Old houses in Richmond. R. 58. 



359 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



II. WATER ROUTES 



Many interesting trips may be taken by ferries and excursion steamers. 
A few only are suggested, the chief historic points to be seen en route 
being outlined. For definite information as to rates and hours of sailing, 
consult the daily papers, for routes consult Globe and Eagle Almanacs 
or Bullinger's Guide. 

A. Governor's Island. See R. 4. 

B. Liberty Island. See R. 4. 

C. Municipal Ferry to St. George, Staten Island. Boats leave the 

Battery at intervals of twenty to thirty minutes. Views of 
lower Manhattan; Governor's, Ellis and Liberty Islands; South 
Brooklyn ; Jersey City and Bayonne. 

D. Riverside and Fort Lee Ferry to Edgewater, N. L, from West 

One Hundred and Thirtieth Street every 20 minutes. Points 
named in Side Trip to Fort Lee, R. 19. 

E. 'Sight Seeing Yachts make the tour of Manhattan twice daily, a 

lecturer on board explaining the points of interest. The chief 
historic buildings and localities seen en route are described in 
the Guide Book as follows : 

North River : Gansevoort Market, site of First State Prison and 
old houses (R. 8: i, 7, 8) ; Aquarium, Battery Park and islands 
(R. 4) ; Custom House and Bowling Green (R. i : 4, 5). 

East River: Jeannette Park (R. 3: 2)2)^ 34). Navy Yard and 
Martyrs' Tomb (R. 2>7 '■ 9i 10); Corlaer's Hook Park (R. 13: 
28) ; Kip's Bay, Shot Tower, Smith and Schermerhorn Houses, \ 
East River Island and Hell Gate (R. 20) ; Hallett's Point and 
Astoria (R. 45) ; Horn's Hook, East River Park and Gracie 
House (R. 20) ; sites of Bronck and Gouverneur Morris Houses 
(R. 31: 49, 50). 

Harlem River: Macomb's Dam (Central) Bridge (R. 30: 25); 
Washington's Headquarters, High Bridge and Fort George 
(R. 23: 47, 50, 53); Hall of Fame, New York University (R. 
30: 30) ; Inwood and Marble Hill (R. 27 and 28). 

The Ship Canal : Spuyten Duyvil (29 a) ; Cold Spring and the 
north end of Manhattan (R. 28b: 93-95). 

Hudson River: Fort Tryon (R. 26) ; Fort Washington and Fort 
Washington Point (R. 24 and 25) ; Fort Lee, N. J. (R. 19 
Side Trip) ; Claremont, Grant's Tomb, Columbia University 
360 



Abater SPECIAL ROUTES Routes 

(R. 19: 3, 7, 9); Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument (K. 18: 5); 

DeWitt Clinton Park (R. 18: C). IVritc Sight Seeing Yachts 

for itinerary^ hours, etc. 
': Ferry to College Point from East Ninety-ninth Street; boats leave 

Manhattan hourly in summer and at g. 11, 3 and 5 in winter. 

(R. 33, 45, 44 and 51 E.) 
}. U. S. Government Boat to Forts Schuyler and Totten, ll'illct's 

Point, Fort Slocum and David's Island, from Pier 12, East 

River, foot of Wall Street, Tuesday, Thursday, Saturday 9 a. m. 

A party of not more than fifteen adults may secure a pass in 

advance from the Commandant, Fort Schuyler. (R. 33.) 



361 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



III. CARRIAGE AND AUTOMOBILE ROUTES. 

MANHATTAN. 

The Fifth Avenue and the Pennsylvania motor buses give good 
opportunities (lo cents) to see central and upper Manhattan. As routes 
are subject to change, it is impossible here to name consecutive points 
of historic interest, but Excursion No. V (p. 102) will aid in locating 
the most important. 

The lines of Sight Seeing Coaches and Automobiles have various 
uptown and downtown routes and a lecturer who explains points of in- 
terest, chiefly modern. Excursions Nos. I, V and VII cover the 
chief routes. 

THE BRONX. 

(Prepared by Randall Comport, 1913) 

A. EASTERN BRONX. 

Figures correspond zuith those in Excursion No. IX (/>. 179) 

Cross the Harlem River by the Willis Avenue Bridge at First Avenue 
and One Hundred and Twenty-seventh Street, passing at the Bronx 
end the sites of Jonas Bronck's homestead (50), and the Gouverncur 
and Lewis Morris Mansions (49). Follow Southern Boulevard to 
St. Ann's Avenue ; turn north to One Hundred and Fortieth Street, 
passing St. Ann's Church (48) at One Hundred and Forty-ninth 
Street ; turn west to the Southern Boulevard and follow it north to 
Hunt's Point Avenue. Turn here to the right, crossing old Lafayette 
Lane (now Avenue, 52) and going as far as Joseph Rodman Drake 
Park (56). The old Hunt Mansion (58) is at the extreme end of 
Hunt's Point. 

Returning to the Southern Boulevard, continue north to Westchester 
Avenue ; follow this north for side trip to Clason's Point (86) ; take 
Clason's Point Road, passing on the right St. Peter's Rectory and' 
Church og^ 98) in old Westchester Village (96) ; the old Causeway 
(96) was near Westchester Square. 

To visit Fort Schuyler and other points on Throgg's Neck, follow 

362 



Automobile SPECIAL ROUTES Routes 

Fort Schuyler Road, east from Westchester Square (seven miles, 
round trip; 89, 90, 91). 

Or follow Westchester Avenue north from Westchester Square, pass- 
ing Spy Oak and Paul House (94, 95). From here a detour may be 
made to see the Ferris Mansion (92) in the grounds of the Westchester 
Country Club. 

Side Trip to City Island ; from the end of Westchester Avenue, con- 
tinue north on the Eastern Boulevard across Pelliam Bridge to Bartow 
station. Take City Island Road to City Island to see Macedonia 
Hotel (106) and other points on Route 34 (six miles round trip). 
Returning to Bartow follow Pelham Bridge Road north from Bartow ; 
turn to left at Split Rock Road, passing Split Rock (113) and other 
points in Route 34. 

At the end of Route 34, follow Columbus Avenue (old Boston Post 
Road) south to St, Paul's Church, Eastchester (132) and the Crawford 
Tavern; continue past Halscy House and Old Point Comfort Inn (130). 

To see the Seton Cave and Mansion (128) follow Two Hundred 
and Thirty-third Street. 

To reach New Rochelle, follow the Boston Road north. 
To reach Manhattan follow the Boston Road South. 



WESTERN BRONX. 

Cross the Harlem River by Washington Bridge at One Hundred and 
Eighty-first Street into the Bronx; turn north on Aqueduct Avenue, 
passing on the left the Lewis G. Morris Mansion (29a) ; at University 
Avenue turn left to visit Neiv York University and the Hall of Fame, 
etc. (30). 

Returning follow Aqueduct Avenue north to Kmgsbndge Koad. pass- 
ing the Fordham Manor Reformed Church (32). Turn east to pass 
the Poe Cottage and Poe Park (69). At Fordham Square follow Pel- 
ham Avenue to Bronx Park; the Zoological Park is toward the south. 
the entrance for automobiles is east of the Southern Boulevard: return 
to Pelham Avenue, cross the Bronx River ; turn to the left at the sign 
board through the Botanical Garden, passing the Lorillard Manswn 
Museum {77) ; continuing north, take the first turn to the west past 
the Botanical Museum (72) and follow Mosholu Parku-ay. passmg the 
Isaac Varian Homestead (36) on the right; enter Van Cortlandt lark 
descend the hill, continue northwest under the railroad tracks to v.s. 
the Van Cortlandt Mansion Museum (4). The Van Cortlandt I aull 

3O3 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

(ii) is on the hill under the trees to the north, and the old Hadley 
House (15) faces the Park west of Broadway. 

At Two Hundred and Forty-second Street, follow Spuyten Duyvil 
Parkway to Spuyten Duyvil, passing the Cozvboy Oak (23) Hudson 
Monument and the Berrian House (24). 

Return to Broadway or follow Riverdale Avenue north to Valentine 
Lane to see the Washington Chestnut (17) and Valentine House (18). 

To return to Manhattan, follow Riverdale Avenue or Broadway, 
passing the Macomb Mansion (2) at Two Hundred and Thirtieth 
Street; see to the west old King's Bridge. 



BROOKLYN. 

Prospect Park, Flatbush and Flatlands. 

Follow Routes 38, 39, 40 and return from the Magaw Homestead 
via Ocean Avenue. 

Fort Hamilton, New Utrecht and Prospect Park. 

Shore Road througTi Bay Ridge to Fort Hamilton, then follow 
Routes 42, 43 and 43a ; return via Twenty-second Avenue and 
Ocean ParkAvay to Prospect Park and reverse Route 38, 

QUEENS. 

Long Island City, IVoodside and Corona. 

Queensboro Bridge or Thirty-fourth Street Ferry to Long Island 
City; follow Borden Avenue to Jackson Avenue, see milestones, 
Riker, Purdy and Lent Farmhouses (R. 47) ; turn at Thompson 
Avenue into Elmhurst (R. 49). 

Astoria to North Beach. 

Astoria Ferry and follow R. 45 to the Lawrence burial ground (33) ; 
continue on Winthrop Avenue or the Old Bowery Road to the 
Moore House (R. 44: 8) and follow Route 44 to North Beach. 

Flushing and Jamaica. 

Astoria Ferry, Fulton Street, Eastern Boulevard, Franklin Street, 
Flushing Avenue to Flushing; then follow Route 51 A; from 
Flushing take Main or Jamaica Avenue to Jamaica, then follow 
Route 52. 

RICHMOND. 

The routes in Richmond (53-60) are best covered by carriage, al- 
though many roads are suitable for automobiles. 

364 



NOTES 



365 



NOTES 



366 



NOTES 



Z^7 



NOTES 



3«8 



APPENDICES 

A. The Milestones and the Old Post Road. 

B. Historical Monuments, Statues and Tablets. 

C. Notable Historic Buildings. 

D. Museums, Libraries and Collections. 

E. Historic Trees, Rocks and other Objects. 



369 




Eleventh IMilestone Unveilt^g, May t.o. lorj. 



370 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 



POST ROADS AND MILESTONES. 
By George W. Nash, M. D. 

The associations of highways and milestones is so intimate that 
a few words may be said of milestones in general. These stones, 
which now call forth a merely sentimental interest, were considered 
by our forefathers a necessity. In 1788 the State of New York 
passed the following: "As milestones are a great public convenience, 
removing or damaging any milestone is punishable by a line of threr 
pounds for such damage, part to go to the informant, part to be ap- 
plied to the repair of the damage, and a third part to be paid to tin- 
overseers of the town in which the offence shall be committed." If 
unable to pay a fine, the party was to suffer thirty days* imprison- 
ment. This law still remains in effect except that a term of im- 
prisonment of two years may be imposed. 

No less person than Benjamin Franklin selected the positions for 
many milestones along the highways, when as Postmaster General, 
in a specially contrived wagon, he measured off the miles at which 
the stones should be erected. Some of these so-called Franklin 
Milestones are still standing, one of them being on the Mi! ford 
Road in Stratford, Conn. 

The first two or three milestones in Manhattan are of white stone, 
then a brown stone is used the rest of the way up the river until Ri-d 
Hook is reached, when again a white stone is used. While mostl\ 
Arabic numerals are used in milestone inscriptions, occasionally wt 
find the Roman numbers, as on the XXIV milestone at Scarsdalc 

N. Y. . ^ 

In early days the people of New Amsterdam felt the need of coin 
munication with the outer world, especially with their neighlK.rs and 
kinspeople at Fort Orange. In the winter when the river was frozen 
over, it was a comparatively easy matter to arrange this communica- 
tion, although the post carriers task was anything but a pleasant on. 
as he skirted the shores of the wilderness and rounded the ponu 
through the gorges against the cold north wind, while skatmg h, 
lonely way to Albany, with Indians often lurking along the rout- 
Something more permanent was needed, and in u..,, tlu- Allun) 

371 



Milestones HISTORICAL GUIDE and Post Roads 

Post Road was established. This was so successful that three years 
later a road was opened from New York to Boston, by order of 
Governor Lovelace. On January i, 1673, a mounted post was in- 
stituted, among the multifarious duties being the carrying of the 
mails ; it was not until 1772 that a stage coach appeared carrying 
passengers at the rate of four pence a mile. 

At that time the City Hall was on Wall Street, at the corner of 
Nassau, where now stands the Sub-Treasury. Broadway up to St. 
Paul's was opened mainly to reach the Post Road where Park Row 
now begins, any further development of the street being undreamed 
of, even to accommodate the outlying farms along the Hudson. From 
the site of the Post Office the Post Road ran through Park Row, up 
the Bowery and Fourth Avenue to Madison Square (Excursion V, 
Section H) whence it turned and twisted northward over toward the 
East River, then doubled on itself. About Eighty-sixth Street it en- 
tered the boundaries of the present Central Park, went through Mc- 
Gown's Pass; thence continued more or less steadily to the northwest 
until it struck the lines of Broadway and Kingsbridge Road, when it 
went soberly along to the toll bridge over Spuyten Duyvil Creek 
(Excursion IV, 2). After getting well over the bridge, the road 
soon separated into the Albany Post Road, following Broadway 
through Yonkers and up the river; and the Boston Post Road, going 
up the hill to the right across to Williamsbridge, thence across 
country through Eastchester to New Rochelle, and beyond 
to Boston. So long ago as the English occupation, the people 
of New York, feeling crowded, overflowed into Harlem, whence 
the Dutch farmers casting their eyes across the Kills, saw a 
country " fair to look upon." Means of getting across were 
soon considered and a ferry established connecting with the road to 
Harlem which branched off from the Post Road at Central Park. 
(Excursion IV, Section i). This ferry was at about Third Avenue 
and One Hundred and Thirty-first Street and a bridge was built in 
1795. As the lower Bronx section across the Kills grew, old trails 
were developed, the early Westchester Path becoming a Post Road, 
following the line of Third Avenue and Boston Road to Bronx Park 
and then northeast, until it joined the early road some distance above, 
thus making quite a cut-off from New York to this junction, saving the 
long detour around Kingsbridge. Lonely as the road was, it was 
not without interesting features. Hardly had the traveler left the 
starting point when he arrived at the first Kissing Bridge, near Chat- 
ham Square; then came the milestones telling slowly, but steadily, the 









15 Milestone 
9 Milestone 



1 Milestone 
New Utrecht 
Photographed by G. W. ^'^^h 



Milestones POST ROADS and Post Roads 

progress made, and, as taverns and road houses were always con- 
venient, there was ever a place for rest and refresliment. Amonp 
the old road houses may be mentioned the Bull's Head Tavern, near 
the first milestone, where the friends of the traveler who had ac- 
companied him thus far, drank to his health and safety on his jour- 
ney to the wilderness beyond. 

At the second milestone, where Cooper Union now stands, was the 
Bowery Village Church. Cato's Road House at Fifty-second Street 
was a noted hostelry; at Seventy-second Street was another Kissing 
Bridge. 

That part of the road near McGown's Pass has a special interest 
from its connection with the march of the British before the Battle of 
Harlem Heights and the presence of Forts Clinton and Fish. At the 
bridge across Spuyten Duyvil Creek, also a Kissing Bridge, there 
was a celebrated tavern well described by Madame Knight where 
sleighing parties came out from town for their frolics. Thence the 
traveler on either of the diverging Post Roads had more time for 
the enjoyment of the scenery, as the evidences of civilization faded 
away and the wilderness opened before him broken only occasionally 
by village or hamlet. 

According to the old maps there was, starting from the City Hall in 
Wall Street, a stone for every mile in what is now Manhattan and 
the Bronx. With the erection of the present City Hall (1803-12) 
these milestones were replaced to bring them in conformity with the 
new starting point. This accounts for the apparent discrepancies in 
their names. Some of the milestones have disappeared, while others 
have had a varied experience. Some of the stones have been used 
by bill posters; one was rescued from a police station and now 
stands in good surroundings not at all embarrassed by the falsehood 
showing on its face; another was removed from a tottering position 
in a neglected section of the road and now occupies a place safe 
from destruction; one stone that stood in the way of public improve- 
ment was apparently improved off the earth; another reposes in a 
back yard uptown, while still another has its resting place in a cellar. 

Milestones in Manhattan. 

1. Bowery, opposite Rivington Street. 

2. Third Avenue, between Sixteenth and Seventeenth Streets. 

4. Third Avenue and Fifty-seventh Street. 

5. Third Avenue and Seventy-seventh Street. 

7. Third Avenue and One Hundred and Seventeenth Street. 

373 



Milestones HISTORICAL GUIDE and Post Roads 

7. Another stone, now stored at 107 West One Hundred and Twenty- 
second Street. (The duphcate 7 Milestone was probably on the 
eastern Post Road after it branched off the old Post Road near 
Central Park.) 

9. One Hundred and Fifty-second Street, between Amsterdam and 
St. Nicholas Avenues. 

10. 561 West One Hundred and Sixty-ninth Street. 

11. In Roger Morris Park (see p. 159)- 

12. At entrance to Isham Park (see p. 175) • 

Milestones in the Bronx 
10. One Hundred and Sixty-eighth Street and Boston Road. 

13. Boston Road, near Pelham Parkway (this stone has lately dis- 

appeared and may be in the vicinity). 
15. Boston Road, near Eastchester (1911 placed in Bronx Borough 

Hall). 
15. Albany Avenue, near Spuyten Duyvil Parkway (see p. 184). 

Milestones in Brooklyn 

At Sheepshead Bay, corner of Neck Road and Ryder's Lane. In- 
scription reads: "8 Miles and ( ) quarters to Brockland Ferry." 

At Van Pelt Manor, New Utrecht ; has two inscriptions : one reads : 
"8^ mile to N. York Ferry This Road To Denys's Ferry 2Y2 
Mile." The other reads, "io>2 Mile to N. York Ferry This Road. 
To Jamaica 15 Mile." 

At King's Highway, within fence line, left side, 100 feet from Ocean 
Avenue. Inscription : "6 Mile to Ye Ferry." 

Milestones in Queens. (All between Long Island City and Flushing.) 
At Jackson Avenue, near Grinnell Avenue : "5 Miles to 34th Street 

Ferry, i Mile to Flushing Bridge." 
At Jackson, near Kelly Avenue: "3 Miles to 34th Street Ferry, 

3 Miles to Flushing Bridge." 
At Jackson, near Hulst Avenue : "2 Miles to 34th Street Ferry, 4 Miles 

to Flushing Bridge." 

Milestone in Richmond. 
Formerly at corner of Signs Road and Richmond Turnpike, now at 
154 Stuyvesant Place, in the Museum of the Staten Island Asso- 
ciation of Arts and Sciences. Inscription reads: "( ) miles 
to N. Yorke." 

374 



MILESTONES. 



MILESTONES IN BLOOMINGDALE. 
By Hopper Striker Mott. 

Little attention, if any, has been given to the two lines of mile- 
stones along the Bloomingdale Road. The first stone was about op- 
posite the present Twenty-fourth Street, at the junction of the Post 
Road. This advertisement from the Columbian of June 6, 1815, has 
been found : 

" A stray steer was found on the premises of the subscriber on the 
5th cA August last. The owner may have the said steer by proving 
property and paying all reasonable charges. 

" Isaac Varian Jun. 
" Bloomingdale — 3 mile stone." 

• This also fixes the Bloomingdale name as extending as far south 
as Twenty-third Street. 

The fourth stone must have been at about Forty-fourth Street and 
we have this advertisement from the Mercantile Advertiser of 
December 10, 1814, confirming the location there: 

" To let for one or more years, the farm at Bloomingdale, near the 
four mile stone, known by the name of Eden's Farm, consisting of 
about 22 acres of land, on which are two dwelling houses and 2 farms 
and to which may be added 2 pieces of pasture land of ab.iut 10 
acres each. Apply to 

"John Jacob Astor, cor. Pine and Pearl Streets." 

This farm was owned by Medcef Eden, an Englishman, and ex- 
tended as far south as Forty-first Street. It was acquired by Astor 
under foreclosure in 1803 for $25,000. So much for the distances 
from V/all Street. 

The evidences for saying that there was a second series marking 
the distance from the City Hall is as follows: We have personally 
seen a stone which stood on the Road at Fifty-fourth Street, during 
our boyhood, which was marked "Four miles from N. Y." 

In John Austin Stevens' notes to the History of the Chamber of 
Commeree, p. 314, he says: "The five mile stone stands near the 
corner of Seventy-fourth Street and the Bloomingdale Road, opposite 

375 



Milestones HISTORICAL GUIDE in Bloomingdale 

grounds lately owned by Pelatiah Perit (20tli President of the 
Chamber) and the 6 mile stone near Ninety-sixth Street, in front of 
the property of Dr. Williams." 

The Evening Post announced that John Moir opened the Bloom- 
ingdale Academy in 1815, located 5 miles from the city, on the Bloom- 
ingdale Road. This was at Seventy-fourth Street. 

Samuel Beman, A. M., opened a boarding school for small boys in 
1838 at the six mile stone, situated "on Dr. Valentine Mott's beauti- 
ful mansion grounds." The house stood at Ninety-fourth Street. 

The 7 mile stone was at One Hundred and Sixteenth Street and 
the 8 at One Hundred and Thirty-sixth Street, a half mile south of 
the junction of the Bloomingdale and Kingsbridge Roads at One 
Hundred and Forty-seventh Street. 



376 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ADDENDA, 1912 
(From a theatre programme of "The African G)mi)any-) 

THEATRE in Mercer Street 
In the rear of the i Mile Stone Broadway 

The African Co., etc. 
Harper's Maga::ine, Junc^Nov., 1889. />. \t,t, 

As historians know nothing of a theatre here, this was probably a 
company of negro amateurs who played in New York in 1820-ji. Old 
residents remember a milestone in front of old St. Thomas' Church, 
Broadway and Houston Street. 

In tearing dowm an old residence in Greenwich at 102 Christopher 
Street in 1910 a block of brown stone 21/2 feet long. 10 inches wide and 
9 inches thick was discovered (now at 380 Bleecker Street) bearing the 
inscription, "9 Miles from Camp," and at the bottom some unde- 
cipherable figures. It is doubtful whether "Camp" refers to a camp of 
Revolutionary days or to some popular roadhouse in upper Manhattan. 

The Board of Aldermen has, by special enactment, transferred to 
the City History Club the care and maintenance of the milestones 
in Manhattan, and the Club expects to receive similar jurisdiction in 
the other boroughs. 

Through a "Milestone Committee," the 15th Milestone, near \'an 
Cortlandt Mansion (p. 184), has been firmly reset in its former location, 
thus saving it from destruction, and the nth Milestone of Manhattan 
has been removed to Roger Morris Park and marked by a tablet 
(p. 159)- Plans are now under way for the care of other stones in 
Manhattan and at Van Pelt Manor, New Utrecht. No. g Manhattan 
and the Richmond stone are already protected (pp. 151, ^27), one by 
private means, the other through a historical society. 

The City History Club obtains the means for this work by a volun- 
tary tax paid by children enrolled in its study clubs. 

See articles in the Outlook (June 24, 1909), "Along the Hudson in 
Stage Coach Days"; Westchester County {N. F.) Miujazine. "Sonic 
Westchester County Milestones" and "Some Bronx Milestones." 



376a 



NOTES. 



^76b 



APPENDIX B. 
HISTORICAL MONUMENTS, STATUES AND TABLETS. 

Monuments and Statues in Manhattan. 

N. B. Those in cemeteries and churchyards and within buildinps 
are, as a rule, omitted. See Addenda, pp. 389-390. 

Columbus Colunm, at the Circle, Fifty-ninth Street and Eighth 
Avenue; has reliefs by Gaetano Riisso; presented by Italian citizens 
of the city. R. 17. 

Firemen's Monument, Hudson Park, to some Volunteer Firemen; 
erected by members of Eagle Fire Engine Company, No. 13. R. 8. 

Grant's Tomb, Riverside Drive, near One Hundred and Twenty- 
second Street; erected by popular subscription, under the care of the 
Grant Monument Association. R. 19. 

Martyrs' Monument, Trinity Churchyard; erected by the Trinity 
Corporation to the memory of American patriots who died in British 
Revolutionary prisons. R. 2. 

Mural Monument to Major-General Richard Montgomery, under 
the Broadway Portico of St. Paul's Chapel, Broadway and Fulton 
Street. R. 6. 

Soldiers' and Sailors* Monument, Riverside Drive and Eighty- 
ninth Street; erected by the city to the heroes of the Civil War. R. 18. 

Washington Arch, Washington Square; designed by Stanford 
White; erected by popular subscription on the one hundredth an- 
niversary of the inauguration of Washington. R. 10. 

Worth Monument, Broadway and Twenty-fifth Street; designed by 
Jas. C. Batterson; erected by the Corporation of the City. R. 15. 

Sculptured Pediment, N. Y. C. and H. R. R. R. Freight Station, 
Hudson Street, to the railroad achievements of Vanderbilt. R. 9- 



Chester A. Arthur, Madison Square, designed by G. E. Bissell. R. 15. 

Bust of Edwin Booth, 70 West Twenty-third Street, marking the 
site of Booth's Theatre. R. 15. 

Simon Bolivar, at the West Eighty-first Street entrance to Central 
Park; by De La Cora, the gift of the people and the Govcrnnicnt of 
Venezuela. 

Roscoe Conkling, Madison Square; by J. Q. A. Ward. R. 15. 

Z77 



Manhattan HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Dewitt Clinton: (i) 52-56 Broadway; by J. Massey Rhind. R. i; 
(2) Hall of Records; by Philip Martiny. R. 5; (3) Chamber of 
Commerce, 65 Liberty Street, R. 7. 

Cadwalader Colden, Hall of Records ; by Philip Martiny. R. 5. 

Columbus: (i), Central Park, near the Eighth Avenue and Fifty- 
ninth Street entrance; (2), Mall, Central Park; a replica of Sunol's 
statue ; erected by the New York Genealogical and Biographical So- 
ciety; (3), McGown's Pass Tavern, Central Park. 

S. S. Cox, Astor Place; by Louise Lawson; erected by the letter- 
carriers of the United States. R. 11. 

Peter Cooper, in front of Cooper Union, Fourth Avenue and Bow- 
ery; by St. Gaudens ; erected by popular subscription. R. 11. 

William E. Dodge, Broadway and Thirty-sixth Street; by J. Q. A. 
Ward ; erected by the merchants of the city. 

Abraham de Peyster, Bowling Green; Geo. E. Bissell, sculptor; 
erected by John Watts de Peyster. R. i. 

Mayor James Duane, Hall of Records; by Philip Martiny. R. 5. 

David P. De Vries, Hall of Records; by Philip Martiny. R. 5. 

John Ericsson, Battery Park; by J. Scott Hartley; erected by the 
Corporation of the City. R. 4. 

Admiral Farragut, Madison Square; by St. Gaudens; presented by 
the Farragut Memorial Association. R. 15. 

Benjamin Franklin: (i), Printing House Square; by Plassman; 
presented by Captain Albert De Groot. R. 5; (2), in front of the 
Staats Zeitung Building, Spruce and William Streets. R. 5. 

Horace Greeley (i), Printing House Square; by J. Q. A. Ward; 
erected by private subscription. R. 5; (2), Broadway and Thirty- 
third Street (Greeley Square) ; by Alexander Doyle; erected by a 
Grand Army Post and Typographical Union. 

Gutenberg: (i), on the Staats Zeitung Building, William and 
Spruce Streets. R. 5; (2), Hoe Building, Grand and Sheriff Streets, 

R. 13. 

Garibaldi, Washington Square ; by Giovanni Turini ; erected by 
Italian residents of New York City. R. 10. 

Alexander Hamilton: (i), on the Chamber of Commerce, 65 Lib- 
erty Street; presented by John S. Kennedy. R. 7; (2), near Hamilton 
Hall, Columbia University; by Ordway Partridge. R. 19; (3), bust 
on the duelling ground at Weehawkcn. R. 18; (4), on the West 
Drive, near the Metropolitan Museum, Central Park; by Conradts; 
presented by his son, John C. Hamilton. 



378 



HISTORICAL STATUES Manhattan 

Bust of Richard M. Hunt, Fifth Avenue and Seventieth Street; \ry 
D. C French; the gift of several art societies. 

Bust of Alexander L. Holley, inventor of Bessemer steel, in Wash- 
ington Square; by J. Q. A. Ward; erected by Mechanical Engineers 
of Europe and America. R. lo. 

Henry Hudson, 52-56 Broadway; by J. Massey Rhind. R. i. 

Nathan Hale, City Hall Park; by MacMonnies. R. 5. 

Caleb Heathcote, Hall of Records; by Philip Martiny. R. 5. 

Winfield Hancock, in Hancock Square, St. Nicholas Avenue and 
One Hundred and Twenty-third Street; erected by members of the 
Grand Army of the Republic. 

Bust of Washington Irving, Bryant Park; by Beer; presented by 
Joseph Wiener. R. 17. 

John Jay, Chamber of Commerce, 65 Liberty Street. R. 7. 

Lafayette, Union Square; by Bartholdi; presented by French resi- 
dents. R. 14. 

Lincoln, Union Square; by H. K. Browne; erected by popular sub- 
scription under the auspices of the Lnion League Club. R. 14. 

Bust of Massini, West Drive, Central Park; by Turini; presented 
by Italian residents. 

S. F. B. Morse, Central Park, near the East Seventy-second Street 
entrance; by Byron M. Pickett; erected by the telegraphic craft. 

Peter Stiiyvesant: (r), 52-56 Broadway; by J. Massey Rhind. R. i; 
(2), Hall of Records; by Philip Martiny. R. 5; (3). effigy, outer 
wall of St. Mark's-in-the-Bowery, Second Avenue and Tenth Street. 
R. II. 

/. Marion Sims, Bryant Park; by Miller; erected by public sub- 
scription. R. 17. 

Wm. T. Sherman, Plaza entrance to Central Park; by St. Gaudcns; 
erected under the auspices of the Chamber of Commerce. R. 17. 

Wm. H. Seward, Madison Square; by "Randolph -Rogers. R. 15. 

General Franz Sigel, Riverside Drive and One Hundred and Sixth 
Street; by Karl Bitter, erected by public subscription. 

Washington: (i). Union Square; by H. K. Browne; erected by 
popular subscription. R. 14; (2), Sub Treasury; by J. Q. \. \\ard; 
erected by public subscription under the auspices of the Chamber of 
Commerce. R. 2; (3), Washington and Lafayette, Manhattan Av- 
enue and One Hundred and Fourteenth Street; by Bartli-l.t, ...ul ibc 
gift of C. B. Rouss. 



379 



Manhattan HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Daniel Webster, West Drive, near Seventy-second Street, Central 
Park; by Thos. Ball; the gift of Gordon W. Burnham. 

Allegorical Statuary. 

Statue of Liberty, Bedloe's or Liberty Island; by Bartholdi; paid 
for by popular subscription in France, the pedestal by popular sub- 
scription in America. R. 4. 

The Pilgrim, Central Park, near the East Seventy-second Street 
entrance; by J. Q. A. Ward; presented by the New England Society 
of the City of New York. 

The Seventh Regiment (a figure of a private soldier of this com- 
mand), on the West Drive of Central Park, near the Seventy-second 
Street entrance; by J. Q. A. Ward; erected in commemoration of 
those members who fell during the Civil War. 

Recording of the Purchase of Manhattan, Hall of Records; by 
Albert Weinert. R. 5. 

The Consolidation of Greater New York, Hall of Records; by Al- 
bert Weinert. R. 5. 

The Movement of American Commerce, pediment of the Stock 
Exchange; by J. Q. A. Ward. R. 3. 

Groups representing Asia, Africa, Europe and America, on Custom 
House ; by D. C. French. Above the cornice are statues representing 
France, England, Germany, Scandinavia, Spain, Portugal, Holland, 
Venice, Genoa, Phoenicia, Greece and Rome; by Elwell, Gelert, Grae- 
fly, Jacques, Lukeman, Louis St. Gaudens and Tonetti. 

Tablets in Manhattan. 

Period of the Dutch Occupation. 

41 Broadway, first zvhite men's houses in Manhattan; Holland So- 
ciety. R. I. 

Collector's Office, Custom House, Fort Amsterdam. R. i. 

Middle Dutch Church, Seventh Street and Second Avenue, Church 
of St. Nicholas in Fort Amsterdam and the original Middle Church 
on Exchange Place. R. 11. 

Within the Middle Dutch Reformed Church, to Minuit, Krol, Huyck 
and Michaelius, officers of the original church. R. 11. 



380 



HISTORICAL TABLETS Manhattan 

Collegiate Dutch Reformed Church, Forty-eighth Street nnd Fifth 
Avenue, the Church in the Fort. R. 17. 

23 Whitehall Street, house of Domine Bogardus and Annckc Jans 
Bogardus; Knickerbocker Chapter, D. A. R. R. i. 

7^ Pearl Street, Stadt Hnys; Holland Society. R. 3. 

Thirteenth Street and Third Avenue, Peter Stuyvesant's f>ear tree; 
Holland Society. R. 11. 

Wall of Jewish Cemetery, Oliver Street and New Bowery, first 
Jewish Cemetery and a Revolutionary fort; American Scenic and 
Historic Preservation Society and the Jewish Historical Society. R. 
12. 

8-10 Pearl Street, iirst Dutch settlers; Holland Dames of New 
Netherlands. R. i. 

8-10 Peck Slip, Warehouse of Isaac Allerton; General Society of 
Mayflower Descendants. R. 7. 

Period of the English Occupation to 1765. 

Battery Park, opposite Custom House (Fort George Monument) ; 
southwest bastion of Fort George; Corporation of the City of New 
York, replaced under the auspices of the American Scenic and His- 
toric Preservation Society and the New York Historical Society. R. i. 

East wall of Produce Exchange, First Huguenot Church; Huguenot 
Society of America. R. i. 

81 Pearl Street, first printing press in Nezu York; New York His- 
torical Society. R. 3. 

Cotton Exchange, Hanover Square, New York Caccttc. the first 
New York newspaper; New York Historical Society. R. 3- 

Murray Street and West Broadway, Kings College. R. 6. 

Mutual Life Building, Nassau and Cedar Streets. Middle Dutch 
Church; Mutual -Life Insurance Company of New York. R. 7- 

Schieren Building, Cliff and Ferry Streets, the Old Szcavtp: Hide 
and Leather Association of New York. R. 7- ..,.,„ c. , 

First Presbyterian Church, old Presbyterian Church vi U all Street. 

R. 14. 



381 



Manhattan HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Period of the Revolution, 1765-1783. 

I Broadway, Kennedy House and the Statue of George III; Sons 
of the RevoUition. R. i, 

Fraunces Tavern, 54 Pearl Street, (i) Frederick Samuel Tallmadge ; 
Sons of the Revolution; (2), in the Long Room, establishment of the 
Chamber of Commerce, meeting of the Committee of Correspondence 
and Washington's Farewell; Sons of the Revolution. R. 3. 

Broad and Beaver Streets, exploits of Marinus Willett; Sons of 
the Revolution. R. 3. 

City Hall, Reading of Declaration of Independence to the Army; 
Sons of the Revolution. R. 5. 

Within the General Post Office, Liberty Pole and Battle of Golden 
Hill; Mary Washington Colonial Chapter, D. A. R. R. 5. 



Thames Street and Broadway, De Lanc'ey House {Burns' Coffee 
House), City Hotel, signing of Non-Important Agreement (?); Hol- 
land Society of New York. R. 6. 

Sub-Treasury, Washington in prayer at Valley Forge) Lafayette 
Post No. 140, G. A. R. R. 2. 

Park space. Park Avenue and Thirty-seventh Street, Murray House, 
scene of Mrs. Murray's detention of British officers; Knickerbocker 
Chapter, D. A. R. R. 17. 

1497 Broadway, meeting of Washington and Putnam, September 15, 
1776; Sons of the Revolution. R. 18. 

Engineering Building, Columbia University, Battle of Harlem 
Heights; Sons of the Revolution. R. 19. 

Park Space, One Hundred and Forty-seventh Street and Broad- 
way, first line of defences in the Revolution; Washington Heights 
Chapter, Daughters of the American Revolution. R. 23. 

Wall of Trinity Cemetery, Broadway and One Hundred and Fifty- 
third Street, defences of the Revolution ; Sons of the Revolution. R. 
23. 



382 



HISTORICAL TABLETS Manhattan 

One Hundred and Fifty-ninth Street and P.roadway, thhJ linr of 
defences in the Revolution; Mary Washington Col. Chapter, Daughters 
of the American Revolution. R. 23. 

Washington's Headquarters (Roger Morris, Jumel Mansion). 
Headquarters of Washington; Washington Heights Chapter, D. A. R. 
R. 23. 

Washington's Headquarters, acquisition of the building and grounds 
for a museum; Park Department. R. 23. 

Fort Washington Avenue, near One Hundred and Eiglity-lhird 
Street, Fort Washington; James Gordon Bennett. R. 24. 

Fort Washington Avenue, near One Hundred and Ninety-sixth 
Street, Fort Tryon; C. K. G. Billings and the American Scenic and 
Historic Preservation Society. R. 26, 

Within Holyrood Church, 179th Street and Fort Washington 
Avenue, exploit of Margaret Corbin; Mary Washington Colonial 
Chapter, D. A. R. R. 24. 

Within the Collegiate Dutch Reformed Church, Fifth Avenue and 
Forty-eighth Street, soldiers and sailors of the Revolution; Daugh- 
ters of the Revolution, State of New York. R. 17. 

Under barred window on Rhinelander Building, Rose and Duane 
Streets, Cuyler-Rhinelander Sugar House. R. 7. 

City Hall Park, near Bridge Terminal, Provost Prison; Mary Wash- 
ington Colonial Chapter, D. A. R. R. 5- 

23 Whitehall Street, Whitehall Ferry, scene of Washington's de- 
parture in 1783; Mary Washington Colonial Chapter, D. A. R. R. i. 

Modern Period, since 1783. 

Sub-Treasury, Ordinance of 17S7; Ohio Company of Associates. R. 
2. 

Within the Sub-Treasury, inscribed slab on zvhich Washington 
stood ivhile delivering his first inaugural address. R. 2. 

Within St. Paul's Chapel, Centennial of Washington's inauguration; 
the Aisle Committee at services held in St. Paul's Chapel. R. 0. 

Within St. Paul's Chapel, One Hundredth Anniversary of W ash- 

ington's death. R. 6. .....#• 

Brooklyn Bridge Pier, Franklin Square, First Presidenttal Mansion; 

Mary Washington Colonial Chapter, D. A. R. R. 7- 



383 



Manhattan HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Hamilton Grange, home of Alexander Hamilton; Washington 
Heights Chapter, D. A. R. R. 23. 

German Reformed Church, Baron Steuben. R. 20. 

William and Wall Streets, cornerstone of the Bank of New York. 
R. 2. 

Directors' Room, Life Insurance and Trust Company, 52 Wall 
Street, cornerstone of the United States Branch Bank. R. 2. 

56 Wall Street, Morris Robinson and the establishment of the 
business of modern life insurance in America; Canadian Society of 
New York. R. 2. 

Within City Hall, two inscribed marble slabs transferred from the 
top course of the coping of City Hall, giving names of the Building 
Committee, architect, stone cutter, masons, etc., and a tablet in com- 
memoration of these being placed here on the 250th anniversary of 
the City Charter. R. 5. 

Block House No. i. Central Park, defences of the War of 1812; 
Woman's Auxiliary to the American Scenic and Historic Preserva- 
tion Society, R. 21. 

Block House No. 3, Morningside Park and One Hundred and 
Twenty-third Street, defences of War of 1812; Woman's Auxiliary 
to the American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society. R. 19. 

Near McGown's Pass, Central Park, Fort Clinton and McGown's 
Pass; children of the City History Club. R. 21. 

Aquarium, acquisition of Castle Garden for a Museum; Park De- 
partment. R. 4. 

Aquarium, Battery Park, outside wall, near entrance: Events in con- 
nection with the history of flic building; erected in 1909 by the New 
York Zoological Society. P. 38. R. 4. 

Fayerweather Hall, Columbia University, defences of the War of 
1812; Empire State Society, Daughters of 18 12. R. 19. 

90 Pearl Street, iire of 1835. R. 3. 

136 Fulton Street, Shakespeare Tavern and organization of Seventh 
Regiment; Veterans of the Seventh Regiment. R. 7. 

Grove Street School, Lafayette's visit to the old school in 1824; 
Charles R. Lamb. R. 8. 

Firemen's Monument, Hudson Park, acquisition by the city of St. 
John's Cemetery for a public park. R. 8. 



384 



HISTORICAL TABLETS Manhattan 

Within Middle Dutch Reformed Church, /. C. Lanphicr, founder of 
Fulton Street Prayer Meeting. R. ii. 

6z Prince Street, Gouverneur House, where President Monroe died; 
Woman's Auxiliary to the American Scenic and Historical Preser- 
vation Society. -R. 13. 

Madison Avenue, between Forty-ninth and Fiftieth Streets, Colum- 
bia College. R. 17. 

5 West Twenty-second Street, home of S. F. D. Morse. R. 15. 

Sidewalk, near west gate of Gramercy Park, gift of park land. R. 
14. 

University Place and Thirteenth Street, home of Ninth Regiment; 
Veterans of the Ninth Regiment. R. 14. 

North of Grant's Tomb, to the memory of General Grant; Li 
Hung Chang. R. 19. 

In Tompkins Square, to the memory of the victims of the S locum 
disaster; erected by popular subscription. R. 11. 

Within the Middle Dutch Reformed Church, to the memory of 
the victims of the Slociim disaster. R 11. 

50 Broadway, first skeleton frame steel structure; Society of 
Architecture and Ironmasters in New York. R. i. 

Twenty-second Street and Twelfth Avenue, Chelsea Improvement; 
Dock Department. R. 16. 

Pavement in front of City Hall, first excavation for the Under- 
ground Railway. R. 5. 

City Hall Subway Station, completion of the first AVxc York Sub- 
way. R. 5. 

West Street, near Bank Street, widening and improvement of West 

Street. R. 8. 



38$ 



The Bronx HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Monuments, Statues and Tablets in the Bronx. 

Henry Hudson Monument, Spuyten Duyvil Hill ; erected by the 
Henry Hudson Monument Commission of the Bronx Citizens' Hudson- 
Fulton Celebration Commission. P. 183. 

Statue of Major-General Josiah Porter, north of Van Cortlandt 
Mansion ; erected by the National Guard, State of New York. R. 29. 

Monument to the Founders of New York University, on the Uni- 
versity Campus. R. 30. 

Tablet on Van Cortlandt Mansion, historic events connected with 
the house; Colonial Dames of the State of New York. R, 29, 

Inscription on the window from the Rhinelander Sugar House 
stating its use as a Revolutionary prison; placed in Van Cortlandt 
Park; by J. F. Oakley Rhinelander. R. 29. 

Tablet on cairn in Van Cortlandt Park, near Mount Vernon Ave- 
nue and Two Hundred and Thirty-seventh Street, in memory of 
the Stockbridge Indians who aided the patriots in the Revolution; 
Bronx Chapter of the Mount Vernon (New York) Chapter, D. A. R. 
R. 29. Removed by vandals, 1912. 

Tablet on Glover's Rock, near Bartow, Pelham Neck, to mark the 
Battle of Pell's Point; Bronx Chapter of the Mount Vernon Chap- 
ter, D. A. R. R. 34. 

Inscription on the Macedonia Hotel, City Island, marking the 
British Frigate Macedonia; placed by the War Department. R. 34. 

Tablets in St. Ann's Church, St. Ann's Avenue and One Hundred 
and Fortieth Street, to the memory of the Morris family. R. 31. 

Tablet on Chemistry Building, New York University, near site of 
Fort No. Eight, to the men of the Revolution and Revolutionary de- 
fences near by; Sons of the Revolution. R. 30. 

Tablets in the Hall of Fame, New York University, to honor great 
Americans. R. 30. See p. 390a. 

Split Rock, Pelham Bay Park, in memory of Ann Marbury Hutch- 
inson; erected by the Colonial Dames, State of New York. R. 34. 



386 



^ 



HISTORICAL MONUMENTS Brooklyn 

Monuments and Statues in Brooklyn. 

Martyrs' Tomb, Fort Greene Park, to the victims of the old prison 
ships in the Wallabout. 

Maryland Monument, Lookout Hill, Prospect Park, in honor of 
Maryland's Four Hundred in the Battle of Long Island; presented 
by the Maryland Society, Sons of the American Revolution. R. 38. 

Monument to the United States soldiers who fell in China in 1836, 
Brooklyn Navy Yard. R. 37. 

Soldiers' and Sailors' Memorial Arch, main entrance to Prospect 
Park; by John H. Duncan, bas reliefs by Power, quadriga by Mac- 
DVIonnies; to the heroes of the Civil War. R. 38. 

Skene Monument, triangle north of Prospect Park Plaza, by J. 
Massey Rhind. 

Henry Ward Beecher, in front of Borough Hall; by J. Q. A. Ward. 

R. ze. 

General Fowler, Fort Greene Park. 

General Grant, Bedford Avenue, near Dean Street; by William 
Ordway Partridge; the gift of the Union League Club of Brooklyn. 

Alexander Hamilton, entrance to the Hamilton Club, Clinton and 
Remsen Streets. 

Washington Irving, Prospect Park, near the Italian Flower gar- 
den; the gift of Demas Barnes. 

Lincoln, Prospect Park, near the flower garden overlooking the 
lake; by popular subscription. 

Henry W. Maxwell, Prospect Park Plaza; by his friends. 

General Slocum, Bedford Street and Eastern Parkway; by Mac- 
Monnies. 

James S. T. Stranahan, Prospect Park; by subscription. 

Bust of Peter Turner, St. James Pro-Cathedral, Jay and Chapel 
Streets. R. 36. 

Major General Warren, Prospect Park Plaza; by Henry Bacrer; 
presented by G. K. Warren Post No. 286, G. A. R. 

Washington, Plaza, Williamsburg; H. W. Shrady; the gift of Ex- 
Register James R. Howe. R. 35a. 



387 



Queens HISTORICAL GUIDE Richmond 

Tablets in Brooklyn. 

Flatbush Dutch Reformed Church, Colonial and Revolutionary 
events in connection with the church; Colonial Daughters of the 17th 
Century. R. 39. 

Smith-Gray Building, Fulton Street and Flatbush Avenue, line of 
defence, Battle of Long Island; Sons of the Revolution. R. 2>7' 

Battle Pass, East Drive, Prospect Park, Valley Grove, and outer 
line of defence. Battle of Long Island. R. 38. 

Fifth Avenue and Third Street, Vechte-Cortelyou House and Bat- 
tle of Long Island; Sons of the Revolution. R. 42. 

On Liberty Pole, in front of New Utrecht Dutch Reformed Church, 
Revolutionary Liberty Pole; Descendants of the Patriots who erected 
the first pole in 1783. R. 43. 

Borough Hall Subway Station, opening of the first Subway con- 
necting Manhattan and Brooklyn. R. 26. 

Monuments and Tablets in Queens. 

Soldiers' Monument, Flushing, to the heroes of the Civil War. R. 

51. 

Tablet, within St. George's Church, Flushing, to Francis Lewis, a 
signer of the Declaration of Independence. R. 51. 

Tablet on boulder, opposite the Bowne House, Flushing, to mark 
site of Fox Oaks; Flushing Historical Society. R. 51. 

Soldiers' Monument, Jamaica, to Civil War heroes; by F. W. 
Ruckstuhl. 

Tablet in Grace Church, Jamaica, to John A. King, Governor 
of New York. 

Tablets in Richmond. 

Two tablets on either side of the flight of steps of Borough Hall, 
giving the dates of principal events in the Borough of Richmond. R. 

53. 

Memorial slab on the Garibaldi House, Stapleton, to commemorate 
the residence of Garibaldi. R. 55. 

St. Andrew's Church, Richmond, in memory of Queen Anne's gift 
to the church. R. 58. 



388 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ADDENDA 
MANHATTAN 

Fulton Water Gate and Monument, to be erected on Riverside Drive, 
between One Hundred and Fourteenth and One Hundred and Sixteenth 
streets, site possibly to be changed to one centring on One Hundred 
and Tenth Street; by subscription under the auspices of the Ruhcrt 
Fulton Monument Association. The architect, chosen b\ competition, 
is H. Van Buren Magonigle, F.A.LA. ' There will be a reception 
pavilion and a naval museum, connected by a peristyle and approached 
by a flight of steps from the water level. Recreation piers will extend 
into the river and enclose a harbor with landing stages. P. i^g. 

National Maine Monument, at the Circle, Fifty-ninth Street and 
Eighth Avenue; by subscription under the auspices of the National 
Maine Monument Association. P. 139. 

Carl Schur3 Memorial and Statue, Morningside Avenue and One 
Hundred and Sixteenth Street; Karl Bitter; by public subscription 
under the auspices of the Carl Schurz Memorial .Association. P. 140. 

Statue of William Cullen Bryant, Bryant Park: by Herbert .Adams; 
erected by the Century Association. P. 138. 

Statue of Alexander J. Cassatt in Pennsylvania R. R. Terminal, 
Thirty-second Street and Seventh Avenue. 

George Dixon Memorial Fountain, Thompson Street, near Broome 
Street. 

Statue of Fit:: Greene Halleck, Central Park, unveiled 1877. 

Bust of Postmaster Pearson in the Post Office, City Hall Park. R. 5. 

Statue of Verrazano, Battery Park; presented by Italian residents 
of New York. P. 38. 

Statue of General Wolfe, 52-56 Broadway; by J. .Masscy Rhind. R. i. 

Allegorical group— Indian Hunter zvith Dog, Mall, Central Park. 

Commemorative and allegorical statuary on the new Municipal Build- 
ing. P. 65. 

Firemen's Memorial Monument, Riverside Drive and One llun.lredth 
Street; the City of New York. 

TABLETS: DUTCH PERIOD 

Custom House entrance staircase, to mark site of Fort Avtstcrdam, 
exploration of Hudson River, founding of Nciv Amsterdam and cstah- 
lishment of American independence; with an outline plan of the fort; 
New York State Society, Order of Founders and Patriots of America. 

P. 2,7. 
Custom House rotunda: site of the first substantial <:h»r,;h edifice m 

Manhattan; Holland Society. R. i 

389 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Court of Produce Exchange, facing Stone Street , site of first Dutch 
School; New York Schooimasters' Club. P. 38. 

48 Wall Street: site of a bastion in the old city zvall; Society of 
Colonial Wars in the State of New York. P. 38. 

Exchange Alley and Broadway: "Tuyn Paat" or "Tin Pot Alley"; 
Dr. Morgan Dix. R, i. 

15 Maiden Lane: "Maagde Paatje" or the Maidens' Path; Maiden 
Lane Historical Society. Pp. 61, 67. See 1912 Report American Scenic 
and Historic Preservation Society. 

Liberty Place: Liberty Place Inscription; Liberty Place Historical 
Society. 

New York University, Washington Square: Adam Roclantsen and 
other Dutch Schoolmasters. P. 83. 

Marble Collegiate Church, Fifth Avenue and Twenty-ninth Street: 
Church in the Port. R. 15. 

ENGLISH PERIOD 

Custom House entrance: first Mass said in Manhattan ; Order of the 
Alhambra. P. :i7. 

St. Peter's Church, Barclay Street: first Roman Catholic Church in 
Manhattan. P. 66. 

John Street Methodist Church: Captain Webb, Bishop Asbiiry, Bar- 
bara Heck, Philip Embury, S. S. Hadley, Bishop E. G. Andreivs, Dr. 
IV. H. De Pay, B. M. Tilton, etc. Pp. 62 and 67. 

Church du St. Esprit, 45 East Twenty-seventh Street: original 
Pluguenot Church in New York; Huguenot Society of America. R. 15. 

Tulip Tree, Cold Spring, upper end of Manhattan. P. 174. 

REVOLUTIONARY PERIOD 

West Side Branch, Y. M. C. A., 318 West Fifty-seventh Street: 
Washington in prayer at Valley Forge. R. 17. 

South end of Viaduct, near West One Hundred and Twenty-eighth 
Street: the Hollow Way; Knickerbocker Chapter, Daughters of the 
American Revolution. P. 139. 

Within Historical Museum, College of the City of New York: the 
occupation of this region by the American Army after the Battle of 
Harlem Heights; Sons of the Revolution. P. 151. 

Fort Washington Point : inscription on boulder monument to mark 
Revolutionary redoubt; Fort Washington Chapter, Daughters of the 
American Re\solution. P. 173. 

Two Hundred and Twenty-eighth Street and Marble Hill Avenue: 
inscription on flagstaff to mark Fort Prince Charles. R. 27. 

390 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 
MODERN PERIOD 

Within pedestal, Statue of Liberty: Emma Lazarus- GcorKina 
Schuyler. P. 38. 

On memorial lantern, new Seamen's Institute, Cocntios Slij): fidelity 
of officers and crew of the S. S. Titanic. P. 38. 

P. S. No. 2, 116 Henry Street: centenary of the founding of this 
school; Alumni Association. P. 102. 

On new Municipal Building, Center Street: arms of the city and 
province of New York. P. 65. 

Cooper Union : Peter Cooper, Abraham Lincoln and Charles Sprague 
Smith. P. loi. 

Fourth Avenue and Seventeenth Street: tablet and medallion head of 
William Lloyd Garrison. P. 138. 

Union Square Hotel, Fourth Avenue: tablet and medallion head of 
Henry George. P. 138. 

North of Grant's Tomb: Japanese cherry trees and tablet to the 
memory of General Grant; gift of Japanese Government. P. 173. 

College of the City of New York: Edivard M. Shcpard. 

On kiosk, Riverside Drive and One Hundred and Fifty-first Street: 
Sailors of the New Hampshire. P. 173. 

Edgecombe Avenue and One Hundred and Fifty-fifth Street: Foun- 
tain and Light Tower; erected 1894 by bequest of George Hooper. 

P. 173- 

Fountain and Memorial Tablet, west end of Washington Bridge: 
Andrew Jackson; Andrew Jackson Chapter, National Society, U. S. 
Daughters of 1812. P. 173. 

BRONX 

Hall of Fame, New York University: bust of Robert l-ulton above 
his tablet. P. 183. See full account of the Hall of Fame, list of tablets, 
etc., in the 1908, 191 1 and 1912 Reports of the American Scenic and 
Historic Preservation Society. 

Heine Monument and Fountain, One Hundred and Si.xty-first Street 
and Mott Avenue; presented by German-.American Societies. P. I99- 

Inscription on boulder in grounds of New York University, to mark 
exact site of Fort No. Eight. P. 189. 

Tablet to Andrew Haswcll Green; Green Memorial Laboratory. New 
York University. 

Soldier's Monument, West Farms Presbyterian Churchyard ; by sub- 
scription. P. 213. 

390a 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Tablet on gates at lower end of Buffalo Reservation, Zoological 
Garden, Bronx Park: Lydig Farm. 

Tablet for Fort No. One, on the Muschenheim residence ; by Wm. C. 
Muschenheim. P. 183. 

Tablet to Jordan L. Mott, in Mott Memorial Church; by the con- 
gregation. P. 198. 

Tablet to Anne Hutchinson on Split Rock, Pelham Bay Park; by 
Colonial Dames of the State of New York. R. 34. See 1912 Report 
American Scenic and Historic Preservation Society, p. 163. 

Tablet on St. Paul's Church, EastcJiester, giving an account of the 
church and village green; Empire State Society Sons of the American 
Revolution. R. 215. 

Two Stones in St. Paul's Churchyard, Eastchester, in memory of 
the American and Hessian soldiers buried here; Bronx Chapter, 
Daughters of the American Revolution. P. 215, 

BROOKLYN 

Tablet, Flatlands Reformed Church; Colonial Daughters of the Seven- 
teenth Century. P. 264. 

Inscription on Sidezvalk, Third Avenue and Seventh Street, in mem- 
ory of the Maryland Soldiers who fell and were buried here during the 
Battle of Long Island. P. 264. 

QUEENS 

Plaza, Queensboro Bridge, Long Island City : Lipton tablet on mast 
of America's Cup challenger. Shamrock 3, presented to the city by 
Sir Thomas J. Lipton. 

1,000-ton shell from the battleship Maine in Londen Park, Corona, in 
honor of Hugo Kruse, a sailor from Corona who lost his life when the 
battleship was blown up in Havana in 1898. P. 314. 

Tablet in St. James Church, Flushing, to Rev. Wm. Urqiihart, the 
first rector; Rev. Edward M. McGuffey. P. 314. 

Tablet in P. S. 35, Palatina Avenue. Hollis Heights : Gen. Nathaniel 
Woodhull; Sons of the Revolution. P. 314. 

RICHMOND 

Statue of R. R. Randall, by St. Gaudens, near entrance to Sailors' 
Snug Harbor. P. 350. 

Three tablets in St. Andrew's Church, Richmond: (i) Queen Anne; 
(2) the first rector, Rev. E. S. Mackenzie; (3) the fourteen later 
rectors. P. 350. 

390b 



APPENDIX C 

NOTABLE HISTORIC BUILDINGS STANDING (1912). 

MANHATTAN. 

Fraunces Tavern, 54 Pearl Street, built 1719 by Eticnne Dc Lanccy. 
Excursion VI, p. 39. 

Golden Hill Inn, 122-4 William Street, built about 1750. R. 7. 

St Paul's Chapel, Broadway and Vesey Street, built 1764-6. R. 5. 

Washington's Headquarters (Roger Morris or Jumel Mansion). 
One Hundred and Sixty-second Street and Jumcl Place, built slicirtly 
before the Revolution (1765), p. 156. 

St. Mark's-in-the-Bowery, Second Avenue and Tenth Street, built 
1795-9. R. II. 

St. John's Chapel, 46 Varick Street, built 1803-7. R- 9- 

St. Patrick's Church (formerly the Cathedral), Mott and Princr 
Streets, built 1809. R. 13. 

Hamilton Grange, One Hundred and Forty-first Street and Con- 
vent Avenue, built 1802-4. R. 23. 

Grade House, East River Park, near Eighty-eighth Street, built 
1813. R. 20. 

Claremont, north end of Riverside Park, built shortly after tin- 
Revolution. R. 19. 

City Hall, City Hall Park, built 1803-12. R. 5- 

Aquarium (Castle Clinton or Southwest Battery), Battery Park, 
built 1807-11. R. 4. 

Fort Jay (Fort Columbus), Governor's Island, built about iSii. 

R. 4. 

Castle Williams, Governor's Island, built about 181 1. R. 4- 
Southeast Battery, Governor's Island, built about 181 1. R. 4- 
Block House No. i, Central Park, built 1814. R- 21. 
Block House No. 3, Morningside Park and One Hundred an.l 

Twenty-third Street, built 1814. R. 19. 

United States Assay OMce, 32 Wall Street, oldest Federal building 

in Manhattan, built 1823. R. 2. (About to be demolished.) 
St. Luke's Chapel, Hudson Street, opposite Grove Street, biuit 1821- 

4. R. 8. 

391 



The Bronx HISTORICAL GUIDE Brooklyn 

St. Peter's Church, Barclay and Church Streets, the oldest Roman 
Catholic Church in Manhattan, built 1838-9. R. 6. 

Trinity Church, Broadway, opposite Wall Street, built 1839-46. R. 2. 

Bedford Street Church, corner of Morton Street, built 1840. R. 8. 

John Street Church, between William and Nassau Streets, successor 
to the oldest Methodist Church in America, built 1841. R. 7. 

THE BRONX. 

Macomb Mansion, Broadway and Two Hundred and Thirtieth 
Street, built 1693. R. 29. 

Van Cortlandt Mansion, Van Cortlandt Park; built 1748. R. 29. 

Hunt Mansion, Hunt's Point, built 1688. R. 31. 

Ferris Mansion, Westchester County Club grounds, near Throgg's 
Neck. Pre-Revolutionary. R. 33. 

St. Paul's Church, Eastchester, built 1765. R. 34a. 

St. Peter's Church, Westchester, on the site of the church of 1700. 
R. 32, a. 

Fordham Manor Reformed Church, Kingsbridge Road and Aqueduct 
Avenue, in one of whose vaults Virginia Poe, wife of the poet, was 
buried. R. 30a. 

Poe Cottage, Kingsbridge Road, Fordham. R. 2,2. 

BROOKLYN. 

Schenck-Crooke House, Mill Lane, Flatlands, built about 1656. R. 
40. 

Bergen Homestead, East Seventy-second Street, Bergen Beach, 
built about 1655. R. 40. 

Wyckoff House, Canarsie Lane and Remsen Place, Canarsie, built 
1664. R. 41. 

Van Pelt Manor House, Eighty-first Street and Eighteenth Avenue, 
New Utrecht, built about 1664. R. 43. 

Van Brunt House, 1752 Eighty-fourth Street, built about 1660. R. 
43. 

Hicks-Platt House, Neck Road, Gravesend, built about 1660. R. 
43a, and p. 265. 

Gerritsen Tide Mill, Gerritsen's Creek, near Neck Road, on the 
site of the original mill of 1636. R. 40. 

Schenck House, Canarsie Park, built about 1770. R. 41. 

392 



Queens HISTORIC BUILDINGS Richmond 

Old Mill (now known as Van Wicklcn Mill), Old Mill Village. 
New Lots, built 1770. R, 41. 

Flatbush Dutch Reformed Church, corner of Flatbiish and Church 
Avenues, built 1793-6, on the site of the oldest church in Long Mand. 

R. 39. 

Erasmus Hall High School (concealed behind new structure), Flat- 
bush Avenue, near Erasmus Street, built 1786. R. 39. 

VanDerveer Homestead, 1159 Flatbush Avenue, built 1787 (98). R. 
39. 

Fort Lafayette (old Fort Diamond), the Narrows, built about i8ij. 
R. 42. 

Fort Hamilton, built 1825-31, on the site of military works of 1808. 
R. 42. 

Bushwick Dutch Reformed Church, successor to the first church 
in Bushwick, built 1825. R. 35c. 

St. James Pro-Cathedral, Jay and Chapel Streets, first Roman 
Catholic church on Long Island, organized 1822. R. 36. 

Borough Hall, built for a City Hall, 7836-40. R. 36. 

QUEENS. 

Bowne House, Flushing, built 1655. R. 51. 

Quaker Meeting House, Flushing, built 1694-5. R- 5^- 

Garretson House, Flushing, built before 1700. R. 51. 

Moore House, Elmhurst, built about 1661. R. 49. 

Corner House, Elmhurst, built 17 16. R. 49- 

St. James Church, Elmhurst, built I735- R- 49- 

Moore House, Steinway, built 1690-5. R. 44- 

Riker Homestead, Steinway, built before 1700. R. 44. 

De Witt Clinton House, Maspeth, built 1725. R- 4^. 

King Mansion, Jamaica, built about 1750. R. 52. 

RICHMOND. 

Billopp House, Tottenville, built 1688. R. 60. 
Fountain House, New Dorp, built before 1700. R. 56. 
Guyon-Clarke House, New Dorp. R. 56. 
Lake-Tysen House, New Dorp. R. 56. 



303 



Richmond HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Moravian Church and Parsonage, New Dorp, built 1763. R. 56. 

Black Horse Tavern, New Dorp, pre-Revolutionary. R. 56. 

St. Andrew's Church, Richmond, on site of church established 1708. 

R. 59. 

Purdy's Hotel, Princess Bay, built about 1700. R. 60a. 
Barne-Tysen House, Karles Neck, land granted In 1667. R. 54. 
Christopher Homestead, Willow Brook, pre-Revolutionary. R. 54. 
Austin House, Rosebank, Stapleton, built about 1710. R. 55. 
Garibaldi House, Stapleton. R. 55. 

Forts Wadsworth and Tompkins, the Narrows, built 1847 on site 
of forts of War of 1812. R. 55. 

Banner's Hotel, Port Richmond, built about 1800. R. 53. 

Kreuzer-Pelton House, the Cove, West New Brighton, built 1722. 
R. sz. 

Sailors' Snug Harbor, West New Brighton, built 1833. R. 53. 



ADDENDA, 1912 

MANHATTAN. 

Schermcrhorn Farm house, East River and Sixty-fourth Street, in 
the Rockefeller Institute grounds; built 1744. R. 20. 

Smith's Folly, 421 East Sixty-first Street, built 1799. R. 20. 

Shot Tower, foot of East Fifty-third Street, built 1821. R. 20. 

Mansion, 7 State Street, built about 1800. R. i. 

Prime House, in grounds of St. Joseph's Orphan Asylum, Eighty- 
nindi Street near Avenue A, built 1800. R. 20. 

Dyckman House, Broadway and Hawthorne Avenue, Inwood, built 
1787. R. 28b. 

BRONX. 

Hadley House, opposite Van Cortlandt Park, west of Broadway, 
before 1750. R. 29a. 

Isaac Varian Homestead, Bainbridge and Van Cortlandt Avenues, 
erected in 1776. Scene of an encounter between the patriots and the 
British in 1776. R. 30b. 

Wasliingtons Gun House, west of Webster Avenue, opposite car 
barns, north of City Line. General Washington stored his guns here 
while withdrawing towards White Plains in 1776. R. 30b. 

Clason's Point Inn, at end of Clason's Point. Part of this is the old 
hou^e erected by Cornell, the first settler, in 1643. R. 3^,. 

Old Pell Mansion, also known as the Coudert Mansion, Wolf's Lane, 
Pelham Manor, near New Rochelle trolley. R. 34. 

394 



APPENDIX D 

MUSEUMS, COLLECTIONS, AND LIBRARIES 

Of special interest to students of local history 

Revised 1912 

MANHATTAN 

American Museum of Natural History (incorporated 1869), Seventy- 
seventh Street and Central Park West. Open free every day in the 
year (on week-days, including holidays, from 9 to 5, and Sundays 
from I to 5, also Tuesday and Saturday evenings from 7 to 10). Free 
lectures Tuesday and Saturday, 8.15 p.m., October to April. .\ library 
of 60,000 volumes. Collections of animals, woods, minerals, gems, and 
material illustrating the customs of various races. The Indian relics 
found in the upper end of Manhattan, the Bronx and Richmond arc 
of particular interest to students of local history. 

Metropolitan Museum of Art (incorporated 1870). at Fifth Avenue 
and Eighty-second Street, in Central Park. Open free Sunday, 1-6; 
Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, 10-5; Saturday, 10-10; Monday and 
Friday, 10-5, admission 25 cents. The collections include the fine arts 
and decorative or industrial arts. Among the collections of special 
interest are the collection of Egyptian art, largely material recently 
excavated in Egypt, historically arranged; the llociitschal Collection of 
French Gothic and eighteenth century decorative arts; and the Morgan 
Collection of Chinese porcelains. The Huntington collection of like- 
nesses of Washington, Franklin, and Lafayette, embracing drawings, 
engravings, prints, busts, faience, medals, and cameos is of i)articular 
interest to students of history. Special privileges are oflfercd to teachers 
and pupils in public and private schools, art students, and craftsmen. 
On application, teachers may obtain a bulletin giving detailed informa- 
tion concerning the practical use of the collection for classes of children. 

The New York Aquarium, Battery Park. Open (free) every day 
in the year; 9-5, April 15-October 15; 10-4, October 16- April 14. 
Exhibits of fishes, turtles, crocodilians. frogs, salamanders, marine 
mammals and invertebrates. By arrangement with the Curaf.r. the 
casemates, bomb proof and other traces of the old fort may be seen. 

Washington's Headquarters, One Hundred and Sixty-second Street. 
east of St. Nicholas Avenue. Open (free) daily, 10= Fitted up as 

395 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

a Colonial Museum ; under the care of the Washington Headquarters 
Association. For detailed account see R. 2^. 
Isham Mansion in Isham Park; see p. 174. 

Municipal Collections 

In City Hall, City Hall Park. Open (free) 10-4 (except holidays); 
Saturday, 10-12. Trumbull's Room: portraits of Washington and for- 
mer governors ; battle Hags ; furniture used by the ofificers and mem- 
bers of the first Federal Government. Aldermanic Chambers: por- 
traits ; ceiling painting : New York welcoming the Nations. Mayor's 
Reception Office: portraits of Lafayette and of mayors since 1783. 
City Clerk's OfUce, Office of the President of the Board of Aldermen, 
Old Council Chamber and President's Office: OfUce of the Municipal 
Art Commission: portraits of historic persons and former officials. 

County Court House, City Hall Park: Portraits. 

Comptroller's Office, Stewart Building, Chambers Street and Broad- 
way : Portraits of Andrew H. Green and heroes of the War of 1812, 

Corporation Counsel's Office, Hall of Records : Portraits. 

Criminal Courts Building, Centre and Franklin Streets : Allegorical 
mural paintings, portrait of Richard Riker. 

Hall of Records, Chambers and Centre Streets : Old records, dating 
back to the Dutch Period and early maps may be seen on application. 

Board of Education Building, Park Avenue and Fifty-ninth Street : 
Portraits of De Witt Clinton and former members of the Board of 
Education. Oil painting, "Am I My Brother's Keeper," presented, 
191 1, by Alfred Mosely, Esq. 

Appellate Division of the Supi'eme Court, First Department, Twenty- 
fifth Street and Madison Avenue: Mural paintings in the vestibule and 
Court Room : Portraits. 

General Post Office Laiv Library, City Hall Park : Portraits and 
tablets. 

State Arsenal, Seventh Avenue and Thirty-fifth Street: War relics 
and tablets from the Elm Street Armory. 

PRIVATE MUSEUMS AND COLLECTIONS 

American Geographical Society (organized 1852), One Hundred and 
Fifty-sixth Street, west of Broadway: Early maps, copies of Valen- 
tine's Manual, Annals of Albany, histories of the counties of New 
York, documents and documentary history of New York. Open 10-5, 
free. 

396 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

American Numismatic Society, One Hundred and Fifty-sixth Street, 
west of Broadway. Collection of coins and medals of all countries 
and all ages, and a large numismatic library. Open to the public. 
10 A.M. to 5 P.M. week days, 1-5 p.m. Sundays. 

Hispanic Society of America, One Hundred and Fifty-si.xth Street, 
west of Broadway. Open (free) daily, including Sundays, 1-5, ex 
cept August, Christmas and Thanksgiving. Library open to holders 
of readers' cards, 10-5, except Sundays, legal holidays and the month 
of August. "A free museum and educational institution for the ad 
vancement of the study of the Spanish and Portuguese language, liter 
ature and history." Spanish paintings, sculptures, pottery, metal work, 
embroideries, laces, early printed books, manuscripts, early map.s. 

Fraunces Tavern, 54 Pearl Street Open (free) daily, under the 
care of the Sons of the Revolution. Collection of Revolutionary relic>. 
flags, china, coins, medals, military commissions, letters, etc. Ex 
cj-irsion VI. 

Cooper Union Museum for the Arts of Decoration, Cooper Union, 
Astor Place. Open (free) daily and every evening, except Saturday and 
Sunday, from October ist to May ist, between 7.30 and 9.30 (secure 
pass at the office), except Sunday and Monday; closed July i-Septeni 
ber 13. Collection of Colonial furniture, costumes, needle-work and 
relics of Peter Cooper. 

Exempt Firemen's Organication, 10 Jefferson Market. Sixth Avenue 
and Tenth Street. Open (free) daily. Collection of old fire apparatus 
and pictures. 

Volunteer Firemen's Association, 220 East Fifty-ninth Street. (^i>en 
(free) daily. Collection of old fire apparatus, pictures and documents. 

Museum of the Military Service Institution, Governor's Island. Open 
(free) daily, except Saturday afternoon and Sunday. Collection cf 
war relics and historic flags. 

New York Historical Society, founded 1804. 170 Central Park West 
Open 9-6, open to the public. 150,000 volumes and pamphlets on Amen 
can History. Gallery of Art, Abbot Collection of l-gyptian Antu|UitK- 
and Collection of Prints and Relics of the City of New York. 

Historical Museum of the College of the City of Nc7V York, Co,i- 
vent Avenue and One Hundred and Thirty-eighth Street. Open (free^ 
daily during the college year. Collection of prints and maps. 

Middle Dutch Reformed Church, Second .Xvenue and Seventh .stre.t 

See R. II : 7- t-, 1 c . c 

St. Mark's-in-the-Bowery, Second Avenue and Eleventh Street. So 

R. 11:2. 

Z97 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Collegiate Church, Fifth Avenue and Forty-eighth Street (Lecture 
Room). Prints and engravings. R. 17:5. 

Brick Presbyterian ChurcJi, Fifth Avenue and Thirty-seventh Street. 
Prints, engravings, etc. R. 17:2. 

John Street Methodist Church, old prints, furniture, books of John 
Wesley. R. 7:34- 

St. Cornelius Chapel, Governor's Island, banners, flags, tablets. 
R. 4 : 46. 

Methodist Historical Society, Methodist Book Concern, Fifth Avenue 
and Twentieth Street. Relics in connection with Methodism in New 
York. 

Hotel Astor, Broadway and Forty-fifth Street, rare prints and en- 
gravings of old New York. R. 18 B. 

Dolan's Cafe, 23 Park Row, model of old Park Row. R. 5 : 15. 

Stewart's Cafe, 161 Fulton Street, prints and cartooons. R. 5: 17. 

Britting's Restaurant, 126 Greenwich Avenue, theatre posters and 
programmes. R. 8:3. 

Hotel Netherland, Fifth Avenue and Fifty-ninth Street. Paintings : 
"The Purchase of Manhattan" and "Stuyvesant Receiving the English 
Terms of Surrender." 

Hotel Imperial, Broadway and Thirtieth Street. Painting: "Bowling 
in Bowling Green." 

New Amsterdam Theatre, 214 West Forty-second Street. Painting 
representing the reading of the Declaration of Independence to the 
Army on the Common, July 9, 1776. 

De Witt Clinton High School, Fifty-ninth Street and Tenth Avenue. 
Mural paintings in connection with the Erie Canal. R. 18: D. 

Republican Club, 54 West Fortieth Street : Prints, cartoons and maps 
of old New York. P. 139. 

Cozvperthwait's Store, Third Avenue and One Hundred and Twenty- 
first Street: Prints of old New York. P. 173. 

LIBRARIES 
The New York Public Library, 476 Fifth Avenue, between Fortieth 
and Forty-second streets, is open every week day, including holidays, 
from 9 A.M. to 10 P.M., Sundays from i to 10 p.m. The reference 
collection, for use within the building, numbers over 1,126,000 volumes. 
Of particular historical interest are the works on American State and 
local history, over 19,200 volumes; 3,600 volumes of American gene- 
alogies ; 600 of British genealogies ; 3,790 of American historical and 
patriotic society publications. General books on American history num- 

398 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

ber 100,000 volumes. The collection of historical prints is of great 
value. Exhibitions of rare books and prints arc held at frequent in- 
tervals. 

For circulation four rooms in the central building and forty hraiuh 
libraries provide over 860,000 volumes for home use. 

The circulation branches are usually open from 9 a.m. to 9 i'..m 
on week days; most are open on holidays and several on Sundays. 

The Travelling Library Office, headquarters in the central buildiuK. 
entrance on Bryant Park and Fortieth Street, will arrange to make up 
and loan (free of charge) sets of books on various subjects for the use 
of schools, teachers and study clubs. 

The Library for the Blind (room 116, central building) publishes and 
circulates books in raised type. 

American Jezvish Historical Society Library, 531-535 West One Hun 
dred and Twenty-third Street, open to members and their friends. Col 
lection of books, prints, relics and rare manuscripts, referring mainly 
to the history of the Jews on the American Continent. 

City Library, City Hall. Open (free) for reference, 10-4; Saturda\. 
10-12. Collection of city records; reports and various municipal pul^ 
lications. 

Columbia University, Lo7V Memorial Library. Open 8.30 a.m. -11 r.M. 
(8.30 A.M. -10 P.M. in summer) daily, except Sunday; closed on New 
Year's Day, Good Friday, Independence Day, Labor Day, Thanksgiving 
and Christmas. Free for inspection ; free for lending to students, grad- 
uates and officers of Columbia University; to the faculties of local 
colleges and universities and to the principals and heads of depart- 
ments of the New York high schools ; free for reference to such persons 
in the cities of New York, Brooklyn, and Newark as may be introduced 
by the librarians of the public libraries of those places. The collection 
includes 450 titles on local history, embracing some of the rarest books 
and prints and 2,500 De Witt Clinton letters. The Holland Society has 
deposited here its valuable collection of books on the early history and 
settlement of this country by the Dutch. The collection of Columbiann 
is rich in material relating to the history of New York City and . • 
Columbia University. 

Cooper Union Library. Astor Place. Open (free) daily. 8 a.m. -10 
P.M.; Sunday, October to May, 12 M.-9 pm. Books for reference onlv 

General Society of Mechanics and Tradesmen, 16-24 West Forty 
fourth Street. Open 9-8. Reference department free to the public. 

Huguenot Society of America, 29 West Thirty-ninth Street. Books 
relating to Huguenot history and genealogy. 

399 



HI3TCRICAL GUIDE 

Mercantile Library, Astor Place and Eighth Street. Open to sub- 
scribers. General collection of 245,000 volumes. 

New York Genealogical and Biographical Society, Genealogical Hall, 
226 West Fifty-eighth Street. Library open daily, except Sunday, 10-6; 
Monday evening, 8-10. Admission through member's card. Collection 
of New York town and county histories; military records; records of 
wills; indexes to conveyances; collections of copies of New York 
church records ; files of the Genealogical and Biographical Record 
from i86g. 

Nezv York Society Library, 109 University Place, near Twelfth Street. 
Open 9-6. Free to the public for reference. Files of eighteen New. 
York newspapers; rare prints; laws of New York from 1694; all the 
well-known histories and guide-books of New York ; nearly all the 
New York directories ; reports of institutions, clubs and city depart- 
ments. 

See also mention above of libraries of the American Geographical 
Society; American Numismatic Society; Hispanic Society of America; 
Methodist Historical Society and Nezv York Historical Society. 



THE BRONX 

Botanical Garden, Bronx Park (R. 32). Reached by Harlem Division, 
N. Y. C. & H. R. R. R. to Bronx Park or Bronx Park Subway train 
to One Hundred and Forty-ninth Street and (free) transfer to the 
Elevated R. R. to Bronx Park. Open (free) daily; buildings open 
10-4. Exhibits — in the grounds : Hardy herbaceous plants, shrubs, 
trees, and natural woodlands. In the Conservatories : Tropical and 
warm temperate zone plants. In the Museums : Plan products utilized 
in the arts, sciences, and industries ; illustrations of the natural families 
of plants ; plants growing naturally within one hundred miles of New 
York ; fossil plants ; library ; herbaria ; laboratories. Lectures on Sat- 
urday afternoons, April to November. A docent will explain the 
exhibits, leaving the museum at 3 p.m. 

Lorillard Mansion Museum, Bronx Park, east of the Botanical 
Garden (R. 32). Open (free) 11-5 daily. Under the care of the Bronx 
Society of Arts and Sciences. Collection of natural specimens of the 
borough ; specimens illustrative of the industries, educational features 
and park system of the Bronx ; Indian, Colonial and Revolutionary 
relics ; historical photographs and rare prints : a reference library. 

Zoological Garden, Bronx Park (R. 32). Reached by the Lenox 
Avenue Subway to One Hundred and Eightieth Street, West Farms, 

400 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

or by the Third Avenue Elevated R. R. to Fordham Road; trolley to 
entrance. Under the care of the New York Zoological Society. Open 
daily 9 to half hour before sunset in summer, after 10 in winter. Free 
except on Monday and Thursday (25c.) ; when a holiday falls (.n 
Monday or Thursday, the fee is remitted, but is charged ( n the day 
following, 

Vati Cortlandt Mansion, Van Cortlandt Park (R. 29). Open (free) 
daily except Sunday, 10-6; Thursday, 25c. Under the care of the 
Colonial Dames of the State of New York. Rooms fitted up in Colonial 
style; a collection of Revolutionary and Colonial relics. 
. New York University Museum, under the Hall of Fame ( R. 30). 
Open (free) daily during the college year. 

New York University General Library. Open daily, free on proper 
introduction. 



BROOKLYN 

Central Museum of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences, 
Eastern Parkway and Washington Avenue (R. 38). Open week days, 
9-6; Thursday evening, 7.30-9.45; Sunday, 2-6; free except Monday and 
Tuesday (if these are not holidays), when there is a fee of 25c. for 
adults and loc. for children under sixteen. Collections in natural 
sciences; paintings; sculptures; historical casts, races and customs of 
men, etc. 

Children's Museum of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciencrv 
Bedford Park, on Brooklyn Avenue. Open (free) daily. ()-5..^o; Sun 
days, 2-5.30. Collections pertain to natural history, local history, occu 
pations of man and an extensive children's lil)rary on the^c subject^ 
See R. 38: 12. 

Hall of Records: Collection of portraits of recorders and other 
officials. 

County Court House: Portraits of Supreme Court justices and othti 
judges. 

Borough Hall: Portraits of mayors of the former City of Rrooklyn 

Long Island Historical Society, Clinton and Pierrepont Street-^. Sr- 
R. 36:6. Open (free) daily. 

U. S. Naval Museum, Navy Yard, entrance Navy Yard, opposite Sands 
Street. Library and historical relics in the U. S. Naval Museum 
Pp. 243, 264. 

Plymouth Church, on Orange, between Hicks and Henry streets 
Memorial windows, battle flags, etc. Pp. 241, 264. 

401. 



HISTORICAL GUIDE 

Libraries 

Brooklyn Public Library, central office, 26 Brevoort Place. Circu- 
lating branches in all parts of the borough. Open (free) daily, 9-9. 
Sunday, 2-6. 

The Department of Travelling Libraries, 67-69 Schermerhorn Street. 
This Department lends collections of books free of charge to clubs, 
schools, factories, societies, etc., within the Borough limits ; gives worn 
books to hospitals, kindergartens, etc. 

Catholic Historical Library, loi Greene Avenue. 

Long Island Historical Society, Clinton and Pierrepont streets. Open 
8.30 A.M. -9.30 P.M. Reference only for members and those introduced 
by members. Collection of 70,000 volumes largely on local history and 
genealogy. 

Pratt Institute Free Library, Ryerson Street, between De Kalb and 
Willoughby avenues. Open week days, 9 a.m. -9.30 p.m. Collection 
of 100,000 volumes. 

QUEENS 

Bownc House, Flushing. Admission 25c. ; six people only allowed 
at a time; larger parties must arrange in advance with Miss Parsons, 
371 Broadway, Flushing. In winter house not open to visitors. See 
R. 51 : 14- 

King Mansion, Jamaica. Open (free) Monday; other days by special 
arrangement with Mrs. William S. Cogswell, Pres., King Manor Asso- 
ciation, 31 Clinton Avenue, Jamaica. R. 52:6. 

Queens Borough Public Library, central office, 402 Fulton Street, 
Jamaica. Circulating branches in various parts of the borough. Usually 
open daily (except Sunday), 9-9. 

RICHMOND 

Public Museum of the Siaten Island Association of Arts and Sciences, 
154 Stuyvesant Place, St. George. Open (free) daily except Sunday.- 
Collections of natural history, geology, archeology, art, etc. Especially 
rich in Staten Island historical and Indian relics, and local biology. 
R. 53:1. 

Billopp House, TottenvUle. R. 69 : 107. 



403 



APPENDIX E.-HISTORIC TREES, ROCKS AND OTHER 

OBJECTS. 

MANHATTAN. 

Two English Yews in front of the Low Memorial Library, Colum- 
bia University, said to have been brought from England about 1800 
and set out in St. John's Park; later removed to the Elgin B(itanical 
Garden at Fiftieth Street (R. 17) ; removed to the Bloomingdale 
Asylum grounds and replanted at their present site in 1897. 

The Wistaria vines frequently seen in Greenwich (R. 8) arc said 
to be descendants of those in Dr. Hosack's Arboretum in the Elgin 
Garden. 

A stunted English oak on the northwest side of the Mall, in Cen- 
tral Park, was placed here by the Prince of Wales (now Edward 
Vn) while here in i860. 

A number of trees remain in East River Park imported from 
China and Japan by Thomas Hogg (R. 20) ; some have been removed 
to Central Park, among them the Japanese elm near the gate at 
Fifth Avenue and Seventy-second Street. 

Some of the trees in Washington Square are survivors of those set 
out when this was a Parade (R. 10). 

A double row of trees in Madison Square formerly lined the eastern 
branch of the Post Road (R. 15). 

In the churchyards of Trinity, St. Paul's and St. Mark's Churches 
are trees dating back to the first part of the last century. 

Many old trees remain in Union and Stuyvesant Sciuarcs and in 
Gramercy Park. 

The Sparrows' Lodging House on the north side of East One Hun- 
dred and Twenty-fifth Street, near First Avenue (old Harlem Lam), 
seems to be a favorite haunt of these birds. 

The giant tulip at Cold Spring (R. 28) is considerably over one 
hundred years old. There remains some of the primeval forest near 
by at the northern end of Manhattan on the hill overlooking the 
Hudson. 



403 



Manhattan HISTORICAL GUIDE The Bronx 

Trees That Have Disappeared. 

The Stuyvesant Pear Tree, once at the corner of Thirteenth Street 
and Third Avenue, now commemorated by a tablet (R. ii). Portions 
of this famous tree are preserved in the Governor's Room, City Hall, 
Police Headquarters and in the New York Historical Society Build- 
ing. A descendant of the original tree from a graft obtained by 
Jesse Ryder about i860 may be seen on the Ryder farm near Ossining. 

The Van Beuren Tree stood until recently in front of the Van 
Beuren Mansion on the north side of Fourteenth Street (R. 14). 
• The Varian Tree used to stand on Broadway between Twenty-sixth 
and Twenty-seventh Streets. 

The Thirteen Trees (sweet gum or liquid amber) brought from 
Mt. Vernon, Va., by Hamilton about 1802 remained on Convent Ave- 
nue and One Hundred and Forty-third Street until all died and were 
finally removed in 1908 (R. 23). 

The " grand old elm " (variously located by different writers, but 
probably at Striker's Bay, near the Hudson at Ninety-sixth Street), 
which inspired George P. Morris to write the lines beginning " Wood- 
man, spare that tree," was cut down only recently (R. 18). 

It is related that a favorite tree on the farm of Hendrick Brevoort 
prevented the cutting through of Eleventh Street between Broadway 
and Fourth Avenue. (R. 14). 

THE BRONX 

The Cowboy Oak at the end of Two Hundred and Thirty-seventh 
Street, west of the Spuyten Duyvil Parkway, is alleged to have 
been the scene of hangings during the Revolution (R. 29). 

The Washington Chestnut on Valentine Lane, now partially de- 
stroyed, is said to have been used by Washington as a place of conceal- 
ment (R. 29). 

The stump of the Delancey Pine still remains in Bronx Park (R. 34a). 

The Howe Chestnut under which the British general is said to 
have lunched, still stands near the Pell Mansion (R. 34). 

The Spy Oak of Revolutionary lore is near Westchester (R. 33a). . 

The Pell Treaty Oak, now nearly destroyed, is near the Bartow 
Mansion (R. 34). 



404 



HISTORIC TREES AND ROCKS 

Hemlock Grove in the Botanical Garden, Bronx Park, is the oldest 
forest of native hemlocks in this part of the State (R. ^2). 



BROOKLYN. 

'' Amusketahole," a white oak marking the boundary line between 
Flatlands and Flatbush; on Avenue G, near Flatlands Neck Road. 
R. 40. 

QUEENS. 

The Maurice Woods, east of Maspeth, was the only extensive wood- 
land of Newtown to escape the ravages of the British when quartered 
in this part of Long Island. 

The forest once covering what is now Forest Park and Cypress 
Hills Cemetery, was reserved as hunting grounds for the Indians in 
their deed to Middelburg (R. 50). 

The site of Fox Oaks in Flushing is marked by a tablet (R. 51). 

NOTED ROCKS AND CAVES. 
MANHATTAN. 

The Capske Rocks near Whitehall Ferry, now under niaile land 
and revealed when the South Ferry Subway Station was constructed. 
R. I. 

The Smuggler's Cave was near the East River shore about Seven- 
tieth Street. R. 20. 

Marco Bossaris Rock just north of Washington's Headquarters on 
West One Hundred and Sixty-second Street, where it is said Fitz- 
Greene Halleck composed his famous poem. R. 23. 

Point of Rocks about One Hundred and Twenty-sixth Street and 
Convent Avenue (now largely cut away for street improvements), an 
outlook for Washington's sentinels in 1776. R. I9- 

Indian Rock Shelter at Cold Spring, within which many remains of 
Indians have recently been discovered. R. 28b. 

The Death Gap Rocks, Fort Washington. Bennett Avenue (One 
Hundred and Eighty-fourth Street), west of Broadway. R. 24. 

40$ 



The Bronx HISTORICAL GUIDE Historic Objects 

THE BRONX. 

Glacial Boulder in front of the Division Engineer's Office near the 
High Pressure Pumping-station of Jerome Park Reservoir. R. 30a. 
Rocking Stone, south end of Bronx Park. R. 32. 
Glover's Rock, near Bartow, on scene of the Battle of Pell's Point. 

R. 34. 

Split Rock, near the home of Ann Hutchinson, not far from Pelham 
Manor. R. 34. 

Pudding Rock, until recently on Boston Road and One Hundred 
and Sixty-sixth Street. R. 32. 

Seton Cave and the Indian Hiding Place near Eastchester. R. 
34a. 

The Devil's Stepping Stones jutting out in the Sound. R. 34. 

Rocks in East River at Hell Gate. R. 20. 

Diamond Reef in the Narrows. R. 42. 

HISTORIC OBJECTS. 

Revolutionary Cannon: (i) Battery Park; placed here by the City 
History Club, R. i; (2) at Pearl Street opposite Cedar Street, R. 7; 
(3) at Peck Slip and Water Street, R. 7; (4) Old Slip, p. 38; (s) 
Central Park, p. 146; (6) Van Cortlandt Park, p. 182. 

Dutch Millstones at the rear of 18 South William Street, R. 3. 

Millstones and Sundial in Van Cortlandt Park, R. 29. 

Dutch Millstone in sidewalk opposite 437 Jackson Avenue near 
North Plaza of Queensboro Bridge, Long Island City; from Brou- 
chard grist mill formerly on Dutch Kills Creek, brought from Hol- 
land about 1657. 

Old Church Bells: (i) in the churchyard of the Marble Collegiate 
Dutch Reformed Church, Twenty-ninth Street and Fifth Avenue, R. 15; 
(2) in the steeple of the Fifth Avenue Dutch Reformed Church at 
Forty-eighth Street, R. 17; (3) in the Dutch Reformed Church at One 
Hundred and Twenty-third Street and Lenox Avenue, R. 22; (4) in 
St. Mary's Roman Catholic Church at Ridge and Grand Streets, R. 13; 
(5) in garden, St. George's Church, p. loi. 

Doliola, sun dial and marble seat from Italy in Grace Churchyard 
on Broadway and Tenth Street, R. 14. 

Pompeiian Columns at the entrance to Delmonico's at Beaver and 
South William Streets, R. 3. 

Cleopatra's Needle in Central Park. 

406 



HISTORIC OBJECTS 



ADDENDA, 1912. 

Revolutionary earthworks still visible in Manhattan: (i) Fort Clin- 
ton, R. 21; (2) Fort Washington, R. 24; (3) Fort Washington Point, 
R. 25; (4) Fort Tryon R. 26; (5) near Fort George, R. 23. 

Parts of iron railing from balcony of Federal Hall: (i) on front of 
main building, Bellevue Hospital. R. 15; (2) in New York Historical 
Society, R. 17. 

Old City Well, Trinity Place and Thames Street. R. 6. 

Old Fire Tower, Mt. Morris Park. R. 22. 

Manhattan Water Tank, Center and Reade Streets. R. 12. 



407 



INDEX 



Abbey, the, 167. 

Abingdon Road, 115. 

Abingdon Square, -jz- 

Academy of Music, 109. 

African Company, 370. 

Albany Post Road, 147, 181, 372. 

Alburtis House. 288. 

Allen, Ethan, 54. 

Allerton, Isaac. Warehouse, 64. 

All Saints' Church, qq. 

Ambleside, 198. 

American Jewish Hist. Soc, 139. 

American Museum of Natural Hi 

tory, 120. 
Amiable Child, Tomb, 127. 
Amity Street, 81. 
Amusketahole Tree, 251. 
Anderson Mansion, 187. 
Androvette House, 350. 
Anthon's Grammar School, 59. 
Appellate Court House, iii. 
Apthorp Mansion, 123. 
Apthorp Lane, 129, 130. 
Aquarium, 33. 
Arbitration Rock, 289. 
Archer House. 189- • 

Arnhem Village 274, 287. 
Arrociiar, 338. 

Arsenal in Central Park, 120. 
Arthur. Chester A.. Home, 112. 
Artillery Park, 133- 
Aspinwall House, Flushing. 306. 
Assay Office, U. S.. 28. 
Astor, \Vm., P^irst Home, 83. 
Astor House, 59- 
Astor Library. 9.1- 
Astor Place Opera House, 9.1- 
Astoria, 275, 281. 
Astoria Methodist Church, 283. 
Audubon, Home, i53- 
Audubon Park, 153. 
Austin House, 337- 



Baisley's Mill Pond, 313. 

Bank of New York, 28. 

Baretto, Francis J., Former Home. 

196. 
Baretto's Point, 196. 
Bark Mill, 31- 
Barnard College. 125. 
Barne-Tysen House, 334- 
Barnum's Museum, S7. 
Barracks of 18 12, 73- 
Barton House, 344- 



Bartow Mansion, 210. 

Bathgate House, 190, 199. 

Battery, t^^i,. 

Battery Flagstaff. 34; 

Battery Place, is. 

Battle of Harlem Heights, 125. 129. 

Battle of Harlem Ileiglits Memorial 

Window, 12.V 
Battle of Long Island. 22%. 
Battle of Pell's Point. 176. 209. 
Battle Pass Tablet. 245. 
Bayard I'arm. 95. 
Bayard House. 73. 
Beadell Homestead, 232. 
Bear Market. 60. 
Bear Swamp. 213. 
Beaver Pond. 310. 
Beaver Street, 31. 
Bedell House. 345. 
Bedford Street Methodist Church, 76. 
Bedloe's Island. 35- 
Beecher. Henry Ward. Memorial. 

264. 
Beecher. Henry Ward. Statue. 242. 
Beekman Hill. i33- 
Beekman House. 133. 
Beekman Place, I33- 
Belden Mansion, 209. 
Bellevue Hospital, i 13. 
Belmont Hall. 328. 
IkMiham Mansion. 34S- 
Bennett Houses. 164. 231. 2Si- 
Bennetl-Schermcrhorn Housr, 257. 
Benson House. 260. 
IkMitUy Manor. 34')- 
Ik-rgen Heach. 263. 
liergen Homesteads. 248. 24Q. 262, 

264, 313. 
Berrian Burying dround. iRj. 
Berrian. Cornelius. I'arm Houses. 

1 8-;. 28.S. 
Berrien's Lane, 28s. 
'Beth Haim." 108, 112. 
Ri-tts Homesteail. Maspcth. 388. 
I'iftt's House, iQO. 
Hillni)p House. 349. 
l?irdsall House. 247- 
"P.Iack Cat." The. 80. 
P.lack Horse Tavern. 167. 341. 
Black Rock. 204. 

I?lack Swamp. 109. , „ 

HIackweil Mansion Homestead. 283. 
Blackwell's Island. 13''. 281- 
Blake-Miller House. 334. 
Blazing Star. 347- 



400 



INDEX 



Blind Man's Alley, 64. 
Block-house, Flushing, 304. 
Block-house No. I, 146. 
Block-house No. Ill, 126. 
Blommaert's Vly, 31. 
Bloodgood Homestead, 316. 
Bloom Farm House, 300. 
Bloomfield, Daniel, Home, 298. 
Bloomingdale, 9, 121. 
Bloomingdale Asylum, 12=,. 
Bloomingdale Dutch Reformed 

Church. 123. 
Bloomingdale Road, 8. 
Bloomingdale Square, 124. 
Blue Bell Tavern, 161. 
Blythe, 196. 

Board of Education Building, 120. 
Bodine's Inn, 333. 
Bogardus, Dominie, House, 20. 
Bogardus, Dominie, Farm, 77. 
Bone Alley, 92. 
Booth's Theatre, 112. 
Borough Hall, Brooklyn, 242. 
Borough Hall, Richmond, 327- 
Boston Post Road, :i72, 181. 
Botanical Gardens, 201, 400. 
Botanical Museum, 201, 400. 
Bouwerie House, 91. 
Bouwerie Lane, 7, 95. 
Bouwerie Village, 89. 
Bowery Bay, 279. 
Bowery Cemetery, 314. ^ 

Bowery Graveyard, 91. 
Bowery, The, 95. 
Bowery Theatre, 97. 
Bowery \'illage Church, 373. 
Bowling Green, 3, 17. 
Bowne Homestead, Flushing, 306. 
Bowne Houses, 207, 215, 309. 
Bowne Store, 207. 
Bozzaris, Marco, Rock, 157. 
Bradford. William, 30. 
Bradley Farm House, 154. 
Brannon Garden, 76. 
Brettoniere House, 302. 
Brevoort House. 134. 
Brick Presbyterian Church, 57, 117. 
Bridewell, '^4. 
Bridge of Sighs, 98. 
Bridge Street, 31- 
Brielle Homestead, 314. 
Brigg's House, 201. 
Brightside, 198. 

British Battery, Flushing, 304. 
British Beacon, 304. 
British Camps, 170, 171, 291, 300, 

302, 344. 
British Earthworks, 154, 155. 
British Fort, 352. 

British Head(|uarters, 300, 324, 341, 
Britton House, 341. 
Britton Mill, 330. 
Broad Street, 6. 
Broadway, .S- 
Broderick House, 75;, 83. 
Bronck, Jonas, Home, 195. 
r.RONX BOROUGH, 176. 
Bronx, Historical Sketch, 176. 



Bronx Park, 201. 

Bronx River, 203. 

Bronxdale, 213. 

BROOKLYN, 225. 

Brooklyn Heights, 241. 

Brooklyn Institute, 245. 

Brower's Mill, 257. 

Bryant Park, 117. 

Bryant, William Cullen, Home, 107. 

Buckhorn Tavern, 112. 

Bull's Head Tavern, 59, 112, 373. 

Bull's Head Village, 112. 

Bunker Hill, 95. 

Burger's Sluice, 277. 

Burn's Coffee House, 1=;. 

Burr, Aaron, Homes, etc., 61, 62, 
.330. 

Burroughs Houses, 294, 301. 

Bushwick, 232-2 34. 

BUSTS AND STATUES: see Ap- 
pendix B, p. 377, and under proper 
names. 

Butler's Hotel, 333. 



Calamus Road, 288, 302. 

Calumet Hall, 157. 

Calvary Cemetery, 295. 

Calyer Homestead, 231. 

Camp Hill, 341. 

Camp of Laurel Hill, 155. 

Canarsie, 253. 

Canarsie Lane, 2.S1. 

Cannon Point, 133. 

Capske Rocks, 20. 

Carey Sisters' Home, no. 

Carll's Mill. 204. 

Carrigan House, 125. 

Cassanova Mansion, ig6. 

Casseltowne Manor, 329. 

Case's Crew, 288. 

Castle Bogardus, 281. 

Castle Garden, 33. 

Castle Hill, 203. 

Castle Stevens, 281. 

Castle Williams, 35, 38. 

Castletdn Hotel, 327. 

Cathedral of St. John the Divine, 

125. 

Catimut's Windmill, 65. 

Cato's Road House, 373. 

Cedar Grove Cemetery, 308. 

Cedar Point, 165. 

Cement House, 328. 

Cemetery, N. Y. City Marble, 92. 

Cemetery. N. Y. Marble, 92. 

Central Bridge, 187. 

Central Park, 119, 120, 145. 

"Century" House, 170. 

Chamber of Commerce, 26, 28, 61. 

Chambers Street, 55. 

Chapel of St. Cornelius, 35. 

Chateauneuf Residence, 193. 

Chatham Garden, 6=;. 

Chatham Square, 95, 97. 

Chelsea Cottages, 116. 

Cherry Garden, 64. 

Cherry Hill, 64. 



410 



INDEX 



Cherry Lane, ig6. 

Cherry Street, 64. 

Clielsea, 115. 

Chelsea Square, 116. 

Children's Museum, Brooklyn, 245. 

Christopher Homestead, 333. 

Christopher Street Square, 82. 

Christ's Church. 66. 

Churches, see under name of. 

Citizen Genet, Seat of, 313. 

City Hall, Dutch, 19, 30. 

City Hall, English, 26. 

City Hall, Present, 53. 

City Island, 209. 

City Library, 53. 

Claremont. The, 127. 

Classen's Point, 203, 204. 

Cleopatra's Xeedle, 120. 

Clermont Terrace, 298. 

Clinch Homestead, 339. . 

Clinton, DeWitt, House, 'Sjj' 287. 

Clinton, DeWitt Statues, 21, 61. 

Clinton Hall, 93. ■ .' 

Cobweb Hall, 98. 

Cock Hill. 172. 

Coe Farm House, 294. 

Coenties Alley and Slip, 30. 

Coe's Mill, 294. 

Coffee House, Rums', is- 

Coffee House, Merchants', 29. 

Coffee House Slip, 29. 

Coffee House, Tontine, ig. 

Cold Spring, 172. 

Colden Estate, 308. 

Cole House. 34-- 

Coleman's Point, 329. 

Collect Pond, 78, 95- 

College Place, sg. 

College Point, 275. 

College of the City of New York, 

112, i^;!. i?.3- 

Collegiate Dutch Reformed Church. 

61, 119. 
Collegiate School, 122. 
Collins House, 21 1. 
Colonial Hall, Jamaica, 312. 
Colonnade Row, 93- 
Columbia College, 1^9. nQ. 125. 
Columbia Heiglits, 241. 
Columbus Memorial. 119- 
Columbus Park, '102. 
Commission of 1807. Q- 
Common Field. Middleburg, 293. 
Company's Farm, 8. 
Coney Island, 261. 
Conkling, Roscoe, Statue, m. 
Conselyea House, 234. , „ 

Cooper, Peter, Houses and Factory, 

113. 232, 233. 
Cooper, Peter, Statue. .93. 
Cooper Union, 93. loi. 
Corbin, Margaret, 161, 167. 
Corlear's Hook Park, 99. 
Cornelissen, Peter, Mill, 292. 
Corner House, Newtown. 301. 
Corona. 293. 

Cbrona Avenue. 294- 

Corpus Christi Monastery, 196. 



Corsen House, 330. 334. 351. 
Corsen-Ives House. 333. 
Cortelyou Houses. 258! 341. 345. 
Cortelyou-Vanderveer House, 248. 
Cortlandt's I'pper House. i8s. 
County Clerk's Office, Richmond, 

344. 
County C ourt House, s."?. 
Court House, Jamaica, 312. 
Couwenhovcn House. 260. 
Cowboy Oak, 183, i8s. 
Cox. Samuel S., Statiic, 93. 
Cox's Tavern. 181. 
Crab Island, 154. 
Crawford Tavern, 215. 
Crocheron Houses, 334. 
Cromwell F"arm Houses, 187, 201. 
Croton .Aqueduct, 117. 
Crowther Homestead. 213. 
Cross Keys Tavern. 153. 
Cruger Mansion, 107. 
Cubberly House, 342. 
Cuckoldstowne, 343, 344. 
Cumberson House, U'oodside. 292. 
Curtis, Cicorge William, House, 329. 
Curtis High School. 327. 
Custom liouse, 3. 19. 29. 
Cuyltr Sugar House. 65. 



Banner's Hotel, 330. 

Day's Tavern, 126. 

Death Gap, 161. 

Debevoise Homesteads. 234, 288. 

Decker House, 330. 

DeGroot House. 329. 

Dell art House. 331. 

Dellart- Bergen House, 257. 

Delancey P.iockliouse, 213. 

Delancey House. 60. 

Delancey Pine. 213. 

Delancey Stiuare. g.s. 

Delancey Street, g.s. 

Demilt Avenue, i93- 

Delmonico Building. 2^2. 

Denton's Mill, 2S7. 

Denyse's I'crry. 258. 

DePeyster. .\braliam, 17. 62. 

DeSille House, 259. 

Devil's Stepping Stones. 210. 

Devoe Cottage. 189. 

Devoe House. Busiiwick. 234 

I)cvoe's Point. 187. 

De \'oor l-arni House. I34- 

DeWitt Clinton High Scliool. 107. 

DeWitt Clinton House. 2S7, JU. 

DeVVitt Clinton Park. 121. 
Diamond Reef. 2.s8. 
Dircksen \Olckert, Home. 231. 
Disosway House. 35^. 
Ditniars Houses, .-84. 3>3. 
Ditmas Houses. 248. 
Dolan's Restaurant. S7. 
l)oniinie's Hook. 277. 
Donck's Colony. 182. 
Dongan Hills. 339- 



411 



INDEX 



Dongan House, 329. 

Dongan Plantation. 308. 

Dongan's Distillery, 351. 

Doughty, Rev. Francis, House, 280. 

Drake, Joseph Rodman, 177, 196. 

Drake's Park, 196, 197- 

Drover's Inn, S9. 212. 

Dubois House, 328, 330. 

Duke's Plan, 7. 

Duke's Woods, Jamaica, 313- 

Duryea Houses, 254, 292, 308. 

Duryea Mill, 313. 

Dviryee House, 231. 

Dutch Garden, Van Cortlandt Park, 

181. 
Dutch Kills, 2Tr,. 
Dutch Reformed Church, Brooklyn, 

First, 231. 
Dutch Reformed Church, Bushwick, 

232. 
Dutch Reformed Church. Hallett's 

Cove, 283; Harlem, 147. 
Dutch Reformed Church. New 

Utrecht. 2.'?g. 
Dutch Reformed Church. Newtown, 

299. 
Dutch Reformed Church, Port Rich- 
mond, 330. 
Dutch Reformed Church, Richmond, 

344. 
Dutch Reformed Church, South. 32. 
Dvitch Reformed Church, Tompkins- 

ville. 335. 
Dyckman House, 170, 172. 



Eastern Hotel, 37. 

Eastchester Village, 214. 

East New York, 253, 255. 

Edgar Street, 22. 

Egbertville Academy, 343. 

Elevated Railroad, 59. 

Elgin Botanical Garden, 119. 

Ellis Island, 3s. 

Elm Tree Beacon, 342. 

Elm Tree Light, 339. 

Elmhurst, 297. 

Emans House. 262. 

Emerson Hill. 339. 

Erasmus Hall High School, 247. 

Ericsson, John, 78. 

Ericsson. John. Memorial, 33. 

Erie Canal, 53, 78, 121. 

Essex Market. 99. 

Exchange Alley, 22. 



Farmer's Bridge, 169. 

Farragut, Admiral, Memorial, iii. 

Fashion Race Course, 293. 

Featherbed Lane. 187, 288. 

Federal Hall, 61. 

Ferris Houses, 204, 205. 

Ferris Point, 204. 

Ferry Village, 22<5. 

Field, Jacob. House, 303. 

Fifth Avenue Hotel, 112. 

Fireman's Hall, d?,. 



Fire of 1835, Tablet, 30. 

Fire Tower, 147. 

First Presbyterian Church, 26. 108. 

Fish. Hamilton, Birthplace, 89. 

Fish's Mill, 280. 

Fish's Store, 292. 

Fish's Tavern, Newtown, 301. 

Five Points, The, 98. 

Fitzroy Road, tz, hS- 

Flatbush, 247. 

Flatlands, 249, 251, 2()'^. 

Flatlands Neck, 251. 

Flushing, 274, 297, 304. 

Fly Brook. 283. 

Fly Market. 62. 

Font Hill, 184. 

Fordham, 199. 

Fordham Lane, 212. 

Fordham Manor, 170. 

Fordham Manor Dutch Reformed 

Church, 190. 
Fordham University, 201. 
Forrest, Edwin, Former Home, 116, 

184. 
Forsyth Street Methodist Church, 97. 
Fort Amsterdam, 3, 19. 
Fort Clinton, 146, 155. 
Fort Columbus, 35. 
Fort Diamond, 2s8. 
Fort Decker, 330. 
Fort Fish, 146. 
Fort Gansevoort, 73. 
Fort George, 19, 155. 
Fort Greene Park, 243. 
Fort Hamilton, 258, 309. 
Fort Hill, 2,2-7. 
Fort Horn, 126. 
Fort Independence, 169, igo. 
Fort Jay, 35. 
Fort Knyphausen, 164. 
Fort Lafayette, 2558. 
Fort Laight, 126. 
Fort Lee, 131, 165. 
Fort Nos. I, 2 and 3, 183, 185. 
Fort Nos. 4, s and 6, 190. 
Fort Nos. 7 and 8, 189. 
Fort Orange, 371. 
Fort Prince Charles, 169. 
Fort Putnam, 243. 
Fort Schuyler, 204. 
Fort Tompkins. 338. 
Fort Tryon. 167. 
Fort Wadsworth, 338. 
Fort Washington, 161. 164. 
Fort Washington Point, 165. 
Fountain, City Hall Park, 55. 
Fountain Houses, 329, 338, 341. 
Fountain and Light Tower, 173, 
Fowler Mansion, 214. 
Fox Corners, 197. 
Fox, George, Mansion, 196. 
Fox Oaks, Flushing, 306. 
Foxhurst Mansion. 197. 
Francis Mansion, 187. 
Frankfort Street, .S7- 
Franklin, Walter, Home, Tablet. 64. 
Franklin, Benjamin, Statues of, 57, 

378. 



412 



INDEX 



Fraunces Tavern, 30, 41-47. 

Free Bridge, 169. 

Free School, First, 55, 97. 

Free School Society, 102. 

Freek's Mill, 257. 

French Academy, i.S4. 

French Church du St. Esprit, 61. 

Fresh Kills, 34s. 

Fresh Meadow Road, Flushing:, 304. 

Fresh Meadow Tract, 308. 

Fresh Pond. Maspeth, 288. 

Friends' Meeting Houses, 61, 91, 

303, 305- 
Fulton, Robert, 15. 
Fulton, Robert, Tablet, 25. 
Fulton, Robert, Water Gate, 139,389- 
Furman Houses, 287, 295. 
Furman's Island, 287. 
Furmansville Road, 29.";. 
Furniss House. 123. 



Gansevoort Market. 8. 73. 

Garibaldi House, 337- 

Garretson Houses, 307, 316, 339, 

349- 
George III, Statue, 17. 
Georgi House, 212. 
General Fort. Eastchester, 214. 
General Theological Seminary, 116. 
German Reformed Church, 135. 
Gerritsen Tide Mill, 250. 
Ghetto, The, 99- 
GifFord House, 341. 
Glover's Rock, 209. 
Goflfe House, 316. 
Golden Hill Inn, 62. 
Golden Hill Battle, Tablet, 63, 67. 
Government House, 19- 
Governor's Gartlen, 57. 
Governor's Island, 34- 
Governor's Room. City Hall, 53- 
Gowanus Canal, Creek, 257. 
Grace Court Spring, 241- 
Grace Episcopal Church, 23, io9- 
Grace Episcopal Church, nronklyn, 

Grace' Episcopal Church. Jamaica, 

312. 
Gracie House, i35- 
Gramercy Park, 1 10. 
Grant's Tornb, 126. 
"Grapevine," 108. 
Gravesend, 261. 
"Great Flat," 249- 
Great Kill, 121. 147- 
Great Road. -JT,, nS- 
Great Maize Land. 161. 
Great Mill Rock. 281. 
Greeley, Horace, 57. no. >33- 
Green Lane. 67. 
Greenpoint. 229. 
Greenridge, 345- 
Greenwich Avenue, 73- 
Greenwich Hotel. 7.S. 
Greenwich Street, 8, 15. 
Greenwich Village. 8. 71- 
Greenwood Cemetery, 257- 



Greenwood House. Jamaica, 313. 
Groshon House. 214. 
Grote House. 343. 
Grove .Street Scllool. 7.C;. 
Guion Tavern. 215. 
Gutenberg Statue, 99, 378. 
Guyon-Clarke House, 342. 

Hadley House, 184. 

Hale, .\athan. Statue of, 54. 

Hall of l-'ame, 183. 189. ' 

Hall of Records, 55. 

Hallctt Hurying Ground, 283. 

Halktt Houses, 278, 281, 283. 

Halktt's Cove, 281. 

Hallctt's Lane, 283. 

Hallett's Point, 281. 

Hamilton, Alexander, Bust, 124. 

Hamilton, Alexander, Country Seat. 

I Si- 
Hamilton, Alexander, House where 

He Died. 73- 
Ilamilton, Alexander. Law Office, 28. 
Hamilton. .Alexander. Statue, 61. 
Hamilton Fish Park, 92. 
Hamilton Free School, 173. 
Hamilton Grange, 151. 
Hamilton Hall, Flushing, 30s. 
Hammer Hotel, 212. 
Hammond Castle. 205. 
Hanover Square, 30. 
Harlem Creek, 147. 
Harlem Heights. Hattic, 129. 
Harlem Lane. 14.S. 
Harrison House, 330. 
Harscnville. 121, 124. 
Hart's Island. 210. 
Hastings, Town of, 27 S- 
Havemeyer Estate. 20.S- 
Havens House, 191. 
llays House. 167. 
Hazard Homestead. 202. 
Health Ofticcr's Resi.lcncc. Old, 33.S 
Heemstede. 27 S- 
Heere Gracht. 3'- 
H.ll Gate. I3^>. -'81. 
Hell Gate Bay, 149. 
Hemlock C.rnve, 201. 
Hempstead Swamp. 296. 
Henricus .\gricola. 279. 
Hermitage. I he. igi. 
Hessian Spring. 164. 
Hessian Springs. 327. 
Higli Hridge. 1 .";4. 
Hicks-natt House. 262. 
Hicksville ij^. 

Ili-;iaiiic Society of ,\mcnra. is.l- 
HISTORIC TREES. ROCKS, etc.. 

Hoc" H<»uses: Brightsidc. igS; Sun 

nyside. 106. 
Hoffman lUnilrvard. 302. 
Hoffman Islaiul, 347. 
Holland's IVrrv. 17". 
Holland's Hook. 33>- 
Hollis HeiKhts. 3«6- 
HoUow Way. 127. "39. »39- 



413 



INDEX 



Holy Nativity Church, 191. 

Holy Spring House 345- 

Holyrood Church, 161. 

Hopper, Yalless, House, 135. 

Horn. John, House, 112. 

Horn's Hook, 135. 

Horse Brook, Newtown, 297, 300. 

Horse Mill, 31- 

Horticultural Hall, 201. 

Horton Homestead, 209. 

Hotel Astor. 121. 

Hotel Gruetli, 22. 

Hotel Nethcrland, Paintings in, 120. 

Hotel Raleigh, 100. 

House by the Mill, 345- 

House of Lords, 102. 

House of Refuge, Old, 113. 

Housman House, 331. 

Howard Farm House, Newtown, 300. 

Howard's Half-way House, 255. 

Howe, Sir William, Headquarters, 

302. 
Howe, Sir William, Intrenchments, 

197- 
Hudson Park, ^d. 
Hudson Monument, 183. 
Huguenot Church, 345. 
Humock Island, 168. 
Hunt Burying Ground, 196, 
Hunt Houses, 197, 212, 302. 
Hunt Inn, 197. 
Hunter-Iselin Mansion, 210, 
Hunter's Island, 210. 
Hunter's Point, 275, 27T. 
Huntington, C. P., Home, 205. 
Hunt's Point, 197, 203. 
Hustace House, 191- 
Hutchinson, Ann, Early Home, 211. 
Hutchinson River Bridge, 211. 
Hyatt's Tavern, 169. 



Indian Brook. 207. 

Indian Burying Ground, 209, 3"?! 

347- 
Indian Ceremonial Pits, 170, 171. 

174- 
Indian Field, 182. 
Indian Fortifications, 214. 
Indian Hiding Place, 214. 
Indian Hunting Ground, 172. 
Indian Rock Dwelling, 172. 
Indian Shell Heaps, 170. 
Indian Trail, 147. 
Indian Village, 171, 213. 
Indian Well, 201. 
Inwood Hill, 174. 
Iron Hill, 339. 

Irving, Washington, 62, 109, 117. 
Isham Mansion, 174. 
Isham Park, 173. 



Jack-Knife. The. 62. 
Jackson Mansion, 291. 
Jackson's Mill-Pond, 280. 
Jacques House, 330. 



Jacobsen-Vanderbilt House, 342. 

Jaeger Camp, \%^. 

Jamaica, 274, 310. 

Jans, Anneke, Farm, 77, 78. 

Japanese Trees, Riverside Drive, 139. 

Jay, John, Statue, 61. 

Jefferson Market, 82. 

Jefferson, Thon:as, N. Y. Home, 61. 

Jeffrey's Hook, i6s. 

Jennings Homestead, 212. 

Jerome Park Reservoir, 190. 

Jessnp House, ig6, 301. 

Jewish Cemeteries, 97, 108, 112. 

John Street M. E. Church, 62. 

John Street Theatre, 62. 

Johnson Farmhouse, 349. 

Johnson's Tavern, 213. 

Joncker's Island, 293. 

Jones Chapel, 134- 

Jones, Humphrey. House, 123. 

Jones Wood, 134. 

Journeay House, 347. 

Jumel Mansion, 153, 156-159. 

Kalch Hoek, 78, 
Kennedy House, The, 15. 
Keteltas Mansion, 48a, loi. 
Kidd, Capt., Home of, 30. 
Kieft's Tavern, 30. 
King Mansion, Jamaica, 312. 
King Park, 312. 
King's Arms Tavern, 15. 
King's Bridge, 168. 
King's Bridge Farm, 190. 
King's College, 59. 
King's Farm, 7. 
King's Highway, 249. 
Kingsbridge; 181. 
Kingsbridge Road, g, 174. 
Kip's Bay, 133. 
Kip's Mill, 280. 

Kissing Bridge, 97, 196, 372, 373. 
Knickerbocker Cottage, 114. 
Kouwenhoven Houses, 251, 263, 279, 
. 285. 

Kreischerville, 349. 
Kreuzer-Pelton House, 328. 
Kruse, Hugo E. Memorial, 315. 



La Blant House. 334. 

Labon's Inn, 243. 

Labor Temple, 10 1. 

Lafayette Lane. 196. 

Lafayette, Statue, 107. 

Lafayette, Portrait, 53. 

La Grange Terrace, 93. 

Lake-Croak House, 331. 

Lake House, 262, 341. 

Lake Tysen House, 342. 

Land Poort (Gate). 26. 

Latourette House, 344- 

Laura Keene's Theatre, 100. 

Laurel Hill, i.s.s- 

Lawrence Burial Ground, Steinway, 

285. 
Lawrence Farm Houses, 184, 284, 

304, 308, 309. 



414 



INDEX 



Lawrence Lane, 28.^. 

Lefferts Homestead, 247. 

Legg:etf Burying Ground, ig6. 

LegRett's Lane, iq6. 

Lenox Farm, i.-^g. 

Lenox Library, i.^g. 

Lent Farm House. Corona, 293. 

Leverich Burial Ground. Steiiiway. 

28c;. 
Leverich Home, 2Q2. 
Lewis, Francis. Tablet, .307. 
Libby Castle. 167. 
Liberty Place, 66. 
Liberty Pole, Flushing, 316. 
Liberty Pole, New Utrecht, 260, 265. 
Liberty Pole Tablet, 54. 
Limerick, Earl of. Plantation, 308. 
Lincoln, Statue, 107. 
Linden Park, 315. 
Linnsan Botanic Garden, 304. 
Linoleumville, 334. 
Lispenard's Meadows. 8, 77. 
Little Church Afound the Corner. 

Little Collect, gq. 

Little Commons, Newtown, 299. 

Little Hell Gate. 137. 

Little Mill Rock, 281. 

Livingscton Sugar House, 61. 

Lockman House, 342. 

Locusts, The. ig6. 

Lodowick's Brook. 27g. 

London Terrace, 116. 

Longacre Square. 121. 

Long Lsland, Battle of, 22?;. 

Long Island City, incorporation, 275. 

Long Island History, 226. 

Long Island Historical Society, 242. 

Long Island Neck, 3.3.3. 

Long Travnes Meadow, 27g. 

Lookout Hill. 246. 

Lord Howe Chesnut. 211. 

Lorelei Monument and Fountain, 

202. 
Lorillard Falls. 201. 
Lorillard, Jacob, House, igg. 
Lorillard Mansion Museum. 201, 

202. 
Lorillard Snuff Mill. 202. 
Lott Houses, 248, 24g, 254. 
Love Lane. 1 1 S- 
Loveioy's Hotel, s^. 
Lowell, J. S.. Memorial, 139. 
Lubbert's Swamp, 278. 
Ludlow Mansion, 204. 
Ludlow House. Newtown, 300. 
Ludlow Street Jail, gg. 
Lutheran Church, 23. 
Lydig's Mills, 213. 



McComb Mansion. 21. 
McGown's Pass Tavern, 145. 
McKesson Jlomestead, 215. 
McKinley Square, 212. 
Macedonia Hotel. 210. 
Macomb Mansion, 181. 



Madison Cottage, i 12. 

Madison S(iuare, gs, 1 1 1. 

Madison Square Garden, iii. 

Maiden Lane. 7, 61. 

"Maine" Relic, 315. 

"Maine" Monument, National, 120. 

Manhattan Company Bank, q8. 

Manhattan Water Tank, The. gS. 

Manhattanvillc. 127. 

Manning's Island, 136. 

Manor House, Bushwick. 234. 

Mapes. Uncle Daniel. Temperance 
House, 213. 

Marble Arcli. i6g. 

iSIarble Collegiate Reformed Church, 
I 14. 

Marble House, 327. 

Marble Hill. .68. 

Mariners' Temple, qy. 

Marketfield Street, i.s, 21. 

Marshall Mansion, 209. 

Marshland. 345. 

Martyr's Tomb. 243. 

Maryland Monument. 246, 265. 

Maspeth, 287. 

Maurice Woods. The. 288. 

Meal Market. 2g. 

Meeting and Sessions House. Ja- 
maica. 311. 

Melrose Hall, 247. 

Merchant's Bank. 28. 

Merchant's Coffee House, 28. 29. 

Merchant's Kxchange. jg. 30. 

Mersereau Mouse. 333. 

Mersereau N'alley. 339. 

Meserole I'amilv. 229. 

^Icsero!e Homestead. 231. 

Mespatkill. 274. 

Messiaii Home for Cliildrrn, 183. 

Methodist Church. lohii Street. 62. 

Methodist Church, Middle NillaRc. 
29S. 

Methodist Cliurch. Sands Street, 
Brooklyn. 24 •• 

Methodist Church. Second M. K.. o». 

Metliodist Church, Seventh Street 
g2. 

Metropolitan Museum of Art, 120. 

Metropolitan Temi>lc, 107. 

I\Ietroi»olitan Opera House, First, 
100. 

Mi.idleburR. 274. 297. 

Middle Dutch Church. 61. 91. 

Middhlcwn H.imlet. 278. 
MiddUtown \ illanc. 295. 

Middle Nillage. 29.S. 

Midwout. 247. 

MILFSTOXKS. Apix-ndix A. p. 37«. 

Milestone, First. 07. 

Milestone, Second, gi. 

Milestone. Fourth. 133. 

Milest(»ne. Fifth. 133. 

Milestone. Ninth, isi. 

Milestone. Tenth, 212. 

Milestone. Kicventh. 159. «o«- 
Milestone. Twelfth. 169. 

Milestone. Fifteenth. 184. 213. 
Milestones. Bronx, 374- 



415 



INDEX 



Milestones, Brooklyn, 250, 260, 265, 

374- 
Milestones, Richmond, 327. 374. 
Milestones, Queens, 291, 374- 
Mill Brook, 212. 
Mill Camp, 147. 
Mill Creek, 147. 
Mill Lane, 31. 214. 
Mill Rock, 136. 
Mile Square Road, 182. 
Milligan Place. 108. 
Mill Stones, 31, 314. 406. 
Minetta Brook. 8. 71- 
Minetta Street, 81. 
Minniesland, Home of Audubon, 153- 
Minto Farm, 328. 
Mitchell House. Flushing, 306. 
Monnot Mansion, 204. 
Monroe, Tames, Death Place, 100. 
Montaerne's Creek, 147- 
Montague's Point, i47- 
Montgomery Cottage, 190. 
Montresor's Island, 137. 
Monument Lane. 80. 
MONUMENTS: see Appendix B, p. 

377. 
Moore Houses, 115, 161, 278, 291, 

297. 393- 
Moravian Cemetery. 339. 
Morgan Residence. 214. 
Morningside Heights, 125. 
Morosini Mansion. 184- 
Morris, Clara, Home of, 184. 
Morris High School, igS- 
Morris Houses, Morrisania, 183, i9!i. 

199, 202. 
Morris, Roger, Mansion, 153, 156. 
Morris Street, 17. 
Morrisania, i99- 
Morse, S. F., Tablet, 112. 
Morton Homes, 19, 76. 
Mosholu, 183. 

Mott Burying Ground, Maspeth, 287. 
Mott Homestead, 121. 
Mott House, 315. 
Mott Mansion, ig"?. 
Mott Memorial Dutch Reformed 

Church, 195, 198. 
Mount Morris Park, 147. 
Mt. Napoleon. 281. 
Mt. Tompkins, 335. 
Mt. Washington Presbyterian 

Church. 173- 
Mt. Zion Cemetery, 288. 
Mouquin's Restaurant, 114. 
Mulberry Bend Park. 98. 
Municipal Building, 65. 
Murray Hill. 117, 309. 
Murray Houses, 309- 
Muscoota, 147. 
MUSEUMS: see Appendix D, p. 395- 



National Arts Club, no. 
National Maine Monument. 120. 
Narrow Passage, 291. 
Narrows, The. 2518. 
Nautilus Hall, 335- 



Navy Yard. 23.S, 243-244. 

Neck Road. 262. 

Negro Burying Ground, Bronx. 197. 

Negro Burying Ground, Newtown, 

299- 
Negro Burying Ground Site, 170. 
Neutral Ground, 176, 
Neville House. 328. 
New Amsterdam Theatre, Painting 

in, 139- 
New Blazing Star, 334. 
New Dorp, 339. 
New Lots. 253. 2<,4. 
New Springville, 333. 
New Street. 21. 
New Utrecht, 2.S9, 260. 
New York Bank. 28. 
New York City Marble Cemetery, 92. 
New York Gazette, Tablet, 30. 
New York Genealogical and Bio- 
graphical Society, 120. 
New York Historical Society, 26, 91, 

120. 
New York Hotel, 102. 
New York Marble Cemetery. 92. 
New York Public Library. 117, 398. 
New York Society Library, 109, 400. 
New York State Prison, 75. 
New York Stock Exchange, 32. 
New York L^niversity Bridge, 170. 
New York University Building 

(Old). 80. 
New York University Buildings 

(New), 189. 
Newtown. 274. 297 et seq. 
Niblo's Garden and Theatre. 100. 
Nieuw Amersfoot, 249. 
Nieuw Haerlem. 147. 
Nipnichsen, Indian Village of, 172* 

185. 
Nolan House, 347- 
Nolan's Hotel, 201. 
North Beach. 279. 
North Brother Island, 203. 
North Dutch Church. 63. 
North Fort, 79- 
Northern Dispensary. 82. 
Nostrand House, 2.=;9. 
Nottston. 277. 
Numismatic Society. Museum of, 

i.=;3. 
Nutter's Battery, 146. 



Oak Villa. 123. 

Oakley House, 347. 

Odell's Barns, 214. 

Odellville. 133. 

Ogden Mansion. 2x1. 

Old Bowery Road, 278. 

Old Brewery, 98. 

Old Broadway, 151. 

Old Brook School-house, 288, 

Old Mill, 2=53, 344. 

Old Mill Village, 2<;3. 

Old Place Mill, 331. 

Old Point Comfort Inn, 



214. 
Old Stone Gate House, 199- 



416 



INDEX 



I 



Old Stone Jur, 212. 

Old Tabernacle, 349. 

Old Wreck Brook, 21, 6?;, 97. 

Oliver Street Baptist Church, 97. 

Oude Dorp, 32.1;. 

Out Plantations, The, 274, 275. 

Oyster Island, 35. 

Oyster Market, 73. 



Paine, Thomas, Home, 81. 

Paisley Place, 107. 

Parade Ground, The, iii, 182, 

Paradise Park, 98. 

Park Avenue Tunnel, 117. 

Parker-Clausen House, 342. 

Park Theatre, S7. 

Parsonage Farm House, Newtown, 
303. 

Parsonage Lot, Jamaica. 310. 

Patten House, 341. 

Patti, Adelina, Home, 193. 

Paul House, 20.";. 

Pavilion Hill, 335- 

Pavilion Hotel, 327- 

Pavonia, 324. 

Paynter House, 277. 314. 

Pearl Street, 5. 20, 30, 31. 62. 

Peck House, 253. 

Pelham Bridge 21.";. 

Pell Family Burying Ground, 210. 

Pell Houses. 210. 211. 

Pell Point. Battle. 176. 

Pell Treaty Oak, 210. 

Penfield Homestead, 193- 

Pentecostal Tabernacle. 228. 

Pero-Christopher House, 333- 

Perrine Homestead, 339- 

Peter Cooper Tenements, 233. 

Petticoat Lane, 21. 

Pettit's Hotel. Jamaica, 316. 

Piewoman's Lane, 26. 

Pitt. William. Statue of, 28. 

Planter's Hotel, 66, 335. 

Player's Clubhouse, no. 

Pleasant Avenue. 149. 

Plymouth Church, 241. 

Foe, Edgar Allan, Homes, 83, 123, 
176, 201. 

Poe Park 201. 

Point of Rocks, 126. 

Police Court. 9Q. 

Pompeian Columns, 32. 

Poole. Townsend, Cottage. 189. 

Poor Bowery, The, 279. 

Port Morris, 196, 203. 

Port Richmond, 330. 

Port Richmond Hotel, 330. 

Porter, Gen. Josiah, Statue, 182. 

Post House, 3.31. 

Post Office, 54. 55, 61. 

POST ROADS, 55, i45. 3i7. Ap- 
pendix A. p. 371- 

Post's Tavern, 165. 

Pot Cove. 281. 

Potter's Field, 210. 

Powell Farm House, 199. 



Spring Street, 
Farms, 



Praa, Peter, House, 231. 

Presbyterian Church, Astoria. 28 1. 

Presbyterian Church, Brick. 57, 117. 

Presbyterian Church, First (Manhat 
tan), 26. 108. 

Presbyterian Church, Jamaica, 312. 

Presbyterian (hurch. Newtown,' 302, 

Presbyterian Church, Second Ave- 
nue, lOI. 

Presbyterian Church, 
76. 

Presbyterian Church, West 
213. 

Prime House, 135. 

Prince Mansion. Flushing, 305. 

Prince's Nursery, 304. 

Prison Ships. Revolutionary, 244. 

Progress Hall, 330. 

Prospect Hill Avenue. 211. 

Prospect Park, 245. 

Public Schools: 97, 102. 242. 

Public School 52, Manhattan, 173 

Pudding Rock. 212. 

Punta Rossa House, :i7. 

Purdy Houses, 213, 291. 

Purdy's Hotel, 350. 

Purdy's National Theatre, 97. 



Quaker Meeting House, Flushing, 
'305. 
Quaker Meeting Houses, Manhattan, 

61, 91. 
Quaker Meeting House, Newtown, 

303. 
Quarantine Ferry Landing. 335. 
Quarantine Station. 337. 
QUEENS BOROUGH, 274. 
Queen Cliarlotte Tavern. 43. 
Oueensboro Bridge. 227. 
Queen's Farm, 8. 
Queen's Head Tavern, 287. 
Quiet Dale, 147. 



Randall's Island, 137. 

Rapalye Houses, 254. 265. 279, 280, 

285. 292, 2Q3. 294- 
Rattlesnake Brook, 214. 
Rattlesnake Spring. 292. 
Ravenswood, 281. 
Reason Street. 81. 
Reedcr House, 300. 
Reformed Dutch Churches: see 

Dutch Reformed, etc. 
Reid's Mill. 214. 
Reniscn Burying Ground. 296. 
Remscn House. 241. 
Renne. Samuel. House, 30a. 
Republican Club, 139. 
Revolutionary Cannon, 21,38.62,64. 

139. 146. 
Revolutionary Earthworks, 146. i5S. 

164. 165. 167. 
Rhineiandcr Sugar House, 6s. 102. 
Richardson House. J9b- 
Richmond. 343. 



417 



INDEX 



Richmond County Court House, 344. 

Richmond Hill Mansion, 76, 

Richmond Terrace, .329. 

Richmond Valley, 349. 

RICHMOx\D BOROUGH, 325. 

Ridgeway House, 334. 

Riker Houses, 279, 291. 

Road from the Ferry, Maspeth, 287. 

Roiierts Homestead, 20.S. 

Robinson, Morris, Tablet, 29. 

Rocking Stone, The, 202. 

Rocky Hill Road, Flushing, 304. 

ROCKS AND TREES, HISTORIC, 
403. 

Rodman Mansion, 211. 

Roman Catholic Church, St. Peter's, 
r,g, 116. 

Roman Catholic Church of Trans- 
figuration, 98. 

Roman Catholic Orphan Asylum, 
190. 

Roosevelt Street. 6.=;. 

Roosevelt, Theodore, Birthplace, 110. 

Rose and Crown House, 341. 

Rose Hill Farm, 112. 

Rose Hill Manor. 201. 

Rossville, 347. 

Rotunda, The, 55- 

Rustdorp, 310. 

Rutger's Mansion, 78. 

Rutherford Mansion. loi. 

Ryder's Alley, 63. 

Ryder Houses, 250. 

Ryder Lane, 25;o. 

Ryerson's Mill, 277, 314. 



Sackett House, 293. 

Sailor's Snug Harbor, 328. 

St. Alphonsus' Church, 78. 

St. Andrew's Church, Richmond, 343- 

St. Ann's Episcopal Church, 195. 
198. 

St. Ann's Hall, Flushing, 307. 

St. Anthony's R. C. Church, Origi- 
nal, 211. 

St. Clement's Church, 81. 

St. Cornelius, Chapel of, 35. 

St. Esprit, du. Church, 61, 113. 

St. Francis Xavier, College of, 107. 

St. George, 327. 

St. George Building, 63. 

St. George's Church, 91, loi. 

St. George's Episcopal Church, As- 
toria, 283. 

St. George Episcopal Church, Flush- 
ing, 307. 

St. James Episcopal Church, New- 

St. James Episcopal Church, New- 
town, 300. 

St. James Hotel, Port Richmond, 330. 

St. James Pro-Cathedral, 242. 

St. John the Divine, Cathedral, 125. 

St. John's Cemetery, 76, 295. 

St. John's Chapel, 78. 

St. John's College, 201. 

St. John's Lane, 78. 

St. John's Lutheran Church, 81. 



St. John's Lutheran Church, New 

Utrecht, 259. 
St. John's Park. 78. 
St. Joseph's Academy, 307. 
St. Luke's Chapel, 75. 
St. Mark's Hotel. 327. 

St. Mark's-in-the-Bowery Church, 89. 

St. Mary's R. C. Church, 99. 

St. Michael's Episcopal Church, 123. 

St. Nicholas Church, 19. 
St. Ronan's Well. 293. 

St. Patrick's Cathedral, 119. 

St. Patrick's R. C. Church. 100. 

St. Paul's Chapel. s8. 

St. Paul's Church, Eastchester, 214. 

St. Paul's Churchyard, 21.S. 

St. Peter's R. C. Church, S9, 116. 

St. Peter's R. C. Church. Westches- 
ter, 207. 

St. Peter's Rectory, Westchester, 207. 

St. Thomas Hall, Flushing, 307. 

Samler House, 184- 

Sands Land, 99- 

Sanford Hall, Flushing, 307. 

Santa Anna, Gen., Residence, 330. 

Sappokanican, 8, 71. 

Saw Mill Brook, 212. 

Schenck-Crooke House, 249. 

Schenck House, Canarsie, 253, 254, 
264, 265. 

Schermerhorn Farm House, 134. 

Schermerhorn Mansion, 112. 

Schorakin, 149. 

Schreyer's Hoek, 20. 

Schurz, Carl, Memorial 140 

Scotch Presbyterian Church, 61. 

Scott-Edwards House, 329. 

Scott, Winfield, Mansion, 135. 

Screven's Point, 203. 

Sea and Land Church, 91. 

Seaman House, 345. 

Seaman's Retreat, 337. 

Seamen's Church Institute, 37, 38. 

Seguine House, 345. 

Seguine's Point. 347. 

Seton Cave, Falls, 214. 

Sevilla Home, 196. 

Seward Park, 99. 

Seward Statue, iii. 

Shakespeare Tavern, 63. 

Shell Road, Newtown, 288, 298. 

Sherman, W. T., Statue, 119. 

Sherman's Creek, 171. 

"Shoemaker's Pasture," 64. 

Shora-kapkok, 172. 

Shore Road Boulevard, 283. 

Shot Tower, Youle's, 134. 

Signs Road, 351. 

Simonson House, 334. 

Skillman House, 234. 

Skillman Avenue, 277. 

Skinner's Road, 73. 

Smith's Folly, 134. 

Smith's Island, 274, 287. 

Smith's Meadows, Newtown, 303. 

Smit's Vly, 61. 

Smoking Point, 347. 

Smuggler's Cave, 134. 



418 



INDEX 



Snake Hill, 147, 

Snedeker Houses, 253, 254, 264. 
Snuggery, Concord, 339. 
Soldiers' and Sailors' Memorial 

Arch, 245. 
Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument, 

1-23, 316. 
Soldiers' Monument, Flushing, 315, 

316. 
Somerindyke House, 122. 
Southampton Road, 73, 115. 
South Brother Island, 203. 
South INleadows, 295, 303. 
Spencer Mansion, 81. 
Split Rock, 21 1. 
Spring Garden, 59. 
Spring Hill Fstate, 308. 
Springsteen Homestead, 295. 
Spy House, 212. 
Spy Oak, The, 205. 
Stadt Huys, 30. 
State Street, 19, 37. 
State Mansion, 19. 
Staten Island, 324. 
Staten Island Association of Arts 

and Sciences, 327. 
STATUES. Appendix B. p. ztt. 
Statues in Prospect Park, 246. 
Steamship Row, 19. 
Steinvvay, 285. 
Stenton Residence, 201. 
Stepping Stones Light, 210. 
Steuben, Baron, Monument of, 135. 
Stevens House, 17, zi, 281. 
Stewart A. T., Grave of, 89. 
Stewart's Cafe, 57, 66. 
Stilwell House, 250, 2(^2. 
Stock Exchange, 32. 
Stone Street, 20. 
Stony Brook, 324. 339, 341. 
Strand, The, 20. 
Streets, Early. 5. 
Strickland's Tavern, 308. 
Striker Houses. 121, 248- 
Striker's Bav, 121. 
Stuyvesant Houses, 20, 89, 9i. 
Stuyevsant Pear Tree, 91. 
Stuyvesant Statue, 21. 
Stuyvesant Square, 91- 
Stuyvesant I'omb. 89. 
Sub-Treasury, 26. 
Suicide Slip. 78. 
Sun Building, 57- „ ,, 

Sunnyside, Home of Peter Hoe, 190. 
Sunset Lane, 165. 
Sunswick Creek, 283. 
Suydam, Dow, Homestead of, 296. 
Suydam's Mill, 283. 
Swamp, The, 64. 
Swan Hotel, 329- 
Swinburne Island, 347. 
Sylvan Place, i47- 



TABLETS: Appendix B, p. 377- 
Tallapoosa Club House, 215. 
Tam.many Hall, 57, 109. 
Tavern, Ye Olde. 66. 



Taylor, Bayard, Home of, 109. 

Teawater Pump, 97. 

Tetard, Uominie, Farm of, 190. 

'i lialia Theatre, 97. 

Thames Street, 60. 

Theatre Alley. 57. 

Thirteen Trees, 151, 193. 

Throgg's Neck, 203. 

Times Square, 139. 

Tin Pot Alley. 22. 

Tippett Mansion, 181, 185. 

Tilden, Samuel J., House, 110. 

Titus, Content, Houses, 294, 298. 

Titus' Mill, 294. 

Todt Hill, 339. 

Tombs, The. 98. 

Tompkins Farm House, 29.^. 

Tompkins, Gov. I). T., Tomb of, 89. 

Tontine Coffee House. 29. 

Totten Homcsttad, 287. 

Tottenville, 349. 

Tower P>ui]ding, 21. 

Townsend Castle, 337. 

Townsend, Henry, House of, Ja- 
maica, 313. 

Townsend Poole Cottage, 189. 

Track House, 342. 

Trains Meadow, 279. 

Transfiguration Church. 98. 

TREES, ROCKS, etc.. HISTORIC. 
403- 

Trinity Cemetery, 152. 

Trinity Church. 8, 23. 25. 

Trotting Course Lane, 295. 

Tryon Row, 55. 

Tubby Hook, 173. 

Tulip Tree, 172, 174. 

Tunissen's Neck. 331. 

Turner, Peter, Bust. 242. 

Turtle Bay, I3.^ 

Twain, JNIark, Former Home, 184. 

Twelfth Street School, 109. 

Twin Island, 211. 

Tyler House, 329- 

I'nderhill Burying <;round, 213. 
L'nderiiill Covert Farm House, 288. 
Union Avenue. Newtown, 299- 
Union Hill Academy, 312. 
I'uion Hotel. Newtown, 301. 
Union House, 112, 349. 
Union Road, Old. 107. 
Union Square. 106. 
Union Tlicological Seminary. 126. 
United States Arsenal, i i 1. 
I'nited States Hrancli Bank. 29. 
United States Marine Hospital. 235- 
United States Hotel. 37, 63. 
United Siites Naval Museum. 264. 
United States Slii|> Canal, ihg- 
Up'icr CortlandtV. 185. 
Upper Road to the Ferry. Newtown, 
302. 

X'alentine Farm House. 20t. 
X'alentine Homestead. I93- 
Vallence's Bark Mil!. 302. 



419 



INDEX 



Van Alst Avenue, 283. 

Van Alst House, 277. 

^'an Beuren House, i07- 

Van Brunt House, 253, 259. 

Van Buren, Gen., Home of, 335. 

Van Cleef House, 262. 

Van Cortlandt Burial Vault, 182. 

Van Cortlandt Gardener's Cottage, 

185. 
Van Cortlandt Grist Mill, 182. 
Van Cortlandt House, Original, 182. 
Van Cortlandt Lake, 182. 
Van Cortlandt Mansion, 181. 
Van Cortlandt Miller's House, 184. 
Van Cortlandt's on the Hill, 185. 
Van der Donck House, 182. 
Van der Donck Planting Field, 182. 
Van der Heuvel Mansion, 123. 
Van Duyn Homestead, 296. 
Van Keulen's Hook, 149. 
Van Nuyse-Magaw Homestead, 251. 
^'an Pelt Academy, 330. 
Van Pelt Cottage, 331. 
Van Pelt Houses, 260, 347. 
Van Pelt-Decker House, 260. 
Van Raust House, 234. 
\'an Schaick Mansion, 205. 
\^an Sicklen Houses, 254, 313. 
\"an Sinderen House, 254. 
Van Wicklen Mill, 253. 
Van W'yck Houses, 249, 251, 312. 
\'anderbilt Houses, 247, 337, 342, 

Vaiiderveer Houses 248, 254. 
\'anderveer Mill, 248, 254. 
Xan Oblinus, Farm of, 161. 
Varian, Isaac, Homestead, 191. 
Vault Hill. 182. 
\'auxliall Garden, 59, 93- 
Vechte-Cortelyou House, Tablet, 
257, 265. 
\ ermont. The, 264. 
Verlettenbergh, 21. 
Verveelen's First Ferry to Bronx, 

149. 
\'incent-Halsey House, 214- 
\ietor House, Newtown, 297. 
\'ineyard Lot, 57. 
\]y : see Fly. 
\'lissingen, 275. 
\'olckert Dirksen, House, 231. 
\'oorhees House, 259. 
Voorhees-Sheppard House, 262. 
\'redeland, 207. 
^'redendal, 146, 147. 
\rceland Houses, 333, 338. 



Wading Place, 169. 
Wall Street. 5, 6, 26. 
W'allabout Bay. 244. 
Wallabout Market, 235, 244. 
Walton House, 64. 
Ward House, 328. 
Ward's Island, 137, 281. 
Warpoes, 97- 
Warren House, 73. 
Warren Road, 115. 



Washington Building, 15. 
Washington Hotel, i.s. 

Washington Market, 60, 66. 
Washington Memorial Arch, 80. 
Washington Square, 80. 
Washington Statues, 26, 106, 140, 

277. 
Washington's Chestnut, 184. 

Washington's Departure, Tablet, 20. 

Washington's Gun House, 193. 
Washington's Headquarters, 153, 
156-9, 191. 

Washington's Landing, 79. 

Washington's Well, 131. 

Washingtonville, 193. 

Water Poort, 26. 

Way Farm House, Newtown, 287. 

Webb Shipbuilder's Home and 
Academy, 190. 

Webster, Daniel. Home, 17. 

Weehawken Duelling Grounds, 124. 

Weehawken Street, 75. 

Wessell's Brook, 279. 

West India Company, 20, 22, 31. 

West Farms, 213- 

W^est Farms Presbyterian Church, 
213. 

West House, 308. 

\\'est Riding of Yorkshire, 275. 

West Washington Market, 60. 

Westchester Creek Causeway, 207. 

\\'estchester Path, 372. 

Westchester Village, 176, 205, 207. 

Whipping Post and Gallows, Rich- 
mond, 344. 

White Hall. 20. 

Whitehall Ferry, 45. 

White Horse Inn. 21. 

Whitepot Road, School. 295. 

Whitestone, 275, 309. 

Whitestone Road, Flushing, 304. 

Whitlock Mansion, 196. 

Wilkins Farmhouse. 203. 

Willett Tract and Burying Ground, 
308. 

\\'illett Marinus. Tablet, 32. 

William Street, 30. 

Williams House, Williamsbridge, 
191. 

Williamsbridge, 191. 

Williamsburg, 227. 

Williamson House. 262. 

Wiltsee House, Astoria, 284. 

Wiman, Erastus, House of, 345. 

Winant House, 347- 

Winant-Johnson House, 352. 

Windmill Lane, 60. 

Wolf Pit. 334. 

Wolf Pit Hill Farm, 309. 

Wolf Swamp, 291. 

Wolf's Lane, 211. 

Woodard House, 289. 

Woodhull, Gen., 259. 

Woodlawn Cemetery. 193. 

Wood Point Road, 232. 

Woods of Arden House, 347. 

Woodside, 291. 

Woodside, Bronx, 196. 



420 



INDEX 



Woodward or Woodard House, 289, 

297. 
Woolf Farm, 187. 
Woolsey, Edward, House of, 284. 
Wright Homestead, 308. 
Wyckoff Houses, 255, 265, 285, 289, 

31S. 



Ye Olde Tavern, 66. 
Yonk-Herr's Land, 182. 
Yorkville, 133. 

Zborowski Mansion, igg. 
Zerega's Point, 204. 
Zoological Garden, 202, 400. 



This Index was prepared under the supervision of Samuel C. Cohen, aided 
by David Rosenberg. Louis Schneider and Morris Slutsky and other mem- 
bers of the DeWitt Clinton City History Club. 



421 



PUBLICATIONS OF THE CITY HISTORY CLUB 

(105 West 40th Street) 

HISTORICAL EXCURSION LEAFLETS 

* No. I. — City Hall to Wall Street, 20 pp., 2 cuts, 4 maps; 5 cents. Revised 1910. 

* No. II. — Greenwich Village and Lispenard's Meadows, 16 pp., 3 maps; 5 cents. 

* No. III. — The Bowery and East Side, 16 pp., 3 maps; 5 cents. 

* No. IV. — Central Park to Kingsbridge, 20 pp., 5 maps; 5 cents. 

* No. V. — The 19th Century City; loth Street to 125th Street; 36 pp., 5 maps; 

10 cents. Revised 1912. 

* No. VI. — Fraunces' Tavern, 12 pp., i map, 3 cuts; 5 cents. Revised 1912. 

* No. VII. — South of Wall Street, 32 pp., 4 maps, 6 cuts; 10 cents. Revised, 1912. 

* No. VIII. — Historic Brooklyn, Part I, 12 pp., 4 maps, 2 cuts; 10 cents. 

* No. IX. — Historic Bronx, 44 pp., 9 maps, 3 cuts; 10 cents. Revised 1910. 

* No. X. — Historic Richmond, 24 pp., 3 maps; 10 cents. 

* No. XI. — Historic Queens, 36 pp., 5 maps; 10 cents. 

* No. XII. — Historic Brooklyn, Part II; 28 pp., 7 maps; 10 cents. 

*HlSTORICAL GUIDE TO THE CITY OF NEW YORK 

Includes the above Excursion Leaflets, several appendices and an alphabetical 
index; 450 pp., 70 maps and 46 illustrations. Cloth, small i2mo, $1.50 net; post- 
paid, $1.60. Revised 1913- 



* Teachers' Handbook: Outlines of a Course of Study in Local Geography and 
History (revised, 1908) ; 25 cents. 

* Graphic Views of Government: to illustrate the relations of our National, 
State and City Governments; 16 pp., 6 plates; 10 cents. 

* N. Y. CJty Government Leaflets: 10 cents each. No. i. Municipal Govern- 
ment in N. Y. State. 

* Hudson°Fulton Leaflet: containing part of the log of Robert Juet: price 10 
cents. 

Historical Souvenir Postals: 10 cents per set of five. 

Club Game — (revised 1909); an historical game of cards, containing many facts 
about New York City History (played like the game of Authors), 25 cents. 

* City History Illustrations: 68 pictures of the famous men, buildings and events 
of local history: 35 cents per set.. 



* Public School Teachers are advised that they can secure the above starred 
publications for themselves and their classes through the Supply List of the Board 
of Education (Nos. 2743-2757) and 7001. 

THE HALF MOON SERIES 

Papers on Historic New York, 24 Monographs on Local History, published in 
the interest of the City History Club of New York. Edited by Maud Wilder 
Goodwin, Alice Carrington Royce, and Ruth Putnam: 10 cents each. 



928 



